Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask how do private schools produce such "confident" kids / adults and how I can do it at home?

995 replies

dragontwo · 12/06/2018 21:11

Ok, I have my reservations about private schools, but I recognise that often they produce kids / adults with high self confidence and self assurance.

I want to know how they do this, how they drill this confidence into them, and how I can replicate any beneficial aspects of this at home into my own kid (state schooled)?

What do they say / do / teach that encourages them to be so confident and expect success?

I know there are down sides to everything but I'm just thinking about good ideas I can help my kid. NB I'm no tiger mother and do my best to encourage my kid as it is already but just looking for ideas and general thoughts on how it's done!!

Just curious!

OP posts:
gillybeanz · 14/06/2018 23:26

Suspiciously

That is an absolutely marvellous summary, that when I read was nodding along. Thanks

SuspiciouslyMinded · 14/06/2018 22:59

If we talk about confidence, just money and privilege won’t provide it. Money and privilege produces arrogant, self-obsessed dunces, the likes of which are running this country at the moment. OP wants confidence for her kids, not arrogance.

Confidence encouraged by good education comes from both academic and social activities. My daughter goes to a private secondary girls’ school, my other two to a private coed primary school. Both schools, although quite academic, are not hot houses. The focus is on making children enjoy learning, discover and nourish their interests and strengths, and on giving everyone the opportunity to be good at something - music, drama, art, design, sport or the more academic subjects. The kids are not taught just to pass exams and are not tested non stop. They are not told they are the best - they are encouraged to do their best. If they are tested, the marks are descriptive rather than in the form of points or percentages that rank them relative to their classmates. Even parents don’t know how their kids rank relative to others. Tests are mainly for the teachers to plan the curriculum, to find out what the individual kids’ strengths and weaknesses are and to teach them accordingly. Smaller class sizes definitely help, as it means the teachers can pay more individual attention to students. Confidence comes from knowing that when you are good at something it is noticed and appreciated.

Socially, there is lots of teamwork, and the kids are taught to respect other kids’ opinions and differences - and of course the other way round: they know their opinions will be respected too. There’s a lot of debating, discussing, critical thinking. Also, feeling included does wonders to your confidence. My eldest daughter is mildly autistic, but she has never been labelled as such or singled out in class - instead, all the kids had a few lessons about autism, and about other conditions that mean people may act a bit differently from what we’re used to, but it’s OK. And nobody has ever commented in a critical way about my daughter’s occasional ‘weirdness’. She is confident if socially ocassionally awkward and shy.

Basically, confidence comes from self-respect. Find your children’s strengths, encourage them to do their best at what they are passionate about. Teach them to respect others and to have the courage to have and express their own views. Teach them to say no to things they are not comfortable with and to not give in to peer pressure.

I know it’s all a bit high-winded, but it works.

EnthusiasmIsDisturbed · 14/06/2018 22:53

I think deep rooted in our society is the issue of class

Of course you will have children and adults who have confidence from whatever their background but projected on to children from mc and upper mc backgrounds is that they shall achieve, they probably have better chances in life, will come from nice homes, will have better opportunities

All this of course we know isn’t necessarily true but people certainly still make assumptions

Kaybush · 14/06/2018 22:49

I should also mention that when I was in my early 20s I went to a dinner party in London and we were 'warned' in advance by the host that there would be three ex-Etonians there.

We couldn't understand why he did this, but OMG they took arrogance to the next level, saying the F-word about twice in every sentence and basically insulting everyone there. It was quite astonishing.

Looking back in makes my stomach sink to think these are the people running our country and leading industry 😬😬.

Kaybush · 14/06/2018 22:41

I went to a private girls' school that unfortunately had mostly rubbish, complacent teachers, and I wasted most of my time dreaming about boys!

BUT, I was surrounded by extremely confident, assertive girls and I think that really rubbed off on me.

Once I'd clawed my way back on track and into university, I graduated thinking I could do anything and it sort of became a self-fulfilling prophecy.

A good state school would have the same effect IMO though.

gillybeanz · 14/06/2018 22:29

user

I do believe you, I've heard it myself and some parents at dd school who have come from others have told us this, too.
I'm sorry that all children can't be catered for in both sectors, it's so wrong. Thanks

Dapplegrey · 14/06/2018 22:26

asked to leave every year

WrongOn - did you ask every year to leave the school, or did you ask every year to leave the drug ridden estate?

Aroundtheworldandback · 14/06/2018 22:26

My ds went to a top private school, hated it. All his friends were in the debating society (amongst others), and used to go on national and foreign trips debating with other schools, the last trip was a “European Union” trip to France. I’m sure public speaking have the boys confidence.

user1466518624 · 14/06/2018 22:24

Gillybeanz it is hard not to be cynical when you have been treated like shit by a private school and while I am glad you are having a great experience sadly you are ina minority x

user1466518624 · 14/06/2018 22:21

Gillybeanz I would love to know what school it is as in my area the schools either want £10k upwards or do not want to know and I am not talking major SEN, just a very bright boy with development and speech running 9 months behind who is making constant progress with no behaviour issues.

gillybeanz · 14/06/2018 22:18

Sorry, must add the dc are very tolerant of children who might be different to them for some reason.
I can't give instances because it isn't fair under our circumstances (small school) but my dd has been faced with some things she found a bit unnerving from a new boy once.
She immediately reported it and the SENCO spoke to dd and gave her info on what to do and how she could help the boy.
maybe some fee paying schools are like you say, but please don't tar them all with the same brush.

WrongOnTheInternet · 14/06/2018 22:17

IMO the benefits ascribed, including educational ability, to private school pupils are entirely due to their coming from the kind of backgrounds that pushed them into private school in the first place. Home-based nurturing will outweigh school-based nurturing every time.

WrongOnTheInternet · 14/06/2018 22:15

Depends on the school, depends on the child, it's difficult to generalise. For what it's worth I went to private school under the old assisted places schemes, no way would my parents have been able to afford fees. I hated it, hated the expectations of multi-millionaire 'success' coming from my drug-ridden estate, asked to leave every year, constantly felt like an outsider, never really re-built confidence, and it left me totally bitter and twisted about the inequality of Britain. The last of which I'm sure I never would have been otherwise Smile.

gillybeanz · 14/06/2018 22:13

user

Lots of children with sn at my dd school, not charged for 1 to 1 support.
i'm not sure they would be able to offer a place to those with severe sn, but state schools don't provide for these cases either.
It has never been posed that any child is less welcome than another and certainly no mindfulness of them affecting anybody else.
I'm sorry if this is your experience.
I love that there are the staff to provide support for not only sn, but mh, learning disabilities, and difficulties, and of course EAL and G&T.

user1466518624 · 14/06/2018 22:02

Want2b fantastic, but take a look at the many threads on here about SEN kids being kicked out of or not even considered for Indies in the UK. Most do not have the resources, the staff appropriately trained or the inclination to cater for SEN. I would love to know these schools that snapped up your ASD children as I would put my ds there tomorrow as he is being let down by the state and we pay for his speech etc but the Indies do not want to know as one put it they have to be “mindful” of other parents who are paying and don’t want my son to be seen to be having a little bit of handholding until he knows the routine. I would also bet that the selectives would want double the fees to pay for 1 to 1 support.

dragontwo · 14/06/2018 21:51

Sorry should have written:

Merely wanting to know how to encourage the positive qualities that I have seen some kids from private school have (and outside of private school too I should add - I did not say it was exclusive to private school). And yes I do have reservations about private schools, as if you had read my OP you might realise.

OP posts:
dragontwo · 14/06/2018 21:48

good point Carycach100, and @arethereanyleftatall, where did I say I wanted a "show off, boastful" DC? Putting words in my mouth, much??

I asked for the "beneficial aspects" in my OP. That does NOT include boasting or showing off. Merely wanting to know the positive qualities that I have seen some kids. And yes I do have reservations about private schools, as if you had read my OP you might realise.

OP posts:
arethereanyleftatall · 14/06/2018 21:44

Spot on @Carycach100
My dh is the most genuinely confident person I've ever met. As such he is the exact opposite of the types of people the op is aspiring her dc to be. He never shows off, never boasts, he could have been in the Olympics and wouldn't mention it.
He would never stand up in front of a crowd of people and talk. He wouldn't want to, so doesn't. Because he's so confident in himself he doesn't have anything to prove.

Carycach100 · 14/06/2018 21:32

I think you are confusing the trademark lesser-private school swagger with confidence.What it is really is a mixture of arrogance and blag which nearly everyone finds deeply unappealing and usually masks insecurity and lack of substance
Confidence is completely different - confident people are comfortable in their skin, aware of and able to acknowlwdge their own shortcomings

NetofLemons · 14/06/2018 21:30

I have noticed it as a recruiter ,there can be (generalising) maybe a bit more bullshitting/fake it till you make it with the privately educated kids but crucially so much less fear of failure. They will often have done something adventurous, started up their own things, they will talk about all this quite unselfconsciously. It must be a great way to feel. Smile

stilltryingstillfailing · 14/06/2018 21:18

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

OCSock · 14/06/2018 21:12

DS has attended four secondary schools, both private and comprehensive since age 13. The first, our choice was a superb school, but proved too challenging logistically, as we lived a long way distant. The second, our local comp, was convenient, he knew people locally, and he did GCSEs there for two years. He learned half of b*gger all, and only passed in the academic subjects thanks to what he had learned in years earlier. (This was at the time rated as an outstanding school.)

For sixth form, we and he chose a newly created school, which failed to attract pupils in its third year of existence and for enrollment/numbers reasons, ended up having to take everyone from the local PRUs. Those students trashed the facilities, caused the whole SLT to have breakdowns or take early retirement and the young enthusiastic teachers were systematically headhunted as HoD/HoY by more established schools.

We bailed out after nine teacher changes in six months and chose to pay for a private school sixth form. It wasn't the greatest school in all honesty, but the teachers taught (sometimes well, but not always) and there were expectations on the pupils to participate in everything that was available. It was noticeable that it was the paying day pupils, whose parents (and grandparents, whose financial contribution was often the factor making fee payments possible) were encouraging the students to join in what was on and available. Interestingly, according to my mole, the school has suddenly refocused on engaging local people because they have noted that the school's participation in prestige events declined significantly while the emphasis was on sports and overseas students.

My read on all this, for ordinary families (we are) is that independent and grammar schools are free to deliver a better, more rounded education because
there's nowhere to hide in smaller classes;
bad behaviour and indiscipline is stamped on hard and quickly; teachers help to find and celebrate every success;
families are supportive, but expect something in return;
education is valued, and achievement is applauded by students as well as parents and teachers;
everyone is expected to have a go at everything, even if you have three eyes and five legs, you'll make the third rugby/netball team every week against another school's third team, and sometimes you'll win. You may hate it, but you will turn out to play, even if it's raining.

The objective of independent, paid for education (and of course I know it's not an option for every family, although I think searching for the closest approximation of it should be available to every person in the country) is to instil confidence that the individual can succeed, to the best of their abilities, provided they are willing to put in the work.

LakieLady · 14/06/2018 21:11

I do think independent school girls (can’t speak for boys as none at my schools) are more confident because they’re not having to watch their back all the time.

I agree. In fact, my position on single-sex education is completely untenable: I think it's great for girls, but that co-ed is best for boys.

The school I went was a Girls Day School Trust school, I think there are around 20-odd across the country. An old boss of mine once told me he that could tell a "GDST girl" within 15 minutes of speaking to her because they are bright, confident and opinionated, and he was married to one. He mentioned 2 women in other departments that he thought bore the stamp of a GDST school, and in both cases, he was right.

The sad thing is, I had no idea at the time that my school wasn't the norm for most people. All schools should be that good, and they should all be producing confident young adults with enquiring minds.

spinn · 14/06/2018 20:58

I've been looking around private schools recently for my kids. Things I've noticed, trust - doors aren't locked, they know codes, they are trusted to move around safely etc as opposed to crowd control in bigger schools.
The students are constantly asked and challenged - if they ask a question then the teacher questions them back to find the answer or helps them find it out rather than it being easier to give them the answer.

flowerpott · 14/06/2018 20:56

Lots of public vs private stuff here, but every school is different. I've taught in both and absolutely believe it's down to the leadership and practices of the school and this varies massively by area and by age grouping. There are incredible state schools that really push and provide everything for their children, but also a lot that are challenged for resources and simply don't have there same environment. There are a lot of amazing private schools, but not each one is right for my DC, or for anyone else's either. There is chat upthread about SEN provision, a lot of the 'top' academic schools won't work with SEN, but there are other specialist private schools who have amazing facilities and environments to support SEN. Every school is different.

I'm on mat leave at the minute from my role in a private school, and it's a workplace I love. There is so much opportunity for the children, but they're also reminded how privileged they are. This serves both as a motivator for them to work hard, so as to be deserving of those opportunities, and also for them to contribute to the school in other ways. The kids raise a lot of money each year for charity through school schemes, a lot goes to educational foundations in less
wealthy parts of the world and the school also provides governance and support to a local state secondary. There is some entitlement from child to child, but the attitude of the school itself is geared much more towards a sense of the responsibility that privilege brings.

Personally, I also have to say that as a teacher my current school makes me feel 100 times more valued than 2 previous state schools. I'm given trust, freedom And the chance to make changes or implement new ideas. I'm given proper time off and proper thanks whenever I go above and beyond (which is every day for state school teachers, with silent expectation not so much as a thank you), less grief from parents... I definitely think we could look at how teachers are treated if we want to look at disparities between state and private.