Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask how do private schools produce such "confident" kids / adults and how I can do it at home?

995 replies

dragontwo · 12/06/2018 21:11

Ok, I have my reservations about private schools, but I recognise that often they produce kids / adults with high self confidence and self assurance.

I want to know how they do this, how they drill this confidence into them, and how I can replicate any beneficial aspects of this at home into my own kid (state schooled)?

What do they say / do / teach that encourages them to be so confident and expect success?

I know there are down sides to everything but I'm just thinking about good ideas I can help my kid. NB I'm no tiger mother and do my best to encourage my kid as it is already but just looking for ideas and general thoughts on how it's done!!

Just curious!

OP posts:
BlueBiros · 13/06/2018 14:34

I don't know about standard class sizes, but here my biggest class is top set year 10 (23 students) and I see them three times each week. At state my biggest class was year 8 (34 students) who I saw 3 times each fortnight. In form (so children I see every day and am the first point of contact for), my current school has around 20, previous school was minimum 30.

I did develop good relationships in my previous school too, but it took a lot longer. I know the evidence on class size and exam results doesn't support the additional cost of extra teachers, but I really do think it has a big impact on increasing their confidence.

IWillSurviv · 13/06/2018 14:34

I Will because they feel they can play outside the rules by using money and cheating. Simple.

@Cheerymom
I’m afraid this still doesn’t answer why private schools employing under qualified teachers is a privilege. For it to be a privilege the students have to be benefiting from it. However if what you are saying is they employ under qualified teachers so they can then cheat etc, this makes even less sense. Confused

arethereanyleftatall · 13/06/2018 14:29

If a private school is top of the league tables, this isn't necessarily because of good teaching.
Everybody I know who goes to our local private, has extra external tutoring too, kumon, and great parental support.
They also have to take an exam each year, and if they fail, it is suggested 'they're not suitable for the school.'
So, it's absolutely bleeding obvious the alevel results are going to be top notch, and I'm frankly staggered that anyone attributes these results to the superior quality teaching. I think they saw you coming.

frasier · 13/06/2018 14:28

Agree it is a lot about how the students are expected to behave, both in and out of school.

Etiquette and manners and experience...

Also, the children are given all manner of experiences at a much younger age and make mistakes when they are young and don’t care, not when they are older and more self conscious.

BarbaraWarpecker · 13/06/2018 14:26

High expectations, better education, probably more intelligent than average. Access to resources, facilities and opportunities that other children don't have. Awareness of privilege (in most cases financial); sense of superiority.

MeyYael · 13/06/2018 14:25

*I'm not from the UK/Anglo btw.

I'm just curious about the British school system. (DH is British...)

cistersofterfy · 13/06/2018 14:25

Haha. Haven't RTFT but have so many sarky responses on the tip of my tongue which I'm sure have already been said (I went to a private school and hated it by the way).

Instil in them a sense of entitlement and superiority by encouraging them to look down their noses at the working classes who can't afford the school fees. If you're very lucky you'll raise a future Tory MP.

Good luck!

MeyYael · 13/06/2018 14:20

@BlueBiros

What is the standard class size in a UK state school?

We were 25-30 in the private school I went to (all the pupils of the same age/in the same year).

But we were usually split up in at lead two groups. (Particularly for things like languages, arts, science etc... Sports, music, orchestra, classics [basically story time when we were little] and rel. Ed. were some of the few subjects we actually had together / as a class...)

Oh, and we went hiking twice a month. (Always a full day. Whether it was snowing, hailing, during a heatwave...)

There were also various facultative one-on-one things. Like "speaking improvement classes".

My cousin took those because he wanted to be a better public speaker.

My parents sent me to the psychomotoric specialist... I was extremely clumsy Blush

gillybeanz · 13/06/2018 14:18

Cheerymom

There are illegal issues in state schools to though, you know.
I left the teaching profession because as Post compulsory qualified, which then included A level, I was expected to not only teach GCSE subjects of which I hadn't any, but further maths when I scraped a level 2. I went to the union who told me I had to be prepared to teach outside my comfort zone.

I didn't want somebody like me teaching my dc, so I left.
Many of those who trained with me (for post compulsory only) are still teaching in local secondary schools.
Most not their degree subject, my ds2 Maths teacher was a potter, his English teacher qualified in computers.
Yes, the state system is much better Grin

AuntJobiska · 13/06/2018 14:15

I was kind of listening to Cheerymom for a while there, but then I got to "Students usually have tutors for all subjects etc." I really don't recognise this, and I think it's an extravagant statement that she may find difficult to support, which has kind of undermined everything else she's said.

BlueBiros · 13/06/2018 14:12

Sorry, I should add that I agree that relationships between teachers and students is (IMO) the big thing which helps them gain confidence in school. So my list of things which make my job easier/better all allow me the head space and time to get to know my students really well. Because I have time for them, they know I care. They (hopefully) feel valued and respected rather than just another kid.

crispysausagerolls · 13/06/2018 14:12

I went to private school and I think a lot of it is about looking confident, even if not feeling it. E.g you HAD to say good morning to every teacher you passed by with eye contact etc. Even if you didn't feel like it or were shy. Therefore you learnt to just do it and communicate with people even when not in the mood. That and having manners drilled into you so that you could be confident in the fact that you "knew how to behave" in all environments. Being allowed seconds and sometimes thirds of pudding didn't hurt either Grin

BlueBiros · 13/06/2018 14:09

Back to the OP, since moving to teach in private school what I like now is that (certainly in my school) I have enough time to actually get to know my students. Smaller class sizes mean that there are simply no students who are able to coast along under the radar.

Nobody has said "we need to do this for Ofsted" to me for a whole year - absolute bliss! Pointless form filling and data processing has gone. Data here is collected when required and then actually used to improve teaching and learning. The whole emphasis is on being the best teachers we possibly can, rather than feeling like you have to constantly justify that you are actually doing your job.

That all makes for a much more pleasant atmosphere across the whole school. I haven't noticed a significant difference in how teachers speak to students, but that wasn't really a problem at my previous school. I'm horrified that some teachers fail to model good manners to their students.

Gretol · 13/06/2018 14:08

I don't recognise cheerymoms description at all.

tremendous · 13/06/2018 14:07

Honestly it's because they are surrounded by others with high expectations. There is only so much you can do as a parent.

I went to a private school. If everyone you know is going to uni you will too. If everyone expects to get a well paid job the likelihood is you will too. Not everyone in a private school is confident though. That's projection.

Gretol · 13/06/2018 14:04

Also - all this talk of gappies and unqualified teachers -

dd is in year 7 at a very good state secondary

since she started in September TEN of her teachers have left. She's had a different maths teacher every single term. That is really, really shit.

mrsm43s · 13/06/2018 14:03

For the record, private schools do not cheat at exams, nor do most students at private schools also have outside tutors. I'm sure there may well have been isolated incidences of stuff like this, but equally there are in the state system too.

Cheerymom obviously has an axe to grind, but nothing she says rings true at all to my vast experience as a student, teacher and a parent at various private schools over the last 30+ years. What I have seen is high quaility teaching that teaches wider and deeper than the curriculum, high expectations of both behaviour and academic standards, happy engaged children, good communication, a wide range of co-curriculars taught to a high level, less bureaucracy and state interference and good outcomes for the pupils.

AuntJobiska · 13/06/2018 14:03

IWillSurviv sorry, crossed wires obvs!! :-)

Gretol · 13/06/2018 14:02

also, what was a massive confidence giver was being spoken to by teachers in a normal way, not like we were scum. When I moved onto state school, tbh I was shocked at the way teachers spoke to us

I hate to say it but this will resonate with my dd.

I really wanted to love her state school but reading this thread is making me even more keen to move her.

BertrandRussell · 13/06/2018 14:01

Did anyone watch the grammar school programme last night? They had a Year 7 class being taught by a gap year student!

bananafish81 · 13/06/2018 14:00

My private school only employed experienced teachers, they weren't going to put someone with no experience into an A-level course to prepare pupils for Oxbridge!

Back in my day there wasn't much / any course work so it was all exam based, and any additional tutoring for anyone struggling was provided by the same teachers at lunchtime to give the pupil 1-1 coaching

I don't recognise that description at all. But just my experience

BlueBiros · 13/06/2018 14:00

I have seen cheating one to one on coursework, illegal, I have seen a HOD rubbing out marks written in pencil, I have seen teachers actually making 90% of practical projects.

I've seen that in state schools too. Hence coursework being scrapped in the vast majority of subjects.

BlueBiros · 13/06/2018 13:58

No state school would allow it

I don't think this is true. It is certainly allowed to have unqualified teachers in academies (one of the reasons unions were against them) and the private school I teach in publishes our academic qualifications but not the PGCE. The vast majority of my colleagues have taught in state schools and I know of none who don't have QTS.

I resent the idea that A level teachers in private schools don't know what they are doing. Frankly, I do know how to teach my subject up to, and including, A level. If you think "anyone can wing it to KS3" then you clearly don't know what you are talking about, regardless of how many post graduate qualifications you have. Anyone can stand up in front of a KS3 class - but it takes a great deal of skill and subject knowledge to teach effectively that age group.

Cheerymom · 13/06/2018 13:56

I Will because they feel they can play outside the rules by using money and cheating. Simple. Lots of tutoring too and rearrangement of results when coursework is involved. Cheating parents too who have no clue, imagine your A Level student being taught by a recent graduate?

mrsm43s · 13/06/2018 13:54

Why would a private school employ a useless teacher, and how come they get so much better results and outcomes for their children if all their teachers are useless?

Once again, having QTS does not guarantee that a person is a good teacher. Not having QTS does not mean that a person is not a good teacher. It simply means that someone has done a particular course.

The proof of the pudding is under the crust - the best evidence of a person being a good teacher is great outcomes for their students. This is what a private school looks for when employing staff, and they have the freedom to choose the best person for the job, regardless of QTS status.

Why would I want to remove my children from their high achieving private school, to the low achieving state six form, just because the state six form has a smaller pool of people to choose their staff from?