Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To change my baby's name... feeling guilt and sadness

286 replies

tiffysaccount · 12/10/2018 15:23

Hello mums

Well long story short we named our baby girl Abigail and registered her and I dislike the name or so I thought. I'd like some help processing these emotions and to try to figure out what's best for us.

I hate it when people call her Abi/Abby and it seems like that is what they constantly do. Plus I knew an Abi who was a complete bitch at school and I don't know why I didn't think of the association beforehand. Stupid. We've told people we are going to call her Abigail no nicknames and they don't seem to respect it. Feels like fingernails on a chalkboard whenever I hear Abigail or Abi. Just seems off to me.

I wanted to name her something else, I don't want to post for privacy purposes sorry but it's also a classic normal name.

I don't know why on earth I didn't name her that, DH loved the name and is now OK with me changing it to that, I have his full blessing.

She is 15 weeks now, if you would have asked me to change it 6 weeks ago i would have done the paperwork immediately but now I am not sure. This absolutely breaks my heart and I'm so confused.

I was going back in her baby book the other day and saw a hospital birth record with Abigail on it and her little feet stamped on it and I just burst into tears at the thought of changing it. I feel that if I changed the name I would be changing her. It's almost like, I hate the name but now it's hers and I can't take it from her. It's the strangest emotion, hating the name but almost loving it because it's hers.

Then I think back to the hospital and my husband filling out the birth certificate and holding her in his arms. The name means "father's joy" as well.

I'm so bloody confused about this whole thing that I'm in tears about it every day. I like the other name so much more and I don't know if I can see her being Abigail or Abi the rest of her life. I think about changing it but I get such a deep feeling of heartbreak and guilt over it and I feel that if I did change it these feelings would linger forever on.

How unreasonable am I being here. From this mess I've typed out, do you think I'm best off keeping the name or changing it? I can't tell if it's mum guilt talking or my emotions or what and it's exhausting.

OP posts:
OutPinked · 12/10/2018 16:05

When my DS was a baby I almost regretted his name choice and wanted to flip his first and middle name around. His first name is more traditional and classic whereas the middle name is a bit quirkier so to speak. Anyway I’m so, so glad I didn’t change it now. His name suits him well and goes with his sisters traditional names.

If you regret it so severely then change it. I understand with regards to people shortening names, it is annoying.

GU24Mum · 12/10/2018 16:05

If you've given it some thought (which it sounds as though you have) and want to change, I'd do it - your baby will never know and that's far easier than her being called Abigail officially but everyone knowing her as Charlotte/whatever new name you choose.

There's nothing to feel guilty about.

diddl · 12/10/2018 16:01

How would you feel if she wanted to be known as Abi when older?

I do think though that until a child decides, then parents wishes should be respected.

I agree with a pp that Gigi is cute.

Jeanclaudejackety · 12/10/2018 15:57

I know an abigail nicknamed GiGi it is so cute and she is a really sweet little girl and it suits her sooo much

BertrandRussell · 12/10/2018 15:57

"my daughter the said teacher in his place very quickly indeed."

I do hope you mean she reminded the teacher, rather than put her in her place.........

Neighneigh · 12/10/2018 15:55

I have two middle names and my first name isn't the name I'm known by (added to some topics still being in maiden surname, the postman finds it all highly amusing). So don't worry about using a middle name. I think it sounds like a weight off your shoulders to change it. She's so young yet it won't affect her but it will affect you, positively, I think.

BertrandRussell · 12/10/2018 15:54

I wonder whether you might be a bit depressed-what do you think? It's quite unusual to feel as strongly as this about names. But if you really can't bear Abi then you do need to change it. It will be impossible to stop- and very, very tedious to try. Just do it-as soon as possible. For information, I have been known all my life by a short version of my full name-it even has a different initial letter. It's never been a problem- my passport has my full name but I don't think anything else has. I have to put both names on forms sometimes, but nothing more complicated than that.

PleaseLetMummySleep · 12/10/2018 15:54

If you do change her name, it'll attract attention for a short while but after 3 months no one will remember that she used to have a different name.

It doesn't really matter if you change her name, it won't cause anyone any suffering. I'd just change it but do it ASAP.

Honestly in a few weeks the change will be old news and you'll get used to calling her the new name quickly.

If you don't act soon you'll need to leave it tho as she will start to know her name very soon

overagain · 12/10/2018 15:50

Is there anything else you are sad or low about? I ask as name regret is a lesser known symptom of postnatal depression and your post just sounds so sad Flowers

Tinty · 12/10/2018 15:49

Change her name, I met someone a couple of years ago with a 9 yr old Dd called Chloe, her Dmum told me she didn't like the name at all but her Ddad suggested it and every one was calling the baby Chloe so she just registered her as Chloe. She told me a slight acquaintance this story 9 years later, she hated the name that much. By then it is to late to do anything about it. At the age your baby is you can change it and no one will think anything of it.

She will be Abby to all her friends at school because that is what her friends will call her. My dd has a friend think Isabella (not her actual name), her Dmum always calls her Isabella, her friends call her Bella, her Dmum was surprised when I invited Bella over (all I had ever heard my DD call her) and told me her name is Isabella, I try to remember and call her this in front of her mum. Smile.

spacefighter · 12/10/2018 15:48

Why not give her the nickname Ally?

Beagle840 · 12/10/2018 15:47

I agree with pp who suggested adding the new name as a middle name by which she is known. You could try just being very firm with people who shorten it but it will happen her whole life and to an extent, it will end up out of your control.

alphajuliet123 · 12/10/2018 15:46

^^ yep, what lostelephant said. Use the new name for a few days and if it makes you happier just change it.

She WILL get called Abby by her friends as she gets older, no doubt about it, and if that's going to grate on you for the next few decades you'd be better doing something asap.

BabyItsAWildWorld · 12/10/2018 15:46

Ahh, just change her name. It'll be OK.

Keep Abigail as one of her names and Abigail will just be part of her 'name story'. And on a daily basis you can use the name you love which will be her name.

Topseyt · 12/10/2018 15:46

As someone who has always been known by her middle name, I have personally found it a pain in the arse and have had a lifetime of explaining it now. So my personal preference would be not to do that.

I actually love the name Abigail. I don't mind the shortening s of Abi, Abs or Gail either, though that is probably just personal taste.

I'm probably no help, but it is a gorgeous name and I would leave it.

Maybe add your other name choice as a second middle name?

BlueBug45 · 12/10/2018 15:44

OP I have a niece named Abigail and she is and had always been lovely.

In regards to insisting on her having no nickname - it doesn't work once they go to school and/or the child is old enough to choose their name.

SleepWarrior · 12/10/2018 15:44

Don't worry about a clunky middle name combo, loads of people have them. You are almost never referred to by your full name and middle name combination.

Write down all your options on a piece of paper so you can see them clearly in front of you. Write the pros and cons of each possibility next to them. Stick it on the fridge and spend a few days mulling it over together.

Take some solace in the fact that there is no wrong answer here. Abigail IS a nice name that she will grow to be perfectly happy with. So if you do nothing because you can't work out what the best thing would be, sticking with Abigail WILL be absolutely fine. And don't waste time feeling guilt, nothing at all to feel guilty about.

Bluetrews25 · 12/10/2018 15:43

Are you depressed OP? That was my first concern, obviously I could be way off the mark (and hope I am Smile)
You must have liked the name at some point. Don't worry about associating it with someone you used to know, as soon the vast majority of your 'Abigail' associated memories will be of your daughter.
You can TRY to control the shortening, but what if your DD likes Abi? (Personally, I think it's lovely.) People will always shorten names however they want to , especially at school. It's a sign of affection. (And speed!)

Enb76 · 12/10/2018 15:42

Can you give her another nickname? People seem determined to use nicknames, my daughter's nickname is the male version of her actual name (although I love her name and it's not exactly long so why people need to give her a nickname...)

I know an Abigail whose nickname is Bibi (Bee-bee) or Bibigail for long.

Otherwise, of course you can change her name. My cousin changed her daughter's name because she hadn't quite realised what her chosen name would sound like in the local accent. She's now New name, old name, surname.

Gemini69 · 12/10/2018 15:41

Change the name.. today Flowers

abigailsnan · 12/10/2018 15:41

My grand-daughter is an Abigail as you can see and she is now 16,she has always insisted when people shorten it to Abby that she was named Abigail and everyone has always respected her wishes,one person slipped up not too long ago at a school teachers interview and my daughter the said teacher in his place very quickly indeed.

IAcceptCookies · 12/10/2018 15:40

If you're going to make the change make it sooner rather than later, then you'll stop agonising, get over it and enjoy the new name.
FWIW I have an Abigail. The name was a last minute compromise and I wasn't delighted with it at first. 21 years later she really couldn't be anything other than an Abi!

HappenedForAReisling · 12/10/2018 15:40

Unfortunately she will always be Abi/Abby whether you insist on Abigail or not. It's just so much easier to say and people with shorten her name without thinking about it.

spinn · 12/10/2018 15:39

My ds3 is known by his middle name to everyone.

He is just 3 and already knows that some people call him Jack (first name) - mainly doctors and passport control but everyone else says his name as usual.
Heck even he plays around and changes his order around when he wants to. It really really isn't an admin nightmare.

lostelephant · 12/10/2018 15:37

Have you tried calling her by the name you would prefer her to be called? I’d suggest maybe doing this for a full week and see how you feel. If it makes you happier and feels ‘right’ then I would change it.