Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People you had a sixth sense about and were right

481 replies

HarryPotterISreal · 30/07/2018 22:24

I’ve just been reading one of the spooky threads here and a poster talked about someone she got a bad feeling about and some months later was arrested for abuse or something. When someone is arrested who is a ‘pillar of the community’ someone always says ‘I never liked him, I could always tell’.

Do you have a story where you genuinely knew someone was bad news, though everyone else thought they were wonderful? How could you tell and did others eventually see their true colours?

OP posts:
Strippervicar · 03/08/2018 16:32

I've been watching a few days. Very different to most experiences. I have a facial birth defect. It definitely sorts people into different camps.
I find it very creepy and offputting when I get the type of person who looks straight through me with an expression on disgust on their face. They are absolutely lovely and friendly to others, including the party I am with. They completely ignore me or anything I say.
This person is usually a man. Usually one who is quite interested in the ladies. I find it so creepy and offputting that they cannot bring themselves to treat me as a person and I wonder just what goes on inside their heads.
Noteable examples, school bus driver he sold cans of pop and sweets, used to chat to the other children. Used to say he'd run out of pop when I got there but served others who were after me.
Barmen. DH has to come and rescue me very often because I have been standing at a not so busy bar being ignored.
A man who was top dog in a drama group I was in. He never spoke to me or looked at me in five years. To the point of buying all my girlfriends a drink bar me.
The next door neighbours at my parents house as I was growing up. (A couple admittedly.) They mounted some sort of campaign against us as a family. It all came out it was due to them not wanting me near their children because I was different. He turned out to be physically abusing the wife and step daughter so I assume it was more him than her. I went round to ask for a ball once. He shut the door in my face.

MrStarkIDontFeelSoGood · 03/08/2018 14:49

Having just read the post about a long lost relative it interested me. Something similar happened in our family in the last few years and the relative has created nothing but discord since they arrived. My immediate family all find them very off and a troublemaker but another family within our extended has pretty much taken them to their bosom. They have effectively, Wendied us in our own family Shock

TSSDNCOP · 03/08/2018 12:54

I’d have bet my house on Ian Huntley’s guilt as soon as I watched that news interview.

bananafish · 03/08/2018 12:25

I tend to trust my instincts even when (especially?) when they seem to go against the prevailing wind.

I worked with a man who was the absolute ‘golden boy’ of the organisation. He was promoted quickly, listened to with respect, no one had a bad word to say about him.

I really disliked him - couldn’t stand him. He made my skin crawl. I just had such a visceral reaction to him. He was my boss for a short while and it was terrible even though he never actually did anything wrong. I just knew he was a fake and a wrong ‘un.

He left, so did I, and I forgot about him. Until he popped up in the nationals convicted of having child pornography and trying to set up sex sessions with a 6 yr old and an 8 yr old. I wasn’t even surprised. Shocked, but not surprised.

Sirrah · 03/08/2018 12:18

My Grandma was married to a man who made my skin crawl, even as a child. I found out later that he'd beaten my dad when he was a teenager, tried it on with my mum, and sexually abused my cousins.

Hofty · 03/08/2018 11:55

@Daisymalone I agree entirely!!

DSHathawayGivesMeFannyGallops · 03/08/2018 11:35

I wouldn't say I think my radar is that great. I think I've met maybe 3 people I disliked in this way & was right. There's a few other people I dislike and I've just written it off as I don't like them for x reason, I can't like everyone.

Wrt to picking murderers etc, I think a couple of times I've thought something didn't add up and been proved right, not necessarily based on seeing people. Occasionally you'll see interviews & think people look/act guilty as fuck, but everyone is different. 1/100 times you might be right. The only ones I've reacted to at the time were thinking that Mick Philpott cried as he thought he ought to (but I told myself I was being awful), and a very visceral reaction to Jeremy Bambers creepy cousin- he set off my creepdar- but nothing proven.

Daisymalone · 03/08/2018 11:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

niketrainersarecomfy · 03/08/2018 11:14

A therapist. She em
Nded up blabbing my stuff after using my expertise work wise to benefit her greatly.
No doubt she's highly successful. Narcs like her often are.

BettyBooHoo · 03/08/2018 11:11

Yes, her expression was one of just the most awful crippling grief. Not stunned or shocked or even incredibly anxious. Just terrible, terrible grief. Like she already knew the child was dead eventhough it was only a few hours after the incident.

He was the one who looked totally stunned and shocked to the point of appearing robotic.

I think it was a tragic, tragic accident caused by her. Poor, poor woman Sad

DontDrinkDontSmoke · 03/08/2018 11:02

Never have I seen so much guilt on a person's face

Not defending them, because we just don’t know. However the actions from that night we do know about are enough to give any parent the guilts.

LittlePaintBox · 03/08/2018 10:50

A friend who'd had a really bad time when her first marriage ended. Met her boyfriend, who seemed lovely. But then she sent me a picture of herself and another chap, who she'd just married, and I just thought 'abuser'.

They divorced very quickly and although I don't know the details, it seems he was very abusive.

Daisymalone · 03/08/2018 10:45

Oh, I just came on here to write about the absolute certainty I have as to who is behind a relatively recent unsolved murder/accident/disappearence but I think previous commenters may have said the same and they have been deleted! Never have I seen so much guilt on a person's face...

ThatLibraryMiss · 03/08/2018 09:56

She was spectacularly wrong about a lot of things but never remembered them.

This - people remembering their one hit and forgetting their 99 misses - is called confirmation bias. Wikipedia article here. I suspect there's been an awful lot of it in this thread.

SinisterBumFacedCat · 03/08/2018 09:45

She claimed to be an excellent judge of character and have a 6th sense. It may have been effective if the other 5 senses and brain were in operation too.

Grin
RosaMallory · 03/08/2018 08:18

He wrote.

RosaMallory · 03/08/2018 08:18

The jumping weather map guy is Fred Talbot. He was the one that was convicted for sexual assault.
Fred Dineage is the news presenter that was on meridian 6 o'clock news and is on the programme investigating well known murderers. I wrote a book about one of the Kray twins by invitation. I haven't ever found him creepy.

DontDrinkDontSmoke · 03/08/2018 08:04

Look at the amount of people who instinctively disliked Jimmy Savile.

Even more people liked him. He was a very successful DJ/presenter. He didn’t get that successful by everyone having a bad feeling about him.

KitchenDancefloor · 02/08/2018 23:47

Wow there are a lot of people on here who think they have never been wrong about their judgement.

I shared an office with someone like this. She said it was down to her Romany/Native American ancestry. She was spectacularly wrong about a lot of things but never remembered them.

She was wrong about guessing that I was pregnant, then wrong about guessing the sex of my child. She didn't spot a colleague who was later convicted of fraud or those hiding health, finance and relationship problems. She claimed to be an excellent judge of character and have a 6th sense. It may have been effective if the other 5 senses and brain were in operation too.

DSHathawayGivesMeFannyGallops · 02/08/2018 23:47

For those saying "can't tell anything through the tv" - do you not form an opinion on politicians, tv personalities etc based on how they come across on screen? Look at the amount of people who instinctively disliked Jimmy Savile. I don't think it's that hard to believe. You're still picking up on their physical & verbal traits. You're still watching & analysing.

Also, in a couple of cases such as with John Tanner, the police want them on camera to flush out these behaviours in them. Rachel O'Reilleys husband did himself no favours with a tv interview. It really turned the tide against him & for the percentage of people who thought he'd done it before the interview.

BabySharkDooDooDooDoo · 02/08/2018 23:25

This is a really interesting thread, some eye opening stories

MissContrary · 02/08/2018 23:21

A quick google says it was fred talbot.

ZanyMobster · 02/08/2018 23:18

@MissContrary - Fred Dineage you mean. I actually know him quite well and whilst I couldn't 100% say he has done anything awful, he is very 'old school' touchy feely and creepy from that respect, well tha's kind of how I feel anyway. He is generally a very kind and seemingly nice man so I am not 100% sure, I may be being harsh. Part of me thinks that he is using his celebrity status to be a bit overfriendly/flirty but the other part of me thinks he's just a naturally friendly person.

I am not sure I am a great judge of character, I certainly don;t have a spidy sense!

PerverseConverse · 02/08/2018 23:13

@YouTheCat I feel exactly the same. A very close family friend idolises him. I've never liked him since being a child. Something very smug and smarmy and creepy about him. I wasn't surprised to hear of suspicions about him. I think the godly, celibate persona doesn't ring true for me.

From my own point of view I'm taking good notice of what someone said about abusive men picking up on vulnerable women who have been abused previously. Will research how to develop my shark cage.

My maternal aunt's second husband doesn't sit right with me. They both don't like me and my aunt hasn't liked me since I was about 12. But there's something I don't like about him. Too opinionated, too tight with his money. Too something. My mum was desperate for £1000 a few years back and they refused to LEND it to her despite spending around £20,000 on holidays each year, owning property and having a pretty lavish life compared to my mum. Instead they told her to get me to lend it to her (single mum of 3, SAHM). Money aside, I still get off vibes from him. There was an incident at a family event years ago where I was trapped by him "playing" in front of lots of other people. I freaked and slapped at him when he wouldn't let me go. He was only "playing" and I shouldn't be so "uptight" however as I'd been trapped and sexually assaulted in my teens and raped by my then boyfriend the same summer, I didn't take kindly to it. However, the whole family seemed the problem to be mine Sad

QueenAnchoret · 02/08/2018 22:54

Reading body language through the medium of TV is also ridiculous.

Swipe left for the next trending thread