Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask how do private schools produce such "confident" kids / adults and how I can do it at home?

995 replies

dragontwo · 12/06/2018 21:11

Ok, I have my reservations about private schools, but I recognise that often they produce kids / adults with high self confidence and self assurance.

I want to know how they do this, how they drill this confidence into them, and how I can replicate any beneficial aspects of this at home into my own kid (state schooled)?

What do they say / do / teach that encourages them to be so confident and expect success?

I know there are down sides to everything but I'm just thinking about good ideas I can help my kid. NB I'm no tiger mother and do my best to encourage my kid as it is already but just looking for ideas and general thoughts on how it's done!!

Just curious!

OP posts:
SuspiciouslyMinded · 15/06/2018 09:30

MinaPaws that’s so depressing. What you have said illustrates the main problem Britain has with education - that is, quite large sections of society that don’t value education, where willingness to learn and being smart are perceived as something to hide or be ashamed of. Too often, underachievement is blamed on poverty or class. It has nothing to do with it - it’s all to do with attitudes. Poor kids can still visit a local library for free, but if reading is not perceived as a worthwile activity, they won’t. They’ll be riding around on stolen mopeds instead because it’s perceived as cool.

The irony of despising the very thing that can really improve your life is just depressing. But changing people’s attitudes is the hardest. Any ideas of how ths can be done?

Can you imagine if in both private and non-selective state schools teachers worked with kids whose parents want them to do their best, despite their abilities, and reinforce the message that learning is valuable and knowing things is cool and something to aspire to? Where all kids get the necessary support at home - in terms of having a safe, quite space in which to read or do their homework for example? The vast differences in achievement in the two sectors would quickly evaporate.

Kaybush · 15/06/2018 09:12

@SuspiciouslyMinded please don't link me with the offensive comments about inheritance and intelligence! 😂😂

My two BILs went to Christ's Hospital and now have great careers. But worryingly it seems to now be suffering from what @MinaPaws described.

A recent student told me that there has been a drive to take in more ethnically diverse students from disadvantaged backgrounds, but that this has now created a culture there where it's 'not cool' to be academic.

SuspiciouslyMinded · 15/06/2018 08:59

‘Etonian’ not ‘Etibian’ obviously 🙄

SuspiciouslyMinded · 15/06/2018 08:58

@Kaybush The only Etibian I ever met was withdrawn and quiet. When asked which school he went to, he was embarrassed and mumbled something along the lines of ‘uhm, a school near Slough’ His mother invited a few of his pals including me to lunch one day and spent the entire time berating her son for everything, making pointed remarks etc. It was painful to be there. His was 22 at the time. So all in all schools have a great impact on how you turn out, but it’s mainly your parents who mess you up or make you into a happy human being. As Philip Larkin knew so well.

As for intelligence - what a horrible and asinine remark to make user. Is it a bad joke? You equate living on a council estate with lack of intelligence? In case you didn’t get it - the talk is about inheritance as in genes not as in money you inherit from a rich grandma.

And it seems to be true - there have been recent studies that showed that intelligence is largely due to genes, mainly on the maternal side - so teacher is right. Intelligence is just that though - ability to learn, adaptability, in other words mental potential. You can be an intelligent cleaner and a dumb manager. How you use your intelligence is down to your environment and opportunities. - and this is where the British education system lets down the very bright underprivileged kids.

I always thought that excellent, academically selective, but means-tested schools with a charity status might address this problem to some extent. Like Christ’s Hospital.

But that’s a topic for another thread.

Kaybush · 15/06/2018 08:53

@MinaPaws gosh that's so sad and very worrying.

It is of course down to where the comprehensive is though. My son went to one of two comprehensives available to us He hared it mainly for the reasons you outline, so last year managed to switch to the other one, where he is thriving.

The schools are only about two miles apart, but the first is near some large estates and attract a large proportion of the kind of pupils you describe.

The second is in a much more affluent area and my son says in almost every class he's been in since he joined last summer, all the students are attentive and well behaved.

I'm really pleased for him but quite sad for his former school. What I always thought was a teaching issue seems to be just down to demographics.

LakieLady · 15/06/2018 08:42

I suspect the difference between me and some posters on here is that I have actually met some state schoo, children and lived to tell the tale......

Almost everyone I know went to state school. The only ones who didn't were my boss, who had rich parents, 3 friends whose parents worked overseas and who boarded in the UK, and those, like me, who got scholarships or assisted places under something called the "direct grant scheme" which only existed until the early 70s.

I know someone whose daughter got a 90% scholarship to Roedean, and my lovely niece got a scholarship to a private school. They are now 13 and 16, and their maturity and confidence has developed massively. They are streets ahead of other teenage kids I know, but whether that's the private school thing or the single-sex thing, I have no idea.

MinaPaws · 15/06/2018 08:32

A good state school would have the same effect IMO though.

I wish I thought that was true, @Kaybush. I think state comprehensives (not grammars) would find that almost impossible to emulate. Because they exclude no one, there will be a high proportion of children passing through who may never work in their lives. Whose parents live on benefits, and they too foresee either benefits or dead end jobs as their horizons. Eye contact and a firm handshake won't solve that chasm in how they view their opportunities. And quite naturally, people who deeply believe they have no opportunities will mock, scorn, threaten and bully those who think they have some. So there's often an unwritten rule in comps that you must play down academic enthusiasm to survive. That was certainly true in the school I went to. I know it was true for several other friends.

And I've discovered it to be true among the state school pupils I tutor, many of whom have said to me: I can't use that word in an essay, people will think I'm up myself. One of the main jobs I have as a tutor for state school children is to foster their self belief and to try and get them past the idea that writing fluently and eloquently is 'posh' and therefore not for them. I think state schools have so many social and economic battles on their hands, and justifiable social and economic anger coming out in their pupils in various ways. It's not all about learning. In private schools, there's less to contend with. There's perfectionism and status games but not such a massive variety of complex issues because the pupils aren't drawn from such a wide social pool.

PepperShake · 15/06/2018 08:17

I should also mention that when I was in my early 20s I went to a dinner party in London and we were 'warned' in advance by the host that there would be three ex-Etonians there.
We couldn't understand why he did this, but OMG they took arrogance to the next level, saying the F-word about twice in every sentence and basically insulting everyone there. It was quite astonishing.

@Kaybush - Your host was an idiot. So they invited the Etonians they clearly loathe for sport?
Of course,no one who went to state school ever swore, ever.

This whole thread is just full of silly stereotypes, and ridiculous generalisations.

Are there annoying, arrogant private school students -Of course
Are there annoying arrogant state school student - Of course
Are there good private schools - Yes, of course
Are there good state schools - Yes of course.
Are there shy, timid lacking in confidence private school students - Yes
Are the shy, timid, lacking in confidence state school student - Yes

Just follow this train and swap adjectives, you can find children that match across both sectors.

silverpenguin · 15/06/2018 07:59

As someone who didn't go to private school but works with lots of people who did, I think it's:

  • believing your contribution is worthwhile, speaking up and just expecting others will listen because why wouldn't they?
  • expecting success, having been pushed to achieve great results from a young age. At my school, if you were heading for a B or a C that was fine, what was the big deal? Private schools expect A or A*s
.
Dapplegrey · 15/06/2018 07:58

Kaybush - why on earth did your host invite old Etonians if he/she felt obliged to 'warn' you about their presence.
Do you ask people to dinner who you feel you must 'warn' the other guests about?

user1466518624 · 15/06/2018 07:44

Walking yes I do my dh was not particularly an exception at his comp loads of his peers went on to University and are successful but that was back in the days before tuition fees and grants were stll around but thats another story.

Teacher22 is making some really sweeping statements which are not true!

MeyYael · 15/06/2018 07:43

*ren (not rent...)

MeyYael · 15/06/2018 07:43

Teacher22 Inheritance a main factor in intelligence???? Then how come my dh who was raised on a council estate achieved a PHD from Cambridge???

Are you saying that people who bring their child(rent) up on a council estate aren't intelligent? Hmm

WalkingOnAFlashlightBeam · 15/06/2018 07:19

Teacher22 Inheritance a main factor in intelligence???? Then how come my dh who was raised on a council estate achieved a PHD from Cambridge???

You do realise that there are exceptions to every rule, right???

user1466518624 · 15/06/2018 07:12

Teacher22 Inheritance a main factor in intelligence???? Then how come my dh who was raised on a council estate achieved a PHD from Cambridge???

user1466518624 · 15/06/2018 07:10

Teacher22 sorry but some of ypur sweeping statements are bollocks.

I have witnessed bullying and banter that you claim will not be tolerated that has driven a child to self harm but it has all been swept under the carpet as the bully was the bursers son.

They do not employ weak, underacademic or under qualified teachers. I have witnessed with my own children some of the weakest and poorest teaching and most parents I know including me have had to employ tutors. After I withdrew him from one my ds told me that the maths teacher used to just stick You Tube videos on.

Enriching opportunities in debating, sport, drama, maths challenges do exist in State and around here the state frequently thrash the Indies in sport, public speaking etc.

tomhazard · 15/06/2018 07:09

They do not employ weak, badly qualified or unacademic teachers.

Having worked in a number of private schools I can assure you that there are a few of these dotted around!

Mmest75 · 15/06/2018 06:33

Agreed - there is non of this - everyone gets a star, a prize etc. The best performing do but that’s it.
It’s a more realistic prep for life let’s be honest, not everyone will get the promotion or whatever.

praisebebitches · 15/06/2018 06:21

For a start there will be a higher proportion of bright pupils in a private school and inheritance, it is now acknowledged, is the main factor in intelligence

Bollocks.

Teacher22 · 15/06/2018 06:03

Sorry, teacher not reacher. No edit button.

Teacher22 · 15/06/2018 06:01

For a start there will be a higher proportion of bright pupils in a private school and inheritance, it is now acknowledged, is the main factor in intelligence. Small classes help as does setting and competition. Opportunities to take part in sports, drama, music, public speaking and other enriching activities are offered with chances to learn self discipline, skills and resilience. Discipline underpins the relationship between reacher and pupil and infringements are punished. The curriculum and teaching methods are still mostly traditional and focussed on success. Exams are frequent and train the children not to fear them but take them in their stride. Manners are taught and articulate and polite speech are expected between adults and children and between the children themselves. Reading is taken seriously and it is expected that children will read voraciously. Children see these rules reinforced at home by parents who are focussed on education. There is no hijacking of funds to spend liberally on the weakest and the worst behaved as the parents are paying and want their child to succeed, not languish forgotten in a class of problem children.

Of course a danger in all of this is that children will become arrogant, spoilt and entitled and, when my two were at prep schools and state grammars, there were a number of children who were obnoxious. Yet there were enough lovely, clever, confident children that my own were influenced (and influenced others) for the good.

Having said that, my youngest is clever but shy and, while she can still be self deprecating, she has been taught a confident manner to see her through public events and dealing with others. In fact, that is the nature of her job now.

These are the positives that private school offers but there is also the issue of what they are not which is almost more important.

Private schools do not push an artificial, caring/ sharing agenda. They do not elevate the badly behaved, the weak, the unacademic and the parents who do not support education, poor speech and manners. Private schools do not tolerate bullying, ‘banter’, cheeking the teacher or other bad behaviour. They do not seek to take clever children down a peg or two or make them feel guilty about being bright or from non-poor homes. They do not employ weak, badly qualified or unacademic teachers. They do not put politically correct values above those connected with education.

I worked and at one time my whole salary went towards paying the school fees. Today I could not afford it but I would mortgage the house to do it. There is nothing so important as education.

BestZebbie · 15/06/2018 01:57

When they tell you they are going to do something (unless it is criminal or likely to be fatal!), you say "awesome!" and ask them more about it in a way which assumes they will succeed.
eg: "I'm going to learn Portuguese and then travel south america next year"
"awesome! which parts in particular? you'll have to take lots of photos to show me!"
not "hahaha you'll never learn Portuguese" or "omg that is quite far away, isn't that scary? How about Bognor instead?" etc.

gillybeanz · 15/06/2018 00:39

whoops.

Forgot to say, lots of brilliant state secondary schools, all over the place.
They are just not known for it round here.
Not a grammar for miles, nearest and only private school about 8 miles away.

gillybeanz · 15/06/2018 00:37

Once again I have to agree,
Due to the area we live our two older dc didn't have half the opportunity that dd is having. It was the complete opposite ds2 finally diagnosed with Aspergers at 18, spent most of his time in isolation or the corridor.
Ds1 sink estate school, drugs, violence, not an environment to learn.
Luckily they had interested parents and we parented them both on the right path, despite peer pressure to the opposite.
They are confident, ds1 has a good career, ds2 we still don't know yet, but he works ft. Neither has aspiration to rule the world, or dominate in a profession.

SuspiciouslyMinded · 15/06/2018 00:28

Thank you gillybeans
I wish all the kids had a great experience at school. The world would be a happier and better place. And it’s not even the question of private vs state sector. I’ve seen private schools where I wouldn’t put my kids even if they paid me to do so: competitive, league-tables-obsessed, with kids burnt out with stress before they even leave. Some parents love such schools, kids not so much. These tend to be the same parents who complain to the teachers about not setting enough homework.

State schools could also be great if the teachers could concentrate on proper teaching and inspiring, without having their hands increasingly tied by stupid governmental inspections, expectations, regulations, testing and paperwork.

Swipe left for the next trending thread