Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Abortion ...genuinely interested if you are Pro life.....

171 replies

Foxy333 · 13/06/2018 18:03

I was undecided, not sure. Then I read this article with example ( pro-choice article) of how to tell if society really does/ or should/ value the life of an embryo the same as an adult or child.

It said imagine you are in a burning building and gave to get out . Next to you is a 2 year old toddler and a small fridge in which 5 embryos or test tube babies post-conception are stored. Building could be an IVF clinic. You can climb out the window of the building but only time to save either the toddler or save the small fridge with embryos in.

Which do you save and which more important?? Those embryos would be massively wanted by some couple going through ivf, could be their last chance at parenthood. Which is more important for you to save.

It made me think. I think the unborn baby does have some rights but a born living child.....Not sure you can say they are equal. How many people would save the fridge with more potential living people in it and leave the 2 year old. I know its hyperthetical but am genuinely interested in others views.

OP posts:
FlyingElbows · 13/06/2018 18:41

Ofcourse I'm "pro-life" if being "pro-life" means prioritising saving a toddler from a burning building as opposed to a fridge of embryos. I honestly think you'd be hard pressed to find anyone who wouldn't prioritise the toddler. The scenario is really not an effective comparison to the concept of being "pro-life" in relation to abortion. In that instance "pro-life" actually means "pro-birth" and I'd have far greater respect for people who acknowledge that reality that for those who pretend they give the slightest fuck about the lives which already exist or the life to be post-birth.

newtlover · 13/06/2018 18:41

it's not an analogy, it's a thought experiment and an interesting one
most people would instinctively choose the toddler, you can then ask why and try to discern what principles underly that choice, and whether they hold in all circumstances
Socrates, innit.

ILikeMyChickenFried · 13/06/2018 18:39

I hate the way people generalise the opinions of pro-life supporters. Some of the attitudes on here are revolting.

Sparklesocks · 13/06/2018 18:36

Of course everyone saves the child.

And regarding the wider issue, you can be pro choice and still not agree with abortion personally - but it’s about respecting the choices of the individual.

Lichtie · 13/06/2018 18:34

Is it my 2 year old or a strangers... And does the fridge have wine in it... Tough call 😉

MsFrizzle · 13/06/2018 18:33

"Pro-life" is just forced birth. There's no 'life' about it when you're putting the rights of something that can't even think yet over somebody who will have to give birth and go through irreversible hormonal, bodily and personal changes. Adoption is not always an option.

Also, my ability to give birth (in regards to the "it could make an IVF couple very happy") does not mean that I have to sacrifice for somebody who is sadly unable to have children. I shouldn't have to have a baby because somebody else can't.

NationalEspresso · 13/06/2018 18:33

It's not called 'pro life' it's called Anti Choice

Walkingdeadfangirl · 13/06/2018 18:30

The point is 'choice'. Forced birthers anti abortionists would try to force you to rescue the embryos no matter the risk to your own life, harm or distress it could cause you. And even worse, they would leave you to deal with all the consequences, for the rest of your life.

Pro choice allows you to make your own decision about who what or even if you rescue the embryos or the baby.

LineRunners · 13/06/2018 18:27

And many women have had an abortion who are 'for life' - for the lives of their families and others. They don't suddenly become 'against life'.

Anti-abortion campaigners aren't ethical paragons of being 'for life' - a lot of them support the death penalty.

So 'pro-life' is a stupid label, to me.

PurpleDaisies · 13/06/2018 18:20

How many people would save the fridge with more potential living people in it and leave the 2 year old

Nobody.

It’s a ridiculous question.

MummyNessi · 13/06/2018 18:17

I think everyone would save the toddler as she is alive and it is in no way garantie that any of the embryos would actually stick and become a pregnancy, it's a bit like saving sperm..
I am not exactly pro life, I respect everyone should have a choice but personally I could never end a pregnancy just because of convenience. And I don't understand how anyone could have a very late abortion when the baby could survive outside the womb.
But these are my opinions and that is all.

x2boys · 13/06/2018 18:16

well obviously the child , the embryos have the potential to be a pregnancy than a baby etc, but the two year old is alive now

zzzzz · 13/06/2018 18:15

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

ILikeMyChickenFried · 13/06/2018 18:15

The analogy doesnt work. There are plenty of people I'd put behind a child if i could only save one, it doesnt mean I don't value them and their life.

Lemonsherberts · 13/06/2018 18:13

A better example would be who would you save from a burning building, a two year old or a pregnant women if you only had time to save one.
I think most people would save the child over the adult, and the adult being pregnant wouldn’t impact on that decision. Still the two year old.

I’m pregnant and if I was me in that hypothetical situation, I’d far rather someone saved my toddler son than me.

PrettyLovely · 13/06/2018 18:13

"Not pro life but an embryo isn't the same as a baby inside the womb."
THIS ^^

LineRunners · 13/06/2018 18:12

'Pro-life' is a ghastly label.

Yokatsu · 13/06/2018 18:11

Save the child....

But I do believe that the maximum time should be bought down for all but abortion on the some acute medical grounds.

I had a 3D scan done of both my babies at about 24 weeks. There was no doubt that was a baby in there, but I was still within the legal abortion limits. Seemed very wrong to me

Figgygal · 13/06/2018 18:08

No one would save a fridge of embryos and no they don't have same right to life as a living child

ERipley · 13/06/2018 18:08

The unborn baby absolutely doesn’t have the same rights as a living child.

Racecardriver · 13/06/2018 18:06

Not pro life but an embryo isn't the same as a baby inside the womb.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.