Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to consider ear pinning for my dd?

116 replies

Thingsthatgo · 25/09/2018 14:45

My Dd is three. Her ears stick out a lot, and also have a batwing look to them. At the moment her hair covers them (she has curly hair), but if we tie it back they are extremely prominent. The idea of her having surgery that is unnecessary is awful, but I really think that her ears are going to cause her a lot of grief when she is older. I wonder if it is worth doing it before she is very aware of the situation. Please let me know your experiences of ear pinning surgery.
How do I go about it? Gp first? I am not expecting the nhs to pay for it, but I would like advice from a gp.

OP posts:
BlackBeltInChildWrangling · 25/09/2018 16:12

We have 4 family members who had very sticky-out ears as children, 3 girls and one boy, to the extent that 2 rocked their nicknames of Dumbo and Batty, and by adulthood had 'grown in to them'. Personally I'm all about the character and less about the appearance with my DCs. We've experienced essential surgery with one DC here, and I wouldn't consider cosmetic surgery except in extreme circumstances. Unfortunately some children (and even adults) will comment, tease or bully on anything, real or imagined, and so I've tried to bring my DCs up to recognise that, be resilient to it, laugh at themselves and the bullies, and then we deal with anything more serious very directly. I'm sure you love her just the way she is, OP, and I would help her to grow up just loving and accepting herself and, as importantly, to be kind to others. Tape or surgery, especially at this young age, will draw attention to it for her, and make it an issue for her - at the moment it's just an issue for you.

museumum · 25/09/2018 16:00

Very good friend of mine had one ear stick out more than the other, she was miserable about it for years and years. Eventually had it fixed about age 15/16 and was so so happy. I think early puberty around 13yrs was the worst, we always reassured her but she was paranoid everyone was laughing at her ear Sad

Spaghettijumper · 25/09/2018 15:55

No I wouldn't. Confidence doesn't come from how you look IMO and I think trying to change your appearance to control how other people think of you doesn't really make sense to me - confidence is about being ok with how you look even if others do remember you as the one with the sticky out ears or the frizzy hair or whatever.

HeadsDownThumbsUpEveryone · 25/09/2018 15:47

to the extent you get medical treatment to make yourself more acceptable to them.

I don't think anyone would it to make themselves more acceptable to others, surely the point is that they have the surgery to give themselves more confidence. Just like people have braces to give themselves confidence when they smile.

If you have ears which stick out so noticeably they worried you, regardless of whether anyone said anything, you worried constantly if they had noticed your ears or if new people remembered you because you were the one with sticky out ears. If you could change that to make them stand out less your telling me that you wouldn't do it?

LightDrizzle · 25/09/2018 15:45

I’ve just read that others found it painful, - sorry about that. We didn’t so it obviously varies.

I had my appendix out a couple of years later and that hurt like fuck afterwards.

babydreamer1 · 25/09/2018 15:44

Just go for it, I had mine done at 14 and both my mum and I wished I'd had it done sooner. I was in and out in the day and it didn't hurt. If she has what I did its not ears that stick out a bit, it's a condition called batwing ear, where the top part of the ear has no fold. To fix it they just score the cartilage to make the fold, very simple op and dissolvable stitches ect. Trying to tape them is extremely uncomfortable and won't achieve the desired effect. I was never bullied for it but always felt very self conscious and hated wearing my hair up, so I never did. I know some schools insist on it now though. If my DS has the same I'm getting it done as soon as he's old enough, no point waiting in my view.

PrincessConsuelaBannanaHammock · 25/09/2018 15:44

I had it done when I was around 9 I think. It was sore but I'm so glad I had it done. Mum said the change in my confidence after I had it done was unbelievable. It was sore but it was really worth it in my case. 3 might be a bit young but at least you know it is an option
Gp would be the best place to start.

LightDrizzle · 25/09/2018 15:41

I’m 47 and had mine done at 8, my step-daughter had hers done at 7.
Neither of us experienced teasing prior to them being done and our parents managed it without making us feel self-conscious or inadequate as we were. I think doing it before secondary but at an age when they can understand is probably a good idea.
It’s not very painful as no big muscle groups are involved.

Spaghettijumper · 25/09/2018 15:40

'Except anyone who has ears as the OP has described will tell you that just because you think it is innocuous and not important does mean that they feel that way. GA is very safe and yes whilst its tragic that sometimes things go wrong you cannot live life worrying that you will be the small minority, I assume you don't react that way to driving your child about.'

I see what you're saying HeadsDown. I agree you can't live your life worrying that you will be the small minority but I also think you can't live your life worrying about what people you don't even know or care about think about your ears, to the extent you get medical treatment to make yourself more acceptable to them. Yes people say nasty things but I don't think the sensible response to that is to say 'I will go and change myself because you don't like how I look'

HeadsDownThumbsUpEveryone · 25/09/2018 15:36

no way on earth I'd do it for something as innocuous as sticky out ears

Except anyone who has ears as the OP has described will tell you that just because you think it is innocuous and not important does mean that they feel that way. GA is very safe and yes whilst its tragic that sometimes things go wrong you cannot live life worrying that you will be the small minority, I assume you don't react that way to driving your child about Hmm.

OP I think it is incredibly considerate to be thinking about the impact on your daughter and I would certainly speak to the GP about the option of using tape. It would be much easier if you could sort it out before she grew too much older. There's no need to wait and risk her being unhappy about her appearance when the fix is so simple and easy.

possumgoddess · 25/09/2018 15:35

My daughter had it done at 8. She was very self conscious about her ears. She had huge bandages on for a couple of weeks but didn't complain about being in pain. I hope she wasn't.... If so she never said! She also had train track braces as a teenager, she was always beautiful to me but she is now beautiful (stunning in fact) to everyone. X

SummerStrong · 25/09/2018 15:31

I have a friend who's DD had her ears pinned back in the summer between primary and secondary school.

She was old enough to know she wanted it and resilient enough to put up with the pain etc. It was her idea.

She went into high school much more confident and most of her new friends didn't even know her before.

I think younger than that is a bit extreme.

Soubriquet · 25/09/2018 15:31

I had mine done when I was 11.

My doctor actually recommended it. It hurt. A lot

And the scarring hurts if I wear sunglasses but I don’t regret getting it done

Tinty · 25/09/2018 15:30

My DNephew had really prominent sticking out ears at 3 but at 11 they are not nearly so prominent and are a lot less noticeable. They probably stick out a bit more than some DC but not as obviously as when he was little. She may grow and they may not stick out so much.

Maybe try the tape (if you can get her to tolerate it), whilst she is little.

hopefullyhelpfully · 25/09/2018 15:29

I taped my DDs ear when she was little (6 mo?) Due to various pregnancy complications one ear was out st a 90 degree angle. Taping worked in a couple of months.

Helenluvsrob · 25/09/2018 15:28

Just to add balance my youngest has ears that made her look like goblin as a baby they stuck out so well .... we sat ent about glue ear when she was 3 and the surgeon said “ let us know when they bother her and we’ll do them”
Well she’s 19 now and apart from her siblings annoying her she’s not had any trouble . She’s quite happy in her skin. I’m very proud of that but would have had them done if she’d wanted.
I’d wait till she is bothered and wants them doing. I worry about setting kids up for a lifetime of “ I’m not perfect enough” though.

Sirzy · 25/09/2018 15:27

I had mine pinned back at 10, I don’t for a second regret it but it was my decision to have it done, I was able to understand the after care needed, the process itself and the fact it would be painful (and it was)

Personally I wouldn’t put a child through an operation for purely cosmetic reasons at such a young age. I think such things they need to be able to understand it and want it themselves.

Spaghettijumper · 25/09/2018 15:27

There's no way I'd be allowing my child to go under general anaesthetic unless she absolutely had to - no way on earth I'd do it for something as innocuous as sticky out ears. GA is pretty safe but it's still a fact that every year a number of people are put under and never come out of it. That's not a risk I'd be taking when you could just accept that she's not 100% perfect and support her in going through a world where some people are arseholes knowing that she doesn't have to have surgery to make herself more acceptable.

Thingsthatgo · 25/09/2018 15:25

Thanks for all of your advice and opinions. I know 3 is very young to start thinking about it, I guess it’s on my mind because she starts school next year, and it occurred to me that I should consider doing something about it before it even becomes a problem. My ears stick out, and it doesn’t bother me much, but hers are at such an angle that I think it’ll be an issue.

OP posts:
schnubbins · 25/09/2018 15:24

No , if she had crooked or prominent teeth you would get them fixed also. I was a paediatric nurse and we often had children coming in for this procedure.Once we has four siblings come together to have it done.I will never forget their little faces post op. when the bandages came off.You may have to wait a little while until she is older but its worth looking into now.

Lellochip · 25/09/2018 15:22

OP look at earfold.co.uk - might be an easier option than usual surgery? I know nothing about it other than stumbling across it once and thinking it looked good so can't give more info than that, but just thought if there's a simpler surgical solution you could wait and see if it bothers her, without the pressure of sorting it before she's aware?

TallulahBetty · 25/09/2018 15:19

BIL had his done at 12. 20 years ago. He had no regrets

Mumminmum · 25/09/2018 15:18

A study showed that pinning the ears with tape can work as long as the child is under 8 years old, so go for it.

ItWentInMyEye · 25/09/2018 15:18

One of my closest friends at primary school had hers done at about 8 and loved the results. It gave her so much more confidence in herself.

SgtFredColon · 25/09/2018 15:14

My sisters both had it as adults and both wished it had been done when they were kids.