Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brave The Shave - NOT IN MY NAME

340 replies

TwitterQueen1 · 25/08/2018 17:25

I know IANBU but posting here for traffic.

I see Macmillan is now advertising BTS on tv. It doesn't seem to matter how many of us protest that the whole campaign:

  • is extremely offensive and upsetting
  • trivialises and minimises the effects of chemo
  • claims that it makes people understand what it's like to have cancer

Would you paint black and bruises on your face to 'show support' for victims of DV?

Would you tie one leg behind your back and hop around town to 'show support' for those with disabilities?

  • Do you know that Macmillan are asking those who've done BTS is "How are enjoying your new look?" or even worse - "Hope you're enjoying your new look!" WT actual Fuck. I mean, us cancer patients absolutely ADORE losing all our hair and feeling like total shit for months.... and random healthy strangers indulging in narcissistic, attention-grabbing stunts makes us feel even better. Angry

And (in response to my complaint) these offensive statements apparently fall within Macmillan's social media guidelines'?

Bathe in baked beans, run marathons, walk a mile, hold coffee mornings.... do ANYTHING ELSE, but don't pretend for a second that shaving your head helps you understand how cancer patients feel. You have absolutely no idea at all. None.

OP posts:
HelenaDove · 03/09/2018 01:11

lakehouse how bloody insensitive and patronizing to boot Biscuit

TwitterQueen Thanks

DameJulie · 02/09/2018 23:21

Lakehouse - actually, TQ spends quite a bit of her time supporting MNetters who have cancer/are awaiting test results. I directed a poster to a thread TQ regularly posts on and, sure enough, TQ stepped up and offered advice.

And I don't know why you're targetting TQ when the majority of people on this thread agree with her.

myrtleWilson · 02/09/2018 22:53

FFS Lakehouse TQ isn't 'spreading hate' - she is rightly pointing out the way in which this 'campaign' has been received by those living with/dying from cancer. That it can be seen as superficial and shallow, not reflecting the real experiences of those it intends to help. Shaving your head gives no more of an insight into living with cancer than if I claimed spending a day hopping was reflective of the experiences of amputees.

ineedtostopbeingsolazy · 02/09/2018 22:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

BuntyII · 02/09/2018 22:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Refers to a previously deleted post

user1457017537 · 02/09/2018 22:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Refers to a previously deleted post

TwitterQueen1 · 02/09/2018 22:24

@Lakehouse
berating people in the street and sending poisonous missives on social media
I haven't done either of these things. I am entitled to an opinion and I'm entitled to express it. You should be ashamed of yourself for your deeply unpleasant and unnecessary comments.

OP posts:
lakehouse · 02/09/2018 22:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TwitterQueen1 · 02/09/2018 22:17

@Lakehouse
Bore off and find some joy in life
I'd love to, but I'm dying of cancer so it's a bit difficult to find that joy right now.

OP posts:
Asterado · 02/09/2018 21:18

Another HCP with Macmillan in the job title here.

I’m absolutely with you OP. When the campaign was announced I was appalled and I still am.

biscuitaddict · 02/09/2018 21:15

I really dislike this campaign. I think it's the wrong message entirely and I completely agree with you op.

lakehouse · 02/09/2018 21:07

@onetimeposter Macmillan nurses do a phenomenal job. @AuntieStella one time's post is an example of where people in this thread are against people not advertising

onetimeposter · 02/09/2018 21:04

I actually think the nature of those ads must put patients off wanting anything to do with Macmillan nurses. How can you expect someone to be gentle and supportive when all you have seen and heard is highly graphic shots of the worst parts of cancer, and shaved heads?

That funding should go to cancer units and put people on the ground.

lakehouse · 02/09/2018 21:00

Offends some of us...others are grateful for the help received by Macmillan and understand the message of the campaign. My point wasn't that everyone had to like it/not be offended by it. My point was I think it is a waste of energy to try and sabotage the fundraising by berating people in the street and sending poisonous missives on social media. As a survivor I am grateful for every day and for every person who does anything to fundraise for the many causes that surround this disease. I think with any days any of us have left we are better putting energy into love and encouragement for those doing what most can't be bothered to. My point of view, that's all. But something positive has come from this thread as the campaign now has more profile and further donations so well done everyone.

HMC2000 · 02/09/2018 20:47

lakehouse when a campaign is offending the people it says it is helping, how can that be a good thing?

nether · 02/09/2018 19:36

Bit off for someone to come on and tell posters with cancer that they're doing cancer wrong and that they should be joyous when they find something offensive.

You don't lose your ability to have opinions about anything and everything just because of your diagnosis. Nor should you be restrained from expressing them because the are nit us.

The close to unanimous view of those living with cancer themselves has been very illuminating

AuntieStella · 02/09/2018 19:32

so why waste precious energy hating people who are trying to help?

They don't hate the people, they hate the campaign.

For extremely good reasons, which even the most cursory reading of the thread would make readily understandable.

Haireverywhere · 02/09/2018 19:26

I don't know much about Macmillan other than they pump prime some nhs posts.

But as far as Brave the Shave I see what you mean OP. It feels distasteful to me.

I have always disliked any kind of battle metaphors when it comes to illness and disease because I remember how much my two relatives felt they failed and cancer won or beaten them (their words) - when one Nan couldn't have any more active treatment and my Auntie chose to stop palliative treatment due to side effects. I think they felt they'd been weak etc because of all the talk of fighting and bravery ifyswim.

Doghorsechicken · 02/09/2018 19:19

I think it probably depends on context, I agree with you in some cases but I think sometimes shaving your hair if you have a child or partner etc that is particularly conscious of losing their hair may be supporting them whilst also raising some money.

Bluelady · 02/09/2018 19:04

Are you really this insensitive, lakehouse? Really? Words bloody fail me. And that doesn't happen often.

ToffeePennie · 02/09/2018 19:02

I don’t donate, snoopy, because when my grandad was died of cancer, all the money collected in his name wasn’t even acknowledged by the charity. They simply sent a letter back with a “you could also fill this envelope” not even a thank you. My nans name wasn’t mentioned, except on the outside of the envelope, no condolences, nothing. I phoned head office as it hurt my Nan deeply and they said it’s standard. Oh and the money had been sent to their admin team in Glasgow to help fund their postage costs, not to actually provide any real help. My Nan was in bits, and was truly devastated.
Because of this we as a family decided Macmillan were not for us.
However the lifeboats (got half the money raised) sent back a lovely letter, mentioned the amount and asked my Nan for my grandads name as they had used the money as the last bit towards their newest lifeboat and would my Nan mind if they named it after him in his honour as without the final bit of money they’d never have bought it. My Nan of course said yes. So there is a boat out there saving lives with my grandads name on it. Not to mention, they regularly send my Nan updates on “grandads boat” and let her know what they are doing with her (not very regular) donations. And it’s not just once she’s sent a donation either!

lakehouse · 02/09/2018 18:57

Is sharing a link to a campaign virtue signalling? What do you call it for those on this thread who have been bashing the campaign online?

CherryPavlova · 02/09/2018 18:56

lakehouse it’s not bitterness, it’s not negativity it’s a real positive strength to stop a horrid way of raising funds that causes distress and offence to many who have or who are on the cancer treadmill (good word!).
Of course, not everyone is offended but a good number are and no, the end result does not justify the means. Macmillan are offending the very people they purport to support.
The Black and White Minstrel show used to entertain many people on a Saturday night. That doesn’t make it acceptable, does it? A charity clearing land mines investing capital in an arms trading business wouldn’t sit comfortably would it?

There are much ‘braver’ more challenging ways to fundraisers than having a haircut.

MrsChollySawcutt · 02/09/2018 18:56

Hope you enjoyed your FB virtue signalling lake house.

Bluelady · 02/09/2018 18:48

Dear God, that's the most contrarian thing I've ever read.

Swipe left for the next trending thread