Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to consider ear pinning for my dd?

116 replies

Thingsthatgo · 25/09/2018 14:45

My Dd is three. Her ears stick out a lot, and also have a batwing look to them. At the moment her hair covers them (she has curly hair), but if we tie it back they are extremely prominent. The idea of her having surgery that is unnecessary is awful, but I really think that her ears are going to cause her a lot of grief when she is older. I wonder if it is worth doing it before she is very aware of the situation. Please let me know your experiences of ear pinning surgery.
How do I go about it? Gp first? I am not expecting the nhs to pay for it, but I would like advice from a gp.

OP posts:
NoTeaNoShadeNoPinkLemonade · 25/09/2018 21:17

Put ear defenders on while she sleeps (while you're awake) take them off before you go to bed. We discovered this method by accident Grin

apostropheuse · 25/09/2018 21:12

My cousin had hers pinned back aged 3 in 1975. Hers were particularly severe, so I'm sure it was the right thing for her parents to do. She coped very well with the surgery. I think YANBU

Polkapjs · 25/09/2018 21:00

I would wait until she’s older but try tape if non-invasive
Mine stick out terribly and I hate them and am now considering surgery for myself - I’d be interested to know how long it takes and what the cost and recovery is like - sorry to hijack

BlackBeltInChildWrangling · 25/09/2018 20:22

I think Oobis is talking about another body part altogether from another thread Grin

Moody123 · 25/09/2018 20:17

I would do it op! I got bullied for something surgery could have fixed when I was little, it was awful x

Oobis · 25/09/2018 20:00

You don't have to have DH there if you don't want to. Maybe worth reminding him of that?
This is a medical procedure, a particularly intimate, frightening and emotional one, the experience of which will remain with you forever. Don't let it be hijacked by over excited relatives. I'm sure they mean well, but a couple of hours won't make any difference to their relationship with your baby.
All the best 😘

El1995 · 25/09/2018 19:57

Never had mine done but wished my parents had done it when I was little, my right ear is normal but due to how I laid as a baby, my left one sticks out, bleh!

Theresahairbrushinthefridge · 25/09/2018 19:46

My daughter (9) finds hats and helmets really uncomfortable due to her ears.

She has poker straight hair, one deformed ear and both very very prominent.

She has not asked to do anything yet but we will when she asks. My mother had the same problem and ha hers done at 65 after years of feeling self conscious. She is definitely in the pro camp.

Thingsthatgo · 25/09/2018 19:26

Iots for me to think about, thank you all. I had my teeth fixed with braces as a teenager, and I’m glad that I did (purely cosmetic reasons and I needed a ga for tooth extraction). I kinda think of ear pinning along the same lines, but I do understand the point of view that it’s more about confidence than looks. Her ears (if she doesn’t grow into them), are outside of the norms of ‘sticky out ears’, so maybe it’s less about cosmetic surgery and more corrective surgery, in the same way someone might remove an extra digit or similar.

OP posts:
BlackBeltInChildWrangling · 25/09/2018 18:48

Bugs Bunny and Radar here. Yes, honestly. YABU.

I don't know why, but I'm half-expecting this thread to go pffft, partly because so many of these seem to, like the recent 'less pretty' DD and the school jumper threads.

InstagramPork · 25/09/2018 18:36

SD had her’s pinned back just before her 5th birthday... she’s 13 now and looking back at pics it was sooooo worth it.
Unfortunately her mum was too lazy to follow the aftercare routine properly (didn’t change dressings or insist on her wearing the post-sugery headband) which led to one ear “popping” back forwards slightly but they’re still 100x better than before.

Kidneyvback · 25/09/2018 18:32

A friend of mine had it done when we were early teens. Did an A amazing job and she was much happier. Bit she was old enough and asked for it. Wait few years and see how she feels x

Eggoispreggo · 25/09/2018 18:29

I'd wait for her to be a little bit older and talk to her about it if comments from other kids start.
My little brother's ears were always worse than mine and he wanted it done when he was about 6 or 7 on their medical insurance at the time.
I decided I didn't, then regretted that in high school when parents couldn't afford it. Paid for it to be done privately myself when I was about 22 and am so, so, so pleased I did.
So I'd wait until she can express her own thoughts about it, then find a private surgeon as mine are much better done than my brothers and it didn't cost the earth.

AlpacaRabbit · 25/09/2018 18:06

We used the ear buddies tape system in our baby and were very pleased with the results. They recommend starting much earlier than 3 but have apparently had success at age 4. I suspect, however, the taping process would be quite prolonged with older children.

www.earbuddies.co.uk/pages/faqs

Surgery can be done later, although probably only very rarely on the NHS.

Racecardriver · 25/09/2018 17:54

But what if sticky outy ears become the height of fashion? After slug brows and tooth gaps I wouldn't be surprised.

divadee · 25/09/2018 17:47

Taping only works under the age of 18-24 months after that it is pointless. I would go and speak to your gp and go from there.

GoodHeavensNoImAChicken · 25/09/2018 17:38

I’d say go for it. I would personally and I think you’re right to look into it so early so you can nib it in the bud before her teens. The anaesthetic would be quick and she’d be back on her feet in no time

Bloodyfucksake · 25/09/2018 17:14

Just let my 9 year old have it done. His confidence has just increased more than you can imagine. He was always hiding behind his floppy long hair. Now he has a normal hair cut and you can see his lovely face.
I did wait for him to ask though. I knew he would the minute he came home saying 'such and such called me Dumbo

Jenjenyeahyeah · 25/09/2018 17:14

I had mine done at 23 depite begging my parents from about the age of 7 to have them done. I wish I could have got them done as a child.
They stuck out a lot, I hated when I had to wear my hair back and would carefully pull the hair over the ears to hold them down, if my hair was down I was always fluffing it up to stop my ears from sticking through. I know it’s only an appearance thing, but it did have an effect on me and leave an imprint on my childhood that could have been avoided. Children are mean and big ear jokes (FA cup, dumbo etc etc) are horrid to have to put up with.
If she is happy to have it done I’d say go for it as soon as possible

Fstar · 25/09/2018 17:12

Im not sure on the process however i had mine done when i was 8ish. Im so glad i had it done, for many years (now 37) i still felt they stuck out a bit and because i was made fun of very young i was scared to wear my hair up in public. Only now am i brave enough to do it. If i had t had the op it would have been much worse.

Pain wise it was ok, i remember wearing a big bandage on my head and not being able to wash my hair, it hurt getting stiches out but im sure it will be better these days.

I read an article years ago about a lady putting a soft headband on her baby at night time and over time they started to look etter and stick out less, not sure if a DR would advise that though

mononoaware1907 · 25/09/2018 17:08

I had mine aged 20. I really wish I done it earlier. They're PERFECT now. Back when I was a child plastic surgery wasn't popular

I strongly recommend it your consider it. A bit painful after, but v quick recovery. I think you can do it when's she's 5, so her ears are in the "final" shape

FabulousTomatoes · 25/09/2018 17:06

As a concept it’s no different to having braces to improve teeth. Both my dds have them and their teeth weren’t even that bad! I’d just get it done op.

Mushroomsarehorrible · 25/09/2018 17:01

to the extent you get medical treatment to make yourself more acceptable to them

It's not about that though, it's about looking in the mirror and the first thing you see are you ears sticking out. Not being comfortable with having your hair in a ponytail. My ex step son had his pinned back because he was teased at school. He went into school a confident little boy but the teasing wore him down, post op he was back to his confident self. GAs are extremely safe now. And as someone rightly said upthread, do you travel with your children by car? A quick search on the net renders the following result

The odds of dying in a car accident in a given year in the United States are about 1/10,000. Mortality attributable to general anesthesia is less than 1/100,000

BabySharkAteMyHamster · 25/09/2018 16:28

As someone sho grew up with the nickname 'trumpet ears ' YANBU !!!

Spaghettijumper · 25/09/2018 16:18

'Unfortunately some children (and even adults) will comment, tease or bully on anything, real or imagined, and so I've tried to bring my DCs up to recognise that, be resilient to it, laugh at themselves and the bullies, and then we deal with anything more serious very directly. I'm sure you love her just the way she is, OP, and I would help her to grow up just loving and accepting herself and, as importantly, to be kind to others. Tape or surgery, especially at this young age, will draw attention to it for her, and make it an issue for her - at the moment it's just an issue for you.'

I agree entirely with this. If you respond to bullying/teasing (or even possible bullying and teasing in this case) by changing yourself, it can become a slippery slope where one thing is fixed but you still don't feel right, so you fix something else - trying to be so perfect that no one will ever comment on you is a fool's errand - everyone gets comments and looks and nasty remarks and the aim should be to simply not care about stupid comments.