Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask how do private schools produce such "confident" kids / adults and how I can do it at home?

995 replies

dragontwo · 12/06/2018 21:11

Ok, I have my reservations about private schools, but I recognise that often they produce kids / adults with high self confidence and self assurance.

I want to know how they do this, how they drill this confidence into them, and how I can replicate any beneficial aspects of this at home into my own kid (state schooled)?

What do they say / do / teach that encourages them to be so confident and expect success?

I know there are down sides to everything but I'm just thinking about good ideas I can help my kid. NB I'm no tiger mother and do my best to encourage my kid as it is already but just looking for ideas and general thoughts on how it's done!!

Just curious!

OP posts:
topcat1980 · 20/06/2018 12:05

;)

Which is why many children are at private school of course....

user1499173618 · 20/06/2018 11:57

I gave a talk the other day to a group of parents about the systems, practises, preparation and planning required to get into a good university course. The parents were in no way forced to attend the talk. Many of them were very resentful of the idea that they were going to need to do any work at all to make their child’s educational future happen. They wanted someone else to do that for them...

BertrandRussell · 20/06/2018 11:43

Oh, and don’t forget unpaid internships. Anyone who can afford to take one of those is at a huge advantage.

BertrandRussell · 20/06/2018 11:41

The nepotism thing is very interesting. The very obvious “Old School Tie” thing in much less of a “thing” of course. But I can think of loads of examples of ways in which kids get on because of people their parents know. One of my dd’s friends spent a summer working in a well regarded architect’s practice because one of the directors is a very good friend of mine and I asked him. My ds got one of his first biggish gigs because a friend of his mates dad was running a corporate do and wanted local “talent” as entertainment. Another friend of ds’s has a dad who does contract work doing track repair for London Underground, and he can recruit the labourers he wants. His son’s friends often get the jobs. Think about opportunities for work experience. It is foolish to say it doesn’t happen. There is also a big element of “you can’t be what you can’t see”. If the people who come to supper in your house are professional people, or creatives, for example, you grow up knowing that those jobs exist.

topcat1980 · 20/06/2018 11:33

Nepotism in the law exists, but especially with the getting of those valuable internships.

user1466518624 · 20/06/2018 11:29

Meant private banking divisions!

user1466518624 · 20/06/2018 11:28

User I agree we do have a lot of choice and our school has had money thrown at it and totally get where you are coming from.

user1466518624 · 20/06/2018 11:26

Topcat if anything the law is ripe for nepotism. My dh has worked in the City for all if his career and never found it apart from a little on private banking day visions.

user1471450935 · 20/06/2018 11:25

OCSock
Our school, is a semi rural catchment school, 10 primaries plus 3 border villages, 4 miles from city which is regularly in bottom 3 in England/Wales. It has only ever been Satisfactory/RI and went Inadequate in October 2018, though was inspected May 2017. It has a progress 8 of minus 2.7. Yeah it's bloody great, but where else to go, two nearest schools 3-5 miles have no better results/Ofstsd ratings, and we can't afford to bus them 15 miles to better ones.

My son's A Level grade depends on a section of coursework on Martin Luther King, hardly unknown historical figure, school have no books, literature on him. So he had to search the internet, trawl our local library, pay neighbouring council to loan a book. Use books mum and dad had from their childhood and a 1971 copy of his famous speech.
Friends daughter, from neighbouring council estate goes to a private school, for Rosa Parks, she got to speak via school to a couple of Uk based USA history professors, and video/Skype the directors of the Rosa Parks Foundation and Museum. Which do you think will get the A/A*. Both will be marked together this year.
In History he has had 5 teachers this year, and 35% of his Geography classes have been cancelled.
Which child is more privileged?
Because according to most it's not my son, and many on the other thread claimed similar happens at private schools, and it would be good lesson for him. Problem is that's not true about private schools, and he has to and will be competing against those private school kids for life, and no we don't even get on Bristol's shit school list.

IrmaFayLear · 20/06/2018 11:17

Confidence and academic success can be quite mutually exclusive. I come from a long line of shy and awkward clever clogs. Can polish off the Times crossword in record time but we’ll always be found bumbling along at the back and pushed out of the way.

Confidence is self-belief, even when it’s unwarranted. In fact it is particularly of benefit in the case of the latter. Empty vessels make the most sound and all that...

topcat1980 · 20/06/2018 11:14

But it does occur, just because it didn't happen in your spehere.

I know of young people who have jobs at law firms, banks they are able yes, but they got their start because they knew someone. Or their parents knew someone.

It isn't even just the first start, its things like much sought after internships being auctioned off at Westminster School fundraisers etc etc.

nevermindthebongos · 20/06/2018 11:09

@topcat1980 I am not completely sure what you are referring to in relation to nepotism, but before having dc i worked in a large international top law firm in London for more than a decade, and i can tell you that the trainees coming through were truly excellent in their own right - they were incredibly clever, competent, emotionally intelligent, very easy to train up. The summer students who came in during the summer were all selected on merit. Nepotism was unheard of, it would have caused outrage, it just would not have happened.

topcat1980 · 20/06/2018 11:02

No but people get much further from having advantages.

As I said there is such a thing as the glass floor!

Lots of people haven't had to work very hard to benefit from things that weren't earned by themselves.

Dapplegrey · 20/06/2018 10:58

Not true

You may be right Topcat, but then no one gets very far lazing around.
Also, riches can disappear. It only needs one gambler or someone who thinks they are good at business and aren't for many years of careful husbandry to be undone.

topcat1980 · 20/06/2018 10:32

"I agree that the only way to get ahead is hard work. "

Not true, there is such a thing as the glass floor as well as the glass ceiling and private schools play a part in perpetuating this. The country also has a great deal of nepotism going on in certain industries and professions.

The narrative spouted by Xenia is neo liberal dogma, that one only gets to where they are by hard work.

Not true, never has been.

user1499173618 · 20/06/2018 10:24

I agree that the only way to get ahead is hard work. But when we are children, the hard work of the adults around us to create an environment in which opportunities are maximized goes a long way to getting us to a place where we will be able to work hard at something interesting.

Xenia · 20/06/2018 10:18

Yes, I think it depends on how we define confidence. I was shy but always believed I had a chance (not a right but a chance) to pursue a career course of action or go into a particular place or building or place. I am not sure it's what you "deserve". We only get what we work hard to achieve. Feeling you deserve things tends to stop ambition and confidence. No one is owed anything. you just have to get on with very hard work to achieve it.

topcat1980 · 20/06/2018 09:51

The vast majority of state schools offer the opportunities stated.

Especially those in the areas where most children who go to private school live.

Its not the opportunities, its the confidence that comes from knowing you are right to be in this position, that this is what you deserve. That comes from home.

As does the culture of narrow horizons and low aspiration. The overwhelming body of evidence shows that if your parents take education seriously, you will.

user1499173618 · 20/06/2018 09:42

Any selection test in the state education system needs to be based on skills that are explicitly taught in schools.

The Kent 11+ predates the national curriculum. Before there was a NC schools could teach pretty much what they felt like and it was therefore appropriate for the 11+ to attempt to sift children according to ability, as there was nothing much else to base the test on. That has not been true for a generation and it is high time that the 11+ be based on rigorous maths, reading comprehension and writing assessments based on the skills of the highest performing pupils in the NC system.

OCSock · 20/06/2018 09:39

User, your school hardly sounds like a failure, but it also sounds as if you have several schools in your town or city. There is just one here, in a huge, rural and poor catchment.

My argument is not with the students; it's with the ethos of low aspiration and blinkered horizons.

Summersorcherisjustsummer · 20/06/2018 09:17

I must admit I can see why Kent has caused an issue but in such areas much more needs to be done to open up grammars to children with potential no matter what their background.

I think admitting that no test is tutor proof would be a good start. maybe the test providers could issue help papers to every applicant, ie how to do NVR. Exam technique and so on.
The way it seems to be done in Kent is not good.
I am very lucky where I am and we have excellent schools in our area and we border grammar areas. Having a dc who is going to sit the 11+ but without the pressure is a blessing.

I also think confidence is something that is skin deep. Many many confident people hide massive anxieties and worries. You could say certain kinds of confidence come from a lack of awareness.

I will never forget my DM taking me into the HOP and the house was pretty much empty except for one man with his feet propped up on the wool sack. Angry - Nicholas Soames.

user1499173618 · 20/06/2018 08:54

I very much agree with Xenia that children who go to private schools are introduced to a far greater range of social situations from a young age where they are given the opportunity to learn expected and appropriate behaviors. It’s the sheer range of quality experiences in which children are expected to participate, and grow, that gives them the confidence to manage life with aplomb.

It is not essential to attend a well known private school to develop such skills, but it certainly helps.

user1466518624 · 20/06/2018 08:15

Not slagging on the thread but real life and the belief there are no opportunities for culture, public speaking etc. Our school regularly participates in debating competitions, maths challenge etc and does well often thrashing the private schools. They are also off to Rome and Naples and those are in receipt of free school meals get it for free as they do for all trips which are offered regularly. The drama performance and music recitals that take place every term are wonderful and can assure you the students who choose to attend know when to clap! However I do appreciate we are lucky and not all state schools offer such brilliant opportunities for those who want it.

Xenia · 20/06/2018 08:04

I didn't see slagging off on this thread, We were just asked where private school children get their confidence (those teenagers that have it). No one should jump to conclusions about whom to blame based on clothes etc. I have always told my children it is vital to gather evidence and don't jump to conclusions about things. However the things that help children grow in confidence and be comfortable in all situations suggested on the thread work whether you are in private or state schools - pushing yourself, public speaking, meeting lots of different people, learning to speak and write well, going to the places and doing the things the people you hope to work with will do rather than feeling "out of place" or that something is " not for people like you are". This is why even basic things like being taken once to a theatre by the school (so later you know what to do in theatres) or to a formal concert (not to clap between movements within a concerto and usually not to clap in a church etc etc etc) is helpful for private and state school pupils.

I still think a lot of it comes down to innate personality - having some shy and some not shy children (and having been a very shy teenager myself and yet all of us only ever went to fee paying schools).

user1466518624 · 20/06/2018 07:53

Well said User, I have had the same reaction when I took my son out of private as he was bullied to the extent of self harming as the bullies were staff children.

It was only meant to be a temporary move but it turned out to be the best thing that happened to him and is thriving and confident with far more opportunities and gcse choices than St Mediocres. He is not the first the Head has mopped up due to bullying in the Indies having to dig into his budget for counselling for ds and others which I am grateful for.

However it is seen as the bottom of the pile in the town despite well above average results at GCSE and A Level. The uniform alone means they get blamed. An example of this was at the bus stop a while back 2 from the “Superiors” school were vandalising the stop and a member of the public pounced on my ds blaming him and calling the police. Luckily he was sensible enough to record the vandals on his phone and go back into school and tell his form teacher plus there was cctv footage anyway but it made my blood boil that the kids automatically get blamed just for being at that school.

I may still however have to go down the Private route for ds2 eventually as he will not cope in the big schools as great as they are.