Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think schools shouldn't teach religion as absolute fact?

593 replies

PoesyCherish · 06/08/2018 13:35

DSD is 6 and is learning about Christianity in school. They're teaching her Jesus is the Son of God rather than "some people believe he is". Everything about the religion is taught as fact. They've also failed to mention anything about any other religion.

AIBU to think they shouldn't be teaching it as absolute fact? How are children supposed to be understanding and tolerant of other people's beliefs if they're taught one world view as fact?

OP posts:
borlottibeans · 06/08/2018 15:39

A lot of posts here missing the point about faith schools - in many areas there is literally no choice but to use these unless you have unlimited time and cash to drive miles and miles away from home. Where I grew up all the village schools were C of E, or if you didn't like that there was a minibus running to a Catholic school in a nearby market town. That was it unless you went private (still all Christian locally!) or willing to do 2 x 40+ mile round trips per day to the nearest city.

The real problem is that taxpayers' money is being used to subsidise particular religions' recruitment strategies. If parents want their children to learn about their religion as though it's fact, they should do it in their own time not expect the rest of us to fund it.

THEsonofaBITCH · 06/08/2018 15:27

I also would prefer religion not to play a part in education
People keep going to war over religion, I personally think its vital that people are educated about religion, the various religions and what makes them the same and what makes them different to de-mystify the differences and counter-act extremists. My childhood was partially destroyed by religion and I took it on myself to learn about as many different kinds/beliefs as possible so I knew where people were coming from and also because of personal history, found it interesting.

immortalmarble · 06/08/2018 15:19

Well, as a catholic school the ethos is ‘as catholics, we believe ...’ and other religions it is ‘Muslims believe ...’

I also would prefer religion not to play a part in education.

THEsonofaBITCH · 06/08/2018 15:14

you were lucky to have those dinner table discussions though
Yes, absolutely and the highlight of my day usually. Not the schools fault if others can't/don't do the same though. The kids all are (too?) happy to argue with their teachers on absolute points as rarely is there an absolute, i.e. school said all manufacturing is bad as they pollute. DD argued that that isn't true and that the classroom was the perfect example as everything in the room was manufactured without which they wouldn't be comfortable nor learning as well thanks to Ipads, digital white boards, pens, pencils, paper, etc. finishing with only bad manufacturing is bad and there are good manufacturers like her father! Grin so proud!

Moltenpink · 06/08/2018 15:05

THEson you were lucky to have those dinner table discussions though. Not all children do.

THEsonofaBITCH · 06/08/2018 15:03

To think schools shouldn't teach religion as absolute fact?
Yes UABU to think a religious school shouldn't teach that religion as fact. They will learn about other religions in RE and be presented with -"these religions believe this, whilst we believe this". I've not heard other religions described as "wrong" or that the school's religion is "right" merely this is what we believe and this is what it says in the bible and therefore why we believe this to be true. We were Protestants in a Catholic school and discussed around the dinner table our beliefs, differences, similarities and how those same were the same or different to other religions - Jewish, Muslim, Quaker, Intergalactic (Earthlings are a lost tribe) and others. Made the kids inquire more and they learned to think about others as both similar and different and not to judge just because they are different.

Moltenpink · 06/08/2018 15:02

YANBU

I went to a fantastic catholic secondary though, that undid all the brainwashing the primary did.

I’m still angry that as a child, I was told things as though they were fact. I really believed everything and religion shaped my early years, even though my parents weren’t catholic themselves.

namova · 06/08/2018 15:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

SarahDoY · 06/08/2018 14:55

At least the Catholic and CoE schools are open in their agenda. It's the state schools teaching the trans religion by stealth as fact, that concerns me.

Everyone is entitled to their belief, you can't force that belief on another. If you send your child to schools that teach a belief as fact - be it Christianity or transgenderism - and have PR then you can either remove your child from the school or being taught that religious belief.

eniledam · 06/08/2018 14:47

but surely if they're teaching Catholicism as fact it'll be teaching the other faiths as being wrong?

Yep. I was taught Catholicism as fact, and that other religions - Islam, Sikhism, Judaism - simply had their own beliefs.

noego · 06/08/2018 14:46

Haven't you realised that our children are being programmed and conditioned into the English, democratic, christian, capitalistic matrix.

eniledam · 06/08/2018 14:45

If you send your child to a catholic school, you should expect them to be teaching your child Catholicism as fact.

I'm sorry you're stuck in this situation, OP. If it makes you feel any better, I went to primary and secondary catholic schools, and I'm now firmly atheist. I think it helped that neither of my parents were religious, so I wasn't completely indoctrinated - I was able to see there were options in how people choose to live their lives.

Pengggwn · 06/08/2018 14:39

PoesyCherish

Of course they will be teaching the other faiths as wrong. They are Catholics.

If you wanted to send your child somewhere agnostic (well, if it were your child we were talking about) a Catholic school was the wrong choice. They believe Catholicism is fact, some people are not Catholics and those people are wrong.

Walkingdeadfangirl · 06/08/2018 14:37

Religion should not be taught in any school.
Schools are places of education where facts, not beliefs, should be taught.

Our world would be a much safer place if we cut out this cancer.

PoesyCherish · 06/08/2018 14:33

They will. They will teach them about other faiths as part of their RE curriculum.

@Pengggwn but surely if they're teaching Catholicism as fact it'll be teaching the other faiths as being wrong?

@RachelAnneJ that's really rubbish. You definitely should be able to opt out.

It's strange because so many people want their children to go to the faith school. At one of my old churches we had so many people attending temporarily just to get a school place. I think if there was a local state school that would work for my child (which there isn't for DSD), I'd far rather them go there even if the ratings were slightly lower.

OP posts:
RachelAnneJ · 06/08/2018 14:25

Yanbu.

My child is at a CofE school. We didn't want a religious school but it is our catchment school and we failed to gain a place at the secular school we wanted.

I believe you should be able to opt out of religious schools when you make school applications.

Pengggwn · 06/08/2018 14:19

@Softsheen and @Mousefunky I would expect or at least hope they would teach them whilst Catholicism is what they believe, not everyone does and that is okay too.

They will. They will teach them about other faiths as part of their RE curriculum.

PoesyCherish · 06/08/2018 14:16

@Softsheen and @Mousefunky I would expect or at least hope they would teach them whilst Catholicism is what they believe, not everyone does and that is okay too.

OP posts:
PoesyCherish · 06/08/2018 14:15

Ahh thanks @jenthelibrarian you answered my question re what they have to teach. I thought that was the case.

I don't think it would be fair to completely withdraw her from the lessons. A girl in my secondary school did that and it really singled her out.

How do we get her to think for herself though? Eventually obviously, I know she's only 6 right now. It'd be nice if we could encourage independent thought and to teach her to be respectful of other peoples beliefs and that whatever she believes is okay.

I don't know why people think I'm anti religion. I don't attend church but that doesn't mean I don't believe in God (I do!). I just think we all have the right to our own beliefs and to be allowed to make our own choices instead of having it rammed down our throats

OP posts:
Mousefunky · 06/08/2018 14:14

In a religious school this has to be expected. I purposely send my DC to a secular school to hopefully avoid it but sadly, not the case. They have returned home brandishing JESUS LOVES YOU drawings and told me all about Jesus and who he was Hmm. I’m a life long Atheist so I’ve always had to correct them and inform them that some people believe that but it’s not necessarily a fact (and most likely isn’t Grin). But sending your DC to a religious school, not sure what else you would expect.

SoftSheen · 06/08/2018 14:12

YABU, she's at a Catholic school! What else would you expect?

PoesyCherish · 06/08/2018 14:12

Oh sorry @SarahDoY i thought you were saying I shouldn't encourage critical thought but reading it back it sounds like you were saying I should. Apologies.

Re the curriculum, I thought it was different in religious schools or do they still have to eventually teach all religions?

OP posts:
jenthelibrarian · 06/08/2018 14:10

You have the right to withdraw your child from RE lessons, even in a 'faith' school.
They must make proper provision for the child's supervision and so on.
I did this with my son at secondary school and he used to time to do his homework.
It's a slightly tricky issue where religion is shoe-horned into other lessons, which is probably the case in a Catholic school [?]
"Faith schools can choose what they teach in RE, so do not have to follow the same syllabus as non-faith schools. As maintained schools, however, parents still have the legal right to withdraw their child from these classes."

PoesyCherish · 06/08/2018 14:07

@Lazypuppy sorry what am I expecting of her? It's hardly anti religion to think it shouldn't be taught as fact. And not that it's relevant but I'm a confirmed Christian so hardly anti religion.

@RomanyRoots I've got no problem them teaching their religion but don't think it should be taught as fact. mine also learned about christianity at school, it keeps them in line sometimes, it's great wow instil in them the fear of God. Great...

OP posts:
PoesyCherish · 06/08/2018 14:03

@SarahDoY she doesn't have God parents. She's not christened nor does she attend church. I have never so much as even suggested to her she should have critical thought surrounding the issue. Whenever she's mentioned Jesus died on the cross or some other religious comment to me I normally just say something along the lines of, oh that's interesting and leave it at that.

@ParkheadParadise I guess when the only other option is to send your child to a busy school miles away which you know is likely to cause your child anxiety, it seems like a better option.

OP posts: