Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to consider ear pinning for my dd?

116 replies

Thingsthatgo · 25/09/2018 14:45

My Dd is three. Her ears stick out a lot, and also have a batwing look to them. At the moment her hair covers them (she has curly hair), but if we tie it back they are extremely prominent. The idea of her having surgery that is unnecessary is awful, but I really think that her ears are going to cause her a lot of grief when she is older. I wonder if it is worth doing it before she is very aware of the situation. Please let me know your experiences of ear pinning surgery.
How do I go about it? Gp first? I am not expecting the nhs to pay for it, but I would like advice from a gp.

OP posts:
t00dle00 · 28/09/2018 08:27

My husband had it done as a teen and wished his parents had ok'd the op done sooner. He was 14 when he got his ears done and has no regrets.

Namechanger55555 · 28/09/2018 08:15

I had mine done at 7 or 8.

I found the process of being in hospital, the anaesthetic etc fascinating.

It was painful though. I remember the doctor not believing me 3 weeks as I remember crying so much at changing the bandage every day. I did get a slight infection I believe.

Didn't regret it though. My ears look great now Smile

I think maybe wait until she's 5 when she can decide for herself if she wants it done through. As at 5 she will understand a bit more which is important for post op when she's in pain and why and why it's important to do all the bandage changing and cleaning etc.

Laiste · 28/09/2018 07:49

I think with regards to what we said to her about getting it done - at 3 or 4 they're really not that aware about big issues if you don't make them one. IIRC i said something about sorting her ears so i don't keep catching them with the hairbrush, or whatever. And played up the fun she'd have with the toys in the ward and the chocolate/toy i would get her afterwards.

Part of parenting is making hard decisions and then downplaying them so all goes smoothly. I've got a photo of DD in our old house with her bandage round her head, holding her new toy and grinning away. It was just two or three of weeks of her life 20 years ago.

BlueJava · 28/09/2018 07:43

My ears were amazingly "sticky-outy" which is what I used to call them. But they fixed themselves over time, I often used to lay in bed on one side though to try and make them lay flat.

Laiste · 28/09/2018 07:40

Haven't RTFT but just wanted to say that when one of my DDs was 3 or 4 we got this done and (she's 23 now) she's eternally grateful! She looks at pics of herself pre op and says ''thanks for getting it done mum''.

I had the same worries as you and as a little one she looked super cute before the op. What's cute at 3 isn't so cute as an adult though so we went for it though and it was all fine.

Chembe · 28/09/2018 07:35

I had mine done at 11 after years and years of begging my parents. I was so so sad about my ears, I even had a note explaining I couldn't put my hair up for P. E! I don't recall any pain and I've never been bothered since. I'd wait until she asks but have it done quickly after. It really did plague my childhood and I still don't enjoy seeing photos of me with my "natural" ears.

Saymaname · 28/09/2018 07:31

I had mine done at 18 and wish I’d had them done earlier.

Easynow · 28/09/2018 07:22

I used Earbuddies on DD when she was 6 months old. I think she had them on for around 6 months.

Your DD would need them on for longer as she is older.

WaltzingIntoTheTide · 28/09/2018 07:19

Sirzy - I was a similar age (maybe a bit younger) and my parents said I could have it done if I wanted to but it was my decision. That did help so, OP, as I said earlier, I’m really glad it was a non-issue when I was growing up and I totally understand what your motives are but a caveat to my other post might be that maybe with your dd you might want to wait until she’s a bit older and can be part of the decision so that she can feel confident in making a choice about her own body.

WaltzingIntoTheTide · 28/09/2018 07:13

I had mine pinned back as a child, I’m glad it was a non-issue as I grew up.

The slightly pious posters who have brought their children up to mock the bullies etc etc. We ALL try and bring our children up like that but bullying happens and it’s not always possible for even the most resilient child to hold fast against the drip feed of bullying.

The OP is trying to avoid a life ahead where her dd might be bullied or teased about her ears or even worse they might damage her self confidence. Most parents would do the same.

Sirzy · 28/09/2018 07:06

I actually think the process itself with such a young child could be pretty damaging to the self esteem of a child as the only way to explain it is telling them that you, as parents, don’t think she is perfect just as she is so needs an invasive operation to fix her!

Like I said I had mine done at 10, but that was my choice supported by my parents.

NobodyToVoteForNow · 28/09/2018 06:50

Yes, I was bullied a lot regarding my ears. Having said that, there were kids with other 'defects' who didn't get bullied. The fact is, if you're quiet, shy and studious, bullies will find something to make you feel shit about yourself. If you're naturally gregarious and popular you could have a face full of 'defects' and escape relatively unharmed. If my parents had had my ears pinned back it would have sent a strong message to me and the bullies that they had been right all along, that 'sticky out ears' are indeed 'wrong', rather than a normal, common, harmless variation. And do you know what? The bullies would have found something else about me that was 'wrong'. Where does this kind of deference to bullies end? A nose job? Skin lightening? A boob job for flat chested teenage girls?

I have to say that as an adult i barely notice my ears and i wouldn't change them

barcodescanner · 28/09/2018 06:47

I had mine done at 13 i wish they'd been done when i was younger. Worst thing about it was not being able to wash my hair for ages after.

I think it's a much simpler op now than it was then

wtfhaveijustread · 28/09/2018 01:06

Had mine done at 14 after years of bullying! Best things my parents done for me only thing is I wish they had done it sooner!!!

florenceheadache · 28/09/2018 01:05

as per dr.google...it can be performed anytime after the ears are fully formed usually after the age of 5.

KittysMyName · 27/09/2018 23:08

Please wait, 3 is so young! My daughters ears stuck out but she’s 6 now and they seem to have sorted themselves out.

Olderbyaminute · 27/09/2018 22:39

I wonder if the previous posters on here have ever been bullied for looking different than their peer group? I had a severe overbite and got bullied over it affected my self esteem greatly and then at 15 I received braces and at 17 I got them removed and literally that night I never felt self conscious about my teeth again-in fact always got compliments on my smile after. I just saw a little boy at a restaurant and his ears were so prominent I immediately felt sure he would be bullied in the future. You aren’t wrong for trying to protect your child.

BlackBeltInChildWrangling · 26/09/2018 01:44

Not everything that others think is 'wrong' with you, or you think is 'wrong' with you, or your DC thinks is 'wrong' with themselves, or you think is 'wrong' with your DC, can be fixed with an operation, brace or whatever. What do you do then?

gttia · 25/09/2018 21:39

I had mine done age ten and wouldn't hesitate to have my daughter's done

Vinylsamso · 25/09/2018 21:38

Attractive sounds weird. They’re 7. I meant the most handsome faces.

Vinylsamso · 25/09/2018 21:38

The 3 most attractive boys in my Sons class all have sticky out ears. They all suit them!

NobodyToVoteForNow · 25/09/2018 21:33

And for the record, my ds has inherited my ears and they look absolutely gorgeous on him - nobody has ever made any negative comments - they suit his face and his features.

Vinylsamso · 25/09/2018 21:32

I know you’re doing it for her but it breaks my heart to think of you sitting in the Docs with her listening, telling him that there’s something wrong with her ears because it’s something she innocently won’t have even considered yet ☹️
If you’re going private could you go without her to first appointment to explain and then just act as though it’s a sort of routine procedure to her? “Oh you need to have an operation on your ears to make it easier for you to hear or some other excuse” - that sounds awful just writing it down but I’d rather lie than let her hear that it’s because she doesn’t look right. It’s breaking my heart just thinking about it!
I don’t know what I’d do because it’s heart breaking the idea they’ll be teased but equally sad to fix it.
I think I’d just open up dialogue a lot about how everyone’s different. Maybe pointing out funny things in myself and try to be open about things I’ve been teased about and how it made me feel but how ultimately it’s not the end of the world and that we can laugh at ourselves. The worst thing would be that she’s teased but feels too ashamed to tell you. If you can get her to come to you about things like this then you could offer it as soon as she brings it up? Good luck x

NobodyToVoteForNow · 25/09/2018 21:30

I've had sticky out ears my whole life. My mum used to tell me I was perfect just as I was, and that i didn't need to change myself for anyone. It took me a while, but do you know what? She was exactly right.

And now when my dcs tell me they don't like the dark hair on their arms/ gap between their teeth/ freckles / whatever, I hug them and tell them the same thing - they're perfect just as they are. Where do you draw the line? Braces are different because without them you can lose the ability to speak clearly and eat properly. Dentists don't give you much of a choice, they just make the referral for this reason.

llangennith · 25/09/2018 21:29

DD1 now 48 had hers done 40 years ago, so she was 8. When she looks at photos of herself before the op she always says she's so glad she had them done before she went to high school. It's not painful though the ears are tender to touch for a few days after and patients feel a bit nauseous after the op and anaesthetic.