Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think schools shouldn't teach religion as absolute fact?

593 replies

PoesyCherish · 06/08/2018 13:35

DSD is 6 and is learning about Christianity in school. They're teaching her Jesus is the Son of God rather than "some people believe he is". Everything about the religion is taught as fact. They've also failed to mention anything about any other religion.

AIBU to think they shouldn't be teaching it as absolute fact? How are children supposed to be understanding and tolerant of other people's beliefs if they're taught one world view as fact?

OP posts:
Pengggwn · 08/08/2018 08:17

The state doesn’t just accept all applications and, in any case, most parents are not capable of doing so.

Sorry, so what you are saying is, because you and people in your community who are of your (hypothetical) faith can't meet the standard required to open a school, I can't send my child to the school that did? Or, if I can, you have to be able to as well (changing its character in the process)?

That is pure dog in the manger.

We are all entitled to apply for passports and leave the country. But there are some conditions, like, you have to provide evidence of your child's identity and appropriately sized photographs. Should I be banned from taking my children to Sweden because you lost your birth certificate and sent in a Polaroid?

This isn't privilege. Everyone has the same rights, some have not put themselves in a position to exercise them. I will not punish my children for that.

CantankerousCamel · 08/08/2018 08:17

People seem to be confused. My children (and probably most of the children here) don’t go to ‘faith schools)

They go to CofE primary schools or Catholic primary schools but those are different to faith schools.

It means they’re connected to a church not that they’re faith schools. Faith schools are run independently and have funding from the church.

BoomBoomsCousin · 08/08/2018 08:11

I have never said it’s a privilege specifically for Catholics and I have some sympathy for Catholic state schools, given the historical CofE domination of schooling. But faith schools in general are an exception to our anti-discrimination laws.

And the idea that parents are equally well served because they could just set up a school themselves? Err, no they can’t. The state doesn’t just accept all applications and, in any case, most parents are not capable of doing so. So there is not the same access to a school that would be exclusionary for them to balance out all the schools that are exclusionary against them.

CantankerousCamel · 08/08/2018 08:10

I see the Easter story as no different to a Muslim preaching about suicide bombers. Neither should be in our schools.

CantankerousCamel · 08/08/2018 08:09

YANBU. In our catchment are three primaries

All are CofE.

We have to deal with my 5 year old coming home and telling us in great detail how Jesus died on the cross with nails through his hands.

Barbaric. You speak to anyone about it and they say that it’s a ‘story about love’ sorry but if it takes the torture and death of a human to define ‘love’ in your religion, you should be having a word with yourself!!

We are atheist and kindly and calmly try and fight against the ‘ramming down throats’ nature of the school.

LEMtheoriginal · 08/08/2018 08:05

Dont like it dont choose to educate your child as a catholic. Its not rocket science.

Also the school is obliged to teach about other religeons however tgeir main ethos will be catholic.

Pengggwn · 08/08/2018 07:59

JassyRadlett

I'm really sorry but I have to take issue with this. You have this backwards. It isn't "their local school". It is a school founded and built by Catholics for the education of Catholic children. It is not discrimination for it to be used, primarily, for the education of Catholic children, and actually I think there is a subtle entitlement going on here. You want to send your child to the school you want them to go to, so you are pretending some injustice is being done because a religious body wanted to educate children of their faith. There is no injustice. You just have to use the nearest school provided by your government.

And Catholic schools aren't "creaming off" children (hideous expression). They are selecting children from within their faith community, as they are entitled to do.

I am out now, because I am getting bored defending the facts to a group of people intent on distorting them.

JassyRadlett · 08/08/2018 07:53

How is it at the expense of others? Education of Catholic children takes place on sites owned by the Church, and is funded to the same level as non-Catholic children.

And allowed to use that money to discriminate against other children.

If a child cannot go to their local school because of religious discrimination, and have to take a bus or drive to a further away school as a result, that comes at the expense of that child’s parents. It also comes at a cost to that family’s free time and the time they have for non-school activities, including homework and family time.

If a child cannot access a reasonably local education, it comes at a cost to them in terms of how able they are to socialise with their schoolmates out of hours, but also how able they are to participate in the out-of-hours life of the school.

If a child is lied to during their education (told that a particular religion is fact), that comes at a cost to the credibility of our education system.

If (as is the case for schools that practise religious discrimination in selection), their intakes are disproportionately well-off, then children from poor and often more chaotic (so unable to meet the criteria for faith selection) homes are unable to access their local school, then they are further disadvantaged then they were to start with, at a cost to social mobility.

If faith schools cream off a large proportion of the better-off children in an area, then children statistically more likely to be challenging to the education system will disproportionately attend other schools, at a cost to those schools.

If social cohesion between faiths is undermined by religious segregation in schools, that comes at a cost to society.

What you want is to be able to treat those schools like they are the property of the State - they are not.

You would be better off not making assumptions about what others want.

LouBlue1507 · 08/08/2018 07:44

I went to a school that taught Christianity as fact. We would learn about Jesus, go to chapel and do the nativity play every year. I never believed in God or Jesus but it did me no harm what so ever. I loved my primary school and going to church was nice, being part of the community etc.

Pengggwn · 08/08/2018 07:42

That’s something you need to take responsibility for, not expect the state to provide at the expense of others.

How is it at the expense of others? Education of Catholic children takes place on sites owned by the Church, and is funded to the same level as non-Catholic children. What you want is to be able to treat those schools like they are the property of the State - they are not.

Pengggwn · 08/08/2018 07:40

You are privileged to be the recipient of positive discrimination for your particular faith by the state.

Nope. People of any faith can set up a school, have it inspected and provide more places for children of their faith. It is not discrimination, because you could do the same thing if you wished.

Pengggwn · 08/08/2018 07:39

BoomBoomsCousin

But that legal exception is made for schools so everyone can have the same right, Boom. It isn't a 'privilege' specifically for Catholics.

JassyRadlett · 08/08/2018 07:34

I want the support of my government to educate my child in her faith, as I believe I am entitled to do.

No, you are not entitled to that. You are more likely to have the opportunity to do so if you are Catholic or CofE, but you are not entitled to the state supporting you in teaching your child your faith. Frankly, raising your child in your faith is your choice. That’s something you need to take responsibility for, not expect the state to provide at the expense of others.

You are privileged to be the recipient of positive discrimination for your particular faith by the state. If you lived in the wrong place, or were the wrong religion, you wouldn’t get that. If you were atheist you would find there is (in law) no secular education in England, and no opportunity to start new secular schools.

I am not going to apologise for that, it is totally fair enough.

‘Fairness’ is an interesting word to use when you’re talking about religious discrimination against five year olds.

BoomBoomsCousin · 08/08/2018 07:34

I think you are missing the point that discriminating on the basis of religion is illegal when employing people or providing services. But a legal exception is made for schools.

Your idea that you don’t have a legal exception allowing you to discriminate would be like saying - don’t worry about the law that gives us free reign to be racist when it suits us. If you want you can set up a racist school too, so it’s fine.

Pengggwn · 08/08/2018 07:18

Boom/Walking:

I am going to wrap up my posts on this now, because this isn't supposed to be a debate about the existence of faith schools. Rather, it is a debate about whether, having sent your child to one, you can expect it to change around you.

But to answer some of your points:

  1. Boom: I don't see it as a "legal exception" for me or for Catholics. The same law applies to you as applies to me. We both have the right to send our children to educational institutions that reflect our beliefs. If you and your family are Jedi knights, and you can find a group of Jedi knights in possession of a school and providing an acceptable standard of education, legally, the government would have to give those people the funding to educate your child. And yes, they would be able to put in place selection criteria to ensure that their educational offering prioritised the families in their faith. But if they own the school and buildings, they are not robbing anyone. They are simply making use of the same funding that would go with each child to a non-Jedi school.

Walking: It is impossible? Well, perhaps that is true. But this system that (may allow - I still have to apply) me to privilege my children by educating them in their faith is available to you too. Whatever faith you are, you can set up schools, have them inspected, offer selection on the basis of that faith. It is not my fault that the faith I happen to hold is older and has more money than the Jedi knights. The law itself does not privilege me over anybody else.

Cuppaorwine · 07/08/2018 22:12

Keep faith out of schools. Teach faiths as part of RE but no more.

Schools should be a place of learning and discovery of facts not fiction.

If you are that scared of non faith schools you clearly don’t think your religion stands up to a child’s scrutiny. Brain wash them at home. Let them breathe at school

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 21:41

Walkingdeadfangirl

Now 'eh, as they say - I just said I was shattered! No need for the parting insulting comments when we can pick this up in the morning!

Walkingdeadfangirl · 07/08/2018 21:40

Pengggwn I am off for the night as well.

But you keep ignoring the cost to society to enable you to privilege your children. Its impossible for every area to have a selective school that caters for every faith and ability that a parent might want.

So when you demand your faith has a privileged education over ever other child not of that religion then you are walking across and breaking the backs of everyone else. Do you not care?

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 21:23

BoomBoomsCousin

I will answer you, but in the morning, Boom. I am shattered.

BoomBoomsCousin · 07/08/2018 21:22

Pengggwn Faith schools have legal exceptions for what they can teach (the very subject of the OP!) and to allow them to discriminate on the basis of religion in hiring and service provision. You were just arguing that a faith school that can't discriminate for entrance was no faith school at all!

As well as costs to society in terms of poorer provision for other children, the inefficiencies in transportation and the social costs of a more divided society, they also cost the state more because they tend to concentrate service on the children who are less expensive to educate (as do virtually all schools with restrictive selection criteria) thereby pushing costs on to other schools.

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 21:22

Walkingdeadfangirl

If the Conservative party started its own medical trust for Conservatives on its own land, but the government picked up the cost of treatment because it would be the same or more expensive not to, I would have not a single thing to say about it other than bit weird, but their choice.

But it isn't quite the same as that. Education has been passed into law - I have to educate my child (not that I mind but the principle remains). The government has therefore left me considerable discretion in how I choose to do it, and rightly so, in my opinion.

Your last point seems quite silly. Faith doesn't work quite like that. It isn't an "education", as I said before. It is a way of living. Parents who choose a faith-based education want faith to extend into the different spheres of their child's life. They want it to be holistic, as is their right.

Walkingdeadfangirl · 07/08/2018 21:13

Pengggwn Its not about the financial cost, its the cost to society. Would you be happy paying taxes for the NHS if you were only allowed to access your closest hospital dependant upon your parents being a member of the Conservative party when you were born?

Or would you support NHS being open to everyone?

Taxes should not be spent to deliberately create inequality. So your privilege has to be balanced with someones else's discrimination. But it seems you dont care about that.

Why do you feel unable to teach your children about your beliefs at home and at church?

AFigTree · 07/08/2018 20:51

OP. I am with you all the way on this. It disturbs me that religion has got its talons into education. It’s wrong.

Now what can we all do about it?

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 20:43

Walkingdeadfangirl

See my post to BoomBoom. I am not asking anybody else to pay for it, and everyone has the same right I am asserting here. If they choose not to participate in any faith, that is up to them.

Pengggwn · 07/08/2018 20:42

BoomBoomsCousin

It costs no more taxpayer money to educate my child in a Catholic context than it does to educate them in a secular context. In fact, it costs less, because the government does not have to pay for the land, the building or for the portion of the maintenance cost that the Church pays.

I also do not want a legal exception. Anybody is entitled to send their child to a school which educates according to their faith, bar extremists.