Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to pay tax as an "Accidental American."

234 replies

budinbloom · 08/06/2018 15:06

Help! Is anyone facing/has faced this recently?

DH is a dual UK/US national from birth. (English Dad, American Mum, born in the US but left for the UK as a baby and never lived or worked there since). He received what we now know is a "FATCA" letter recently and after copious googling and increasing panic, it looks like he is supposed to file tax returns to the US and potentially pay tax on the funds he holds in his ISA. Luckily, they aren't threatening to close his account....yet but the internet says that is what's happening in other countries!

We're still flapping but becoming resigned to the fact that, we have to pay to enter a foreign tax system in the first place before we can exit and renounce his US citizenship if we are to even plan for our future retirement. We're still at the going backwards & forwards stage - should we/shouldn't we? It's so unfair? What do we do? How would they know? We can't lie/nor do we want to? At the same time, we don't want to pay ANY tax to a foreign government on our already taxed UK income. He's always been PAYE here! Is the final solution renouncement but this process which will involve backfiling tax returns which we should never have to do, in the first place and will costs thousands (yes, we've got a few general quotes for the work).

We really want to keep hold of his stocks and shares ISA. Do we only really need to sell the funds in them but keep the actual direct company shares? No-one seems to admit to having anything other than cash ISAs but is that because they have already sold them in advance of filing for the first time? No idea what to do without paying even more for expensive legal/tax advice.

OP posts:
Lisette40 · 09/06/2018 14:57

If you renounced four years ago underfall did you only have to pay 650 dollars?! It really leapt up to over 2000 dollars.

underfall · 09/06/2018 14:53

To expound a bit on renouncing:

US citizens have a right of expatriation (renunciation). As long as you meet the requirements, you can renounce.

The requirements are stated in Sec. 349. [8 U.S.C. 1481]. Relevant bits:

"(a) A person who is a national of the United States whether by birth or naturalization, shall lose his nationality by voluntarily performing any of the following acts with the intention of relinquishing United States nationality-
[..]
(5) making a formal renunciation of nationality before a diplomatic or consular officer of the United States in a foreign state, in such form as may be prescribed by the Secretary of State; "

The Consular Office has a duty to consider whether the individual is acting voluntarily (i.e., not under duress). That's all. The Consular Officer will form his/her opinion based on the forms and documentation submitted by the individual. There will be no questions about IRS compliance.

The Consular Officer takes your money, administers the Oath and sends the forms and documentation to Washington, stating his/her opinion as to whether the loss of citizenship should be approved (i.e., the person is acting voluntarily). Eventually, a CLN arrives. Job done.

Consulates differ in the documentation they ask for, and in the time it takes to get an appointment. Check the website of the desired consulate/embassy for further information.

Once you've renounced, give your bank a copy of the CLN and sign their self-certification form (certifying that you are not a US citizen). That's all they want. They keep it on file, and it proves that the bank does not have to report your account to HMRC for forwarding to the IRS.

FATCA/IGA has been incorporated into UK law. That makes it a potential problem for anyone born in the US, because anyone born in the US is a potential risk to a bank. Advisable either to show them that you're not a USC, or to confirm that you are indeed a USC and sign the W-9 and give them your SSN.

US tax law has not been incorporated into UK law. Once you've renounced, if you have no US assets or income, you're no longer tax-resident in the US and can prove you're not tax-resident in the US, so FATCA/IGA is no longer a problem.

TalkinPeece · 09/06/2018 14:45

FATCA was a really stupid piece of legislation based on a false premise.
The IRS convinced themselves that all Americans overseas were millionaires with Swiss bank accounts

The truth is that lots are children and pensioners and housewives and low earners
and many of the high earners pay tax at higher rates than they would in the USA (ie they live in Europe)
so when they submit returns the IRS owes them money Wink

So, big surprise, the IRS is not pushing for all of us to submit returns
and why my family member - despite being a UK 40% taxpayer with expensive houses - was told
IN WRITING BY THE IRS to ignore FATCA Grin

So I have no guilt at all in ignoring it too Smile

Lisette40 · 09/06/2018 14:44

My husband had to indicate whether he was in good standing with the IRS before he could renounce. That's within the last two years.

underfall · 09/06/2018 12:01

"Ticking a box to say you’ve complied when you haven’t isn’t something we want to do."

He doesn't need to. He can just renounce.

It takes a while (couple of months?) for the CLN to arrive, but in the meantime he can show the bank his receipt (it states "Renunciation" on the receipt. Once the CLN arrives, his loss of citizenship is confirmed and backdated to the date he swore the oath.

Alternatively, if he opts to become compliant before renouncing, he could use free tax software to generate a "model" return - entering the numbers for, say, 2013, then using the model to help him fill in all five years (with correct numbers for each year obvs) and backfile together with payment. Then backfile six years of FBARs. Then renounce. Then next year (in 2019) he should file a dual-status return and Form 8854.

I believe stocks-and-shares ISAs get treated as PFICs which reportedly is a very very expensive and complicated subject (which I don't know about).

There's a very helpful blog run by a US tax expert called Phil Hodgen. Googling should bring it up. You'll probably find helpful (free) information about PFICs.

budinbloom · 09/06/2018 10:46

It’s just DH. He can’t pass on his US citizenship to our DC since he left as a baby and never lived there since, thank God. I’m a Brit with no other nationality. He has no dilemma with renouncing because it’s not useful apart from being in a shorter queue for holidays which we can gladly sacrifice! Basically, we’re too inclined to be law abiding to even consider renouncing as a “covered expatriate” I.e renounce without tax compliance. Ticking a box to say you’ve complied when you haven’t isn’t something we want to do. He/we are stuffed if we are inclined to be totally honest. It’s absolutely crap from all angles - we’re feeling boxed into a corner. He’s now considering a DIY approach!

OP posts:
underfall · 09/06/2018 09:57

"DH is a dual UK/US national from birth. (English Dad, American Mum, born in the US but left for the UK as a baby and never lived or worked there since)."

Similar to the situation of my children, yet my children will never get a FATCA letter because they were born in the UK. Not fair, is it? The FATCA legislation requires banks to search for "an unambiguous place of birth" and treat the accountholder as tax-resident in the US unless they can prove that they have renounced US citizenship.

"We can't lie/nor do we want to? "

I felt the same - not about to let the IRS force me to lie. It just depends how important your US citizenship is to you. You can renounce, without filing anything; or you can rearrange your savings to minimize US taxation, and just start filing, if you want to hang on to your citizenship.

Renouncing is expensive, especially if you're paying for your children as well as yourself. But it does solve the problem. Keeping the citizenship does not: US law is always changing, and many US expats who own shares in a foreign (e.g. UK) corporation are currently being hit with a demand for payment of a "transition tax" retroactive to 1986!

Good luck.

Tumilnaughts · 09/06/2018 09:01

I recently refinanced my house in the UK and as an American citizen they asked about the citizen for tax purposes thing. Turns out if you don't owe US taxes (which I don't - and I file every year), it's just a formality and they just tick a box. They seemed very laid back about the whole thing at the bank.
Filing every year is a nuisance but I always get it done (eventually). But I empathise with your frustration and hope it all works out for you.

MiniMaxi · 09/06/2018 08:24

Accidental American here too. You have to declare the content of your bank accounts under the FBAR and file a tax return.

Tax wise you are fine if you earn under the threshold (usually about $95k) but as PPs have said usually fine if you earn over the threshold as you can deduct taxes paid in the UK.

There's also an issue with selling property FYI, as in the UK you pay tax on purchase of your home (stamp duty) where in the US you pay capital gains on the sale. Dual nationals are potentially stuffed!

underfall · 09/06/2018 08:16

I renounced four years ago. It was expensive but very easy. I didn't file any tax returns. I received a Certificate of Lost Nationality which I have since used to open an account with no problems.

The European Parliament has recently done a study on the problems created for EU/US dual citizens by the FATCA legislation. You can download it from the EU Think Tank website. The title is "FATCA Legislation and its Application at International and EU Level"

Anyone born in the US has this problem because the US birthplace indicates US citizenship unless you can prove otherwise. Renunciation solves the problem.

If you don't want to renounce, the other solution is to move savings to the US. It's the tax-free savings such as ISA (stocks and shares) that incur US tax, usually, because the fact that they're free of UK tax allows the IRS to tax them without breaching the terms of the US-UK Double Taxation Treaty.

Lisette40 · 09/06/2018 06:39

clockwork you do get a certificate upon renouncing.

You also have to indicate on a form that you are tax compliant before you renounce. Whether the IRS would ever know if you tick yes when you're not compliant, I don't know.

Portland1812 · 09/06/2018 03:07

To Mrs. Pratchett. You can renounce without being tax compliant . They are not connected.

Portland1812 · 09/06/2018 02:06

Budinbloom. Please pay close attention.
Don’t do anything rash until you have done a lot more research. There are several million accidental Americans or dual citizens living outside the US who haven’t filed and do not need to file.
Once you enter the IRS system, it becomes a nightmare. Better to stay out.
If your bank doesn’t know he is US born, DONT tell them and carry on.
If they do, you could tell them he is renouncing US citizenship.

You will be told by others that you need to be tax compliant before renouncing but this is very simply not true. State department does not talk to IRS except to give them a list of those who have renounced.

So, Make an appointment at the nearest US consulate. Fill in the forms. Pay $2350. In due course he will receive a certificate of loss of nationality.
After that, do not file anything. There is nothing they can or will do. The IRS is broke, their computers are decades out of date and they cannot chase an unknown person in another country.
A good resource is the Isaac Brock Society. We have helped hundreds in your position. It’s a lot of reading on a rather haphazard forum but well worth it. Good luck.

calyppso · 08/06/2018 23:19

My husband and I are both UK born but lived in USA for number of years and have USA citizenship. As do our children who were born there. We've been back in UK for quite a few years and at first I filled tax returns with the IRS. Quite ironic as I don't do a UK tax return. We never owed the IRS
anything as our income comes within the foreign earned income exclusion. If it was above then we would do foreign tax paid credit, or whatever that's called. Anyway after a while I stopped bothering, and the IRS never contacted me. Then last year I got worried because of scare stories and also because we have some money in USA pensions which we will want to access at some point, and contacted various tax advisers who were going to charge me £££ to file. I thought screw that, why should I pay all that to tell the IRS I don't owe them anything? So I got an American friend to purchase Turbo tax for me which was about 80 dollars and did one year's return using that, then used it as a template to do four years' back returns. I also filed the FBARS on line, for the past however many years. The whole thing took me ages and ages, and made me weep endlessly, but I heard nothing from the IRS after I sent the returns off. I've just done this year's using my template from previous years which really was pretty straightforward. We have earned income, rental income, capital gains and ISAs. So my advice is use Turbo tax or similar, and always file paper returns, not online. I don't see why the IRS should drive me to give up my US citizenship!

ClockworkNightingale · 08/06/2018 23:08

Ah, bugger, I'd blissfully forgotten about all this. I'm going to have to renounce before I start earning next year, I'll never be able to afford private accountants to protect me from the wrath of Uncle Sam.

Has anyone else renounced recently? Do they give you some sort of certificate to prove to banks, etc, that you're not a citizen anymore?

TalkinPeece · 08/06/2018 23:01

Budin
I've had no problems with ISA and other savings since FATCA
(I was born in the USA and my Tax name is my US one so its really, really obvious)
I just give them all my UK UTR and if they say no I move on a provider who will say yes.

TalkinPeece · 08/06/2018 22:58

budin
Oh blimey, I come up against the impact of FATCA every month

  • I cannot open bank accounts
  • my IFA is very limited on which funds they can use
  • my employer has loads of extra forms for pensions
  • I am a company director
I am not in the least bit hidden - my name and address are all over the web because of my work and when the IRS come knocking I'll line the numbers up and ask for my taxes back Grin

dsc1907
Think priorities
what was in it for the organiser of that conference to say
"line up your ducks and do nothing"
no fees to be earned that way Wink Grin

In my own work I encourage 100% compliance - it pays my rent

when dealing with FATCA I play a different game as its my own money at stake

Grasslands · 08/06/2018 22:53

Born in the USA live in Canada for 45+ years. Will never claim any USA pension or social security benefits. Was told to ignor.
The only people I know who comply, have worked in the USA and plan to collect small pensions at some point.

budinbloom · 08/06/2018 22:51

TalkinPeace
Yes, we've read enough that the reporting requirements gathered by financial institutions is likely to land in the ether. So, the strategy of giving the least amount of data, if any data, would probably work for quite along time. It's a massive jump from never filing to having assessed tax debts to the IRS if you don't give any data. We do realise this (after watching the millions of Canadians openly rebelling on blogs/forums/the whole can of internet worms) which is why we are so indecisive.

But....you can't transfer an ISA (new accounts are being blocked as soon as you declare your place of birth - we tried that already!) I suspect that all applications for financial products will prove an obstacle as soon as you appear "American" (apparently, already happening in other countries). So potentially, new bank accounts, mortgages, insurance, pensions, etc. It's OK if you don't do anything to trigger a FATCA letter at the moment - basically, any action which requires you to reveal that you are an American citizen for tax purposes e.g US passport or in DH's case - his place of birth. They explicitly ask you the question so it's hard to avoid. I suspect that you can remain under the radar longer if you were born in the UK and lie but you can't with an obviously American city place of birth. So...it makes life difficult without renouncing because we need to wave around a certificate of nationality loss to protect & preserve his pension/retirement savings and I guess avoid any headaches for me & our DC in the future.

Just shouting & kicking as I go under....

OP posts:
marjorie25 · 08/06/2018 22:47

Not sure if you have answered:
But as an American you as the mother should be filing taxes as well.
So this not only applies to you son, but to you.
One way round this is to renounce your citizenship - you cannot have it both ways.

Dsc1907 · 08/06/2018 22:44

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

RyvitaBrevis · 08/06/2018 22:43

Sorry, OP, I got muddled on whether he was debating about whether to renounce. If your DH would be happy to never enter the US again, I wonder if they would really pursue it?

It's such an unfair and galling position you're in. It's worth drawing attention to this petition to the EU Parliament to block enforcement of FATCA:
american-accidental.com/en/support-the-petition-against-fatca-at-the-european-parliament/

@TalkinPeece Your views are intriguing and I would like to subscribe to your newsletter.

RyvitaBrevis · 08/06/2018 22:31

Ugh, I know you can't underestimate how punitive and unfair the US law code can be, but compliance is surely the better option, rationally speaking. The OP's DH would still have to file 5 years of compliant returns and pay some kind of exit tax to renounce his citizenship, right? Make sure you are getting good advice, and pay for it.

I thought the foreign currency gain on the mortgage is only taxed at teh point when the mortgaged is paid off or refinanced -- you don't need to pay on the gain or loss each year.

TalkinPeece · 08/06/2018 22:28

SO MUCH PARANOIA
sorry but I used "free fillable forms online"
for several years
the help sheets were great
I happen to be a CCAB accountant but a UK CIOT is a chocolate teapot for US law

the main thing is
keep good records, do not panic
in the case I have, the IRS backed away from FATCA the moment it cost them money
tee hee
nuff said

Dsc1907 · 08/06/2018 22:28

Honestly, from the experience I've had with FATCA I don't think trying to ignore it will end well. The best outcome you can work towards is to get to a position where you're compliant and can give up the citizenship to get out of the system.

I know it completely sucks. A lot of people were aghast that it catches people in your position in such a heavy handed way.

I'm sorry you're having to deal with this.