Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to pay tax as an "Accidental American."

234 replies

budinbloom · 08/06/2018 15:06

Help! Is anyone facing/has faced this recently?

DH is a dual UK/US national from birth. (English Dad, American Mum, born in the US but left for the UK as a baby and never lived or worked there since). He received what we now know is a "FATCA" letter recently and after copious googling and increasing panic, it looks like he is supposed to file tax returns to the US and potentially pay tax on the funds he holds in his ISA. Luckily, they aren't threatening to close his account....yet but the internet says that is what's happening in other countries!

We're still flapping but becoming resigned to the fact that, we have to pay to enter a foreign tax system in the first place before we can exit and renounce his US citizenship if we are to even plan for our future retirement. We're still at the going backwards & forwards stage - should we/shouldn't we? It's so unfair? What do we do? How would they know? We can't lie/nor do we want to? At the same time, we don't want to pay ANY tax to a foreign government on our already taxed UK income. He's always been PAYE here! Is the final solution renouncement but this process which will involve backfiling tax returns which we should never have to do, in the first place and will costs thousands (yes, we've got a few general quotes for the work).

We really want to keep hold of his stocks and shares ISA. Do we only really need to sell the funds in them but keep the actual direct company shares? No-one seems to admit to having anything other than cash ISAs but is that because they have already sold them in advance of filing for the first time? No idea what to do without paying even more for expensive legal/tax advice.

OP posts:
grc5060 · 12/06/2018 11:10

Suddenly the uncollectible penalties and taxes become, well, collectible unless (wildly inprobable) the Brit is also a citizen of, say, Denmark which doesn't make it easy to be a dual national after majority, Torben Dileng case procedurallytaxing.com/why-is-the-irs-collecting-taxes-for-denmark-2/ (I'm not going to go into details of how the result could have been avoided: suffice to say I try not to write stupid or unsupportable comments.)

underfall · 12/06/2018 11:09

"Whether the IRS would have any interest in an ordinary U.K. citizen earning below the double taxation limit, I have no idea, but in theory, you do need to notify the IRS."

Yes, the information is shared with the IRS: the DoS sends a copy of the CLN to the IRS. It's up to the renouncer (who is no longer a US citizen following renunciation) to consider whether their best course of action is to file or to let sleeping dogs lie. It depends on their individual circumstances. There is no risk in choosing not to file, for those with no US assets/income. Any assessed tax debts obviously should be settled.

grc5060 · 12/06/2018 11:07

In a case I am working on, siblings have very different status, leading to US citizenship for some children, alienage for others also born abroad. Although partly overtaken by Justice Ginsburg's decision in the Morales-Santana case (the 365-day uninterrupted presence of the mother of a nonmarital child is abolished in favour of a 5-year interruptible residence or status of dependent of USG employee or military abroad) Vice Consul Amelia Shaw's article shows how chance affects outcomes: www.afsa.org/citizenship-and-unwed-border-moms-misfortune-geography

athingthateveryoneneeds · 12/06/2018 11:00

I'm definitely leaning towards relinquishing citizenship.

Thanks for this thread, OP, because I really didn't know this information. (oh how I miss my happy bubble)

underfall · 12/06/2018 10:57

"The Dewees case is a signal warning."

The Dewees case is a sad example of what can happen if a USC is too quick to trust the advice of a tax professional. Dewees lived and worked in Canada for years, until FATCA came along and he sought advice from a US tax advisor, who told him his best course was to sign up for OVDP, a notorious IRS "programme" for people with reason to fear criminal charges.

Once he was in OVDP, his fate was sealed. When he found out how much he would be assessed for, he refused to pay. The IRS requested collection assistance as per the US-Canada treaty, and Canada withheld his refund until he paid, which eventually he did.

A very sad case, but not relevant for dual US/UK citizens or indeed for USCs resident in the UK regardless of whether they have UK citizenship.

"what of a British citizen who exercises right of free movement and goes to work in France or Denmark or Sweden, etc"

What of it?

WickedGoodDoge · 12/06/2018 10:51

Re the IRS, TBF, part of what I signed did tell me that I must contact the IRS (#10) and the form where I ticked the box to say whether or not I filed US taxes did say the information could be shared with the IRS.

Whether the IRS would have any interest in an ordinary U.K. citizen earning below the double taxation limit, I have no idea, but in theory, you do need to notify the IRS.

To not want to pay tax as an "Accidental American."
underfall · 12/06/2018 10:40

minipie, They don't ask any questions about your parents or siblings, but they do ask you to state how you acquired US citizenship.

For those born in the US, a US birth certificate and US passport is sufficient.

Those who were born elsewhere and got citizenship through a USC parent, do end up giving details of the parent's US citizenship. It doesn't have any consequences for siblings (i.e., they needn't fear that they'll be tracked down by the US). The US DoS doesn't try to find potential USCs.

grc5060 · 12/06/2018 10:02

@Portland1812 wrote "Once again and for the last time, you do not have to be compliant in order to renounce. For many renouncing and not filing anything is the best course of action."

Taxation is not interdependent on or with renunciation and hasn't been since Thomas Jefferson (long before income tax). In a brief statement of issues, it is best at least to guide someone to avoid being a "covered expatriate". You may think it doesn't matter but every so often it does. For most but far from all accidental Americans compliance outside the horrid IRS programmes is not difficult. Facts matter: are there assets, income, heirs in the USA? Social Security credits totalised or otherwise? Maybe Medicare eligibility, for what it's worth. Nationality of present or future children? To ignore FATCA and PFIC when place of birth (largely ignored up to now by UK but not other foreign financial services providers) could make one "poison": a CLN may help but the potential for worse to come from the IRS as to accidental Americans can't be discounted. The Dewees case is a signal warning: OK, he failed to get Canadian citizenship. But what of a British citizen who exercises right of free movement and goes to work in France or Denmark or Sweden, etc.? Here we had a query from someone who knew nothing. S/he is not going to get an education on Mumsnet, and compliance condors could ruin his and her lives. I made what points came to mind for what they are worth, and suggested reference to the Isaac Brock Society site. I think your criticism is unwarranted. My advice is free, and perhaps that's what it's worth. But it's better than some and comes with authority and qualifications that I won't mention because I don't take new clients.

Portland1812 · 12/06/2018 07:27

To answer your question. The IRS thinks they do. A great many others don’t agree.

underfall · 12/06/2018 07:27

"This is very confusing. If a US-born citizen has lived in the UK for most of his/her life, and is also a UK citizen with an NI number, bank account, etc... does the US still have jurisdiction over that person's income tax?"

A dual citizen has rights and obligations from both citizenships. The US deems US citizens to be "tax-resident" in the US (in the District of Columbia, I believe) regardless of where they actually live.

HMRC has primary taxing rights on UK-source income, regardless of whether the taxpayer is a UKC, a USC, or both.; the US has primary taxing rights on US-source income.

Under a recent-ish US-UK agreement, and now implemented in UK law, UK banks and financial service providers must identify and report to HMRC all accounts held by USCs; HMRC forwards the information to the IRS. Because of this law, USCs with US birthplaces are likely to receive letters from their UK banks, asking them to provide SSN and sign a US form W-9 to confirm that they are a US citizen.

You can choose to sign the form and give them your SSN, or you may prefer to renounce your US citizenship. Renouncing is easy but costs $2350. Email a US consulate, ask for an appointment, they'll send you instructions. You don't have to file any tax returns in order to renounce. It's a completely separate.

That's all. It's your decision what you do about filing US tax returns and paying US tax on top of paying UK tax on your UK-source income. The UK does not enforce or collect US taxation of UK-source income received by UK residents, and the US has little power to do so.

"I've just been informed by a tax professional that 5 years of compliance is necessary before renunciation is possible."

That's not correct. You lose your citizenship the day you swear the Oath, regardless of whether you've been filing US tax returns. The loss is confirmed when you eventually receive the Certificate of Loss of Citizenship; you can show the CLN to your bank to prove you're not a USC.

What you choose to do about your US tax obligation is a separate matter. If you have US income/assets, or you frequently need/want to travel to or over the US, you may want to jump through the hoops and enter the system and backfile the five years and file final forms. Everyone's circumstances are different. Everyone must consider the options and decide what they need to do. If you do decide to file, you could have a go at D-I-Y before paying for help.

Portland1812 · 12/06/2018 07:25

Beware of that tax professional. He or she doesn’t know what he’s talking about. Perhaps trying to separate you from some of your hard earned money.
Renunciation is absolutely not dependent on tax compliance. My spouse has been there done that.

athingthateveryoneneeds · 12/06/2018 06:24

This is very confusing. If a US-born citizen has lived in the UK for most of his/her life, and is also a UK citizen with an NI number, bank account, etc... does the US still have jurisdiction over that person's income tax?

I've just been informed by a tax professional that 5 years of compliance is necessary before renunciation is possible.

languagebridget · 11/06/2018 22:44

if you are a US citizen and you own more than 10% of a UK limited company which is at least 50%owned or more by US citizens you will have bigger US tax headache. Since Trump signed into law last november the Tax cuts and jobs act, businesses owned by US citizens overseas are taxed at upto 17.45% on the retained earnings of the business. So even though we pay all our UK taxes we are now taxed by uncle Sam personally on the money our UK business has in its account. I have been compliant for years as I could file my own US tax returns and never owed money but that has all changed now. And it will continue next year with the introduction of GILTI, a tax on the UK profits of our company that will have to be paid through our personal return.

Slightlyperturbedowlagain · 11/06/2018 22:39

wow, that is really cheeky of them, to charge americans who live abroad tax!!
Not only them but their spouses too, even if they are not US citizens, never lived in the US and have no intention of ever doing so. One of my sisters was furious when she discovered her income had to be declared on her DH’s tax return despite all the above. Her DH left the US at the age of 19 as well, and they live in Europe on my Dsis’ UK/EU entitlement with their DC, but as his parents are getting elderly he feels he needs to hang on to his US citizenship. (In fact after Brexit the US could end up being the only place they could all legally live together as DSis is effectively a trailing spouse and it would take a while for her to be able to earn enough to bring him into the U.K despite being married for 18 years. Its so complicated)

underfall · 11/06/2018 22:31

Definitely no questions about parents or siblings.

I wouldn't call it an interview. They check the forms you supply, ask you to confirm that you understand it's irreversible, that kind of thing. They may ask why you're renouncing. A brief simple answer is enough (e.g., I want to simplify my life, or, I don't need two citizenships.

No need to be apprehensive. Renouncing is a perfectly reasonable choice and it's your right. I found the consular staff professional and helpful.

minipie · 11/06/2018 22:27

Thank you!

WickedGoodDoge · 11/06/2018 22:25

When I renounced, I had a perfectly pleasant chat with the Consul General (Edinburgh) before saying the oath. I did mention my children and how they were wanting to emigrate to the US someday, but I volunteered this and she didn’t take notes or anything. Grin

The chat was really just for her to ascertain that I wasn’t renouncing under duress.

minipie · 11/06/2018 22:18

Thank you. So no questions about parents and siblings? And is there an interview (I think I read that somewhere)?

underfall · 11/06/2018 21:54

minipie - There's a form DS-4079 which is not required for renouncing but the London Embassy does ask renouncers to complete it. It asks very intrusive questions, including whether you've ever registered a child as a US citizen born abroad. Not all consulates ask for it. Check the consulate web sites for information.

Apart from that, no questions are asked about family members.

minipie · 11/06/2018 21:34

Does anyone know if the renunciation process is likely to include any questions about family members (ie whether family members are also citizens)?

underfall · 11/06/2018 19:22

"The UK-US tax treaty doesn't have a collection agreement. But any US resident here should get UK citizenship ASAP."

Unfortunately, UK citizenship can be a lengthy and very expensive process nowadays. Fortunately, UK legal residents don't have to worry about HMRC demanding payment of US taxes - regardless of citizenship status.

underfall · 11/06/2018 18:51

grc5060:

"Renunciation ($2,350) means having to be compliant for 5 tax years."

This is incorrect. A USC can renounce US citizenship by making an appointment with a US consulate/embassy, supplying the required documentation, attending the appointment, paying $2350, and swearing the Oath. Then wait for the Certificate of Lost Citizenship to arrive, and use it to prove non-USness to banks and financial service providers. Expensive, but very easy; and it solves the problem.

Portland1812 · 11/06/2018 18:29

grc5060. Once again and for the last time, you do not have to be compliant in order to renounce. For many renouncing and not filing anything is the best course of action.

grc5060 · 11/06/2018 17:32

The answers to all the questions about renunciation, and many of the tax questions are on the Isaac Brock Society web site out of Canada. Easily found with a search engine. The comments there are serious and many of the forum members are highly qualified.

While the IRS hates "quiet disclosure" (filing back returns, etc.) they can't send in the Marines. Noncompliant and accidental Americans might want to avoid travel to the USA until the statue of limitations runs out. (It is tolled extended as to "absconders" but someone who has lived all her life abroad is hardly an absconder.

The issue of FATCA and the Inter-Governmental Agreements is that enforcement of US tax law has been delegated to banks and financial services providers. There is a "presumption of alienage" for persons born outside the USA, and those without a SS number really don't have to do anything. But with a passport showing a US place of birth there are problems.

Another point: any US Person (citizen, green-card holder, etc.) who has 10% of shares in a foreign company needs to file Form 5471 every year: $10,000 per year penalty for not having filed it: it gets filed with your 1040. The worst that could happen happened to a guy called DeWees (he was levied a $100,000+ fine which Canada Revenue Agency collected from him because he wasn't a Canadian citizen.

The UK-US tax treaty doesn't have a collection agreement. But any US resident here should get UK citizenship ASAP.

grc5060 · 11/06/2018 17:21

I seem to have mis-read this, largely because this is Mumsnet. The case seems not to relate to a (possibly non-US) baby with a JISA but an American adult with an ISA. In that case there is an FBAR, maybe an 8938 and certainly a PFIC problem. You could use the Streamlined IRS program to "come clean" but since you live abroad the IRS can do nothing. There is a 6-year statute of limitations on FBAR penalties. You could change your investment from a fund to specific stocks and shares. You could start filing FBARs. Or you could do nothing. Indeed, of the Amcit DH has no Social Security number doing nothing brings the only risk that a bank or financial services provider might assume he is a US citizen, as he is. Renunciation ($2,350) means having to be compliant for 5 tax years. I would avoid joint accounts. SIPPs and other pensions are outside the scope of US taxation (Tax Treaty art. 18). And you have until 30 June to file a 2017 FBAR if you choose to do so.