For a start there will be a higher proportion of bright pupils in a private school and inheritance, it is now acknowledged, is the main factor in intelligence. Small classes help as does setting and competition. Opportunities to take part in sports, drama, music, public speaking and other enriching activities are offered with chances to learn self discipline, skills and resilience. Discipline underpins the relationship between reacher and pupil and infringements are punished. The curriculum and teaching methods are still mostly traditional and focussed on success. Exams are frequent and train the children not to fear them but take them in their stride. Manners are taught and articulate and polite speech are expected between adults and children and between the children themselves. Reading is taken seriously and it is expected that children will read voraciously. Children see these rules reinforced at home by parents who are focussed on education. There is no hijacking of funds to spend liberally on the weakest and the worst behaved as the parents are paying and want their child to succeed, not languish forgotten in a class of problem children.
Of course a danger in all of this is that children will become arrogant, spoilt and entitled and, when my two were at prep schools and state grammars, there were a number of children who were obnoxious. Yet there were enough lovely, clever, confident children that my own were influenced (and influenced others) for the good.
Having said that, my youngest is clever but shy and, while she can still be self deprecating, she has been taught a confident manner to see her through public events and dealing with others. In fact, that is the nature of her job now.
These are the positives that private school offers but there is also the issue of what they are not which is almost more important.
Private schools do not push an artificial, caring/ sharing agenda. They do not elevate the badly behaved, the weak, the unacademic and the parents who do not support education, poor speech and manners. Private schools do not tolerate bullying, ‘banter’, cheeking the teacher or other bad behaviour. They do not seek to take clever children down a peg or two or make them feel guilty about being bright or from non-poor homes. They do not employ weak, badly qualified or unacademic teachers. They do not put politically correct values above those connected with education.
I worked and at one time my whole salary went towards paying the school fees. Today I could not afford it but I would mortgage the house to do it. There is nothing so important as education.