Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People you had a sixth sense about and were right

481 replies

HarryPotterISreal · 30/07/2018 22:24

I’ve just been reading one of the spooky threads here and a poster talked about someone she got a bad feeling about and some months later was arrested for abuse or something. When someone is arrested who is a ‘pillar of the community’ someone always says ‘I never liked him, I could always tell’.

Do you have a story where you genuinely knew someone was bad news, though everyone else thought they were wonderful? How could you tell and did others eventually see their true colours?

OP posts:
DiegoMadonna · 31/07/2018 01:44

I always had a weird feeling about Bruce Willis and thought it was odd that nobody ever seemed to interact with him. Then it turned out he is a ghost and I felt totally vindicated.

AuntieFesterAdams · 31/07/2018 01:43

Jimmy Saville always scared me as a kid- hated seeing him on TV.

I recently went to a family gathering. The husband of a relative was there- he is usually working. At home I mentioned him leaving early. DD1 (10) said she found him creepy...weird as do I. Mentioned my DD comments to DH later and he finds him creepy.
So no leaving our kids near him as 3/4 of our family find him too creepy

MrsCrabbyTree · 31/07/2018 01:36

Where we lived once, there were 3 milk bars in the local shops. I chose to support the middle one as he seemed to have the least custom. One night, one milk bar burnt down and unfortunately a young boy perished as he could not escape through the window. The next time I bought milk I came home and told my husband that my instinct was telling me that this particular owner was involved but husband told me I was nuts.

18 months later, evidence turned up and he was charged. He only meant to get rid of his competitor's business, not kill anyone. This sad tragedy has stayed with me for 30 years.

LoveIsNotInTheAir · 31/07/2018 01:34

I met a guy in a bar the other weekend and we talked for ages but I just felt more and more uneasy around him. I can’t put my finger on it but it was almost like he knew exactly how to get you to like him, how to have things in common etc. Talked to my friend the next day and she got the exact same feeling and found him creepy. I got the feeling he takes advantage of people psychologically Sad

JamieVardysHavingAParty · 31/07/2018 01:14

As an aspie, I've learned to construct the world's largest (it sometimes feels!) database of human behaviour in my head, so I can check people's actions against the prior experience of a lifetime and make a quickly calculated decison about how to respond. The older I get, the more comprehensive the dataset and the swifter the calculation - too swift to notice but based on experience rather than anything more woo. I was pretty naive as a youngster, which backs up this idea to some extent. I'd be interested in whether any other aspies relate to that as an idea.

I 100% relate to every word. My database is still incomplete at present, and I wouldn't trust myself to identify sex offenders, for example. However I can automatically recognise certain types of people who are unpleasant to have in one's life much faster than my more competent NT friends do, simply because I've encountered similar people before.

EndofSummer · 31/07/2018 01:00

@Hofty I get the same too. I had to be quite independent from a young age, look after younger siblings, and then travelled the world on my own aged 19/20.

I think it really homed my instincts. Even now I trust me feelings if I feel on edge, I’ll move railcarriages, cross the street, be wary of friends. I pick up on any threats.

I once took a very strong, instant dislike to a new ‘acquaintance’ of my boyfriend. I told him never to bring him to our house again. I’ve never said that before or since. A few months later he was convicted of manslaughter, a very violent man.

And yet I’ve turned a blind eye to milder warnings in my boyfriends! Two have been borderline emotionally abusive, and all our friends thought they were lovely too. My last one cheated on me for months by sexting other women - I had a strong feeling that he was distant but I never thought he’d been cheating, he was the archetypal good sweet guy. That was a huge shock!

PyongyangKipperbang · 31/07/2018 00:52

Weird!

This happened to me today.

I saw online that a local business man has been convicted of sexual assault on 2 women, I am sure there are more. I rang mum and she said she had seen it and 'I said to your dad "Pyong said she didnt like or trust him the first moment she met him" and you were right!" He was my FIL's boss at the time and he was involved in my MIL's funeral. He was rude and obnoxious to me and clearly only interested in speaking to penis owners. My husband got very angry with him and pointed out that due to the circumstances of her death, he and his father were struggling so I was the one arranging everything so he needed to listen and do what I said. You could tell he was furious at being instructed to listen to a woman. I would have changed companies but FIL felt he had no choice but to use him as he worked for him.

So yes, I do get it and every single time so far I have been proved right.

Ignore your instinct to your cost.

Flowerfae · 31/07/2018 00:44

I do trust my instincts mostly now about people, although I question them all the time though, incase I have got it wrong.

I also sometimes know who is calling before I pick up, or what people are going to say , news etc, before they say it. For example, a couple of weeks ago I dreamt my friend's daughter was pregnant (which was a really, really random thing to have a dream about) but I was certain about it so I said to DH 'awww is pregnant'. We saw our friend later in the day and I said to them 'how is ?' and they said 'oh .. she's pregnant'. I can't explain how I knew because there was no way for me to know about it. I think that I can only do it with people I know. DH thinks I'm a freak Grin it doesn't happen much.

Menolly · 31/07/2018 00:41

DH made a new friend through a hobby, I had this instant dislike and couldn't work out why, he just made my skin crawl. He quite clearly didn't like me either and made lots of snide 'jokey' comments trying to wind me up, lots of little sexist jokes etc then would comment on my temper, the way I spoke to DH and generally shit stirring, got to the point I threw him out the pub I was working in one night because he was drunk and really annoying me and he phoned DH in tears and told DH that he should keep me under control. DH at this point apologised to me and agreed the guy was a bit of a dickhead and they stopped hanging out.

Anyway, few months later he was arrested, turned out he had done the same with another man, offered him a place to stay after an argument with his wife, spiked his drink and sexually assaulted him, took photos then tried to blackmail him.

mirialis · 31/07/2018 00:27

It's very easy to have a "hindsight" response to someone,

Only once have I had a realtime response and that was my best friend's new boyfriend. Attractive but not intimidatingly so,very intelligent, worked in a caring profession. best friend feeling very happy... what's not to like? And yet within 10 seconds of him walking into the room on our first meeting my hackles were up. Got a subsequent telling off for my cold reaction (confused and hurt from best friend, bemused from husband) so tried to squash the feeling for the sake of those who love me but couldn't.

And then he turned out to be creepy as fuck... not sure I believe in "six sense" but within seconds something this "lovely" man was doing had me on high alert... but actually he was an averagely good looking and intelligent person in a lovely job and there was no rational reason for me to have such a visceral response to his mere presence in the room.

KitchenDancefloor · 31/07/2018 00:22

Not as sinister as some of these but I was repulsed by my DH's colleague when I first met her. There was something predatory about her but everyone seemed to think she was sweet and vulnerable and in need of looking after.

Not only did she try to seduce my DH but nearly every male colleague or supplier she worked with. She caused chaos in that work place and slept with loads of people including a very junior (apprentice level) employee. She is utterly shameless about the problems she has caused to the point that I think she has a major personality disorder. There is something a bit 'dead-eyed' about her.

However I didn't spot a colleague who was convicted of fraud. That shook our office as no one saw that coming.

Twombly · 31/07/2018 00:09

I too would say I have good instincts about people, and always act on them. DH takes my instincts seriously too, especially since I made him turn down a couple of contracts years ago that looked lucrative but ended up making the people who did take them go bust.

The only time I can say with certainty my instincts about an individual were spot on was about 25 years ago when I was waiting (and waiting) for a bus in a London suburb late one evening. A middle-aged lady in a car pulled over and offered me a lift, and in all honesty I might have been tempted except for a really bad feeling, not even of danger prticularly but just of darkness or badness. I said no, not a problem, and she pressed me a bit, saying she'd feel bad if anything happened to me ('you read such dreadful stories' etc). It sounds hokey, but it's the sort of thing I would do now if I saw a young women stranded somewhere at night, and it didn't seem suspicious at a rational level but I just had a really strong sense that I was safer at that bus stop. Anyway, to cut a long story short, it turned out to be a man presenting pretty bloody convincingly as a woman, and he turned out to have a string of sexual abductions to his name.

That's the only time I've ever known for sure how the story ended, but I get 'bad feelings' occasionally about people or situations and I always pay heed.

I also have a strong nose for deceit. For instance, a friend's DH recently confessed to an affair and this is a guy who you would have put money on never ever being unfaithful. But somehow I knew, almost like being psychic. I had to wait while it all played out over nearly two years before coming out into the open, because there was nothing concrete I could point to, just a certainty.

I've wondered if that kind of 'sixth sense' is related to being autistic. As an aspie, I've learned to construct the world's largest (it sometimes feels!) database of human behaviour in my head, so I can check people's actions against the prior experience of a lifetime and make a quickly calculated decison about how to respond. The older I get, the more comprehensive the dataset and the swifter the calculation - too swift to notice but based on experience rather than anything more woo. I was pretty naive as a youngster, which backs up this idea to some extent. I'd be interested in whether any other aspies relate to that as an idea.

Squidgee · 31/07/2018 00:07

OH, and a male teacher.

PE teacher when I was at secondary school in the early 90s. I'd known his DD for a while, she was in the year above me. He was one of those PE teachers who liked to come into the girls changing rooms to 'hustle' us along or 'just coming through' as the exits went through the changing rooms.

I later found out a couple of years after I left, he was charged with sexual assault of a 15yo girl, and during the trial, several others came forward.

Theimpossiblegirl · 31/07/2018 00:00

@mummyof2munchkins
Trust your instincts, make the call. Better to be wrong than wrong, I always say.

mrsjackrussell · 30/07/2018 23:57

Yes. I normally get on with and like most people. I hated a new colleague and I couldn't understand why. I couldn't trust her or take to her and what made it worse everyone seemed to love her. I thought maybe it was me being jealous but I'm not that sort of person. I think she knew I could see through her. She eventually did something illegal at work and involved me in it and I could have lost my job. It was found out that she was a compulsive liar and she eventually left.

Squidgee · 30/07/2018 23:57

my ex SIL.
I took an instant dislike to her, she was right up her own arse.
Didn't surprise me when my DB admitted she'd been abusing him their whole marriage and had even blackmailed him into marrying her.
She's a Narc.

HarryPotterISreal · 30/07/2018 23:55

I used to think that I was a very bad judge of character, but it's more that I tended to ignore my first reactions to people. I was too worried about people liking me to think for a moment about whether I liked them, or if they were safe to be around.

This bears repeating.
I read The Gift Of Fear years ago but have not respected my instincts and am trying to stop giving everyone a bloody ‘chance.’

OP posts:
TheMonkeyMummy · 30/07/2018 23:53

I have a good friend who married this man. He just absolutely creeped me out, to the point where I couldn't even bring myself to be bridesmaid for her (I did try to give myself a big talking to, but I just couldn't do it). Fortunately, I had just had a baby so used that as an excuse.
I always felt that he would be the type to murder a sex worker, if that makes sense.
Fast forward a few years and after a few incidents that were explained away, she finally discovered that he had been using sex workers throughout their marriage. He admitted that he would have carried on if she hadn't found out, so she left and they divorced.

I still am waiting for him to make the headlines but obv am hoping to be proved wrong

blueangel1 · 30/07/2018 23:50

I do tend to have the spidey sense, but sadly it didn't work with EXH as he was very good at covering his true personality.

Agree with pp who picked up on Ian Huntley and Jimmy Saville; both of them instaneously gave me the creeps.

MissContrary · 30/07/2018 23:50

That Fred? bloke who used to do the weather on this morning, jumping around his floating map. I used to turn the tv over.

There's a couple of men who were/are on Countrywide who make me feel iffy.

ToEarlyForDecorations · 30/07/2018 23:48

.

MrsScrubbingbrush · 30/07/2018 23:48

I'm another who felt exactly the same about Ian Huntley.

As soon as he appeared on TV I just knew he was guilty.

IHeartKingThistle · 30/07/2018 23:44

I don't have the spidey sense and it frightens me that I don't.

I've worked in Adult Ed for years and meet all kinds of people, which is wonderful. Generally I look for the positive in people but I always thought I was a pretty good judge of character. Then I found out a guy I'd taught a few years ago had been jailed for rape and sexual assault which had happened during the time he'd been in my class. He was a model student and I had been so pleased with what he achieved. Had he asked for a reference, I'd have written him a glowing one. Makes me shudder to think of that.

My friend in the police tells me that it's not me, it's just the fact that these people are so good at appearing to be decent people. Still, I no longer trust my own judgement and actually that's quite hard.

EndOfEternity · 30/07/2018 23:44

Growing up I took an instant dislike to one of the 2 ministers in our church, he gave me the creeps. Don’t know why but I was certain, even at a young age, that he shouldn’t be around children. No one else I asked saw an issue. Moved away from the area age 16 but have always wondered if I’d see him on the news one day.

TheMonkeyMummy · 30/07/2018 23:42

@GorgeousJaws , I actually watched that last night for the first time. It was heartbreaking, I had to watch all three episodes

Swipe left for the next trending thread