Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brave The Shave - NOT IN MY NAME

340 replies

TwitterQueen1 · 25/08/2018 17:25

I know IANBU but posting here for traffic.

I see Macmillan is now advertising BTS on tv. It doesn't seem to matter how many of us protest that the whole campaign:

  • is extremely offensive and upsetting
  • trivialises and minimises the effects of chemo
  • claims that it makes people understand what it's like to have cancer

Would you paint black and bruises on your face to 'show support' for victims of DV?

Would you tie one leg behind your back and hop around town to 'show support' for those with disabilities?

  • Do you know that Macmillan are asking those who've done BTS is "How are enjoying your new look?" or even worse - "Hope you're enjoying your new look!" WT actual Fuck. I mean, us cancer patients absolutely ADORE losing all our hair and feeling like total shit for months.... and random healthy strangers indulging in narcissistic, attention-grabbing stunts makes us feel even better. Angry

And (in response to my complaint) these offensive statements apparently fall within Macmillan's social media guidelines'?

Bathe in baked beans, run marathons, walk a mile, hold coffee mornings.... do ANYTHING ELSE, but don't pretend for a second that shaving your head helps you understand how cancer patients feel. You have absolutely no idea at all. None.

OP posts:
Septima · 25/08/2018 20:07

I think they care more about the money than anything else. I suppose they’ll claim that the end justifies the means, but I think it’s cynical at best and totally dismissive at worst.

HelenaDove · 25/08/2018 20:05

Oh Blimey i didnt know that No chemo specifically for children Shock i also didnt realize about the runny nose problem

Both things ive learned from MN not Macmillan.

LunaLovegoodsRadishes · 25/08/2018 20:04

My dB had a lymphoma a few years back.

I agree with OP on everything she said.

My dB had thick curly hair. I saw him (we live miles and miles apart) just before he started treatment. I visited him on his good days or when his partner said it was ok to come (when he wasn’t in hospital with dangerous infections, throwing up or sleeping for days on end).

We never told him he was brave. We never said how epic he was. We just said, get through this day, until the next one. Stick with it. We can only hope it’ll pay off. And it did. He’s been lymphoma free for about four years now.

But his thick curly hair never grew back as it was. It’s now fine, and straight, and barely there. DB says it doesn’t bother him but he wears hats more when he goes out, and keeps it very short. I know he misses it. He’s alive, but he’s lost a little bit of himself. His beard also didn’t grow back right either.

So no, BTS is a shit idea, because my brother cannot grow his hair back like it was before chemo. Because he lost a bit of his identity. Because he had to quickly adapt to a new image, which is quite important to most people. It should be stopped. It’s insensitive.

AnoukSpirit · 25/08/2018 20:02

This is why I stay away from any media presence by cancer charities and have them blocked on SM.

Their fundraising arms don't give a shit about the distress and trauma their campaigns cause as long as it brings in donations. They do not fucking care.

Their ignorant shock campaigns after I helplessly watched my parent suffer and then die from cancer were fucking torture. Did my parent need to be confronted with that horrific bullshit as they were dying? Hell no. But you're not allowed to say anything because "but it's a good cause".

Yes, fine, but is it necessary to fucking traumatise those of us who've had the misfortune to actually be affected by the disease in question and are therefore the people their charity supposedly exists to help?

And anybody trying to tone police people on this needs to wind their fucking neck in. People have a right to be angry and distressed and to express that without being criticised or silenced.

GhostPerfume · 25/08/2018 20:00

I agree I don't like it

CherryPavlova · 25/08/2018 19:57

I too have contacted Macmillan and said this is a deeply offensive campaign to many. The concerns by many who have been through chemo fall on deaf ears.

It is not brave it’s a haircut.
It does not show solidarity - unless you shave off literally all your hair, everywhere and have streaming eyes and runny nose.
The idea some people will have a laugh whilst mimicking one of the most traumatic side effects is ‘brave’ is at best insulting. One wouldn’t do a sponsored shake for epilepsy awareness, or a sponsored crawl in camouflage clothing for help the hero.

People will say “It’s a bit of fun” and the complainers are “over sensitive” but same was said of black and white minstrels and gollywogs until most people realised what the message these were giving out was.
Please stop Macmillan. There are other, far braver ways.

user1457017537 · 25/08/2018 19:54

I was speaking to someone yesterday who is a healthcare professional. During the conversation a certain type of chemotherapy came as I was querying the truly appalling side effects a friend had had.
She said they use that on children and that there still isn’t a chemo specifically for children. Now I don’t know if she is correct, but if she is why not? Billions of pounds have been raised to fund cancer cures. Where does all the money go?

EdWinchester · 25/08/2018 19:53

I totally agree and have been ranting over these adverts.

It's insensitive and crass. Raise money by all means but do it in a way that won't cause offence or isn't attention seeking.

Gonegrey31 · 25/08/2018 19:53

I’m absolutely with you on this Twitter Queen.

Minniemountain · 25/08/2018 19:51

I did a search to find out more about MacM's idea. It brought up a Sun "story" knicking a similar thread from MN in 2016.

So clearly they don't give a crap what actual cancer patients think as it raises lots of money.

helpawomanout · 25/08/2018 19:50

My best friend is going through chemo now and it's heartbreaking. 4 months ago she asked me to shave her head as it was all falling out and she couldn't take it anymore. She was silently sobbing as I turned the clippers on so out of sympathy I gave the clippers to her and sat in front of the mirror so she could do mine first. The smile on her face was one I'll never forget and the 'bald besties' photo frame she made me is one of my most precious treasures.

To sum up, I can see why people do it out of sympathy and solidarity however it was not a "fun" experience and mine grew back so it was a hell of a lot easier for me to do than her having to do it because she was potentially dying. Huge difference not to be ignored. Definitely not something to be made light of.

KatyMac · 25/08/2018 19:50

My dad was a writer - he had lung cancer and 22 months later he died

During that time he wrote a book - his intent was to self-publish as an ebook and raise money for cancer research - he died before it happened and the charities weren't interested in a book from someone who had died and couldn't publicise it

But he wrote this:
"‘Brave Doreen (or whoever) finally lost her battle for life against cancer.’ – Even before my present circumstances became apparent I almost used to scream at this trite sentence; invariably trotted out by newspapers and magazines. The implication of it is quite awful. Poor Doreen (or whoever) would have made it if she’d just fought harder or more cleverly. It’s just the most cheap, insulting epitaph ever coined."

Elderflower14 · 25/08/2018 19:49

My Ds2 shaved his head just before my DP died of cancer in Jan. My DP died three days later. Ds2 stood up to do his eulogy at the funeral with his head shaved. He made £600 for CRUK....

user1457017537 · 25/08/2018 19:49

Not in my name either. Can’t say how much I despise the “fight cancer” ideology as well, as if you didn’t try hard enough if you “lost the battle”. If anyone comes near me or mine mouthing any of this crap they will seriously be sorry.

Mrsmadevans · 25/08/2018 19:48

Totally agree with you Twitter Queen

HelenaDove · 25/08/2018 19:46

DHs mum died of breast cancer in 1973 Exactly six weeks before i was born so i never met her. She was 46 DH was 23 at the time.

stevie69 · 25/08/2018 19:43

This has made me quite sad Sad

For those of you suffering in any way, I wish you all the love and strength in the world.

I shave my head. Am I an attention seeker? Not consciously, no; it does provoke opinion though. Do I profess to understand how people suffering illness and unwanted hair loss feel? No, of course not. It's just my style of choice Blush

TwitterQueen1 · 25/08/2018 19:42

I agree with you in principle but your aggressive attitude is unpleasant and unnecessary. You don't have a monopoly on cancer and the agony and distress it generates.

I'm now laughing at the 2 posters who have posted this.... I'm SO sorry if my aggression is upsetting you... [not]. I should of course be sitting quietly in a corner being terribly polite and muttering quietly to myself and being a good, quiet cancer patient.

And, for the record, I don't claim to have a monopoly on cancer or on agony or distress. This post is about one specific campaign that I strongly disagree with.

OP posts:
onetimeposter · 25/08/2018 19:40

Totally agree.
Macmillan's whole fundraising strategy is sick imo. The asverts are triggering to those with cancer and their families and bereaved people. Someone with cancer sat having their tea and seeing that on telly, having had a good day, must be plunged back into the abyss.
BTS is also highly distasteful. Like the analogy to DV and disability.

doodlejump1980 · 25/08/2018 19:39

Thankyou to all the previous posters who have articulated my thoughts more eloquently than I could ever put down on paper.
My Mum died of metastatic breast cancer 5 years ago, and I’ve had trouble putting my thoughts on BTS together. It just doesn’t sit right with me at all.
Flowers and whatever doesn’t taste like crap to those who are going through it at the mo.
“If you’re going through Hell, keep going!”

Pigeonpresent · 25/08/2018 19:38

I agree OP

CatkinToadflax · 25/08/2018 19:38

I agree. Am a HCP with Macmillan in my job title! A number of us discussed this with the fundraising team at an annual conference Macmillan do for us. They said they'd "take our comments on board". This was last year, so guess someone somewhere still thinks it's a money earner.

Unfortunately, it seems to me, the larger the charity with the bigger the fundraising budget, the less interested they are in the opinions of their stakeholders. The result is that the fundraising team has the power to effectively just get on with it and do what they want. I am extremely lucky to have no immediately personal experience of cancer, but I do of extreme prematurity. One of the baby charities has repeatedly produced campaigns that have offended me and others in my situation, and when we raised our concerns with the charity it simply wasn't interested. It wanted to raise money and get attention but didn't seem to care how it did it. This is very likely the same with BTS - did Macmillan actually discuss the concept with their stakeholders and did they listen to their answers?

BTW, I am a professional charity fundraiser for a tiny charity with a tiny budget. Without our stakeholders we are nothing, and I hope our compassion shines through for them during our budget on a shoestring campaigns and fundraising.

Flowers to all of you affected by cancer, chemo and everything that goes with them x

Penninepain · 25/08/2018 19:36

On a really small level, when I was going through treatment, and for a year or so afterwards, friends and family had a daft thing going whereby if they were doing anything, well, frivolous, I suppose they put a fiver in the pot.
Going out with friends for a curry? Stick a fiver in the pot. Going on a luxury cruise? Stick a fiver in the pot.
We called it the 'Piss Pot' ( simply because we were pissed off with not just me, but a couple of people in our social circle being diagnosed).

In three years we raised over £3k. No fanfares, no over the top gestures and no bankrupting ourselves.

So the 'there by the grace of God' fund does it for me 😁

IGiorni · 25/08/2018 19:35

I know someone who did it and live streamed it on social media, talking about how scared she was. My husband has a number 1 cut all over and her hair didn’t end up as short as his. After about a week, she started wearing a wig, then got extensions when it had grown back enough. She’s made comments on Facebook about shaving it again “because it’s so much easier” Hmm Bit different when you have a choice!

Namechangeforthiscancershit · 25/08/2018 19:34

Cancer Resarch have an excellent point but it should have been part of the same campaign that some of the cancer treatment itself can cause weight gain

This is a really good point. I didn’t ask for
The weight gain and don’t want to be judged on it. Or the early menopause coming to that. Or any of the other shit!

Swipe left for the next trending thread