Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to ask parent to not let my son play COD and Fornite when at their house?

84 replies

TheOrigFV45 · 01/08/2018 11:29

Boys are 9.
Is it better that I just don't allow my son to go to their house because I don't agree with children this age playing COD and Fortnite, or AIBU to ask the parent not to allow my son to play? Or just trust my son to not play (would be an odd play date in that case).

The only time I've done similar is with DS1 (now 19), when I said he wasn't allowed to go on friend's trampoline because it didn't have a net.

OP posts:
YeTalkShiteHen · 02/08/2018 09:07

nearlythesummer the graphics, the special effects (blood, guts the whole shebang) is a LOT more realistic in COD. Again, if it’s an adult playing who can cope with that, fine. Not a child though.

I did write upthread but not sure if it’s been lost but COD prompted a Combat PTSD related episode for BIL when his (old enough) son played it. The noise was just too realistic for him and he became very ill.

So while I’m not COD bashing, and can appreciate there are many adults who enjoy it, it is absolutely in no way suitable for children.

ProfessorMoody · 02/08/2018 07:56

Mild violence

There is mild violence in most computer games. Do you let them play Mario based games where you're encouraged to shoot characters with fireballs, push them off ledges and smash into them with cars? Zelda? Star Wars?

What about Minecraft where children are encouraged to stab villagers with swords and pickaxes and slaughter sweet looking animals by bludgeoning them to death? Fighting hoardes of zombies and other enemies?

If you let your children play these games, why not Fortnite? It's far less violent than Minecraft.

Also, it is not similar to Cod at all. Yes they both involve shooting others, as do many games. COD is very realistic and so are the deaths. The guns are real, there is blood. Some of the games are about real events in real places with realistic human people. There is in game bad language and very graphic content.

Fortnite has cartoon graphics with different characters, is played on a cartoon map which is the same every time. Yes you shoot people as you do in many children's games but there is no blood, you don't 'die', no bad language or graphic content and everything is aimed at children.

The games are worlds apart.

Have you played both , Nearlythesummer, to make that comparison?

thegreylady · 02/08/2018 07:29

I have two dgs aged 9 and 11. They have an X box and iPads. They mainly play Fifa and Forza. They had a spell of loving Minecraft but when I mentioned Fortnite there was zero interest and I was told it was ‘just a bit faddy ‘ and none of their friends play.
As for CoD and GTA they have never been mentioned and certainly wouldn’t be allowed in the house.

extinctspecies · 02/08/2018 07:22

The best thing about Fortnite is that my kids have lost interest in COD now.

(They are older teenagers though)

nearlythesummer · 01/08/2018 23:44

I know COD has bad language in it, but on the whole the violence is quite similar to Fortnite-guns, rocket launchers etc. I could be wrong though.

Monkeymonstermum · 01/08/2018 23:44

We’ve had a message from (primary) school setting out huge concerns they had about children playing Fortnite (I’d never heard of it before....). Apparently they thought they were getting issues with behaviour creeping over into school. The line from school was it’s a 12 so no one should be on it at primary. No one should feel left out as you should all stop it then it’s not an issue (love our headmistress and her whole school messages, no messing about and mincing words)!

HicDraconis · 01/08/2018 23:27

Neither of my sons are allowed to play CoD or Fortnite (12 and 10yo). We are a family of gamers (they play World of Warcraft at the weekends with us, Zelda, Ni No Kuni etc) but CoD isn't appropriate at their age and I have some concerns with how addictive Fortnite is. They have never seemed bothered about stopping WoW for the day once a dungeon is finished or a quest handed in but I have heard of older children having screaming tantrums when Fortnite is turned off.

I have no problems with parents asking for their children not to play certain games while at ours, and the boys have no issues with telling their friends they don't play Fortnite and finding something else to do. "All the other boys are allowed to play" gets met with "I'm not their mother. All the other boys probably aren't allowed other things that you are so it all evens out." And I know all the other boys aren't allowed either, it always comes as a surprise that mothers occasionally talk to each other!

Freshfeelings · 01/08/2018 23:10

I don't let peer pressure guide my parenting - my DS (10) also isn't allowed to play fortnite due to the violent theme and the chat. He doesn't get bullied about it because his school is big on raising nice, respectful kids. I wouldn't let him do anything I'd judged as inappropriate just because 'all the other kids are doing it and will bully him' - that's awful parenting. I think you're fine to tell other parents he's not allowed to play.

SunflowerJo08 · 01/08/2018 22:59

My DS is 11 and although we have a playstation here, laptop etc he does not play with it a huge deal here, we've deliberately always steered him away from it. As such I think it is fine for him to join in at a friend's house, and indeed he does with fortnite, but I would draw the line at COD and I would mention it to the parent.

we have some 18 games here such as GTA etc which came with the playstation, it's second hand; DS only really uses it when friends are round but I do not allow them to go on any shooting games as I don't think it is right, and my DS knows he is not allowed to do the same at friend's houses. The mum's know that too.

cariadlet · 01/08/2018 22:51

(Fortnite is) a 12 because of online chat capabilities and US copyright law

The online chat is a big potential danger, but if you go to the VSC rating board website (the authority that decides on PEGI ratings for games) it says that Fortnite "was rated PEGI 12 for frequent scenes of mild violence. It is not suitable for persons under 12 years of age."

GreenTulips · 01/08/2018 20:20

And not being allowed fortnite does create a social stigma

Maybe teach your kids to be nicer and not exclude others

LovingLola · 01/08/2018 19:38

And not being allowed fortnite does create a social stigma. Hate to say that but it does exclude kids from ALOT of school chatter. Just be wary you aren’t singling your kid out at an age when peer is everything. It’s good to police it a bit but don’t be ‘that’ parent.

This is a good article about not having a child play fortnite
www.independent.ie/life/family/parenting/dear-david-coleman-we-banned-fortnite-in-our-house-but-now-my-son-is-lonely-all-of-his-friends-play-it-for-hours-on-end-37160144.html

YorkiepudNgravy · 01/08/2018 18:55

DD plays fortnite & COD - only plays COD on the multiplayer mode where it isn’t the story isn’t graphic/swearing, you just try and find each other - wouldn’t let her play the story mode part though

DiegoMadonna · 01/08/2018 18:54

I am 'that' parent. Are you telling me that every single child has a playstation?

No, but those kids who don't have one have usually played on it at a friend's house, so they can at least join in the conversations and know what people are talking about. If they're banned from even playing it at a friend's then they've got no clue!

YeTalkShiteHen · 01/08/2018 18:49

ProfessorMoody I love that people are surprised Grin everyone needs something they can escape reality for a bit in don’t they? Mario Golf is about the only game I can play competently Blush

My kids run rings round me with technology!

ProfessorMoody · 01/08/2018 18:47

No problem! I'm a massive COD fan which surprises people as I'm old and a teacher but I love the realism and it's so therapeutic!

As for Fortnite being suitable for a 6 year old - it depends on what you want them playing. If you disable online chat, there aren't any concerns there, but the content of the game is guns and running round shooting. If you don't mind that, it's no worse than Star Wars. If you don't like gun stuff, then no, don't let them play it.

It's a 12 because of online chat capabilities and US copyright law.

Martydog · 01/08/2018 18:39

My 11 year old is not allowed to play either. They have their rating for a reason. He knows he is not allowed to play them and I have said to parents that he is not allowed to play them. I just tell my child that every parent has their own rules and he has to follow ours.

YeTalkShiteHen · 01/08/2018 18:31

ProfessorMoody sorry I missed your earlier post, my mistake.

I confess I’m not a gamer and as such am completely clueless about it but DPs brother is a huge fan of CoD and games like it. DP is a gamer but because of his experience in the theatre of war COD isn’t for him.

I apologise for not RTFT Blush

stayathomer · 01/08/2018 18:26

I'm not a gamer, is fortnite fine for 5/6 year olds as well? I thought it was quite violent but happy to be corrected!

I think it is actually meant to be for 12 and up

ProfessorMoody · 01/08/2018 18:09

For an adult

As I've clearly said in my earlier post.

However, the above poster said she wouldn't let them play it at any age. I'm curious as to why she wouldn't ever have them in her home, as they are fantastic games with amazing story modes and great online cooperative modes too.

Jadely98 · 01/08/2018 17:55

At the end of the day YOU are the parent and you're the one who gets to set the rules for your kid. I say, ask the parent not to let him play and explain your reasons why, assure them that you're not making judgement on them letting their son play it. Ask them if they can provide a different source of entertainment. Then, before the sleepover you explain to your son that you don't want him to be playing these games, you've told his friends parents, and if you find out that he's played it then he won't get another sleepover. He should be so excited just that you've allowed the sleepover.

If your son asks why you're not allowing this say honestly what you think and say he has to respect your wishes as a parent.

upsideup · 01/08/2018 17:50

YABU
If you don't like the way they parent and run playdates then dont send your child for them to look after.

YeTalkShiteHen · 01/08/2018 17:45

Why? It's a fantastic game

For an adult!

ProfessorMoody · 01/08/2018 17:40

I would never allow COD or anything of that ilk no matter what their age- it will not be in my house

Why? It's a fantastic game.

stayathomer · 01/08/2018 17:29

Definitely nub about COD but the issue with Fortnite is more something that is an issue at home (the addictiveness!). We've had children come here with instructions on what they're allowed play and we just kept the Xbox off and I was very impressed that they were mature enough to say it to us but if you think he'd be embarrassed/not say it it might be better if you way it to the parents, possibly just a relaxed by the way text message.

Swipe left for the next trending thread