Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think schools shouldn't teach religion as absolute fact?

593 replies

PoesyCherish · 06/08/2018 13:35

DSD is 6 and is learning about Christianity in school. They're teaching her Jesus is the Son of God rather than "some people believe he is". Everything about the religion is taught as fact. They've also failed to mention anything about any other religion.

AIBU to think they shouldn't be teaching it as absolute fact? How are children supposed to be understanding and tolerant of other people's beliefs if they're taught one world view as fact?

OP posts:
Justanotherlurker · 06/08/2018 21:08

Has religion always been so insular and corrupt?

Of course it has, hence why we are in a situation of some religions being the ridicule of comedians worldwide for decades and Tommy Robinson recently being some kind of martyr

WrongOnTheInternet · 06/08/2018 21:08

YAVVDNBU.
My book recommendation for tonight (drum roll please) is Catherine Nix's "The Darkening Age", which, while a bit polemical, is a good summary of how Christianity (by extension, religion) has not been a good friend to science in the past. Other sources could confirm how much of a friend it has been to women in the past. Durkheim pointed out years ago how it can be a way of propping up social structures of otherwise dubious legitimacy or worth. I am very disturbed by how much influence religion has on education, and the increase in influence in society as a whole. I never heard anyone claim that the UK was a Christian country until relatively recently, as a quick example - in the 90's most of us would have said it was secular.
Faith schools began to increase under Tony Blair. There was a very deliberate increase in their involvement. For many of us there is no choice but to use them, as pp's have said. Thankfully, some of us were educated in religious schools at some point and have still turned into rampaging atheists Grin, but one presumes that they expect some return on investment.

Walkingdeadfangirl · 06/08/2018 20:54

Apparently any man and his dog can set one up and promote whatever shite they want in them

I guess you dont know much about education then. Any man and his dog cannot open a free school, that is not how it works. And if you did open a school it would still be illegal to open a secular school, never mind an atheist, anti-theist, devil worshipping or even academically selective school.

Pengggwn · 06/08/2018 20:50

Walkingdeadfangirl

Yes, I think it has 😂

But to be fair, there are non-Catholic children in Catholic schools, as demonstrated in the OP. It is fair enough for them to primarily serve their own religious community because they exist to provide a Catholic education. Where someone wants to send their child there without baptising them, it is fair enough for them to specify that the parents have to support the ethos of the school.

Walkingdeadfangirl · 06/08/2018 20:48

You wonder why? Really?
Well I always assumed it was because of privilege.

But I do wonder why the people who are genuinely religious allow it to go on? What happened to loving thy neighbour, and even reaching out to spread the word. Has religion always been so insular and corrupt?

Pengggwn · 06/08/2018 20:46

The government has offered an alternative. Free schools. Apparently any man and his dog can set one up and promote whatever shite they want in them. Why not band together with your community and start one? No?

I cannot know what people will be saying about the free school experiment in as little as ten years, but I imagine it to be something like: "We sent our children to be educated by people who had never run a school, didn't know anything about how schools worked and thought Ofsted was a cream for thrush. What the fuck is wrong with us?"

JaniceBattersby · 06/08/2018 20:42

Given, in most cases, the people of the Catholic parishes paid for the land on which the buildings stand, and the buildings themselves, how do you expect our county councils to pay for the land and buildings when they turn all religious schools into secular schools?

Honestly, it’s a bit rich expecting the church to fork out for all that then telling the they can’t teach Catholicism.

The government has offered an alternative. Free schools. Apparently any man and his dog can set one up and promote whatever shite they want in them. Why not band together with your community and start one? No?

LittleMia · 06/08/2018 20:39

I'm a non-catholic who teaches in a catholic school and I would teach as you suggest... because that reflects my belief. However, for some of my colleagues, their belief is so strong that it IS fact for them.. does that make sense?

I think if this is something you're uncomfortable with, you need to change schools. It's kinda part of the deal.

cloudyweewee · 06/08/2018 20:36

I am a Catholic teacher in a Catholic Primary School and I teach RE as fact, because I believe it is. We also teach about other world religions, but obviously not to the same depth. I find it very strange indeed that you are shocked that Catholic RE takes priority in a Catholic school Confused

rinabean · 06/08/2018 20:34

Faith schools shouldn't be allowed anyway, no matter what they teach.

Pengggwn · 06/08/2018 20:34

Walkingdeadfangirl

You wonder why? Really?

Walkingdeadfangirl · 06/08/2018 20:32

Pengggwn No CofE schools can discriminate as well, just some choose not to. Other religions could choose to be inclusive. They dont, I wonder why that is?

Pengggwn · 06/08/2018 20:32

JacquesHammer

Oh right. I honestly didn't think so.

Pengggwn · 06/08/2018 20:31

Walkingdeadfangirl

I'm not sure, but if the Church owns them then of course they can sell them. I know Catholic schools receive considerable Church funding anyway, so there would be a shortfall there.

JacquesHammer · 06/08/2018 20:31

CofE schools have to accept all applicants, I think?

They can have criteria based on faith

Walkingdeadfangirl · 06/08/2018 20:29

Who owns the land and buildings of faith schools. If they were banned could the church just sell them off for millions. Or are they owned by the state and could just carry on as comprehensives in a MAT?

Pengggwn · 06/08/2018 20:23

RafaIsTheKingOfClay

Well, I believe the state has a duty to provide appropriate educational environments for its children and to allow for parental choice. I believe there ought to be more schools, smaller classes, lots of other changes before faith schools come under my scrutiny.

Pengggwn · 06/08/2018 20:21

Walkingdeadfangirl

As far as I know, CofE is different because it is the 'state' religion. CofE schools have to accept all applicants, I think?

HarveySchlumpfenburger · 06/08/2018 20:14

In terms of funding, it depends on whether the school is VC or VA. VC schools have all of their funding, provided by the LA. VA schools have all of the running costs and 90% of the upkeep of the buildings costs is paid by the LA. The church pays 10% of the buildings costs.

Pengggwyn, you might want your child to go to a faith school, but why should my taxes be paying for your choice of a school which might essentially exclude my child for being the wrong faith. That doesn’t seem particularly fair or Christian.

At the very least the number of faith places should be limited to the proportion of funding the church provides.

JacquesHammer · 06/08/2018 20:11

*faith: ironic really as I don’t think fair comes into it Grin

JacquesHammer · 06/08/2018 20:09

There are CofE schools near me. They dont have faith in admissions

I wonder how faith schools decide whether fair is a selection criteria. The two closest to me that are CofE do select on faith grounds.

Walkingdeadfangirl · 06/08/2018 19:58

Pengggwn Yes I agree about the op, and she could have opted out of RE lessons but maybe she didn't know about that.

There are CofE schools near me. They dont have faith in admissions, they dont teach their religion is the one true religion and they dont discriminate against teachers of the 'wrong' religion. Yet they seem to still be 'faith' schools and attract mainly CofE families. Why cant other religions do that?

dressesdressesdresses · 06/08/2018 19:53

This is why my child is being sent too a non religious school

Pengggwn · 06/08/2018 19:50

Walkingdeadfangirl

I don't disagree entirely. I know that happens and I can see why you would have a problem with it.

My issue with the OP is that she is fine with the school, she just wants the school to run along the lines she prefers. It's rather like buying a tin of Ronseal fence paint and then complaining when it doesn't tarmac your drive.

People using the services of a faith school shouldn't be moaning about something that was perfectly obvious to them when they signed up.

derxa · 06/08/2018 19:49

Move to France, the education is non secular there.