Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think council house 'auto bidding' takes the point away from home CHOICE

68 replies

LolaPickle · 25/09/2018 15:06

I have just realized in our area, that certain bands awaiting council housing, get placed in an auto bid cycle. Why do they call it home 'choice'?

This means you could end up miles away from support networks etc

Plus the housing site is very hit and miss if it even works, the person I help bidded for three last week, but only two of the bids registered, despite us re-checking them over the weekend, one of the bids has disappeared, meaning one bid will be an auto bid!

OP posts:
YeTalkShiteHen · 26/09/2018 13:37

Simply speaking, I think people should stand on their own two feet

Lovely.

I think that how we treat each other defines the type of society we are. Treating people like shit because they have less money/a disability/are a carer/don’t have the opportunities and advantages that some have really isn’t a pleasant or decent thing to do.

We all make up society, so I’m always a little surprised (aye I know I should know better) and more than a little gutted when people swoop in with sweeping statements and euphemisms which effectively mean they’d support fucking over an entire group of people who have already been fucked over.

Ugh.

Zoflorabore · 26/09/2018 13:34

Wow, what a statement, standing on own two feet. Like that's a choice too for some
people.

I like the fact that MN is diverse. Some of the dc go to private schools ( not mine ), others live in big houses etc, some people have very strong views on certain things etc but one of the things that I would say is unanimous on MN is we tend to agree that social housing/benefits/any form of help is there for our society for those who need it.
I am included in that part.

God forbid the rug is swept from underneath your feet and you have a life change where you need help. What would you do then?

The ignorance of that statement is utterly astounding.

For people like myself with a chronic illness and the pp who is a wheelchair user I find that comment insulting at best and fucking disgraceful at worst.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 26/09/2018 13:25

Libertarian I have never had to use social housing but I am very thankful it exists because sometimes life doesnt go as planned, shit happens and I like living in a society where children for example dont end up on the street due to ignorant attitudes like yours.

ProfessorMoody · 26/09/2018 12:46

Simply speaking, I think people should stand on their own two feet

Ah, bit hard considering I can't walk, so am sat in a wheelchair. I did stand on my own two feet for over 20 years though, working my ass off to pay my mortgage. Unfortunately, after being a victim of domestic violence, having my home repossessed and losing the ability to move, I wasn't able to do that any more.

What do you suggest I should have done then, Libertarian, with no home, a child, a severe physical and mental illness and a wheelchair in tow?

The sheer twattery of some people baffles me.

thebangle · 26/09/2018 12:41

@RavenWings I agree, we have had to move over half an hour away from where all our family live and where we both grew up as we didn’t have a chance of owning our own home if we stayed there. It’s sad but unfortunately its life.

RavenWings · 26/09/2018 12:39

There are plenty of young couples who buy their own house and have to move far from support networks. I'm sure not getting a house in your choice of area is annoying, but that's a given in the private market in many areas. I'm not hugely sympathetic.

thebangle · 26/09/2018 12:39

@Libertarian and life doesnt always work out that way. How are disabled or homeless people able to get on their own two feet?

Libertarian · 26/09/2018 12:34

Simply speaking, I think people should stand on their own two feet.

ProfessorMoody · 26/09/2018 11:38

Eh? Why?

Libertarian · 26/09/2018 11:01

Personally I think we should do awar with social housing all together.

AamdC · 26/09/2018 10:38

My council housr is £10 /week cheaper /week than a similar size private rented house so slightly cheaper but not massivly so, the advantage to them though is a secure tenancy and being able to decorate etc.

Dorsetdays · 26/09/2018 06:34

As some have already said, the autobid system is used where people are classed as homeless and therefore an urgent priority to rehouse.

Also most HA’s offer incentives to downsize including help with moving fees, redecorating, vouchers etc. This is most commonly used as incentive for elderly tenants to downsize and free up family homes which are most in need.

Sugarformyhoney · 25/09/2018 21:40

It’s a choice if you are waiting on s house in a lower band ie waiting your turn sometimes with a need for extra space or a medical/social need.
Most LA use autobid for families who are ‘homeless’ and living in temp accom- the aim is to move them on quickly to house other emergency cases and to prevent them sitting in temp accommodation indefinitely and ‘cherry picking’ where they want to go. If every homeless family chose where they lived the emergency places they have would be over run

OurMiracle1106 · 25/09/2018 20:49

In regards to my local authority the auto bid only comes into play if your in temporary accommodation and fail to bid for a number of weeks or are in the top band as having been released from hospital or similar or have an urgent medical need to move. (In which case you get housed in general on first bid). So actually for our LA it seems fair that you are placed somewhere if you won’t bid for yourself or if you are ready for move in from hospital but can’t be discharged because of accommodation

ProfessorMoody · 25/09/2018 20:45

Long term stability is definitely the main plus point for me. Knowing I'm not going to have to find a wheelchair adapted property and a deposit and months rent at short notice has worked wonders for my anxiety.

SunnySkiesSleepsintheMorning · 25/09/2018 20:07

Auto bid is really helpful for people who struggling to navigate websites or have disabilities or mental health problems which means they’d struggle to log online regularly. It’s opt in around here which works well.

irehs · 25/09/2018 19:55

Thanks professormoody. Sounds like a vicious circle. Yes i can see the long term stability would be a plus.

joanslegs · 25/09/2018 19:52

In merseyside and lancashire you choose if you want auto bids or not - lots of people don't have internet access or are not computer savvy.

You specifty what areas you want and auto bids are set up for you. The general rule is you get three offers only, so you do still have choices.

Aaaahfuck · 25/09/2018 19:48

Wow! Some charmers posting on here! Support networks are so important.

BootsMagoots · 25/09/2018 19:28

It is because some people are in urgent need of housing, however, will manipulate their banding and wait for a desirable area/property. With the autobidding system in place for those in urgent need, it does the job, as the urgent cases are housed and if they were really as urgent as made out they would accept it. That's my understanding of it anyway but it's not something my LA does.

ProfessorMoody · 25/09/2018 19:27

Honest question, how can council housing not be cheaper

My mortgage was £220 a month. My rent in a previous house was £420 a month. Rent in my council bungalow is £530 a month.

If it were more expensive what purpose does it serve

It is more expensive. For me, its purpose was so that I wasn't homeless when my ex husband beat me black and blue and neglected to tell me that he wasn't actually paying the mortgage when he said he was, and I only found out when the repossession people turned up.

Now it's purpose is that I can never get a mortgage again due to my house repossession, I can't afford to build up a deposit and first months rent on zero income, and finding a private rental bungalow that is adapted for a wheelchair in my area is nigh on impossible. Oh and I'm not going to be kicked out.

HTH.

irehs · 25/09/2018 19:22

Honest question, how can council housing not be cheaper? If it were more expensive what purpose does it serve?

Racecardriver · 25/09/2018 19:09

@Dorisdog sorry your sister is having a hard time but without the government help she would be on the street. Its not an ideal system, or even a good system but we should all be appreciative when we receive finacial help from the tax payer. It is a privilege of living in a country like Britain with a generous welfare state, if she had been born in a different country chances are she would be out on the street or a burden to her family instead.

@OP isn't the pout of autobidding to ensure that people don't kiss out on the chance to get a house if they don't make the choice to bid? Obviously the glitchy system has removed a choice in your instance but the problem us a system that has glitches, not the autobidding principle.

Dickybow321 · 25/09/2018 19:02

Makes me laugh how people bash private landlords on here all the time, yet somebody is complaining about the social housing system and they are piled on and told take it or leave it. Well which is it... do you want private landlords to exist or do you think everybody renting should be looking at social housing?

JassyRadlett · 25/09/2018 18:57

Council housing certainly isnt the cheaper option in my towm but then of course we dont all live in London and the south East.

But more than a quarter of the population does, and that’s added to by the many other parts of the country with less affordable housing, any of which the PP may be talking about.

But you know, any excuse for a London/SE bash eh?