Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask how do private schools produce such "confident" kids / adults and how I can do it at home?

995 replies

dragontwo · 12/06/2018 21:11

Ok, I have my reservations about private schools, but I recognise that often they produce kids / adults with high self confidence and self assurance.

I want to know how they do this, how they drill this confidence into them, and how I can replicate any beneficial aspects of this at home into my own kid (state schooled)?

What do they say / do / teach that encourages them to be so confident and expect success?

I know there are down sides to everything but I'm just thinking about good ideas I can help my kid. NB I'm no tiger mother and do my best to encourage my kid as it is already but just looking for ideas and general thoughts on how it's done!!

Just curious!

OP posts:
Openup41 · 16/06/2018 13:19

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at poster's request.

Ohsuchaperfectday · 16/06/2018 11:30

Cblue.

People make friends on who they like, not checking first the size of someones house or the money in their DP account, we are drawn to who we are drawn too. So it doesn't surprise me in the slightest.

Usually the more relaxed DP who give the dc some space and allow then to stay are going to be the winners not uptight ones with show homes...or the tight ones who re use tea bags. So yes, this stuff really doesn't matter.

Thehogfather · 16/06/2018 10:16

Not rtfd, but I really can't think of anything that a similar background wouldn't be doing in the state system.

There will be a range of backgrounds at any independent, from the traditionally working class on a bursary, first/second generation immigrant, wealthy but abusive/ neglectful parents and everything in between. As well as the stereotype of the typical background.

The one thing they all have in common is privilege. Whether that's the privilege of being able to access the bursary system through parental involvement and ability, parents able and willing to make sacrifices to access what they believe is the best education, or the privilege of class and/ or wealth.

The only thing I can think of is all those different privileges rubbing off on each other.

Anecdotal, and certainly won't apply at the type of independent that attracts large numbers of parents there for the snob value, but I'd also say at dd's the sense of security in the parents own social status is part of it, whatever that status is.

Ime the social group where the most snobbery occurs is the lower middle class. Some seem to feel a need to affirm their own social status either by putting down the working class or deprived, through inverse snobbery, or both. And certainly at dds, and experiences I've heard about other similar independents, that mentality is such a small minority they don't have the opportunity to reduce other dcs confidence.

Also won't apply to all independents, but the pastoral care. State schools with all the will in the world simply don't have the resources to support every major problem that could destroy a child's confidence, let alone minor temporary dents. Whereas an independent that values pastoral care does have the resources

Clarabel22 · 16/06/2018 09:14

In my experience (2 children currently in private school, one started in state primary) it is all about class sizes.
Both of mine are fairly confident but for the one who started in state primary, when they moved to private the difference in confidence with adults and others noticeably increased and when they were younger they were both quite, sometimes embarrassingly, precocious with strangers when out and about. I think this is down to two things: the teachers would chat with the children individually, because they had time to and also, they were put on the stage all the time, doing little plays, poetry readings, etc. My feeling though is that it is largely down to the amount of attention they get - when they open the mouths to speak they get listened to and interacted with by the teachers. They are also picked up on their manners and rewarded for being helpful, e.g. opening doors for staff, and they shake hands with the teacher at the end of the day.
In our case it is absolutely nothing to do with feeling superior or social status as this does not apply to our family and the schools they attend(ed) are not at all elitist.

nevermindthebongos · 16/06/2018 09:05

@bertrandrussell no I am definitely not agreeing with you!! I explained in my earlier post The mannerisms and social "rules" still get handed down from year to year whether or not the majority come from one particular social group and that probably comes from when it was the preserve of the privileged, all those years ago.

BertrandRussell · 16/06/2018 08:52

“the mannerisms I referred to are picked up from the other children, handed down year to year.“

So you’re agreeing with me- the vast majority of the other children already know “the rules”? I am a little puzzled here.......

nevermindthebongos · 16/06/2018 08:48

@bertrandrussell I posted too soon - you say one of the functions of a private school was to teach children how to fit into a particular social group-examples being the emphasis on table manners and greeting people properly I am assuming that wasn't me, but if you did mean me, you misunderstood as I said that you learned rules of a particular social group but not that it was one of the functions of the school to teach children how to fit into a particular social group - the mannerisms I referred to are picked up from the other children, handed down year to year. The teachers were mostly very down to earth types, focused on teaching and helping the pupils learn.

nevermindthebongos · 16/06/2018 08:42

@bertrandrussell firstly same social "group" is not the same as "class". There are lots of social groups in the UK not related to class. Secondly you say I pointed out that most pupils at private school would be part of that social group already, and would have learned those rules at home. This applies to them whether they are funded by grandparents, come from single parent families or have additional needs and no that is wrong, no, they were not mostly from the same social groups, nor the same class for that matter, and were not learning the "right" social skills at home.

The sort of mannerisms you pick up in private schools which gives the impression of confidence are similar to those you'd find amongst the lawyers, politicians, etc, I think, and it isn't primarily to do with table manners, it is also to do with how you engage with people and interact with people. It is an interesting thing about social rules in the UK, I think. Knowing the "rules" disguises your background.

The main things I got from the school, however, was a love of learning and know how about how to pass exams, and different expectations, for example a new expectation that i'd go to uni.

BertrandRussell · 16/06/2018 07:58

"Being deliberately obtuse in order to misrepresent people's views might help you to feel self-righteous, but it's neither helpful nor intellectually honest."

I was responding to a PP's assertion that one of the functions of a private school was to teach children how to fit into a particular social group-examples being the emphasis on table manners and greeting people properly. I pointed out that most pupils at private school would be part of that social group already, and would have learned those rules at home. This applies to them whether they are funded by grandparents, come from single parent families or have additional needs.

strawberrybubblegum · 16/06/2018 07:22

BertrandRussell
What’s that got to do with the social class they belong to?

It's clear that these are different dimensions which vary within the 'wide range of children':

  • wide range of social class (previously aluded to)
  • wide variety of needs for educational support ("many with SEN")
  • wide range of income ("GP funding it")
  • wide range of family setup ("single parents")

These are orthogonal concerns (which is made clear by the phrase "and so on").

It's in no way implied that these all apply to the same child Confused The examples all show that in each of these dimensions, there are children who don't adhere to the stereotypes held by some people.

Being deliberately obtuse in order to misrepresent people's views might help you to feel self-righteous, but it's neither helpful nor intellectually honest.

BertrandRussell · 16/06/2018 06:34

However your average local private usually has a wide range of dc there,. including many with special needs, so many GP funding it, single parents and so on.“

What’s that got to do with the social class they belong to?

Cblue · 15/06/2018 21:23

@Ohsuchaperfectday - yep a mix here too

I am an ex grammar girl (don't heckle!!) from a working class background (grandparents bought their council house)
Decent job and decent money
Single parent and for 12 years no financial contribution from her father
DD goes to a middle/high tier selective independent
DD is dyslexic.
Many of her friends are very very rich (think old money and also some footballers wives types)
Some parents own shops, some are Drs (actually lots are GPS, surgeons and dentists) some are investment bankers, many of them are kids of foreign international diplomats
I live in a small house in a decent area

And where do they all come? Where do they have sleep overs? Yep, mine

So please don't assume that all private school kids are up themselves!!
That's inverted snobbery at best

Ohsuchaperfectday · 15/06/2018 20:47

you said that the people who go to private school are from the same social group and I said no, that I was as common as muck and that I wasn't the only commoner

This is my experience too - I can only assume posters who make those comments have not had any experience of private school. There are the Big Ones, Harrow, Eton etc, where it really will be quite exceptional to have lower socio economic dc there.

However your average local private usually has a wide range of dc there,. including many with special needs, so many GP funding it, single parents and so on.

Ohsuchaperfectday · 15/06/2018 20:41

Is it the school or the parents though?

Getting dc to be polite and aware of other people takes time! I'm constantly reminding mine to be aware of the elderly etc, be polite. At parties for her sibs I try and get her to introduce herself and make her "aware" that the people coming to our house have never been here before, they are our guests and its up to us to make them feel welcome..offer them food...and even if she feels shy - just say " hello" and make eye contact etc.

Also lavish with affection and praise. If your family isn't interested in education or improving yourself...they may not praise in that particular way...

Having something about you to get you away I think gives confidence, it could be money - or brains. but sometimes to just get out and away from a situation, many people with no money cant do this - feeling so stuck and trapped does squash spirit.

Personally I feel teachers and school step in where parents can't to me its the whole point of school.

Ie the personality of the teacher comes through but it cant come through if that teacher is frantic - meeting deadlines and targets and spending most of the lesson managing the dc.

user1466518624 · 15/06/2018 20:37

Jonbb what a load of twaddle of course you can!

gillybeanz · 15/06/2018 20:37

Jonbb

I disagree, you can encourage all these things through H.ed if you've a mind too.
Maybe, it's easier in a private school, but people on here have posted how some good state schools can gain the same result.

Jonbb · 15/06/2018 20:32

In answer to your original question, you can't, that's why private schools exist, thankfully.

DownstairsMixUp · 15/06/2018 20:29

I don't buy the grammar school thing. I live in a huge grammar area, know lots of people who went to grammar schools, including my husband and they are like normal state kids. I go to uni across the road from a grammar and kids all behave like typical teens when they kick out. There's a private school near the back entrance of our uni though and I definitely can tell a difference with them, they often go jogging and are so well behaved and polite!

pallisers · 15/06/2018 20:26

This is what DH experienced, from both school and home. He was ridiculed by his (working class, Liverpudlian, family) and told that “people like us, from around here, don’t go to university”.

I have heard something like this on MN before and it always astonishes me. I don't know any Irish family who didn't/don't want their children to go to university if possible - doesn't matter what socio-economic group you are in. Maybe traveller families would prefer their children to stay away from outside influences? Ditto in the USA, every family I know from a wide range of economic groups aspire for their child to go to university - might not always happen but it is an aspiration. Only group I could think of who would say something like the above are maybe deeply conservative christian or jewish families - even then most evangelical christians will want their child to go to one of the religious universities.

Cblue · 15/06/2018 20:17

@foxpox - torn between hoping that they get their comeuppance and hoping that they can be happy in their little bubble

.....I guess that's luck.

But hey, that's them. Who cares. Sounds like you care about bringing up socially responsible polite kids which is what I have tried to do too. The private vs state things will never replace decent parenting.

I want my DD to be confident, look people in the eye, express opinions and to try her best and I like to think she has been taught to take everyone on their own merits. To get on this world you need to be a decent fair human being that people want to work with and who respects others (unless you fancy yourself as a 3rd world dictator).
The days of jobs for the boys are on the way out even in my industry (think white, middle aged, male, public school old boys - or 'old white male and stale' as a colleague describes them Smile)

I wonder what (if anything) the OP got out of this thread?

OCSock · 15/06/2018 20:15

But children make their own (usually astute) judgements of their parents and their friends/social groups (and their standing within groups) from a surprisingly young age. A friend's elder daughter very neatly pigeon-holed the more/less bright v more/less educated couples into their partnership roles at about nine. That was an eye-opener. She wasn't being intrusive or judging: she just knew which partner was the cleverer of each pairing. She had listened and observed.

What she did not know how to judge then (I bet she can now, 15 years on) was the dynamic behind those relationships. All remain married/couples, and all still friends. As an adult she will be making a more considered evaluation of what each brings to the partnership and why it continues to work, after 30 - 40 years. She could have been asked to set the table for dinner and work out who should sit where, and would have done it based on her observation of who liked each other most. And, she would have got it pretty well spot on. Some children are clever, quick students and work out very young how to manage people and relationships. They usually do well in life, even if they don't have squillions of qualifications or degrees. They have emotional intelligence and a knack for personal relationships, and in most cases, they will do better than people who are equally clever but have fewer soft skills. We all want to feel liked, valued and listened to, and IMVHO, those skills are learned very young and not from your parents. Boarding prep schools seem to do it best, BUT only for those that have the innate aptitude.

foxpox · 15/06/2018 19:51

@cblue
I've thought about that, what they will do in a situation where they're not considered important...honestly though, with this family I just don't think it would ever happen. Or it would but they'd be so self assured they'd read the situation all wrong and to their advantage! There are plenty of people floating about like that.

Cblue · 15/06/2018 19:32

@foxpox - TBH that's the behaviour that ISNT tolerated at her school. Not just not tolerated by the teachers but by the students too. I think I said earlier about having an opinion but respecting others opinions

Can you imagine a class where everyone thinks they are entitled to tell everyone else where to sit?
The class would never start. You could probably make one of those documentaries about it hahahaha.

Basically you are describing total brats.

Like you I wouldn't say anything about it but I would probably sit through the ordeal thinking
Child - wait until you meet someone bigger and stronger than you who feels just as entitled as you
Parents- wait until they are teenagers

That would amuse me enough to sit through the entire evening Smile

foxpox · 15/06/2018 19:13

@cblue
I suspected as much but it totally not my place to challenge it and I'd not come off well! I've never met children like them and they can be good company sometimes. They are inclusive of my younger dcs at all times and do have manners. Glad they're not indicative of most independent school kids though. I've never really been sure if the parenting is a product of the status the family feel they have, i.e their self confidence or the self confidence is a product of the way they all behave.

Cblue · 15/06/2018 18:56

@foxpox - oooerrrr
That's nothing to do with private school and confidence that's something else entirely. Breeding 'My Little Prince' and 'My Little Princess' is shameful!!!
What you end up with are total brats who will get a nasty shock when they grow up and will spend their lives with a sense of entitlement or marry people who will do exactly as they tell them to.

Don't wish to be rude but they sound thoroughly spoilt. I don't think that's just private though (well mine isn't like that - she has her faults but that isn't one of them). I know lots of state school kids who are exactly the same so it's not a private vs state issue it's a 'My kid is more important than anyone else'issue

Swipe left for the next trending thread