Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think schools shouldn't teach religion as absolute fact?

593 replies

PoesyCherish · 06/08/2018 13:35

DSD is 6 and is learning about Christianity in school. They're teaching her Jesus is the Son of God rather than "some people believe he is". Everything about the religion is taught as fact. They've also failed to mention anything about any other religion.

AIBU to think they shouldn't be teaching it as absolute fact? How are children supposed to be understanding and tolerant of other people's beliefs if they're taught one world view as fact?

OP posts:
Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 12:32

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cult_of_Reason

There is a quite interesting correlation between some of the anti-clerical attitudes expressed in this thread and the attitudes enshrined at the peak of the French Revolutionary Terror in the Festival of Reason.

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 12:29

echt

No, I inferred it. The attitudes expressed by that poster towards reason bear several comparisons to the attitudes expressed by some persons of faith towards their gods: the sense of infallibility, the sense that others must recognise that infallibility, the desire to eradicate all other modes of thought or feeling. Very similar to deification.

I don't care one speck whether you agree or not.

echt · 07/08/2018 12:26

may or may not be reasonable in my inference

You're definitely not. You made it up.

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 12:24

that's irrational

It would be irrational to say the other poster intended the implication. Obviously I cannot say that. I can only say that I think the implication is present, whether she intended it or not. That certainly isn't irrational.

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 12:22

ImAIdoot

I am not 'holding anyone responsible' for anything, am I? I am merely stating my view of the implications of the marks on a page made by another person. I am 100% entitled to do so.

MrsPreston11 · 07/08/2018 12:18

We're atheists so didn't even consider any faith schools for our girls.

But TBH that's what I'd expect of a catholic school. Surely Catholics believe the bible as fact?

I'd be very upset though if a non-faith school starting teaching Jesus as fact not a story that some people believe.

ImAIdoot · 07/08/2018 12:18

People cannot be held responsible for things people impute that they did not intend. They can apologise for giving offence but that is at their discretion.

This is actually one of the markers of our slide into post-rationalism and results in non-existent concepts like microaggression etc.. You cannot make up intentions someone does not have in your own mind and hold them accountable for those intentions, that's irrational, you can only hold people responsible for what they did say.

ImAIdoot · 07/08/2018 12:14

Faith schools have a right to exist if they aren't inciting extremism and violence, and if they service a community that wants them, extreme secularists should not be allowed to prevent those communities or government from offering them funding. Of course people with antipathy towards other people's religions should have a right to express their opinion but not step in and dictate. A line has to be drawn.

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 12:14

echt

Let me help you. Implications are not things that people say. Implications at e things that are implied.

But those things can only be considered to be implied because they are inferred, and inference can only occur through the mediating presence of the mind of the listener or reader.

You do not infer the same from her statements as I do. I may or may not be reasonable in my inference, and you may or may not be reasonable in your interpretation.

That she did not explicitly say what I inferred is irrelevant because, if she had explicitly said it, it wouldn't be inference at all.

echt · 07/08/2018 12:10

Again, I know it is not her deliberate implication. This is my view of the implications of her attitude and words. This is what happens when our thoughts and words encounter those of others: others think through the implications and draw their own conclusions.

No, Pengggwn, in the context of this thread, which is about religious belief, your ascribing the deification of reason to what WrongOnTheInternet said is not what she said. You made it up.

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 12:04

noeffingidea

But the government funds faith schools in the full knowledge that many parents want religion taught as fact. Why would they draw your line for you?

noeffingidea · 07/08/2018 12:03

Any school that receives public money should not be allowed to teach religious belief as a fact, whether they are a faith based school or not. Of course children need to learn about religion in order to understand other subjects - history, sociology etc but there needs to be a line drawn.

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 11:50

echt

Again, I know it is not her deliberate implication. This is my view of the implications of her attitude and words. This is what happens when our thoughts and words encounter those of others: others think through the implications and draw their own conclusions. It is irrelevant whether she thought them through to that conclusion or not - I did.

echt · 07/08/2018 11:43

Confused But your inference is not her implications i.e. you say she said things she never said, i.e. that reason is a god.

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 11:39

echt

I know it isn't. I inferred it, so I think it.

Deadheadstickeronacadillac · 07/08/2018 10:54

*rtft not raft!
(I can actually raft tho)

Deadheadstickeronacadillac · 07/08/2018 10:53

@missfattyfatty regarding Santa, I had a formal complaint against me for saying that Santa was a construct as well as a lot of the Christmas traditions...including how the Gospel writers used Greek, Roman and Hebrew myth around the birth narrative of Jesus. We were investigating the concept of religious myth and their purpose and how there can be the same in secular society.
I wouldn't mind but this was with a Year 8 class, not even primary!

echt · 07/08/2018 10:53

Oh I am. Nothing else is valid, everybody who says anything she deems "irrational" has automatically lost the argument

But she has not set up reason as a god. You have inferred she has, which is not the same.

Deadheadstickeronacadillac · 07/08/2018 10:49

Typical useless RE teaching in primary school because the teachers don't understand and refuse to consult with the secondary specialists who are more than willing to help.
We then have to deal with kids who detest RE, but most of the time within one term they realise it isn't an absolute and they really begin to enjoy it.
It is the only subject that has to be taught in some form until age 18 and therefore needs to be taught in a discursive, non absolutist way.
I do apologise but I can't raft as I know it will push my blood pressure up!
I bloody love my subject and am not religious at all, I have taught many students who have also come to love the subject and it still helps them in their careers...actors, lawyers, doctors, midwives, accountants, SAHM etc!

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 10:35

the worship of your gods

Monotheist here. God.

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 10:34

echt

Oh I am. Nothing else is valid, everybody who says anything she deems "irrational" has automatically lost the argument.

echt · 07/08/2018 10:33

I'm not sure WrongOnTheInternet has set up reason as god.

WrongOnTheInternet · 07/08/2018 10:33

With the number of people ‘encouraging’ the worship of your gods over reason, and the increasing backing of the state, we’re in danger of losing it. Anyway, things to do, people to see, toodle pip.

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 10:26

WrongOnTheInternet

I didn't say I have no use for reason. It is very useful. I said I don't worship it as a deity.

WrongOnTheInternet · 07/08/2018 10:23

Well at least that’s honest. I take it you will make no further demands on the knowledge that reason has brought then? No more medicine, no more schools at all - why do you bother? - and a very restricted food supply? Why are you on the internet even, using devices created by reason?

Swipe left for the next trending thread