Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brave The Shave - NOT IN MY NAME

340 replies

TwitterQueen1 · 25/08/2018 17:25

I know IANBU but posting here for traffic.

I see Macmillan is now advertising BTS on tv. It doesn't seem to matter how many of us protest that the whole campaign:

  • is extremely offensive and upsetting
  • trivialises and minimises the effects of chemo
  • claims that it makes people understand what it's like to have cancer

Would you paint black and bruises on your face to 'show support' for victims of DV?

Would you tie one leg behind your back and hop around town to 'show support' for those with disabilities?

  • Do you know that Macmillan are asking those who've done BTS is "How are enjoying your new look?" or even worse - "Hope you're enjoying your new look!" WT actual Fuck. I mean, us cancer patients absolutely ADORE losing all our hair and feeling like total shit for months.... and random healthy strangers indulging in narcissistic, attention-grabbing stunts makes us feel even better. Angry

And (in response to my complaint) these offensive statements apparently fall within Macmillan's social media guidelines'?

Bathe in baked beans, run marathons, walk a mile, hold coffee mornings.... do ANYTHING ELSE, but don't pretend for a second that shaving your head helps you understand how cancer patients feel. You have absolutely no idea at all. None.

OP posts:
Everyoneiswingingit · 25/08/2018 22:45

I didn't know they were doing this. Having lost my DM to cancer and knowing how traumatic her hair loss was, I think this is very wrong.

I have seen others shave hair off for other charities but the comparison with cancer treatment is in bad taste imo.

Claire2313 · 25/08/2018 22:38

Whilst I get that some cancer patients might get some comfort from friends shaving their heads in an act of solidarity (especially those in their teens or younger), I personally would have found it patronising had any of my friends suggested it.
Shaving your head is a drop in the ocean, you don’t get the ‘cancer face’ and your hair will start to grow back as normal in a few days. I mean no disrespect to those cancer patients who don’t lose their hair, just that having absolutely no facial hair is an obvious sign of chemo treatment.
Neither am I down on those wishing to cut their hair to donate for wigs. What I am against is the trend of faux empathy, filming having your hair shaved off so that you can post it on Facebook and be told how noble, how inspiring you are, safe in the knowledge your hair is already starting to regrow.
My nails stopped growing and peeled, my skin on my hands and feet peeled so that I had to frequently moisturise and wear cotton gloves to stop the itching. Food tasted wrong (apart from Jaffa cakes!), but my side effects could have been so much worse.
I’m not looking for sympathy, it wasn’t something I could avoid, it was 8 years ago, and I now have a wonderful 4 year old boy, but I would ask anyone considering doing it to think carefully.
Sorry for the ramble, i’m a cider down!

Tara336 · 25/08/2018 22:37

MIL died in a MacMillan hospice, I have never told DH what was said to me by one of the nurses as it would break him. She casually told me they knew MIL would pass that day as “they can tell” MIL died alone, she could have at least have had us there with her if one of them could have been arsed to pick up the phone that morning.

ThistleAmore · 25/08/2018 22:29

Although I'm not a believer these days, I was brought up in the Church of Scotland and have fairly entrenched views about 'the right hand shouldn't see what the left hand is doing' when it comes to charitable giving.

I tithe about 10% of my annual income to various charities (through either regular DDs or anonymous one-off donations) and that's it.

I don't do sponsored things, or FB things, or any of that other sh*te and I couldn't give a toss if people think badly of me for it. I just quietly give what I can and nobody has to know anything about it.

ReanimatedSGB · 25/08/2018 22:23

I hear you. I think your viewpoint is wholly valid and there is an awful lot of attention-seeking behaviour around 'charity'.
There are also people who do fundraising 'stunts' with the knowledge and enthusiastic acceptance of the sick person they are close to, and people with cancer who find it comforting and supportive if their close friends or family shave their heads - the key thing is to go with what the person with cancer feels.

And yes, holding my hand up, I had my head shaved to fundraise five years ago. It was a spontaneous thing at a street party, where they were inviting people to step up and do it. I had previously lost a couple of friends to cancer and had heard the night before that another friend had died suddenly, and I had consumed a few drinks on the day. I'd also had a cancer scare myself a few months beforehand.

Namechangeforthiscancershit · 25/08/2018 22:20

I have no issue at all with this when someone has a close friend/family member who they are supporting and who is on board with this. If they make money then great, but more importantly if it helps demonstrate their love and support then brilliant.

It’s suggesting it as a fundraising activity in general that I hate.

I also hate the Macmillan TV adverts that show a ridiculously cliched idea of cancer in my opinion and are on all the bloody time. It’s relentless.

iVampire · 25/08/2018 22:19

I support Bloodwise, as the research they put funds towards includes finding better treatments for childhood blood cancers (principally leukaemias).

BillywigSting · 25/08/2018 22:17

I can see both sides of the coin here tbh.

When I was in college a girl in one of my classes was going through chemo and loosing her absolutely gorgeous long thick glossy hair. It was her pride and joy and she was understandably quite distraught.
So her friend shaved her hair with her, so she wouldn't be alone. They went shopping for scarves and hats together.

The friend raised some money for a cancer charity by getting sponsors but I strongly got the impression that she would have done it even without sponsors. The girl with cancer felt a bit less alone and a few hundred quid got raised.

There does seem to be a fair few now doing it just for the attention which I think is pretty despicable.

So I suppose it comes down to both the intention and the patient.

I can totally see where you are coming from though op and I hope you are well soon

Tara336 · 25/08/2018 22:16

I totally agree with you OP it’s very poor taste. My dad is about to begin radiotherapy. I wish you well

Theunmumsymummy · 25/08/2018 22:13

I agree that it's insensitive and can definitely see how it would make you angry, OP, but I'm sure that lots of people do it for the purpose of raising money and trying to hope and that they're not trying to say that they know what having cancer feels like. I hope not, anyway.

CherryPavlova · 25/08/2018 22:04

I think ‘Not in my name’ is an excellent campaign title.

LoveMyLittleSuperhero · 25/08/2018 22:02

I'm glad you've made this thread OP and grateful for the posts on it. I had been thinking of doing a head shave to raise money for them but I honestly hadn't realised how so many people feel about them.
Hope all of those currently undergoing treatment improve, I'm thinking of you all and I will find another way to fund raise. Thank you.

TwitterQueen1 · 25/08/2018 21:52

Marylou and anyone else suffering from cancer - you're very welcome to join us on the cancer support thread here . We're honest about our fears, our treatment and how cancer affects our everyday lives.

OP posts:
Happypuppy · 25/08/2018 21:50

I agree, I’ve found it distasteful for years and my mum died of cancer.

Can anyone set up a petition?

AuntieStella · 25/08/2018 21:47

Whilst I had this thread open, a CRUK ad came on the telly.

Much simpler - using the words of someone has recovered from cancer saying that ir's great to be a survivor and wanting to support research so that more people can be survivors.

bingbongnoise · 25/08/2018 21:45

YANBU. I am actually sick of this now, and sick of people in general who do stuff for 'charity' and crow about it all over social media.

marylou1977 · 25/08/2018 21:41

@TwitterQueen1. Unfortunately I get it. I’m not brave. I’m not a warrior. I’m just trying to get through it to the best of my ability without boring my friends and family to death, while trying to stay alive. Someone else’s bald head does not make me feel any better. Don’t shave it on my account because it is meaningless.

MyNameIsNotSteven · 25/08/2018 21:40

All of it is bullshit. The no make-up selfie is another prime example. What, exactly, was it supposed to raise awareness of?

In answer to a previous poster - the amount of research into children's cancers is almost none existent. It's why I don't donate to cancer research.

I don't either. When the drugs are needed they're not available, particularly if you live the wrong side of the border (though still using the same currency to donate to the same charity).

RedRosie · 25/08/2018 21:38

I hate this.

My DH is in 'partial remission' from a late stage lymphoma which will return. I try not to cry much because it's not especially useful. But last time I did was during his most recent treatment, when his hair started to come out in handfuls at the start of his second cycle of chemotherapy. He didn't want to shave it - he just let it come away.

I don't have the words to describe how far away 'braving the shave' is from his lived experience.

AuntieStella · 25/08/2018 21:35

"The aim is to donate hair to make wigs for cancer patients"

You don't need to shave your head to donate hair. My DD, when she was planning to get her long hair cut decided to donate it via the alitrle Princess Trust. It is utterly explicit in their website that shaving is not required, but that donations need to be at least 6 inches long. It also states how it needs to be tied and how to wrap it for sending.

The Macmillan campaign does not even remotely touch on those aspects and is simply a way to raise money, and it's one that I was uneasy at seeing, but could not - before reading this thread - quite articulate why.

SmilingButClueless · 25/08/2018 21:34

I think there should also be more controls around what’s acceptable as a radio ad from Macmillan. I say radio ads in particular, because a lot of people will be listening while they’re driving.

There was an awful one a couple of years back, basically acting out a scene where someone is given their diagnosis. A close family member had just been told they had cancer and I found the advert so upsetting I actually had to pull the car over. I can’t imagine what it would have been like hearing that if it had triggered memories of someone’s own diagnosis. And this was in prime drivetime Angry

It did not make me want to donate...

Knittedfairies · 25/08/2018 21:33

User what your son and his classmates did was in direct support of a friend - not to raise money, or climb on a bandwagon.

fieryginger · 25/08/2018 21:32

When my daughter was having cancer treatment (she started at 4 years old) I asked her consultant if I should shave my head, so she didn't feel alone or worry about mine swishing about. He said, "she'll look at you every day, and it won't look like mummy. It's not helpful to her" and, thinking about it, he was right.

Normality, the boring, run of the mill life we took for granted before she was diagnosed, was what we craved. Being back to normal when our lives had been tipped upside down - the school run, what's for tea, pj's and Corrie. These things, and a hundred others, had been taken away from us. Our family scattered to family to help with our other kids whilst she spent many weeks in hospital, needing someone to bring me more knickers in, more pjs for DD as she'd been sick on all we'd bought in.

The nuances of living with cancer, are only understood if you have to live with cancer.

Wishing you the very best 💐💐💐

Putyourdamnshoeson · 25/08/2018 21:32

I totally agree and it has always made me squirm, it seems insensitive and mocking.

But... The two people I know who did it, did it with the full consent and support of close friends/relatives who were undergoing treatment.
First was mutual friend of a wonderful woman who died last summer, she shaved bald in solidarity when friends treatment started. She also did lots of other awareness raising with friend and after her death for the specific type of cancer

The other is a 16 year old whose mother has just been given the all clear from breast cancer. She donated the 13 inches of hair to the little princess trust. Her mother was overwhelmed by the support and emotion.

I guess not every cancer sufferer feels the same.

DreamingofSunshine · 25/08/2018 21:31

I volunteered at Macmillan when they created this campaign and raised that it was inappropriate. I'm glad I'm not the only one who thinks so.

Swipe left for the next trending thread