Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People you had a sixth sense about and were right

481 replies

HarryPotterISreal · 30/07/2018 22:24

I’ve just been reading one of the spooky threads here and a poster talked about someone she got a bad feeling about and some months later was arrested for abuse or something. When someone is arrested who is a ‘pillar of the community’ someone always says ‘I never liked him, I could always tell’.

Do you have a story where you genuinely knew someone was bad news, though everyone else thought they were wonderful? How could you tell and did others eventually see their true colours?

OP posts:
airedailleurs · 31/07/2018 11:35

MrStark I had the same experience with a woman at work; she absolutely made my blood run cold and I didn't know why she obviously had it in for me as I was good at my job. If the woman you work with is your boss, beware is all that I can say; I had to resign as she made my life hell and when I complained to HR they defended her with a total whitewash and tissue of lies.

user546425732 · 31/07/2018 11:34

A lot of localish people were suspicious of Karen Matthews.

MrStarkIDontFeelSoGood · 31/07/2018 11:27

There was a local newsreader in my area who got caught up in Yew Tree, I never liked him as a child and remember saying so to my Mum. I would have been 9 or so. Also creeped by Savile and had read rumours online

Conversely one of my teachers at school, a really nice man with a community presence was sent down for a sex offence against a minor. I'm still quite surprised by it, because it's so at odds with his character but he was definitely guilty

At the moment I work with someone, a female and I constantly get a vibe that she bears me ill will, I only have to be in her presence to feel it from her tone, her eyes, her body language. I don't know what the significance is or what to do really. I can't think of a single thing I've done to inspire her visible loathing

carbuncleonapigsposterior · 31/07/2018 11:12

Karen Matthews, all that posing with soft toy and the overt criticism of Madeline McCann's parents getting preferential treatment, that shouldn't have been her focus at such a time, couldn't help thinking there was something not quite right about Shannon's disappearance.

BluebellCockleshell123 · 31/07/2018 11:09

When I was 17, I working for the summer in a rural location far from home. I was on my own one day and was crossing the main road, about to start the 2 mile walk down the country lane to the house I was staying in.

There was a man just hanging about at the lane entrance and I just got this awful feeling about him. I started walking briskly down the lane...and he started following me. I was freaking out and didn't know what to do but as soon as I went round a corner where he couldn't see me, I started running. About 500yards further down the lane there was a cottage. I ran straight up to the door and thankfully someone was in and let me into the house...a young mum with a screaming crying baby who was on the phone and had a dog barking in the background. She looked so stressed but i was so so grateful that she let me in.

I'll never know if something could have happened to me, but I'm glad i trusted my instincts and didn't take the chance.

twoshedsjackson · 31/07/2018 11:08

I think it's true, as several PP's have said, that younger children with less sophisticated language and social skills can be better tuned in to oddity in non-verbal signals.) We are conditioned to "give people the benefit of the doubt", but luckily some adults keep the instinct.
Years ago, we had a slightly dodgy supply teacher; he seemed personable and well qualified; several staff commented that it was strange he hadn't got a permanent post more easily (a time with far fewer supply teachers)
But some of the little girls started to complain to me that he was "creepy"; I tried to reassure them, but - eg "he puts his arm round our shoulders". Me: "Mr (Headteacher) did that the other day when you were crying and upset". Girls: "It was different when (lovely family man Head) did it". Then they reacted strongly to being told who was covering their class for the afternoon. I told the Head, nothing you could put a finger on, but these little girls are uneasy. The Head agreed that there was nothing he could do directly, but opted for another supply teacher next time the need arose. We learned later that matters had escalated at another school where he assaulted a little girl.

UnlawfulBananaPeeler · 31/07/2018 11:08

I am a good judge of character. Most people brush it off as me being mean until my original opinion of the person becomes obvious.

When I was in primary school we got a new head teacher who insisted on taking pictures (without parental consent) on his first day to’get to know us’ . He also told mr off for something minor by getting a cm from my face and shouting so all of his spit went on my face . I instantly disliked him.

I was once sent to his office by my teacher to show some work he was very impressed with. I walked into his office and he shut the door behind me , I felt instant terror and my hair stood on end I still remember this feeling 20 years later, and he looked at my work with his hand on the small of my back the whole time.

A few months later he was convicted for indecent imagines of children as young as 4. I’ve never felt so ill in my life.

He also arranged a whole school sleepover and ‘volunteered’ to do the night shift and walked around the room shining torches into our faces all night.

We also had a family friend who was my aunties partner for a while. He just radiated an heir of wrong, he used to bring me presents and visit regularly but I hated him. He ended up physically abusing my auntie and my dad made it very clear he better never turn up at our house again .

iknowimcoming · 31/07/2018 11:01

Just remembered my best friends new (now ex) boyfriend when I first met him he gave me the shivers, but she was smitten so I said nothing - it took her several years to tell me he was violent and financially abusing her, she's now married to a man who doesn't give me any dodgy vibes thankfully. Also I often get a feeling when someone I know is pregnant.

TheGoldenWolfFleece · 31/07/2018 10:58

Apparently lots of people like to think they "had a feeling" about saville and Harris. If that's so why were they so popular? Harris especially.

I could say I've got negative feelings about lots of people. If it later turns out they're bad it doesn't mean im more perceptive than anyone else. It could just mean im rewriting history to make it seem like i am.

As for Ian Huntley - wouldn't anyone be suspicious of a school janitor inserting himself so firmly into the publicity of the case?

Wonderwine · 31/07/2018 10:41

I think I am good at subconsciously 'reading' other people, but it's only recently that I've realised that not everyone has the same skill, or acknowledges their gut feel and acts upon it.

I had a boss at work who used to publicly lie about things (and later be found out). I used to say to co-workers "he's so clearly lying, can't you tell?" but they couldn't. It seemed so clear and obvious, as if everything about his eyes, his speech intonation and his body language was screaming the fact.

Never liked/ trusted my friend's boyfriend at uni - always felt he was sly and a cheat. Sure enough, he had an affair and left her after they were married.

Jimmy Saville/ Rolf Harris - uurgh - would never watch them on TV as they made me feel weird and dirty, even when I was very young.

Tinty · 31/07/2018 10:36

I worked somewhere once, where a guy twice my age (I was 17), used to keep coming and chatting to me. He was married and first of all I just thought he was being kind to the newest (and youngest) member of the team.

After a while he started walking the same way I did when I went home (he had a car and lived in a different direction). He also started asking about my boyfriends and if I didn't have one would I go out with him (hypothetically of course). He would also hang around until everyone else left (I had to lock up).

I was so freaked out by him that I him and had to have a big meeting with management higher up. They told him to leave me alone and stop following me home. I was quite embarrassed because they all thought he was a lovely man and that I was exaggerating.

Two months later he stabbed his wife, and ended up in a MH unit.

Spidey sense was definitely working for me. Looking back I am quite impressed with myself that I didn't just brush it off and I took it too management at 17.

bettytaghetti · 31/07/2018 10:21

Tessliketrees I think picking up on potential violent misogynists isn't a spooky 6th sense thing but rather a (unconscious?) survival technique for women.

Unfortunately, as this website is testament to, not all of us possess this skill.

Re Jimmy Savile, I think that's what makes it all the more galling, that so many of us as kids couldn't stand the man, and yet the adults around him did nothing.

PrincessButtockUp · 31/07/2018 10:19

There was a dad at the school a while ago. Can't say I liked him. Something in the way he spoke to his wife just seemed unpleasant. I liked her but just low-key tried to stay out of his way. Still came as a real shock when he was convicted of child sex offences.

DreamingofSummer · 31/07/2018 10:09

When we first met her, I noticed my mother in law had the coldest eyes I had ever seen. She also insisted on mispronouncing my mother's name despite several corrections. I hated her on sight and nearly walked away.

She turned out to be a nasty, vindictive, controlling narcissist and we went no contact very soon after we were married. We're still together after 37 years but that bloody awful woman nearly ruined it.

eyycarumba · 31/07/2018 10:08

I can read people very well, some of my friends have actually got me to 'vet' people they were dating in the past. Must say, I'm a decent 99% right!

Worst was someone I used to work with. Massive creepy vibes, I hated going near him or having to speak - there was an inside joke on our desk about him giving off paedo vibes and him coming over to us just because our window looked over a school. He got arrested a few weeks later and work computers had to be searched by police. Turned out he was an actual convicted paedophile who had changed his identity to avoid detection!

Adversecamber22 · 31/07/2018 10:00

I'm always right and it is a survival thing.

The saddest is my younger sister I know siblings can be rivals but the gut feeling she has always given me has been proven correct.

She has no moral compass whatsoever. Her behaviour when our Mother died recently plumbed new depths. Her children have been to prison and she has taken part in criminal activity herself and has been sacked for stealing from various jobs. She never took me in but she is charming and takes in many. She uses people horribly.

We consider her to have strong traits of psychopathy,

YouTheCat · 31/07/2018 09:57

I couldn't stand Savile as a child. He gave me the creeps.

There's a 'clown' around the corner from where I work. He has one of those trick cars and stuff. He gives me the chills. I find him very sinister.

Tawdrylocalbrouhaha · 31/07/2018 09:51

Off topic, but did anyone read The Gift of Fear and get the feeling that Gavin de Becker was untrustworthy himself?

His presentation smelled to me of used car salesmanship, and I gave up reading when he recounted an anecdote about a girl on an aeroplane which I felt was a lie (as he reported it). I followed my instinct and chucked the book!

CrabappleBiscuit · 31/07/2018 09:47

Friend who had to go out and visit a customer, after the first time she refused to go on her own, nothing bad actually happened he just gave her the creeps. He got convicted of 3 rapes recently.

brizzledrizzle · 31/07/2018 09:45

A Catholic priest many years ago, something about him seemed rather odd but this was before all the stuff we know now about some priests and child abuse. He got a conviction for assault and later on was found to have child pornography but wasn't sent to prison for that one.

I googled him and he was later living on a sea front in a Welsh town near a leisure park Shock

Mrsmadevans · 31/07/2018 09:41

I can echo Shirley Ballas she is just dire.

LemonysSnicket · 31/07/2018 09:39

When I was a kid I met a Christian missionary and felt so sick to my stomach suddenly that I threw up. Turns out they had been abusing children in Nairobi, it came out a year later.

LoveInTokyo · 31/07/2018 09:36

My first thought when I saw my ex-boyfriend was "you're going to break my heart".

Before we had even spoken.

LimboLuna · 31/07/2018 09:35

I used to think that I was a very bad judge of character, but it's more that I tended to ignore my first reactions to people. I was too worried about people liking me to think for a moment about whether I liked them, or if they were safe to be around.

Yes I was the same. Having been abused, bullied and neglected I am a walking cliche. I realise if I look back the signs were there I ignored my gut and tried to be ‘liked’.
I don’t now though

I remember seeing a documentary about jimmy saville and one of his victims said upon a first meeting “he knew (she was vulnerable and had stuff happen to her before) they all know”.
That too resonated with me, there must be a sixth sense for the vulnerable.

Moononthehill28 · 31/07/2018 09:33

Another one who knew about Ian Huntley.
Many years ago, we moved to a rural village. There was a couple there and the husband was a Solicitor who worked nearby to my husband. He used to offer my husband lifts into work sometimes as we only had one car.
He and his wife offered to babysit our two young sons, but something made me very wary and I kept making excuses.
After we left, he was convicted for child sex offences against his step son and his step sons friend who also lived in the village. We used him to draw up our Will. I never felt good about him though.

Swipe left for the next trending thread