Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Abortion ...genuinely interested if you are Pro life.....

171 replies

Foxy333 · 13/06/2018 18:03

I was undecided, not sure. Then I read this article with example ( pro-choice article) of how to tell if society really does/ or should/ value the life of an embryo the same as an adult or child.

It said imagine you are in a burning building and gave to get out . Next to you is a 2 year old toddler and a small fridge in which 5 embryos or test tube babies post-conception are stored. Building could be an IVF clinic. You can climb out the window of the building but only time to save either the toddler or save the small fridge with embryos in.

Which do you save and which more important?? Those embryos would be massively wanted by some couple going through ivf, could be their last chance at parenthood. Which is more important for you to save.

It made me think. I think the unborn baby does have some rights but a born living child.....Not sure you can say they are equal. How many people would save the fridge with more potential living people in it and leave the 2 year old. I know its hyperthetical but am genuinely interested in others views.

OP posts:
GoogleJuicer · 23/11/2021 22:58

@SusieBob women where?

GoogleJuicer · 23/11/2021 22:57

@Yokatsu

Save the child....

But I do believe that the maximum time should be bought down for all but abortion on the some acute medical grounds.

I had a 3D scan done of both my babies at about 24 weeks. There was no doubt that was a baby in there, but I was still within the legal abortion limits. Seemed very wrong to me

Yes and I’m sure you had a bump?
SusieBob · 23/11/2021 22:54

@Sunshine1235

I am ‘pro life’, I believe an unborn baby is a living person and that it is ethically wrong to end that life for any reason in the same way it would be with a person outside of the womb. I know that people find themselves in very difficult and desperate situations and understand the arguments about making abortion illegal would push them underground and make them unsafe. But we could make the same arguments about slavery, slavery is illegal now and so modern day slavery continues unseen and hidden with many people in horrendous situations. We could legalise slavery again in order to be able to properly regulate it, ensure slaves were treated well etc. But we don’t, because we recognise that ethically there is something fundamentally wrong with owning another human being. In the same way I believe there is something fundamentally wrong with the destruction of an unborn baby being something that is not only legal but is funded by the state
You aren't pro-life.

You are pro-unsafe abortions that kill over 100,000 women a year.

Making abortion illegal doesn't make it go away. It just makes it more dangerous.

JurgensCakeBaby · 23/11/2021 22:36

Did you actually just compare terminating a collection of cells not yet viable as a baby, with slavery?!?!?

Sunshine1235 · 23/11/2021 22:23

I am ‘pro life’, I believe an unborn baby is a living person and that it is ethically wrong to end that life for any reason in the same way it would be with a person outside of the womb. I know that people find themselves in very difficult and desperate situations and understand the arguments about making abortion illegal would push them underground and make them unsafe. But we could make the same arguments about slavery, slavery is illegal now and so modern day slavery continues unseen and hidden with many people in horrendous situations. We could legalise slavery again in order to be able to properly regulate it, ensure slaves were treated well etc. But we don’t, because we recognise that ethically there is something fundamentally wrong with owning another human being. In the same way I believe there is something fundamentally wrong with the destruction of an unborn baby being something that is not only legal but is funded by the state

BrocolliFloret · 23/11/2021 21:58

But abortion is not usually the embryo’s death weighed up against the mother’s death. It’s the embryo’s death weighed up against the mother’s mental health/happiness.

A more accurate analogy would be, would you save the fridge and cause a woman to suffer trauma and risk minor physical injury, or vice versa.

The few cells in the ivf tubes are not all going to attach or prove viable. I guess it would be more like taking the morning after pill, which I know some pro-lifers are against but not all.

blahblah789 · 23/11/2021 21:51

@sleep5

Personally, I don't think abortion is a good thing health wise and it's expensive for the health service.

The govt should be spending the money on sex education and promoting contraception and making it more freely available - vending machines, schools, etc.

Introduce fees for abortion based on income with exceptions for rape and so on.

Abortion was the best thing for my health and I genuinely believe it’s the reason I’m alive. I had an abortion at the age of 16 after a sickness bug meant my pill failed. Something about the father never seemed right to me and the relationship was toxic and unstable although we stayed together after. A couple of years down the line he became incredibly abusive. I’m 6 years out of that relationship and it ended after multiple times of him threatening to kill me, often holding a knife to my neck or strangling me. I barely made it out alive and truly believe that if I had been tied to him because of a baby, or if the abuse started sooner because he had a baby to use as leverage, I would either be dead or a shell of myself. I also know that he would have ruined that child’s life with what they would have seen. At 16 I could never have afforded an abortion if I had to pay for it. Schools focus heavily on sexual health and safety now from a very young age but accidents happen. Why should people who can afford private medical care have the opportunity to continue their lives childfree if an accident does happen, but a younger or poorer cannot? When those are the people who most would say shouldn’t be having children in the first place. Money should not dictate whether women are allowed to make decisions about their own lives, bodies and personal safety.
whumpthereitis · 23/11/2021 21:48

I didn’t regret mine, and I also work in abortion services, so I absolutely dispute the notions that regret is inevitable, and women don’t actually know what they’re doing, because if they did they’d be pro life. I’d say the psychological burden is far higher in bringing an unwanted child into the world, both for the woman and the child.

I think the original question is relevant, considering pro lifers do like to state that an embryo or fetus is indeed a child, equal to a toddler in every way. If that is true, then it would make sense for them to save the freezer, considering the number of ‘children’ it contains.

PurpleDaisies · 23/11/2021 21:45

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

MushMonster · 23/11/2021 21:43

My last post is in reply to Cloud, page 5

HTH1 · 23/11/2021 21:40

And who cares if it’s a zombie thread, what difference does that make to the question?

HTH1 · 23/11/2021 21:39

It’s really not the same thing as being anti-abortion.

I doubt anyone would disagree with abortion where the mother’s life is genuinely in danger such that it is a ‘she or the foetus lives’ situation but when you’re more on the “couldn’t be bothered to use a condom” or “the pregnancy is inconvenient because of a planned holiday” spectrum, a lot of people would disapprove of the woman deciding to abort.

MushMonster · 23/11/2021 21:38

It is for you and whoever came up with the statistic, any actual source?
I know I would regret it, and I know my DD would regret it. I happen to know her, and she is maternal.
If you or 95% of other womendo not have the same feeling, my respects for it, but I am still 100% sure of what I would choose, and I would keep the baby.

JunoMcDuff · 23/11/2021 21:29

ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE
ZOMBIE
ZOMBIE
ZOMBIE
ZOMBIE
ZOMBIE
ZOMBIE
ZOMBIE
ZOMBIE
ZOMBIE
ZOMBIE
ZOMBIE
ZOMBIE
ZOMBIE
ZOMBIE
ZOMBIE
ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBIE

Scirocco · 23/11/2021 21:13

For myself, I don't think I could terminate a pregnancy due to my personal experiences and beliefs. But that's me. I'm not every woman on the planet, so I don't have the right to impose my own preferences on other people.

I think safe, legal access to contraception and termination is needed. I also think there should be more support and counselling available for women who are pregnant and unsure about what they want to do or who would want to continue with a pregnancy but are worried about how they'd cope.

Respecting and valuing life needs to include the lives of pregnant women and their right to choose. I don't need to agree with a choice to respect it and to defend someone's right to make it.

TractorAndHeadphones · 23/11/2021 21:11

Christ it’s a zombie thread! I watch..

TractorAndHeadphones · 23/11/2021 21:10

@sleep5

Personally, I don't think abortion is a good thing health wise and it's expensive for the health service.

The govt should be spending the money on sex education and promoting contraception and making it more freely available - vending machines, schools, etc.

Introduce fees for abortion based on income with exceptions for rape and so on.

An unwanted baby being born is more expensive
ittakes2 · 23/11/2021 20:59

I am pro choice. Woman should have a choice what happens to their bodies.

PanicPrevention · 23/11/2021 20:51

I dont think your question is really sorting people into pro choice or 'pro life' as most people would save the child in those hypothetical circumstances.
I am pro choice and believe women should have freedom to decide what to do with their own bodies and pregnancies.
I would even go so far as to say that women should have the right to an abortion after 24 weeks but this is obviously another hypothetical because the law will not change in that direction.
I must admit I feel a bit iffy about sex selective abortion but issues around that could be addressed/reduced with the right education and support for women.
When push comes to shove, as a feminist I dont believe that any woman should ever be forced to carry to term and give birth to a baby she does not want to carry, birth or care for.

knittingaddict · 23/11/2021 20:41

I think that's an absolute no brainer, even for an advocate for pro life. It doesn't take a seconds thought, does it?

strivingtosucceed · 23/11/2021 20:35

@SumAndSubstance

*Force a woman to give birth because it will save a life. Force a woman to donate a kidney because it will save a life.*

Whats the difference to 'pro-lifers'?

Fairly obviously, I would have thought, 'pro-lifers' don't want to force a woman to give birth, they want to prevent anyone from killing a foetus, which they believe to already be alive. They are not trying to save the foetus' life, they are trying to prevent it being killed. In the latter example, nobody is under threat of being killed, just of dying. These are not the same thing.
Whether you agree with 'pro-lifers' or not, I find it very odd how many people don't seem to grasp the basic concept that they believe that a foetus is alive already and has a right not to be killed.

This is exactly how I feel. I'm pro-life, but I don't think abortions should be illegal. I understand why a woman would want one and think safe abortions should be accessible for all because back street ones cause more issues than they solve.

I also think the time limit should be reduced, obviously, Texas is mad with only 6 weeks, but I think if people wait for 12 weeks because of the chance of miscarraige, the abortion limit should be quite close to that. Maybe 14-16 weeks.

30whatacrock · 23/11/2021 20:09

It’s a ridiculous comparison. No one with a brain would save a fridge of embryos rather than a live child.

DontWantTheRivalry · 23/11/2021 20:07

Abortion is such an emotive issue.

20 years ago I had an abortion. The option to keep the baby wasn’t even presented to me….I was just swept up in the situation and somehow I went from telling my mum I was pregnant to then finding myself at an abortion clinic and I don’t really even know how it happened.

After the abortion I felt relief for a few weeks and then the absolute guilt kicked in and for many years I went on a complete self destructive downwards spiral because I couldn’t bear to think about what I had done. I would have been about ten weeks pregnant when i terminated and I find it really hard to think about. I would say it took about 5-6 years before I could finally put it behind me….yet 20 years later I still remember the date I had the termination and the baby’s due date. I remember everything single last detail about the building, the things people said to me, how I felt beforehand, how I felt afterwards and how I had to sit in a room with many other women forcing myself to have a cup of tea and a slice of toast because I couldn’t go home until I had done that. It was an extremely distressing time of my life and as I’m writing this I’m crying as I re-live it.

I am pro-choice but abortion is not always the easy answer and I imagine for a lot of women (not all) it’s something they find very hard to ever put behind them.

TheCloudBotherer · 23/11/2021 19:55

I do say to my DD, given the circumstances, think about the massive psychological implications. Many are scarred for life. They feel guilty having children later on and so on. We are built to love our babies. I do think that the burden is higher by stopping the pregnancy that by facing the social or financial implications of an unwanted pregnancy.

About 5% of women regret having an abortion, I think it's estimated at. Not scarred for life. Regretful.
What you're telling your daughter is inaccurate and irresponsible.

TedMullins · 23/11/2021 19:47

Pro lifers could literally have handed me a cheque for a million pounds, a full time nanny and a mansion and I STILL would have had an abortion. Of course there should be unbiased support for women who are undecided about their pregnancy or want the baby but have financial/mental health/physical etc issues (free childcare would go a long way to help women in many aspects) but this kind of support pro-life people talk of isn’t given in an unbiased way is it? Especially when the offers of such support come from people hanging about intimidating women outside abortion clinics.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.