Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To change my baby's name... feeling guilt and sadness

286 replies

tiffysaccount · 12/10/2018 15:23

Hello mums

Well long story short we named our baby girl Abigail and registered her and I dislike the name or so I thought. I'd like some help processing these emotions and to try to figure out what's best for us.

I hate it when people call her Abi/Abby and it seems like that is what they constantly do. Plus I knew an Abi who was a complete bitch at school and I don't know why I didn't think of the association beforehand. Stupid. We've told people we are going to call her Abigail no nicknames and they don't seem to respect it. Feels like fingernails on a chalkboard whenever I hear Abigail or Abi. Just seems off to me.

I wanted to name her something else, I don't want to post for privacy purposes sorry but it's also a classic normal name.

I don't know why on earth I didn't name her that, DH loved the name and is now OK with me changing it to that, I have his full blessing.

She is 15 weeks now, if you would have asked me to change it 6 weeks ago i would have done the paperwork immediately but now I am not sure. This absolutely breaks my heart and I'm so confused.

I was going back in her baby book the other day and saw a hospital birth record with Abigail on it and her little feet stamped on it and I just burst into tears at the thought of changing it. I feel that if I changed the name I would be changing her. It's almost like, I hate the name but now it's hers and I can't take it from her. It's the strangest emotion, hating the name but almost loving it because it's hers.

Then I think back to the hospital and my husband filling out the birth certificate and holding her in his arms. The name means "father's joy" as well.

I'm so bloody confused about this whole thing that I'm in tears about it every day. I like the other name so much more and I don't know if I can see her being Abigail or Abi the rest of her life. I think about changing it but I get such a deep feeling of heartbreak and guilt over it and I feel that if I did change it these feelings would linger forever on.

How unreasonable am I being here. From this mess I've typed out, do you think I'm best off keeping the name or changing it? I can't tell if it's mum guilt talking or my emotions or what and it's exhausting.

OP posts:
RockYourSocksOff · 16/10/2018 21:57

Give it a few weeks, stay with us on this thread. If you still feel strongly about it change it, go with your heart and how you feel, don’t think about what other people think!

amumoffour · 16/10/2018 12:13

None of my children ended up with the chosen name, my husband registered them and couldn't remember what we chose. The only one who is a little bothered is my youngest when he found out he should have been Noah and ended up with boring Ian. could have been worse.

tiffysaccount · 15/10/2018 15:37

@Gatehouse77 yes, absolutely. My mum didn't quite understand the dilemma at first and thought I had completely lost it, told me to go check myself into an institution! Since then she has softened to it and tells me to follow my heart but it made me feel a bit judged at first- and I perhaps wondered how others perceived this as well if my mum reacted that way at first.

Had a long chat about this with DH last night and expressed that I felt guilt about taking the name from him. Again with the emotions as it means "father's joy" (I think I am hanging wayyyyy to much symbolism on a stupid meaning) and he really chose the name for her as I was in the hospital exhausted and agonising and confused. He admitted "I confess I lied to you...I really just told you it was my favourite name so you could commit to it and we could leave the bloody hospital and get on with it"! So that makes me feel better.

Asked about the possibility of moving it to the middle, DH doesn't like that idea.

Nothing really seems all that right at the moment but I do know that for a long time Charlotte did until I overthought it all to exhaustion! x Waiting on a call back from a therapist now.

OP posts:
YearOfYouRemember · 15/10/2018 15:34

You've had a tough year but changing the name is something you can do. Make things better. Take away one stress.

Gatehouse77 · 15/10/2018 15:26

I haven't read the whole thread but I knew someone who was in a very similar position to you. Someone misheard the name of her newborn which was the name of her school bully. It threw her in a tailspin.
Eventually, after 2 name changes (not officially, they tried them out for a while) they settled on a name.
On the surface, it can seem trivial but choosing a name is so emotive which I didn't truly appreciate until I had my own children and from seeing how much it affected this friend.

It's not stupid and I wouldn't feel guilty or silly about it. Everyone's got a 'thing' that seems incomprehensible to others.

tiffysaccount · 15/10/2018 15:26

@YearOfYouRemember I know deep down I should as well. From all of your replies I think I've gathered a couple of things, that I should change the name and that I need to get my mental health sorted as far as the overthinking and anxiety.

My heart is in my throat about this all day every day- I just love my baby girl so much and it's what I'll be calling her every day for 50 years God willing perhaps more- lofty decision to make when I feel so anxious and I start second guessing myself, and thinking all this is just me being unreasonable due to my mental health at the moment. I don't want to look back and think "why the hell did I do that"! I've asked my inlaws to call her by the new name and forget the old, maybe once I hear this for a while and I get my anxiety in check I will be able to move forward and feel like she had the name she was always meant to have - no feelings of guilt, shame, embarrassment, anxiety over whether or not it's right, just happiness and acceptance.

Just been a bloody hard year. Been in tears about it all this morning, from moving, to having no family/friends to really talk to- pregnancy, birth, new baby, dysfunctional stressful job, my work friend left as well when I was on maternity leave, financial issues. Now this bloody name dilemma. I know I deserve to feel lighter than I do, I just need to get from A to B. x

OP posts:
MinaPaws · 15/10/2018 15:14

A friend of mine told me the other day that she changed her DDs name after a few months too. It just felt wrong. I love her DDs name and it really suits her. The other name really didn't. She's in her 20s now and I can promise you she has no hang ups about having had her name changed when she was tiny. Change her name and let everyone know. Do a new footprint. You can always keep Abigail as a middle name.

YearOfYouRemember · 15/10/2018 15:07

Please just change the name. All this angst over something you can change.

Your dh is happy to change it. Your baby doesn't care. Just change the name already Flowers.

You're miserable now. Even if you do have PND you won't be worrying about your baby's name as she'll be the name she always need should have been …

tiffysaccount · 15/10/2018 15:02

Got up this morning and had a chat with my mum, she thinks I'm being silly re: feeling guilty and reminded me that we had been out for a coffee months back when I went home to visit, and I kept going on about how I loved the name Charlotte and it just felt right. She agrees that changing an infant's name is no big deal but hinted at there being deeper mental health issues at play being that I'm feeling so many strong emotions about this. And I agree with her.

I am just trying to process things now. I don't know why I feel an immense sadness about changing the name and I'm trying to get to the bottom of it. Perhaps it's because the name is a part of my daughter's history, I think. I imagine seeing the name in the future and feeling tinges of sadness because that's what we brought her home as and she's not that anymore... on the other side I don't know if I can keep on immediately going "ugh" and kicking myself each time someone says my DD's name.

So bloody confusing, back at work for the week and it's all I can think about at my desk!

Suppose if I don't change it I'll always wonder "what could have been" though. Hate the way my mind works sometimes.

All in all my biggest fear is that I won't feel better if it's changed and I will regret changing it.

Going to book a therapist today as well I've decided to help me to sort out these emotions. x

OP posts:
3luckystars · 15/10/2018 14:57

I not 100% sure but i think the Native Americans give a name and then 're name or give a spirit name when they get to know the child.

Just change the name, you love Charlotte! It's ok!

Klmn · 15/10/2018 13:28

I can empathise with your agony. I've not read all the replies, so apologies if I am repeating something that has been said before. I named DS the name DH wanted, I cried for 4 days about it, then told myself to get over it, anything for DH. DS is 29 now and I still feel a little sadness that he's not called the name I really wanted (after my DF) I remember the pressure to name him, and still feel the resentment that I went through the pregnancy etc, and DH gets to name both DC!

Stop the guilt, its a complete waste of your time and energy, choose the name you love. This is your DD, this time next year you won't even think about the agony you are experiencing now. Your gut feeling is always right. Best of luck, and happy times ahead.

IthinkIsawahairbrushbackthere · 15/10/2018 10:43

Nothing to feel guilty about.

You say you are sitting there imagining telling her a fairytale about the princess - I think that is an amazing way to look at it.

I get where you are coming from with the meaning and not wanting to take that away. When I got pregnant for the 4th time - total shock, I was on the pill! - I laughed and laughed and decided that if I had a boy it would be Isaac because it means "God has made me laugh".

Unfortunately the rest of the family hated it. And then my husband came up with a combination of names that included Isaac, fitted all my criteria and had lovely meanings so Isaac is still very much a part of his name although he has never been called it.

If you call her Charlotte Abigail you will always have that record that she is her father's joy. What little girl wouldn't love the story you told us - to be the princess who has brought so much happiness.

Your situation has really touched me and I feel quite emotional for you. You know what you want to do, your husband is supportive, it will make no difference to your daughter. Give yourself permission to do what will make you happy.

MismatchedStripySocks · 15/10/2018 08:24

I think it’s a lovely name. DSS has a name that is very commonly shortened but he is always known by the full version and it suits him far better. It’s up to you as the parent to guide it Flowers

Italiangreyhound · 15/10/2018 01:30

"Been sitting here with a nice cuppa and a blanket on watching the snowfall..."

Is it snowing somewhere??

"Thanks ladies, I know deep down I've nothing to be guilty about. It's just that I have overthought this to the point where nothing feels right anymore and I've played it up in my head."

You have nothing to be guilty about Thanks
You have nothing to be guilty about Thanks
You have nothing to be guilty about Thanks

You have nothing to be guilty about Thanks

You have nothing to be guilty about Thanks

Please talk to someone about possible PND and please change the name to one you want. Xx

garethsouthgatesmrs · 14/10/2018 23:35

feeling like I've let DH and DD down

I am feeling pressure to make sure everything is right

this pretty much sums up my PND both times. I got obsessive but over different things each time. It's actually reassuring to hear that it's not just me. I am recovering now, DD2 is 12 months, I am on meds and have had CBT, both worked really well. I won't be coming off the meds for a while. I acually cried on the phone to the mental health assessor because even the fact that I was having to talk to her meant that things weren't perfect for DD, every minor thought and acknowledgement that I was finding things tough felt like I was letting her down.

Now I just feel proud that I sought help, that I took the help and mostly that I have such wonderful DCs. All the things that seemed to matter so much in those early days fade in my memory and it will for you too OP.

either name choice will be fine, even if you use one as a middle but call her that it will be fine but if your gut says Charlotte go with that.

Fraula · 14/10/2018 23:31

Once you've made the decision, write down one good reason for it. Read it. Feel confident in it. Then try not to go over and over it in your mind. The decision has been made! I bet you'll start feeling better.

garethsouthgatesmrs · 14/10/2018 23:26

I never did love Abigail to begin with. It was a total compromise name

for me now you've said that I think you should change it. If this really is the case then on balance you will regret NOT changing it more than changing it. But do get your GP to refer you for some counselling or something, I also am crap at decision making and in times of high stress it can make me feel really anxious and unwell.

tiffysaccount · 14/10/2018 23:17

@ravenmum Been sitting here with a nice cuppa and a blanket on watching the snowfall, great suggestion. Wish I could buy all of you ladies a coffee for your help and conversation, each reply has been heartwarming.

Been thinking of calling her Gail or BiBi or GiGi and while those are all adorable suggestions something inside says it's not right.

Forgot if I had mentioned this, we actually coin tossed in the hospital and I was hoping for Charlotte and it won. Still went with the other name in the overwhelm of the moment. Agh!! Really wish the US didn't do things that way, with coming round with the certificate to exhausted and emotional new mums. If I'd have had 6 weeks to spend with her and calm down from the birth and just get my head straightened out a bit I dare say this may not have happened.

You know- at this point I'm convinced I could keep Abigail and be happy in time if I'd just shut up and commit. It's likely she'll be my only LO so I am feeling pressure to make sure everything is right, probably adds to the agonising. If we had planned on more DCs I think I'd have been more relaxed at the chance to really get it right the second time.

Might sound a bit juvenile, but I've been sitting on the settee looking outside this afternoon imagining if this story is a fairytale I read her in a few years. Would make for a sweet story knowing the princess came home with a name that didn't fit... her mum went round and round wondering what she should be called... then looked back and went with her old favourite that felt right in mum's heart when she was pregnant with her.

I've set myself a deadline of Nov 1... happens to be my 30th birthday. Bit of symbolism there with not looking back and going forward into the new decade.

Thanks ladies, I know deep down I've nothing to be guilty about. It's just that I have overthought this to the point where nothing feels right anymore and I've played it up in my head.

OP posts:
crosstalk · 14/10/2018 23:06

I'm with ree 500 years ago when my DC were born no one came round in hospital - you had to go to a registrar to formalise their names. All the hospital would do would sign the baby on as baby crosstalk on their cards. And I didn't change my surname so it was always baby crosstalk until registration. I think you've got plenty of time to calm down, go for the name you like - as many as possible so s/he can choose which one suits when you do the formal registration. Meanwhile enjoy your baby.

AcrossthePond55 · 14/10/2018 22:32

Oh love, you aren't 'stripping' her of anything! Her identity will be formed by her as she grows older. Certainly I'm nothing like my mother would have first imagined me to be as a newborn. I doubt very many of us are! We become 'ourselves' in our own time.

Her name is not 'who she is', it's simply 'what you call her'.

retainertrainer · 14/10/2018 21:58

I don’t understand what on earth you’re feeling guilty about. How can there be anything other than a positive outcome?

Sorry to sound harsh but you really need to get this in perspective and get a grip. Your DH is ‘numb’ to it because he’s seeing it as it is-a name change which will have zero impact on anybody. The only difference will be that you’ll love your DD’s name.

Enough now. You sound like you’ve tourtured yourself over this unnecessarily. Be kind to yourself.

This is no reflection on you as a mum. It’s no reflection on anything. Dear god,the horrors that some poor children go through in life. This is utterly insignificant.

Change the name,just crack on and do it. Send a mass texts telling everyone you and DH decided it didn’t suit Dd and you didn’t like the shortening. She’s a Charlotte to you. Then move on,enjoy your life, your lovely little girl.

It’s just a name.

MemoryOfSleep · 14/10/2018 20:24

Sorry if this has been said already, but what about Gail as a nickname? Would that be better? And get those who insist on nicknames to call her that instead? Or does she have a middle name you could refer to her as? I know lots of people who go by middle names and only use their first names for formal purposes.

theWarOnPeace · 14/10/2018 20:22

Please OP, you really aren’t letting anyone down. I’m always quick on the mark to call someone irresponsible or selfish or whatever. You know that this is not the place for sycophants telling you you’re brilliant if they don’t believe it. Everyone telling you it's fine, really means it, i dare say including your husband. I know my husband wouldn’t mind either way, he’d probably have the same response I think. You’re worried about making a horrible mistake or being a bad mum, honestly I cannot see this is the case here. You’re doing nothing wrong at all! You’ve totally lost perspective, and for that alone I think you should ask your GP to refer you to speak to someone. Or if you can’t face that, at least keep talking on here and try and rebalance your perspective a bit. There’s no shame in struggling with being a new parent, I think it’s something that nobody really warns us about, but you have a baby and feel like your emotions have been tipped upside down and been out back in the wrong order. It’s hard, and makes you question yourself more than any other period of your life. This (name problem) is not something that can or should be used to measure your parenting skills. I said probably a few pages back that my son had a different name on his BC to the one he uses, and so does his dad actually. I have a few friends with the same situation. It makes no difference to anyone, anywhere, at all. My kids were all called “the baby” for the first few months. To some people that might seem odd, to us it was totally normal. Again, perspective. It’s all about the way you’ve put value on something. How important something is, that isn’t an issue for others. If you can look at the issue from arms length and can realise that it’s not worth the heartache you’re giving it, then you need to surround yourself with different perspectives. Some cultures, especially ones with high infant mortality rates, don’t name their children for months. Some areas of my husband’s culture, name their babies after inanimate objects for the first few months, even up to a year or more old, because they are trying to confuse “evil spirits” into leaving their precious babies alone. I’m not suggesting you belive any of that stuff, I just mean that to those people a name change does nothing to take away a person’s identity. Not at all. It’s all a mindset, and yours is currently wrapped around something that really doesn’t make a person who they are. Names to me are something that has to sound nice to my ear. If your child’s name doesn’t sing to you or make you feel good, you ought to change it now and think nothing more of it. It really is just a name. Pre-1990s France, you had a list of names you could choose from and that was that, there are all sorts of ways of giving and using names. Try to look into naming in other cultures, to understand it from another mindset.

ravenmum · 14/10/2018 20:19

I mean that literally. Make those purchases.

And read through all the examples of people saying they did exactly what you want to do, without even thinking twice about it. I don't even know if my mum bothered to mention it to my sister: she was a tiny baby so obviously has no memory at all of being called anything different.

Get another footprint done with her new name, hang them both on the wall and see which one you like best Grin

ravenmum · 14/10/2018 20:14

May I suggest that you buy a Magic 8 ball and ask that? :) Actually they really are quite useful, as when you read the answer, if it isn't the one you were subconsciously hoping for then you feel disappointed, so you know what you really want. Try flipping a coin - heads change, tails keep the name. Then see how happy/disappointed you feel. That can be the sign.

Your husband sounds like a nice guy, but even the lovely ones are going to get a bit bored of discussing the same subject day after day Grin

I had my babies abroad too, and like I said, the first birth left me a wreck, not just because it was a Caesarian but because I was just overwhelmed by EVERYTHING. People giving me all this advice I couldn't take in, as it was all unfamiliar (being foreign and all), I couldn't tell if it was good or bad, or what I was meant to do. Like you say, no family or network nearby for support. I couldn't get the baby to feed, got mastitis, basically all was shit.

Second birth, two years later, I was in a room with two other women with their first babies. I was the super expert mum! One was in a total state, couldn't get the baby to feed, etc. Poor woman kept getting visitors so she couldn't just play around and experiment with the baby. When the room emptied I just told her that it didn't matter if she breastfed or not, and she was doing just fine. I think it was the first time she'd heard anyone suggest that she didn't have to do it all perfectly.

You don't have to do it all perfectly. It is fine not to have a bloody clue what you are doing, to sit there all day in your pajamas with the baby, watching TV and eating chocolate. It is normal when you have just have a baby to be in a total state, get everything muddled up and feel like a clueless idiot.

Give your mum a ring, buy huge reserves of chocolate, ready meals, a gripping book and a box set of treat-yourself TV from the UK. Spend the entire day on the settee. Wrap yourself in cotton wool. It's hard work having a baby abroad, molly-coddle yourself a bit.