Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think schools shouldn't teach religion as absolute fact?

593 replies

PoesyCherish · 06/08/2018 13:35

DSD is 6 and is learning about Christianity in school. They're teaching her Jesus is the Son of God rather than "some people believe he is". Everything about the religion is taught as fact. They've also failed to mention anything about any other religion.

AIBU to think they shouldn't be teaching it as absolute fact? How are children supposed to be understanding and tolerant of other people's beliefs if they're taught one world view as fact?

OP posts:
bellinisurge · 07/08/2018 08:27

Talk to the child as they get older. Seems like the thing to do. It's what my parents did (one was non-Christian, the other a devout Catholic) and what I do with my dd.
If you present a positive, thoughtful and humane example, isn't that a good thing?
If you are the stepparent, op, defer to the parents.

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 08:26

BoomBoomsCousin

That may well be the case, but I don't believe that there is no other local primary other than the faith school, but local parents still send their kids to a school miles out of their way. It makes no sense.

BoomBoomsCousin · 07/08/2018 08:09

Pengggwn it may well be undersubscribed because demographics have changed significantly since it was built. Local authorities don’t get to manage the enrollement in most faith schools the way they do in local authority schools.

HopefullyAnonymous · 07/08/2018 08:05

YABU. To Catholics it IS fact, so to speak.

Anyway it could be worse; I lived in Ireland for a bit as a child and there were regular trips from school to the village church for confession.

politicalcorrectnessisgreat · 07/08/2018 07:57

There should be no religious schools at all. Imagine a whole education based around one fairy story.

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 07:52

BoomBoomsCousin

But it isn't likely the case that there are simply 'no other choices', is my point. This school is undersubscribed (apparently) so the other local children must be going somewhere else. The OP said the other choice was a non-faith state school miles away - it just seems rather strange that, given the option of a local Catholic school, most parents would travel miles out of their way? Maybe it's just me but I'm not buying it.

Sirzy · 07/08/2018 07:51

But the op made it very clear that was the School they chose. Therefore that puts a very different slant on things.

It’s awful when there is no other choice and that shouldn’t be the case but it isn’t the case here. The parents decided it was the best school yet want to pick and choose which bits they like!

BoomBoomsCousin · 07/08/2018 07:49

”Moreover, the OP said in an early post that the Catholic school is undersubscribed. That doesn't often happen in an area where there are no other realistic choices, does it?”

Yes, this does happen. For instance, I n some areas there aren’t any choices other than faith schools, in others many children may be able to choose other schools because they have transportation options or after school care options that work but people without those options are stuck. And in some places it is the undersubscribed school that you get stuck with after all your choice schools turn you down because they are oversubscribed.

PurpleFlower1983 · 07/08/2018 07:42

That’s what happens in faith schools, particularly Catholic schools, you will have ‘signed up’ for this when she started. In my school it’s not taught as fact.

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 07:36

P3onyPenny

Don't be so silly. They built schools on land they owned to aid the common good in the first place. There is no reason they should give that land to the state just because the state decides (which it hasn't) that they don't want religious involvement in education. If the government doesn't want faith schools, the government needs to provide the alternative.

P3onyPenny · 07/08/2018 07:34

I think churches holding onto land with schools on should think of the common good and release it ie practise what they preach. They have no need for it.

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 07:14

freshstart24

Fair enough, Fresh, but you still don't get to demand a school changes its whole ethos because you were limited in your choices. How is that their problem?

Moreover, the OP said in an early post that the Catholic school is undersubscribed. That doesn't often happen in an area where there are no other realistic choices, does it?

Dovesfly · 07/08/2018 07:12

YABU it is a Catholic school, so the pupils will be taught the faith.

That's what happens when you send a child to a religious school.

freshstart24 · 07/08/2018 07:08

Skittles I get your point in regard to the OP. However, I had no choice but to send my DC to our local large CofE primary.

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 07:05

P3onyPenny

The Church owns land for the same reason anyone else in this country does: they bought it or they stole it. Get rid of all private property rights (including the Queen's) and I would agree with you.

Paradyning · 07/08/2018 07:05

Ok just rtft. But still. As a PP said. Concentrate on teaching her critical thinking at home. She's at an RC school as her parents chose that get over it. The tiny, perceived terrible, part about religion is probably negated but the great ethos and education she may be getting otherwise. And thriving in a small school Environment.

Skittlesandbeer · 07/08/2018 07:00

I’m shaking my head.

If you saw a Thai cooking class advertised and signed up, would you come away huffing that the teacher didn’t spend enough time explaining German cuisine, and explaining that other cultures use different ingredients??! Would you be complaining that they should have catered especially to you, because the other cooking classes were too geographically far away for you, or were beyond your budget?? This is what your posts sound like.

Leaving aside that as a step-parent your only involvement with the kid’s religious education is the initial choice you made to join a religious family.

A religious school teaches, reinforces and lives the doctrine of that religion. To the people in that religion, what you call ‘beliefs’ are actually their truths. Why you’d think they’d do anything different beggars belief.

Paradyning · 07/08/2018 06:58

Oh my days. You've chosen to send to a RC school. And you aren't accepting the religious teaching. Hahahahhaha

freshstart24 · 07/08/2018 06:48

Our local primary is a CofE school.

Religion was taught as fact.

At one point DS believed in it all firmly and had 'the fear' and 'guilt', that is so familiar to me as a child educated in a convent.

At 11 he now does not believe. I'm not sure why. I too am an atheist but haven't shared my views with him as I didn't want to influence him either way.

The local primary spent hours and hours and hours teaching RE. After literacy and numeracy it was viewed as the most important subject.

Many of the children were from homes which practise different religions, or no religion at all. It all feels like a colossal waste of precious time to me. I appreciate that everyone has a right to their own belief, but to spend hours and hours teaching one set of beliefs to children who could sorely do with more physical education and guidance on the challenges of the modern world (technology, social media, mental health relationships).

My firm belief FWIW is that RE should be scaled down and lessons geared towards improving mental health and resilience should take their place.

P3onyPenny · 07/08/2018 06:42

Well surely it’s about time said land was taken off churches. Goes back to ancient hardly fair laws. Didn’t Henry 8th also then go on to taking church land off those he didn’t like to give to his mates. Some houses are built on previously owned church land which reserved the right to still ask for taxes if they so wish when they sold it. Still could if they wanted to.

The state shouldn’t be funding church schools, for many parents they literally have no choice and have to suck up church schools foisted on them. It’s an outdated system.

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 06:29

Rafals:

It was just my understanding. But having looked it up:

The school buildings and land of Catholic schools are owned by the Catholic Church. The Church provides these premises, at no charge, to enable the state to fulfil its obligation to provide education for the population. The day to day running costs of Catholic schools are funded by the state in the same way that all schools are funded (either through local authority or DfE funding agreements). The Church covers 10% of the capital costs for the maintenance of the premises.

So, although the cost of education is funded by the state, if the Catholic Church was disallowed from providing education, the government would have to build about 2,500 new schools.

Trazey · 07/08/2018 04:31

It's a Catholic school! YABVVVU.

Her parents were unreasonable to send her to a religious school. I wish we lived in a secular society but CofE is interwoven into our politics.

Not all schools have to follow the NC.

HarveySchlumpfenburger · 06/08/2018 22:45

I know Catholic schools receive considerable Church funding anyway, so there would be a shortfall there.

Do you have personal experience, because I think you’d be surprised how little they are paying. The last figure I can find is 5 years out of date and it’s likely to be much lower now given the number of VA schools that have converted into academies since then.

Walkingdeadfangirl · 06/08/2018 22:36

People A lot of voters want selection, but it seems unacceptable to say so. So we use 'faith' selection as an acceptable code for promoting/increasing it. Why cant people just be honest.

Don't answer I know why Sad

WrongOnTheInternet · 06/08/2018 21:12

Oops, that should have been Catherine Nixey. Clearly not the best example of checking my sources Smile www.amazon.co.uk/Darkening-Age-Christian-Destruction-Classical/dp/1509812326?tag=mumsnetforum-21