Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think schools shouldn't teach religion as absolute fact?

593 replies

PoesyCherish · 06/08/2018 13:35

DSD is 6 and is learning about Christianity in school. They're teaching her Jesus is the Son of God rather than "some people believe he is". Everything about the religion is taught as fact. They've also failed to mention anything about any other religion.

AIBU to think they shouldn't be teaching it as absolute fact? How are children supposed to be understanding and tolerant of other people's beliefs if they're taught one world view as fact?

OP posts:
PoesyCherish · 13/08/2018 12:36

@Cantankerous please stop grouping all Catholics together as one. You cannot group all Catholics together any more than you can group all Muslims or all Hindus or all Sikhs together. Whilst I get what you're saying about Catholicism being one slice of Christianity, not all Catholics believe the same. Just like not all Anglicans believe the same thing. Whilst the Catholic church is guilty of covering up some awful crimes and whilst I'm sure there are some Catholics who do probably support that, the vast majority of them don't.

@Gin96 that is awful you weren't supposed to be taught contraception. The view on periods reminds me of an ex. He told me pain during birth is God's punishment to us for Eve eating the apple, so under no circumstances would I be allowed pain relief! Yeah, he was crazy...

OP posts:
sweetsomethings · 12/08/2018 01:27

Cantankerous so many valid points there.

sweetsomethings · 12/08/2018 01:26

Wow gin that’s worse than I thought how dare they. Totally disgusting behaviour .

CantankerousCamel · 11/08/2018 20:21

The Catholic Church thought nothing of starving children to death while claiming money from the government for their food.

Or sawing women’s pelvis’s in half so they could ‘do God’s work’ and have more children.

Seriously messed up, hideous organisation. The disregard for human life, the hatred of women and the complete lack of care or sense of responsibility for the welfare of children is literally penned in its teachings.

How or why ANYONE in this day and age trusts, prays with, gives MONEY TO or respects the Catholic Church is beyond me.

It’s an absolute abomination, a stain on society.

Catholic schools? Should be illegal.

reteacher101 · 11/08/2018 20:18

Stating these stories as truth, is not okay
I totally agree.

Gin96 · 11/08/2018 20:09

And girls were told periods were a curse from god for Eve giving Adam the apple.

Gin96 · 11/08/2018 20:02

Oh I went to a catholic school and the things they taught us were unbelievable. We were not allowed to be taught about birth control but my biology teacher said it was ridiculous and taught to us any way, she was then sacked. They showed us videos of abortions and said we would go to hell if we ever had one. It put me off religion for life. I am talking 40 years ago, the things they got away with under the name of religion

CantankerousCamel · 11/08/2018 19:55

Political I was livid they went into so much detail with my five year old.

How DARE these people do that? How can anyone think it is acceptable or okay

politicalcorrectnessisgreat · 11/08/2018 19:38

My 5 yo Dd was traumatised about the Easter story. She asked me to ask if she could leave the classroom when they talked about hammering the nails in the man hands

BananaToffo · 11/08/2018 19:38

There are million of people in the world who consult their horoscopes daily but we don't teach that nonsense in school. Religion earns a small place because of the role it's played in history, but it's actual teachings are no more sensible than horoscopes, and have nothing of any significance to say, to deserve to be sidelined in the same manner.

School ought to be about evidence based facts.

BananaToffo · 11/08/2018 19:34

I don't really see the need to teach about specific doctrines. Will we do that for all religions, or just the "special" one....Christianity?

You can broadly teach about about all of them, and what each religion generally believes. If nothing else, it's important to have a basic knowledge otherwise much history & literature won't make sense.

I also can't see why religion always gets lumped in with morality & ethics. Most religious teachings are neither moral nor ethical and I don't like the implication that religion has a special voice that ought to be listened to when discussing such matters. It doesn't no matter how much it thinks it does.

CantankerousCamel · 11/08/2018 19:27

That’s no reason to bombard children with faith as truth from an early age.

To tell children from 4 that Jesus lived and was tortured on a cross then came back to life.

Stating these stories as truth, is not okay.

Reteacher101 · 11/08/2018 19:18

Camel, because there are millions of religious people in the world.

politicalcorrectnessisgreat · 11/08/2018 18:59

One day religion will just be taught in history lessons Smile

CantankerousCamel · 11/08/2018 18:57

So if morality can be taught without religion, why do we need to teach religion?

I do think we should teach about religions, from a social science perspective if nothing else.

Reteacher101 · 11/08/2018 17:58

Tofffo I think understanding some of the nuances of religion helps children be more analytical about opinions they hear. So they can question, for example, why far right Christians think life is sacred when it comes to abortion but not capital punishment.

Reteacher101 · 11/08/2018 17:53

Mutually inclusive? I don’t think they are, and I didn’t say they were. I think you’re just looking to pick holes in whatever I say!

BananaToffo · 11/08/2018 17:26

*I don't think there should be any faith schools
*
Me neither. And I think the fact that we have them makes it very difficult, in large part, to have a truly even-handed approach in lessons about religion - which, you're right, are needed.

It's just that America isn't (imo) the best example for anything, good or bad at the moment.

You have the far-right gun lobby screaming about their constitutional right to be armed, and the far-right Christians (usually the same people) trying to force their religion into schools & government and getting pissed off when anyone else tries to uphold their own constitutional right to freedom from religion.

CantankerousCamel · 11/08/2018 16:26

Please explain how ‘morality’ and ‘religion’ are mutually conclusive in your eyes?

Reteacher101 · 11/08/2018 15:59

Look I open a thread and see a comment about how religion should be taught at home not at school. This is my bread and butter so I have an opinion on it. I don’t think there should be any faith schools. I do strongly think children should learn about morality, religion and also stances such as atheism and humanism. It was my understanding that there was no subject for teaching about religion in America, I can accept if that was wrong. What happens there is relevant if addressing a post saying it would be better to have religion taught at home not at school, if they are an example of a country where that happens. Do you think a fundamentalist-anything family is going to teach their child about other religious viewpoints? Of course they won’t. I think education is the way out of intolerance and bigotry.

CantankerousCamel · 11/08/2018 15:57

I think Reteach was derailing as they were talking about religion in American schools, which is absurd when you consider the massive scope of issues in America and the socio economical differences there. You can’t simple look at Americans many problems and say ‘oh it’s because there is no religion in schools’ it’s an absurd position

BananaToffo · 11/08/2018 15:54

I didn't think you were derailing, I just thought maybe it seemed like I was talking about changes to US schooling rather than ours, which I wasn't.

CantankerousCamel · 11/08/2018 15:43

*Derailing

CantankerousCamel · 11/08/2018 15:39

Quite right Banana

Detailing is definitely a mark of a crap argument

BananaToffo · 11/08/2018 15:22

Nothing America does is my priority. I'm the UK and it was our schooling I was addressing.