Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think schools shouldn't teach religion as absolute fact?

593 replies

PoesyCherish · 06/08/2018 13:35

DSD is 6 and is learning about Christianity in school. They're teaching her Jesus is the Son of God rather than "some people believe he is". Everything about the religion is taught as fact. They've also failed to mention anything about any other religion.

AIBU to think they shouldn't be teaching it as absolute fact? How are children supposed to be understanding and tolerant of other people's beliefs if they're taught one world view as fact?

OP posts:
JacquesHammer · 08/08/2018 09:28

How exactly do atheists think their own kids will be damaged by being told to love their neighbour, to be kind, to share, to take turns

I’ve taught my child all of that. Those character traits aren’t a sole bastion of Christianity Hmm

Pengggwn · 08/08/2018 09:26

CantankerousCamel

I am not engaging with you any further. I find everything about your posts so far deeply offensive.

CantankerousCamel · 08/08/2018 09:25

pen
‘The church’ don’t educate people in state schools. The government do.

CantankerousCamel · 08/08/2018 09:24

I think the question of whether some schools that focus on religion should be avaliable is very different to the reality that next to no secular schools are available.

Actually it makes far more sense for schools to be secular. I say secular because, of course, anyone with a brain knows that ‘atheist’ isn’t a faith Hmm

To best meet the needs of all children in the catchment, schools should offer an education suitable for the majority of those children. That is no longer a CofE or Christian school as more people stated they are ‘jedi’ than Christian on the last census.

Pengggwn · 08/08/2018 09:23

RafaIsTheKingOfClay

But nor is it the fault of the Church that the demographics of society changed. Why should they take responsibility for educating people who aren't Catholics anymore? It doesn't make sense.

You are basically saying the government was lazy and still is lazy, so the Catholic Church should now plug the gap. No.

Babdoc · 08/08/2018 09:20

It’s sad that some of the aggressive atheists on here are claiming that their non belief is fact and Christianity is fiction. Millions of Christians over two millennia have had direct encounters with the presence of God, including me. We know our faith to be a fact.
And it is not “a personal thing that should stay in the home”, or only be performed during a church service for one hour on Sundays - our faith affects every act of daily living and colours everything we do. Therefore we want our children to have the benefit of a loving relationship with God, and to be educated in accordance with that.
How exactly do atheists think their own kids will be damaged by being told to love their neighbour, to be kind, to share, to take turns, to know that Jesus loves them? “Sweet injuries” indeed, as the old hymn says!

Pengggwn · 08/08/2018 09:19

JassyRadlett

Again, not my responsibility.
Catholic schools were not historically within the purview of state education. Nobody has been disadvantaged, only helped, by these schools (notwithstanding the many issues regarding discipline, abuse, etc, which are horrifying but nothing to do with this).

This situation and its history does not give people the right to demand access to faith schools irrespective of faith. These schools were built for a purpose and are fulfilling that purpose.

Speak to your MP if you feel a new school needs to be built to meet your needs.

CantankerousCamel · 08/08/2018 09:18

For the last time, the CofE schools are NOT FAITH SCHOOLS.

They are paid for, in their entirety by the state.

They have a responsibility to educate every child, which in an increasingly secular Britain should represent the needs of all those families.

HarveySchlumpfenburger · 08/08/2018 09:18

It is a school founded and built by Catholics for the education of Catholic children

Historically they weren’t really. They were mainly set up because the government didn’t want the lower classes to be literate so the job of teaching children to read and write fell to the churches and some philanthropists. And often the church school is the local school because the aim was very much to widen access to education by opening a school in every parish.

It isn’t really the fault of parents now that the 19th C government decided the easiest way to provide universal education was to pay grants to pre existing church schools or that the Butler Act has been so undermined that church schools can now pay nothing towards the running of the school and still get to select which pupils they take.

The CofE is recognising the unfairness and is making steps towards removing faith based criteria. The Catholic Church, as is traditional, are resisting any change.

Pengggwn · 08/08/2018 09:16

JassyRadlett

The fact that the government takes account of faith schools in its planning - and thereby escapes the financial burden of building schools - is not my responsibility. The government needs to provide sufficient funding for you to educate your child according to your lights. It should not be banned to open secular schools. That does not mean I am doing anything wrong by exercising my rights.

Your problem is with the government, not with me.

JassyRadlett · 08/08/2018 09:15

I suggest you move or home educate so you don't have to expose your children - who I am sure are suffering as a result of your educational decision - to stories about torture and horrific death. How irresponsible of you.

But state-funded faith schools that exclude children who live locally (and in the case of CofE schools were historically their ‘local’ school) don’t come at the expense of anyone else? Wink

Giving up my job or home educating would cost quite a bit.

JassyRadlett · 08/08/2018 09:12

Schools are funded per child on the roll. Catholic schools - or any other schools selecting on faith to educate children on premises they own outright - are not soaking up state funding.

School planning - the provision of schools for a local area overall, and identification of need (one of the criteria for new schools) - is carried out on the basis of all state-funded schools in an area. Faith schools are included in this. So yes, a concentration of faith schools in a particular area for historical reasons, where the local demographics no longer match the faith school provision, means there is going to be limited scope for new schools. Even where there is demonstrated local need it is incredibly difficult to open a new school.

And if you want all children to have the same number of schools available to them regardless of faith, that is a reasonable position. I don agree with it, because I think educating your child within your faith is a fundamental right, but I accept that that is your argument.

It is not a fundamental right to have the taxpayer pick up the bill for your choice to educate your child within your faith. Your faith is given a privileged position in this country, and further you have had the luck to live somewhere where there is a school that caters to your faith. Plenty of people of faith do not get this provision from the state.

People of no faith are, of course, not allowed secular schools. And it is banned to open new ones.

In many countries faith education is funded by the faith or the parents. In very few places do they expect the state to pick up the bill, or for their schools to be included in state education provision.

In that case, the government would need to buy out the sites currently provided by the Catholic Church at their commercial value.

Well, not to ditch faith-based selection. That’s a simple change in the law, and it would be up to the Church of England and the Roman Catholic Church to decide whether they wanted to remain in the state system, or whether they wanted to withdraw from the state system and educate those children at their own or parents’ expense. It would be interesting to see. Given a significant number of more rural faith schools are undersubscribed, those schools would carry on as they are now.

However if the state did decide to make a generational investment in equality (which I’d be up for, because of the social benefits), I imagine any honest organisation would reflect in the sale price the vast sums of money they have saved in 70 years’ worth of maintenance, upkeep and new building. Wink

The government doesn't own them at the moment so no, they are not "the local schools"

The government treats them as if they are, to the detriment of children not of that faith.

JacquesHammer · 08/08/2018 09:09

I suggest you move or home educate

Notwithstanding the other points, that shouldn’t have to be the options for people who want a secular education.

Pengggwn · 08/08/2018 09:06

CantankerousCamel

I'm not here to defend my beliefs. They are none of your business. I suggest you move or home educate so you don't have to expose your children - who I am sure are suffering as a result of your educational decision - to stories about torture and horrific death. How irresponsible of you.

CantankerousCamel · 08/08/2018 09:01

Pen

Super argument. Well done.

Jassy

I tend to speak directly to the head and just make it very known that I don’t bloody want my children told about torture and horrific death in PRIMARY SCHOOL.

It, of course, doesn’t go in. They simply say that they are a CofE school and therefore quite happy to push the religious crap.

The fact that there are NO none CofE schools in catchment seems irrelevant to them or anyone else.

JassyRadlett · 08/08/2018 08:55

We are atheist and kindly and calmly try and fight against the ‘ramming down throats’ nature of the school.

We took the ‘we don’t want to undermine the school and confuse by saying his very nice teacher is unfortunately required by her employer to lie to him’ route. Lots of ‘some people believe’, you know the stuff.

He came home earlier this year and told us God had been killed by the Big Bang.

Sadly, it is undermining his enjoyment of school. He occasionally asks to leave/change schools because he feels excluded because ‘it’s a school that believes in god.’

Pengggwn · 08/08/2018 08:52

CantankerousCamel

Unhinged. That's all I have to say.

Pengggwn · 08/08/2018 08:51

JassyRadlett

That isn't how funding works, Jassy. Schools are funded per child on the roll. Catholic schools - or any other schools selecting on faith to educate children on premises they own outright - are not soaking up state funding. They are funded when - and only when - parents choose to send their children there.

And if you want all children to have the same number of schools available to them regardless of faith, that is a reasonable position. I don agree with it, because I think educating your child within your faith is a fundamental right, but I accept that that is your argument. In that case, the government would need to buy out the sites currently provided by the Catholic Church at their commercial value. The government doesn't own them at the moment so no, they are not "the local schools" - they are Catholic-owned.

I agree that the government is letting you down by not funding sufficient secular schools. I do not agree that the logical outcome of that is for you to automatically be able to send your children to a school that was not set up for them and not paid for by you as a taxpayer.

Anyway, I am out.

CantankerousCamel · 08/08/2018 08:36

missfatty

From my limited experience, Islam seems on a whole a far more peaceful doctrine and the majority of issues with those who follow it are socioeconomical. Something the war monger Christians don’t have to justify their blood thirst.

pen

More death, slavery, torture and pain in rhe name of Jesus than any other religion on earth.

Your religion is geared around a Roman ideal of divide and conquer. It’s a mass terroist handbook.

Again, if you need to use the torture and death of a person to define love, you have some issues to work out.

JassyRadlett · 08/08/2018 08:33

I'm really sorry but I have to take issue with this. You have this backwards. It isn't "their local school".

If, because of historic (not current) local demographics it is the only state-funded school within walking distance of their home, it is their local school. If, because of the past stranglehold of the Church of England, the only schools reasonably near them select by faith (and take children from some distance away), it is their local school. Either that, or they have no local school, which means that state funding for a faith school is putting them at a disadvantage because there is no state funding for a non-faith school. The state funding of a faith school comes at a cost to them.

It is a school founded and built by Catholics for the education of Catholic children. It is not discrimination for it to be used, primarily, for the education of Catholic children,

If the Catholic Church (or Church of England, or whomever else is running a faith school) were putting up the capital and administrative funding in direct proportion to the number of children to whom they were giving preferential access, then you’d have a stronger argument. In fact, all the administrative and almost all the capital funding comes from the state. State money is being used in ways that are discriminatory.

and actually I think there is a subtle entitlement going on here. You want to send your child to the school you want them to go to, so you are pretending some injustice is being done because a religious body wanted to educate children of their faith.

No. I want all children to have the same number of schools available to them, regardless of faith. I’d go further and have catchment-based lotteries to decrease discrimination by wealth.

There is no injustice.

Statistics suggest otherwise.

You just have to use the nearest school provided by your government.

My three nearest provided by my government are faith schools. The only schools I was offered by my government were faith schools. For some children, the state funding of faith schools means they only school they can access is a great distance from their homes. That has an impact on them. If the state were not engaging in the farce of educating your children in your faith because you don’t want your children to mix with children not of your faith or be exposed to equally weighted ideas, the state would be able to fund local provision.

If the state did not allow religious selection, you would have to either make the choice to live near enough to a school that matched your faith to be sure of getting in (at a cost to you), or get the same provision as anyone else.

And Catholic schools aren't "creaming off" children (hideous expression). They are selecting children from within their faith community, as they are entitled to do.

Yes. It is that current entitlement I take issue with and campaign as it is discriminatory by both religion and by class. Like it or not, the effect of religious selection is a disproportionately middle class intake. For people of faith to have preferential access to up to a third more schools - and some areas the majority of schools - is archaic and divisive.

A discriminatory works in your favour, and your children benefit from that discrimination. Good for you. Have the grace to acknowledge that it comes at a cost to others.

missfattyfatty · 08/08/2018 08:31

Dear cantankerous,

‘I see the Easter story as no different to a Muslim preaching about suicide bombers. Neither should be in our schools.’

Actually part of the resistance of Muslims to Christian theology and terrorist ideology is that we celebrate Eid every year rejoicing that God doesn’t require you to sacrifice your sons. The story of Abraham and his son (from the Bible) that God swapped out Isaac/Ishmael with a ram, we use every year to remind ourselves that whatever other rules God requires of us it’s never at the expense of our children. And our puzzlement with the New Testament story: why should God sacrifice his own son when he allowed the prophet Abraham to keep his?

Pengggwn · 08/08/2018 08:28

CantankerousCamel

Believe what you like, personally, obviously. Don't tell me the basis of my faith is the same as that of a terrorist, because that's shite and I will call you out on it.

CantankerousCamel · 08/08/2018 08:26

Pen

My children haven’t committed ‘sins’ that require anyone to be tortured to death for, neither have I.

You can keep your sin, your guilt, your Roman war-lord God who sacrifices his own children and spends eternity in a rage coz some chick ate an apple.

The whole thing is nothing but a woman hating, guilt infested excuse to send boys and men off to war to ‘die in glory like Jesus did’

No. Not in my house.

sashh · 08/08/2018 08:24

Even science does not produce absolute facts, it just produces theories

I'm not sure you understand science, a scientific theory explains how something works.

If you drop something it falls to the ground, the theory explaining this is the theory of gravity. A scientific theory is not the same as the way the word 'theory' is used as a guess or an idea in everyday English.

OP

If you look at the mission statement of RC schools quite often the education is secondary to 'Catholic ethos' or 'promotion of faith'.

The National Secular Society has a campaign, 'no more faith schools'

www.secularism.org.uk/faith-schools/

Pengggwn · 08/08/2018 08:19

I see the Easter story as no different to a Muslim preaching about suicide bombers. Neither should be in our schools.

You think Jesus sacrificing himself for the forgiveness of the sins of others is the same as people blowing up other people? Hmm

Swipe left for the next trending thread