Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask how do private schools produce such "confident" kids / adults and how I can do it at home?

995 replies

dragontwo · 12/06/2018 21:11

Ok, I have my reservations about private schools, but I recognise that often they produce kids / adults with high self confidence and self assurance.

I want to know how they do this, how they drill this confidence into them, and how I can replicate any beneficial aspects of this at home into my own kid (state schooled)?

What do they say / do / teach that encourages them to be so confident and expect success?

I know there are down sides to everything but I'm just thinking about good ideas I can help my kid. NB I'm no tiger mother and do my best to encourage my kid as it is already but just looking for ideas and general thoughts on how it's done!!

Just curious!

OP posts:
topcat1980 · 18/06/2018 10:40

"I can’t see much difference in confidence between my own privileged state educated children and their privileged privately educated friends."

Me either really.

The way public speaking is described by Wonderwine isn't anything to do with private school.

I really object though to the idea that state schools don't encourage children to do their best and all sorts of other things repeated here by private school parents.

This : "Lastly being the best you can be and being inspired happens at private schools. "

As happened in all the state schools my children attended, and like I said, students with the same grades as private schools from state ones do better at uni.

Wonderwine · 18/06/2018 10:26

I think 'public speaking' is being used as a descriptor in this context to mean all sorts of occasions when children are encouraged to 'speak up and be heard/listened to' rather than the more formal 'presentation to 300 people' sort of thing.
A person needs to be very confident in their own ideas and beliefs first before they are able to explain and articulate these to others publicly.
So many jobs require the ability to communicate well with others, even if it is in relatively small groups. In the industries I've worked in there have always been people 'stuck' in junior positions as they simply didn't have the skills/confidence to e.g. present their ideas to a group/meeting or commicate and contribute effectively as part of a team. I worry these days, as I see so many young people who seem unable to string a sentence together without padding it out with words such as 'like', 'y'know' and 'stuff' (instead of being specific).

BertrandRussell · 18/06/2018 10:06

I am fascinated by this obsession with public speaking. As I said, it’s great for those that can do it, but must be hell for many.

For what it’s worth, I think happiness and privilege are the main rivers of confidence. I can’t see much difference in confidence between my own privileged state educated children and their privileged privately educated friends.

mouseistrapped · 18/06/2018 09:58

It is a culture that starts at a young age. My so. Is in the nursery of the prep school he will be going to and even from 2 they play games where they sit in a circle and take turns standing up in the group and introduce themselves/ talk about pets/ what they did at the weekend. This culture is encouraged the whole way through.

It is deemed positive amongst your peers to do well in tests and exams, speak up, put your hand up, be clever and hard working. You are not berated by others for trying to be your best as this is a culture they are used to and parents expect and friends of parents expect etc.

It just cl becomes the norm and builds all the way through with drama plays, choir, music recitals, success in exams.

That is a big chunk of what you pay for.

Lastly being the best you can be and being inspired happens at private schools.

It's not terribly fair but such is life. I know people that don't do private school but have a better car and holidays than me but that's the decision I've made as it's important to
Me as I came from it and can see the value.

If you want to emulate, you could add in extra curricular drama, scouts, brownies, summer camp, competitive sports etc etc and your non pressured expectation.

Wonderwine · 18/06/2018 09:55

@Cblue - I've also PM'd you for dyslexia tips, as DS needs to get his act together for A levels!

EnthusiasmIsDisturbed · 18/06/2018 09:51

Not in some parts of London

Many of the better schools have such a small intake after siblings and those that are given priority

Ds got my last choice and was only put on the list to avoid an even worse school. Time out spaces for children in year 2 ffs yet the school down the road was completely different. This school somehow received a very good
ofstead report while it being acknowledged that it struggled with disruptive pupils Confused and results were not that good

It has certainly improved in the last five years as the area has changed. Schools have become a good house marking selling point

BertrandRussell · 18/06/2018 09:50

“Absolutely. But the system doesn’t work when you DO fill in the form correctly and you don’t get any of the schools you put. Of course we lost out on one because it is selective on faith grounds, but it should be a reasonable assumption if you put the 5 nearest schools you get one of them! (Nearest being 0.4 Miles)”

Yes it should. Your situation is incredibly unusual. [Sad]

BertrandRussell · 18/06/2018 09:49

There is, as far as I can see, no “slagging off”.

JacquesHammer · 18/06/2018 09:48

Oh and we know what stupid mistakes people make on applications, my local school turned down 400 children this year who put it down as first choice, but when you find out that people put it down as first choice from 4 miles away ( in a London borough) with 5 secondary schools between their house and the school of choice, kind of indicates this was pie in the sky

Absolutely. But the system doesn’t work when you DO fill in the form correctly and you don’t get any of the schools you put. Of course we lost out on one because it is selective on faith grounds, but it should be a reasonable assumption if you put the 5 nearest schools you get one of them! (Nearest being 0.4 Miles)

Wonderwine · 18/06/2018 09:47

This thread started off as an interesting, balanced discussion about what it is that builds confidence in children yet seems to have gone the usual route of slagging off state/private parents and pupils, depending on which side of the fence you're on... how sad.

topcat1980 · 18/06/2018 09:45

"Having just checked the stats, in our LEA for her year of entry only 68.9% got first choice. "

So still a significant majority?

Oh and we know what stupid mistakes people make on applications, my local school turned down 400 children this year who put it down as first choice, but when you find out that people put it down as first choice from 4 miles away ( in a London borough) with 5 secondary schools between their house and the school of choice, kind of indicates this was pie in the sky.

topcat1980 · 18/06/2018 09:43

"I'm sure the local comprehensive is lovely, but it just wasn't right for my dcs as they're very academic "

Yes that one is funny.

Seriously just admit that you want to buy your kids a head start, there is no shame in it.

JacquesHammer · 18/06/2018 09:43

80 percent of all secondary school children get their first choice, so yes again the people who don't get their first choice catchment school are in a minority

My DD is in primary school. Having just checked the stats, in our LEA for her year of entry only 68.9% got first choice.

It is still naive to think that every can choose a school (or indeed 5 schools) and they always get one of them!

BertrandRussell · 18/06/2018 09:42

“Are you really so naive that you think everyone gets their catchment school?“

Not everyone, no. But the vast majority, yes.

topcat1980 · 18/06/2018 09:40

"Are you really so naive that you think everyone gets their catchment school?"

80 percent of all secondary school children get their first choice, so yes again the people who don't get their first choice catchment school are in a minority.

IrmaFayLear · 18/06/2018 09:39

I always enjoy the, "I'm sure the local comprehensive is lovely, but it just wasn't right for my dcs as they're very academic " We got the last laugh Wink

Also, regarding "sink" or "bad" schools: I have recently been working in one such school. True, the GCSE results are awful. But that's nothing to do with the building (very nice), facilities (excellent), teachers (really dedicated). It's because the pupils are mostly your classic white underclass. No diversity - no ambitious immigrant families. If you got every pupil and swapped them with the "leafy" comprehensive pupils a few miles away, the results would just swap from one school to the other.

JacquesHammer · 18/06/2018 09:36

The other thing that fascinates me is the number of mumsnetters with that much money available seem to live clustered in the catchments of “dire” state schools, thereby forcing them to go private. Which, considering that almost all “dire” state schools are in areas of significant deprivation does seem a bit odd...

Are you really so naive that you think everyone gets their catchment school?

We put 5 on our list when we applied for our daughter. The 5 absolute nearest in order of distance. We got none of them. We got given a school 30 minutes away.

the average day school fees £13,194

We pay nowhere near even half that figure for a year.

topcat1980 · 18/06/2018 09:35

Oh yes, all those people with 13k a year for school but only local sink schools. Yeah, yeah.

Don't mind if you make the decision, go for it, but don't weasel about it.

BertrandRussell · 18/06/2018 09:30

“Oh and its amazing how many people on MN "scrimp and save" to send their kids private, and go without a foreign holiday to send kids to private school, the average day school fees £13,194, so for two kids you need to have scrimped and saved more than the average salary (before tax) in order to send them”

Yep.This.

The other thing that fascinates me is the number of mumsnetters with that much money available seem to live clustered in the catchments of “dire” state schools, thereby forcing them to go private. Which, considering that almost all “dire” state schools are in areas of significant deprivation does seem a bit odd.....

There are loads of excellent reasons to go private. Many private schools are fabulous. Be delighted you can afford it if that’s what you want. Just don’ weasel about it!

IrmaFayLear · 18/06/2018 09:27

I think there is a huge range of private school pupils. Obviously at one end we have the true poshos (quite a small number, really) who ooze generations of privilege, whether they have much money or not. They seem to care not one jot for anyone, especially aspirational middle classes.

The vast majority of private school people are the middle-class stereotype of Mark Warner holidays, Boden, London suburbs, etc etc. They often have dcs that are "confident" as their parents are a bit pushy and always keen to be doing the "right" thing (but just a leetle bit better than anyone else...).

The academically successful types are generally not the ones rollicking around Rock in Cornwall or baying in Ski resorts; all the very clever (privately-educated) kids I know are rather quiet and self-effacing.

topcat1980 · 18/06/2018 09:22

"I think its independence/ self sufficiency that give you confidence to navigate the world. We were put in difficult situations, challenged in class, and asked to problem solve."

Independence and self sufficiency? Kids in state schools are challenged in class and given problems to solve, kids who get 3 As at A level from private and state schools progress to the same results at uni, kids who get 3 bs? The ones from state schools do better.

Privilege more like.

CaptainGT · 18/06/2018 09:21

I don't think it's a public speaking thing. I was never chosen to speak in assembly or anything. I think it comes more from being given opportunities to learn basics. In sixth form we had to do our own washing there were cooking classes etc.

I think its independence/ self sufficiency that give you confidence to navigate the world. We were put in difficult situations, challenged in class, and asked to problem solve.

topcat1980 · 18/06/2018 09:19

Oh and its amazing how many people on MN "scrimp and save" to send their kids private, and go without a foreign holiday to send kids to private school, the average day school fees £13,194, so for two kids you need to have scrimped and saved more than the average salary (before tax) in order to send them.

There will be some people who do this, there will be some kids whose GPs pay, but lets not pretend that the vast majority of children attending private school are from wealthy backgrounds.

Also, it makes it easier to try something and fail, if you are from one of these, those from less well off backgrounds may have to make safe choices in order to keep a roof over their head.

topcat1980 · 18/06/2018 09:15

How do they get kids so confident?

More than anything else I think coming from a relatively well off background gives you confidence, as well as to become accustomed to privileges. Both those bought buy the parents through their paid for education and the ones that come in life.

For example, look at Jacob Rees Mogg he "bought shares" when he was gifted £50 as a child, and attended AGMs and hectored directors about the size of the dividends paid. Now as shares cannot be owned directly by children he had no position to be at an AGM, however his father was the editor of the Times so he was indulged.

He went to Oxford, from Eton, and achieved a 2.2 History degree he went to be a banker in Hong Kong (again through father's contacts) and in the world of finance he didn't really set the world alight, his Lloyd George Emerging Markets fund under performed in comparison to other funds in the same market at the same time, suggesting poor stock selection. Yet he was later asked to become the chairman of a new company (fronting only a small amount of the cash himself). Mainly because he is a name and opens the doors to the right sort of contact, not because he is any good.

He isn't a great mind, but he has the confidence to say things and people take him seriously, even when he is wrong. He went on Marr last week saying that the UK wouldn't have to check EU imports at Calais, which is wrong and utterly against WTO rules (unless of course we give that to everyone), but still felt confident enough to do it.

It isn't extra curricular activities, it isn't the small class sizes, its being accustomed to privilege and to people deferring to you because of it.

Cblue · 17/06/2018 23:44

@Gentlygently will PM you tomorrow!

Lots of stuff we tried and in her case lots of stuff failed. All of it is worth a shot.

Funnily enough not the 'normal' solutions in her case which is why I think it's worth sharing!!!!