DS has attended four secondary schools, both private and comprehensive since age 13. The first, our choice was a superb school, but proved too challenging logistically, as we lived a long way distant. The second, our local comp, was convenient, he knew people locally, and he did GCSEs there for two years. He learned half of b*gger all, and only passed in the academic subjects thanks to what he had learned in years earlier. (This was at the time rated as an outstanding school.)
For sixth form, we and he chose a newly created school, which failed to attract pupils in its third year of existence and for enrollment/numbers reasons, ended up having to take everyone from the local PRUs. Those students trashed the facilities, caused the whole SLT to have breakdowns or take early retirement and the young enthusiastic teachers were systematically headhunted as HoD/HoY by more established schools.
We bailed out after nine teacher changes in six months and chose to pay for a private school sixth form. It wasn't the greatest school in all honesty, but the teachers taught (sometimes well, but not always) and there were expectations on the pupils to participate in everything that was available. It was noticeable that it was the paying day pupils, whose parents (and grandparents, whose financial contribution was often the factor making fee payments possible) were encouraging the students to join in what was on and available. Interestingly, according to my mole, the school has suddenly refocused on engaging local people because they have noted that the school's participation in prestige events declined significantly while the emphasis was on sports and overseas students.
My read on all this, for ordinary families (we are) is that independent and grammar schools are free to deliver a better, more rounded education because
there's nowhere to hide in smaller classes;
bad behaviour and indiscipline is stamped on hard and quickly; teachers help to find and celebrate every success;
families are supportive, but expect something in return;
education is valued, and achievement is applauded by students as well as parents and teachers;
everyone is expected to have a go at everything, even if you have three eyes and five legs, you'll make the third rugby/netball team every week against another school's third team, and sometimes you'll win. You may hate it, but you will turn out to play, even if it's raining.
The objective of independent, paid for education (and of course I know it's not an option for every family, although I think searching for the closest approximation of it should be available to every person in the country) is to instil confidence that the individual can succeed, to the best of their abilities, provided they are willing to put in the work.