Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brave The Shave - NOT IN MY NAME

340 replies

TwitterQueen1 · 25/08/2018 17:25

I know IANBU but posting here for traffic.

I see Macmillan is now advertising BTS on tv. It doesn't seem to matter how many of us protest that the whole campaign:

  • is extremely offensive and upsetting
  • trivialises and minimises the effects of chemo
  • claims that it makes people understand what it's like to have cancer

Would you paint black and bruises on your face to 'show support' for victims of DV?

Would you tie one leg behind your back and hop around town to 'show support' for those with disabilities?

  • Do you know that Macmillan are asking those who've done BTS is "How are enjoying your new look?" or even worse - "Hope you're enjoying your new look!" WT actual Fuck. I mean, us cancer patients absolutely ADORE losing all our hair and feeling like total shit for months.... and random healthy strangers indulging in narcissistic, attention-grabbing stunts makes us feel even better. Angry

And (in response to my complaint) these offensive statements apparently fall within Macmillan's social media guidelines'?

Bathe in baked beans, run marathons, walk a mile, hold coffee mornings.... do ANYTHING ELSE, but don't pretend for a second that shaving your head helps you understand how cancer patients feel. You have absolutely no idea at all. None.

OP posts:
BewareOfDragons · 25/08/2018 18:06

I completely agree, OP Completely.

NeverStopExploring · 25/08/2018 18:05

I don’t think anyone does it to make you feel like you have cancer. The aim is to donate hair to make wigs for cancer patients if they choose to wear them and it is a very easy way to raise thousands of pounds. I agree it isn’t the most tasteful way and not the way I would choose to raise money but it is very effective. £16.8 million since 2015 with Macmillan alone looking at thier website which is a huge amount of money. I am sure there are people who do charity events for the glory and attention but every fundraiser I have met has done it because a loved one has been helped by the charity they are supporting and what to give something back.

FuzzyCustard · 25/08/2018 18:04

Our least favourite phrases in this cancer journey have been "stay strong and keep positive". They give me the absolute RAGE (and I have called several people out on this)

If I can't fall apart now, then when can I?

And of course, if only people could be a bit more cheery then their cancer would get all better, wouldn't it?

And if only you fought a bit harder then you wouldn't die., would you?

These words are a sop to the speaker and I think the real meaning is "Don't fall apart in front of me because I am afraid of cancer and afraid of you and afraid of your reaction....and I'm so glad it's not me"

HelenaDove · 25/08/2018 18:04

Im very happy to donate but i wouldnt shave my head. I once got told that "everyone should do it" by a woman in a supermarket queue whose young daughter had done it. I also saw people attempting to bully others into doing the ice bucket challenge. I dont like this new "chullying"

madamy · 25/08/2018 18:03

....and don't even get me started on the brave bit!!

madamy · 25/08/2018 18:01

I agree. Am a HCP with Macmillan in my job title! A number of us discussed this with the fundraising team at an annual conference Macmillan do for us. They said they'd "take our comments on board". This was last year, so guess someone somewhere still thinks it's a money earner.
Those if you with personal experience have very eloquently described the reality of hair loss from chemo and the stark contrast with this campaign.

TwitterQueen1 · 25/08/2018 18:01

Lima apologies - my post has been pretty much female-focused but of course, it's no different for men, it's just as distressing.

OP posts:
Bluelady · 25/08/2018 18:01

And ignore spiteful comments about your anger. You're absolutely entitled to be angry. It's a healthy reaction to the shit you're going through.

YeTalkShiteHen · 25/08/2018 18:01

My Mum despised the “Brave the Shave” campaign, absolutely hated it.

She didn’t want to be called brave, or heroic or any of the other trite bullshit that gets trotted out, she wanted to live.

OP I wish you all the very best, for what it’s worth. I hope that bastard disease is gone soon. Flowers

Minxmumma · 25/08/2018 18:01

As a woman who has had cancer twice, lost my hair and it failed to grow back properly so now every blooming day when I look in the mirror it is slap in the face and often reduces me to a sobbing mess.
I fail to see how shaving your head actually helps anyone.

I have close friends who suffer alopecia and feel the same way.

Fundraise in any way you wish but please do not use it to undermine or diminish how patients feel. One of the few positives I can find is perhaps less people will stare, tut or comment when they see a bald person and may have a little more empathy for the way cancer (and other) patients are treated.

Yes cancer makes you angry to your core with trite comments and attention seeking behaviour.

I have seen my loved ones sob when I lost my hair, sat while my husband shaved my head with shakey hands, and live with that forever haunting shadow in my mind. Cancer is a destructive force like few others, and it never ever truly leaves anyone touched by it

TwitterQueen1 I wish you well lovely xx

YourVagesty · 25/08/2018 18:00

I dislike it too, and all that 'fighting' talk mentioned upthread. So and so can 'kick cancer's ass' because she's a 'fighter', etc.

Orchidflower1 · 25/08/2018 17:59

I think what nostaples says sums it up- giving to charity is great and supporting someone/ charity in a way that you can is great- you just don’t need Vegas lights and a brass band to show you care. Someone’s donation should not detract from the cause.

OP so sorry you’re having a rough time and hope you’re on the road to recovery.

TwitterQueen1 · 25/08/2018 17:58

Yes Fuzzy I didn't touch on the whole 'brave' thing... which is also horribly offensive. I think I'm in the majority in saying that many cancer patients HATE being called brave. We're not brave at all. We're monstrously shit scared most of the time, afraid of pain (even though all the medics work wonders in alleviating this) and in despair at the thought of leaving loved ones behind. Brave? No. There just isn't any option.

So 'Brave' the shave is offensive on that level too. Those who do it are most definitely not brave, just misguided.

Pandora it WILL come back. Flowers

OP posts:
nostaples · 25/08/2018 17:54

Agree OP although those who do it are well meaning.

Heard a really interesting programme recently (on R4 I think) which was about the weird obsession with having to 'do' something in order to justify giving money to charity. Why not just give the money? You don't need to shave your head or do a run or stop drinking for January. Just give money direct without the nonsense. If you want to 'do' something, actually lend your support to the charity or people in need.

LimaHotel4 · 25/08/2018 17:54

I agree totally with you, OP. I went through a course of chemo last year, and as a man, found the hair loss aspect just as distressing as anyone else would.

I really can’t see how shaving your hair can make someone more empathetic towards someone who has actually undergone chemo. I have seen people on social media before now who have done this, asking for donations etc - and I’ll be honest, it does seem a bit attention seeking in some cases. However, I can, in some cases see why people might feel comforted by doing something like this, say for example if a friend or relative was unwell.

Like @Pickleypickles I agree that it is absolutely fine for someone actually havimg chemo to shave their hair before treatment to raise money and awareness - I just think there is a real difference between doing this as someone with experience of the treatment and as someone with little personal experience.

happypoobum · 25/08/2018 17:49

YANBU

The only person I know who has done this completely fits your description of indulging in narcissistic, attention-grabbing stunts and I find it very disrespectful.

FuzzyCustard · 25/08/2018 17:49

I have voiced a similar opinion to Macmillan myself, even though they have been absolute brilliant throughout the two years of my Dh's cancer (and continue to be).

For me, there is such a huge difference between the total hair loss of a person undergoing chemo (eyebrows, eyelashes, all your body hair) and the effects of it (feeling the cold, hair taking months to grow back and then coming in thinner, or frizzy or grey) that it is not a good thing for MacM to promote.

There's so much "look at me, I look great with a no 1 cut (so not "chemo bald" at all) and I know that in a month or so it'll all be back to normal again, but I am a WARRIOR"

And the notion that people who do it are "brave" makes me feel both angry and upset.

Pandoraslastchance · 25/08/2018 17:49

I'm currently under going chemo for stage 3 breast cancer at 32. I'm losing my hair and I'm terrified of being bald. The adverts are making me angry and I have to turn over. Run races,do midnight bra wakes or do the coffee mornings but this brave the shave shit is really pissing me off.

Pickleypickles · 25/08/2018 17:44

I totally agree with you! People seem to treat it like some brave thing they have done for the poor cancer patients. It is disrespectful and I agree with your other points about not hopping around for a day etc.

If a cancer patient wishes to shave their head and raise money before the chemo takes that is different but healthy people thinking they are doing a brave and respectful thing is totally misguided and minimising of the psychological effects chemo actually has.

Nikephorus · 25/08/2018 17:44

So only bald cancer patients matter? You do realise that chemotherapy is used in other illnesses and the side effects don't go away just because it's not cancer.
Given that it's about Macmillan, the cancer charity, I think it's ALL about bald cancer patients

weebarra · 25/08/2018 17:44

TQ - I'm with you. I'm not currently a bald cancer patient, but I'm coming up to five years since diagnosis.
I understand that people are expressing solidarity and it's an obvious way to do it - it would be hard to emulate my lack of boobs or surgical menopause, my peripheral neuropathy or the constant nausea.
The people who supported me did so by looking after my children while I had treatment, the school secretary who took my oldest home from school when he was ill the day after my first chemo, by cheering me up, by listening to me droning on.
I think it's a bit distasteful tbh.

MrsChollySawcutt · 25/08/2018 17:43

I agree OP, it's an abhorrent campaign promoting attention seeking behaviour. Nothing whatsoever to do with supporting cancer patients.

CheshireChat · 25/08/2018 17:42

I think it's just a cash earner for them now, similar to the ice bucket challenge for ALS, though at least that raised vital funds.

I recall reading for some articles from cancer patients that found it comforting so if you're doing it for someone in particular you'd be best asking. Some will appreciate the thought and some will feel it trivialises their experiences and neither are wrong.

chronicallyawesome · 25/08/2018 17:42

From the other side of the desk - as it were - I support you OP.
My senior colleagues fight a LOT against the "fighting" talk of cancer charities because I believe that many of our patients feel like you do.

PaulRuddislush · 25/08/2018 17:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.