Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think schools shouldn't teach religion as absolute fact?

593 replies

PoesyCherish · 06/08/2018 13:35

DSD is 6 and is learning about Christianity in school. They're teaching her Jesus is the Son of God rather than "some people believe he is". Everything about the religion is taught as fact. They've also failed to mention anything about any other religion.

AIBU to think they shouldn't be teaching it as absolute fact? How are children supposed to be understanding and tolerant of other people's beliefs if they're taught one world view as fact?

OP posts:
Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 10:18

WrongOnTheInternet

That's not 'the point', it is your point. What if I don't care for the god of Reason?

WrongOnTheInternet · 07/08/2018 10:13

Reason has brought us improvements to women’s rights, now and in Rome. Reason has brought us medicine. Reason has brought us the ability to understand our impacts on the environment, and could give us the tools to reduce that. What does religion offer, beyond intolerance and burning at the stake?

00100001 · 07/08/2018 10:09

Just teach something different at home 0 it's not that bloody hard

WrongOnTheInternet · 07/08/2018 10:09

Ah. “Shut up and go away because I want my religion over reason”. You do realise you’re proving the point, which is that religion and reason are opposed?

00100001 · 07/08/2018 10:09

OH DEAR GOD!

you send your child to a FAITH BASED school and then get pissy that they teach the fucking faith... EYE ROLL

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 10:04

WrongOnTheInternet

It worries you. Fair enough. It doesn't worry me. Why do your needs and preferences trump mine?

JacquesHammer · 07/08/2018 09:58

On another note if you CHOOSE to send your child to a CATHOLIC SCHOOL when you are not catholic then basically shut the fK up

Yeah....have you seen the posts from people where there isn’t a choice? Or you have to have the money to educate elsewhere?

so many non catholics send children to a Catholic school because simply they are always come out on top

They don’t.

lazyhazysummer · 07/08/2018 09:57

Why on earth is it always ok to bash Christian beliefs, but if a muslim came on to talk about their beliefs and what their religion stands for hardly anyone would dare question anything. Islamic beliefs are taught as facts, Catholic schools have the right to do the same.

user1484424013 · 07/08/2018 09:51

If you send your child to a CATHOLIC SCHOOL then they should learn about how jesus is the son of god because to is he is.

Also they will be taught about other faiths as it is part of the curriculum and I find its something catholic schools do very well.

On another note if you CHOOSE to send your child to a CATHOLIC SCHOOL when you are not catholic then basically shut the f**K up.

so many non catholics send children to a Catholic school because simply they are always come out on top. That's a fact and before some mn warriors jump on me it's am catholic I raise my children as catholic baptised within 2 weeks of birth and the whole shebang however I do not force it upon my children however is you were to asking them what christmas is about they will simply reply jesus.

so my advise to you is going to a non catholic school because your post is offensive

ladyvimes · 07/08/2018 09:45

In defence of Catholic schools this isn’t how it should be taught. Our diocese encourages questioning and discussion over all aspects of Catholicism and children are encouraged to make up their own minds. And we definitely teach ‘catholics believe’ rather than ‘this is the truth’!

LynetteScavo · 07/08/2018 09:42

My D.C. go to a Catholic school and in RE lessons they have always been taught "Catholics believe..." But in every day life of the school (assemblies, etc) it will be said that Jesus is the son of God. Because that is was Catholics believe.
So, yes YABU to think this shouldn't be considered a fact in Catholic schools.

How are children supposed to be understanding and tolerant of other people's beliefs if they're taught one world view as fact? This could be taken as quite offensive by many Christians, Muslims, etc who raise tolerant, respectful D.C. while still teaching them if their faiths beliefs.

WrongOnTheInternet · 07/08/2018 09:37

A quick google on the matter of choice brings up these. Circumstances may be different, but they demonstrate the reality of choice in schools.

fairadmissions.org.uk/how-religious-selection-in-schools-unfairly-limits-parental-choice-2/

www.secularism.org.uk/opinion/2013/04/why-are-children-being-forced-into-faith-schools

“Choice” politics have often been shown to provide no choice at all, particularly for those at the bottom of Britain’s social hierarchy.

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 09:30

BoomBoomsCousin

I'm just not seeing it. A community where people are so reluctant to send their child to the Catholic school that it is undersubscribed, but where the only other option is a long drive away? I am feeling it is more likely that this was a goady post.

BoomBoomsCousin · 07/08/2018 09:25

r Pengggwn

What makes no sense? The most local school is a Catholic school. Most local people don’t want to send their children to it and so those that can apply elsewhere. Some of those that apply elsewhere get in. The rest are left with the local school, which cannot be adapted by the LA to suit local parents or made smaller to reflect demand because it is a faith school. So it continues to serve whatever small Catholic population still wants it and the few unlucky others who aren’t allocated a preferable school that they can actually get to. That’s a perfectly normal situation for parents to find themselves in.

freshstart24 · 07/08/2018 09:08

I appreciate that the OP may have had a choice regarding sending DC to catholic school.

Some of us had no choice- my DC went to local CofE primary which had a huge emphasis on RE. I had absolutely no choice in this- yet had to go to the local school as allocated by LEA.

As I said earlier, RE was taught intensively, and delivered as fact. That's hours and hours and hours of religious teaching to Christian children, children of other faiths and children of no faith at all. In the case of my DC they left feeling it was folk-law.

I felt it was a shame that so many hours were devoted to this when the school itself claimed that the demands of the corriculum left insufficient time for PE, and lessons realating to the modern world such as social education, discussions about technology, mental health, resilience etc..

There is a general consensus that education needs to change to embrace these things- why not reduce RE at least a bit to make way for these essential lessons.

WrongOnTheInternet · 07/08/2018 09:04

Religion is demonstrably not true. Their reliance and elevation of the ‘nobility’ of faith in defiance of the blindingly obvious is not consistent with science anyway - and again, given the role of religion in propping up inequality and misogyny it’s interesting that it should grow in power now.

WrongOnTheInternet · 07/08/2018 09:01

Penggwn, at the moment I have the option but I can easily see not having it in the future. Secondaries around here are nearly all faith schools. Plus as local government’s control of schools continues to be attacked and religion grows stronger there is likely to be yet more nonsense and less choice in the future. Given religion’s historic uses and current trends in our society, I find this genuinely worrying. I still have the opt-out option at the moment for main school RE, but using it makes my child stand out. It is worrying.

LeighaJ · 07/08/2018 09:01

I went to a private Christian school, zero people were surprised or bothered that I was therefore taught about Christianity and as a fact.

Why would anyone be shocked that a private Catholic school did the same?

It doesn't matter why a child is put in a specific private, religious school, sending them there means accepting they will be taught about that specific religion in addition to normal classes. Also why should they teach them about all the different religions equally?

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 08:58

Teach religion as folkloric history. Not as fact

How damaging. "Billions of people in the world believe X but it's bollocks, obvs."

IfyouseeRitaMoreno · 07/08/2018 08:50

Teach religion as folkloric history. Not as fact.

Plus, don’t just teach them Abrahamic religions. DS went to regular secondary school. Islam and Xtianity were the main ones studied and they weren’t encouraged to debate in case it offended the Muslim or Christian children.

Which is a bit annoying in itself as you can’t really have a Muslim or Christian child when faith is supposed a personal choice.

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 08:49

The ultimate get-out clause. How much nonsense are we prepared to tolerate compared to actual observable facts?

You don't have to tolerate it. Don't send your child somewhere they are going to teach what you consider to be "nonsense" if you are not prepared to accept them doing that. It isn't rocket science (which is, I consider, "observable fact"!).

JacquesHammer · 07/08/2018 08:48

That may well be the case, but I don't believe that there is no other local primary other than the faith school, but local parents still send their kids to a school miles out of their way. It makes no sense

We applied to the 5 closest by distance. 3 and 4 select on faith grounds. We didn’t get any of them.

We went to appeal and were given the local catholic primary which is (and remains) undersubscribed.

We were fortunate in that we were able to take other options. Had we not though we would have been left with a school completely not of our choosing.

As I said early “choice” is a misnomer. It’s expressing a preference.

WrongOnTheInternet · 07/08/2018 08:44

"YABU. To Catholics it IS fact, so to speak."

The ultimate get-out clause. How much nonsense are we prepared to tolerate compared to actual observable facts? Schools are supposed to educate in knowledge and thought, not random unsupported beliefs. We are in danger of losing science and civic toleration both if this trend teaching that beliefs and feelings trump fact and thought (thinking of trans ideology too) continues.

lazyhazysummer · 07/08/2018 08:43

I'm appalled that anyone thinks catholic schools shouldn't teach about their religion as fact. How odd to teach it but then to say but this might not be true. Can you imagine any other religion doing that. If you send your child to a Catholic school just because it's "a good school" then don't be disgruntled because shock horror they're teaching their religion. I hope the day never comes when they stop.

Vicky1990 · 07/08/2018 08:43

My thoughts are that no school should teach any religion as they are made up concepts from long ago when people didn't know any better.
They all cause problems and have resulted in more conflicts and deaths over the centuries than any thing else.
It is a form of brain washing where different sets of bullshit are handed on from one generation to the next.