Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brave The Shave - NOT IN MY NAME

340 replies

TwitterQueen1 · 25/08/2018 17:25

I know IANBU but posting here for traffic.

I see Macmillan is now advertising BTS on tv. It doesn't seem to matter how many of us protest that the whole campaign:

  • is extremely offensive and upsetting
  • trivialises and minimises the effects of chemo
  • claims that it makes people understand what it's like to have cancer

Would you paint black and bruises on your face to 'show support' for victims of DV?

Would you tie one leg behind your back and hop around town to 'show support' for those with disabilities?

  • Do you know that Macmillan are asking those who've done BTS is "How are enjoying your new look?" or even worse - "Hope you're enjoying your new look!" WT actual Fuck. I mean, us cancer patients absolutely ADORE losing all our hair and feeling like total shit for months.... and random healthy strangers indulging in narcissistic, attention-grabbing stunts makes us feel even better. Angry

And (in response to my complaint) these offensive statements apparently fall within Macmillan's social media guidelines'?

Bathe in baked beans, run marathons, walk a mile, hold coffee mornings.... do ANYTHING ELSE, but don't pretend for a second that shaving your head helps you understand how cancer patients feel. You have absolutely no idea at all. None.

OP posts:
Maldives2006 · 25/08/2018 21:29

There’s hardly any medicines that are licences for use in children because it’s too difficult to obtain ethical approval to test medication on children.

Children’s chemo regimes have been developed very carefully over the years. By experts who have worked out safe ratios.

lovelychops · 25/08/2018 21:29

In answer to a previous poster - the amount of research into children's cancers is almost none existent. It's why I don't donate to cancer research.
Agree with posters who despise the 'stay strong' rhetoric. When my DD has cancer it's all anyone said to us... I know people mean well and don't know what to say... but I spent so long hiding my real fears I almost had a breakdown...
anyway. Glad to read this thread. Best wishes to all

iVampire · 25/08/2018 21:29

Not in my name either please,

(BTW cutting your hair and donating it to Little Princess isn’t the same as this Macmillan campaign by a long way)

silkpyjamasallday · 25/08/2018 21:24

I was planning on shaving my head to raise money, before the BTS was on my radar, and then donate my hair to the Little Princess Trust. I wanted to do something to raise money for the hospice in which my beloved MIL died a month after her cancer diagnosis, and to help to provide a wig for a child going through chemo - which I know can be a great comfort from friends who had cancer in childhood.

I can't run a marathon due to arthritis, I certainly can't afford to donate a large sum of money myself, but I can inform family and friends what I am doing and ask if they would like to sponsor or donate. I don't have social media, I won't be publicising it beyond our friends and family, it certainly isn't coming from a place of narcisim, I have more than two feet of untreated good condition hair which could bring someone else a tiny bit of comfort or cheer during a devastating time and raise a lot of money for the hospice which relies on donations and receives no other funding. Perhaps I should rethink though if people find it so offensive, MIL certainly wouldn't have but it is clear that many people on here would find it distressing to see or hear about.

I can only concur that the 'fighting','brave' rhetoric around cancer is damaging and hurtful, I hated seeing it when MIL was ill, it was terminal from the diagnosis only a month before she died, and no amount of fighting or bravery was going to help. Flowers

bobstersmum · 25/08/2018 21:22

Wishing you the very best TwitterQueen, yanbu

user1471450935 · 25/08/2018 21:18

Not every one would agree with you Op
Sorry for all the cancer sufferers, but Ds1 (18 now) shaved his head when in year 10, lovely girl, died last year, was coming back to school, bog standard comprehensive, and was truly sick with worry she would stand out and didn't want to, her parents asked if anyone would go bald to stand next to her, all 31 in her form did.
Her mum still thanks Ds and friends for putting a smile on her daughters face.
We no longer give to cancer charities, sick of all the hype, we give to PSP and other worth while charities no one gives a fuck about, all you ever hear about is people fighting cancer, and many have similar angry nasty attitudes as the Op.

Septima · 25/08/2018 21:10

We sometimes have Macmillan nurses who visit people in the nursing homes, but we’re already trained in palliative and cancer care so are already doing all the things the Macmillan nurse tells us to do Hmm nursing is nursing regardless of the disease involved and palliative care isn’t rocket science. These nurses don’t have special powers.

When my late dh was ill one came round to the house and had a cup of tea and talked about herself then never came back.

I reckon all the money they raise mainly goes on keeping the head honchos in jobs. They don’t even employ most of the nurses they train, the nhs employs them.

fleshmarketclose · 25/08/2018 21:06

Well said OP couldn't agree more.

No need to shave your head to donate hair to the little princess trust either. Dd donated 15 inches of hair when she decided to go short, no fanfares just a jiffy bag and padded envelope and I popped in a cheque to help cover the costs of using her hair.

yolofish · 25/08/2018 21:00

I suppose the point is that the big charities are big businesses. Our Charlotte was featured in photo shoot for Clic Sargent. She and her mum were absolutely appalled when they went for the shoot by the high end offices that Clic Sargent have. And when you start to look into what senior management of eg CRUK earn, its quite a shocking amount. A very shocking amount.

And they all give out the blah about £1 spent earns us £3 more (or whatever their ratio is) but they spend a LOT of money on resources, staff etc, and then they choose to focus their research spend on the areas where they can make a quick and easy difference.

Look at the difference in spend on breast cancer and brain cancer (and I mean absolutely no disrepect to those with breat cancer) but breast cancer is now relatively easy to treat; survival rates have gone up enormously, and if the worst comes to the worst then a mastectomy does not mean end of life. Whereas with a malignant brain tumour: no new drugs since 1999, because it is an expensive, difficult, time-consuming area to research. And eventually, with a malignant brain tumour you will die, because surgery, chemo, radio and meds cannot offer a solution at the moment.

Brain cancer recieves only 1 per cent of national cancer research funding; yet in the words of one consultant I work with "if we can beat brain cancer we can beat any other cancer".

I dont know the answer: I am lucky to have survived two melanomas with maybe a 3rd on the way. What I do know is that the cancer patient and their family shoudl have more of an input into the messages that are put out.

Ummmmgogo · 25/08/2018 20:50

whats the point in fundraising for Macmillan? all they do is make offensive adverts asking for more money. do they not realise that they are constantly upsetting cancer patients and their families or do they just not care? cancer research can fuck off and all.

ILoveDolly · 25/08/2018 20:50

It seems hard for people to truely believe you have cancer if you don't lose your hair doesn't it twitter
I have quite a recent form of treatment that I can do at home and has no hair loss. Everyone comments about how well I look with enquiring eyes, am I really ill at all, was it lies? ........ I can't usually explain how depressing the diahorreah, acne, sore skin and nose problems, cystitis etc are because its not chemo and those problems are all yukky.

derxa · 25/08/2018 20:48

Macmillan 'discharged' me and my DF. He was dying and in terrible pain. Thank God for our local cottage hospital. They were wonderful.

TwitterQueen1 · 25/08/2018 20:44

That's another brilliant point Dulce... anyone who hasn't lost their hair clearly isn't suffering enough.... you obviously don't have 'real' cancer if you're not bald.....

Similarly, I was looking 'exceptionally well with rosy cheeks'.... no matter how many times I said my latest chemo turned my skin red because it was red in colour.

OP posts:
Badcat666 · 25/08/2018 20:44

Crisps and Mrs Cholly Thank you for posting, I have a rage for them as well.

When my mum and Nan were diagnosed with cancer within months of each other (the types of cancer you have no chance of recovering from) they didn't want anything to do with us even though it was just my sister and I caring for both of them at the same time.

Thank fuck for St Georges hospital and the Princess Alice Hospice.

I'd also like to know what type of cancer patient you need to be for them to get involved.

dramaqueen · 25/08/2018 20:41

Completely agree with you TQ. I was recently diagnosed with BC last month and this advert gives me the rage. Mind you most things gives me the rage at the moment!

Bluelady · 25/08/2018 20:38

I've worked with Macmillan and found them very difficult to deal with. They also spend a huge amount of money on marketing and other backroom functions. Not my favourite charity.

MrsChollySawcutt · 25/08/2018 20:35

Same here Crisps, have yet to meet a Macmillan nurse despite MIL dying of pancreatic cancer last year and DH being 4 years post cancer diagnosis and in ongoing treatment.

I'm unclear what kind of special cancer patient you need to be to warrant their input.

Crispsareafoodgroup · 25/08/2018 20:31

My husband died this year from cancer. We never saw any Macmillan nurses. All the hand holding and squeezing in the adverts makes me angry. I have some rage issues with Macmillan.

lauryloo · 25/08/2018 20:31

I lost all my hair to alopecia and found the brave the shave really insulting from that point of view. Losing all your hair isn’t a choice. I’m just lucky mine wasn’t due to illness

user1457017537 · 25/08/2018 20:28

The point is we shouldn’t be reliant on charity or charities. Aren’t MacMillan paid by the government or the NHS to provide palliative care.

Lightweightstroller · 25/08/2018 20:14

The shame is that charities are all slugging it out for funding. Ever more extreme and “viral” quests are being touted as the thing to do, and the victims are thrown under the bus to get the social media hits.

Only half of the funding of a charity I’m involved in comes from statuary funding- the other half must come from fundraising... for an essential service.

It’s truly outrageous that our services aren’t supported 100% from taxes, as that way we can plan ahead and expand our much needed services..

Meanwhile the public, bless them, are suffering from charity giving fatigue.

It takes ages to come up with a campaign and if there is one already there, well, it’s cheaper to just roll it out again. This is what I suspect is happening with Macmillan.

I do feel for cancer victims and all those who’s hair loss is upsetting, who have to put up with narcissists on insta getting off on the shave..... or the ice bucket or whatever is the thing of the moment....

I also feel for sponsored marathon runners, as they all compete for a smaller pot of public giving.

Personally I despise the “seven mountains in seven days” or peak climbs like Kilimanjaro or Maccu Pichu type of fundraising, as environmentally it’s just disasterous...

I think we need to campaign for proper funding from taxes / government to run such services, (with full regulatory compliance and proper governance of course), rather then having to resort to cheap tricks to sell our services to the public.

It leaves a bad taste in everyone’s mouth, to have a service offered by a charity seen as a product that has to be hawked.

derxa · 25/08/2018 20:10

I've been well for a few years now and try not to think about it all the time but it never really goes away. Yes Lily that's the part that people don't understand.

CountFosco · 25/08/2018 20:09

OK. One in three of us will get cancer at some point in our life. That means 100% of us have been affected by cancer in some way. We all react differently to that and no-one has a monopoly on how cancer and can claim that how they feel is the right way to feel. Macmillian have obviously found this a successful campaign and that raises money to help lots of people however you feel about it.

Me personally, I think it makes it harder again for people like my Dad whose chemo DIDN'T make him bald so we had to deal with everyone being surprised how quickly he died because he didn't have the usual signs of being 'ill with cancer'. MIL and GM didn't have chemo at all since they had breast cancer (treated with radiotherapy and hormone therapy). Still cancer. My parents lovely neighbour that we all still miss 10 years after she died refused treatment. Still cancer. We all know lots of people with cancer and no-one, even if you are dying of it yourself, can dictate how others deal with it.

Lilyhatesjaz · 25/08/2018 20:08

I am fortunate to be well at the moment and didn't have any comments about my weight when I was going through chemo but I did have comments from people that I looked well or didn't look like I had cancer, ya I may look well but I was so anemic from the chemo I had a blood transfusion yesterday. I actually found the mental bit the hardest having to pretend to be strong and not talking about it too much for the sake of DH and my children but being really scared. I've been well for a few years now and try not to think about it all the time but it never really goes away.

Dulcedelecherocks · 25/08/2018 20:07

I'm totally with you my lovely TQ. As someone who hasn't lost hair with chemo, it makes me feel as if i shouldn't be unhappy with my treatment as at least I got to keep my hair. Almost as if I'm a fraud. I can't feel shit because I have hair. Never mind all the other lovely side effects. They don't matter at all.
And to those who think your opinion counts if you haven't had cancer, I'm sorry but it just doesn't. I've seen several relatives suffer from it and when it was me it was a completely different experience. So yeah we do have monopoly even though we don't want it and hopefully you will never join our club.