Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to pay tax as an "Accidental American."

234 replies

budinbloom · 08/06/2018 15:06

Help! Is anyone facing/has faced this recently?

DH is a dual UK/US national from birth. (English Dad, American Mum, born in the US but left for the UK as a baby and never lived or worked there since). He received what we now know is a "FATCA" letter recently and after copious googling and increasing panic, it looks like he is supposed to file tax returns to the US and potentially pay tax on the funds he holds in his ISA. Luckily, they aren't threatening to close his account....yet but the internet says that is what's happening in other countries!

We're still flapping but becoming resigned to the fact that, we have to pay to enter a foreign tax system in the first place before we can exit and renounce his US citizenship if we are to even plan for our future retirement. We're still at the going backwards & forwards stage - should we/shouldn't we? It's so unfair? What do we do? How would they know? We can't lie/nor do we want to? At the same time, we don't want to pay ANY tax to a foreign government on our already taxed UK income. He's always been PAYE here! Is the final solution renouncement but this process which will involve backfiling tax returns which we should never have to do, in the first place and will costs thousands (yes, we've got a few general quotes for the work).

We really want to keep hold of his stocks and shares ISA. Do we only really need to sell the funds in them but keep the actual direct company shares? No-one seems to admit to having anything other than cash ISAs but is that because they have already sold them in advance of filing for the first time? No idea what to do without paying even more for expensive legal/tax advice.

OP posts:
YankeeDad · 07/10/2018 18:48

Underfall is asking good questions. The right course of action for any individual depends their risk tolerance, versus their willingness & ability to pay the administrative costs of getting everything sorted.

For a person who would not owe any US tax even if they filed everything correctly, I think the main risk relates to access to banking and other financial services outside of USA. US pressured the banks worldwide to help them identify and tax US citizens, and some banks are more diligent than others at doing that. The worst situation is with non-US banks who don't have their s* together and panic if they find out someone is a US citizen. I have heard about rare cases of accounts being frozen.
One practical problem with renouncing citizenship without sorting out the tax side of it (per Underfall's suggestion to ring the embassy) is that some banks will, in certain instances, demand proof of compliance with US tax law (for instance copies of filed Forms 1040), and in the absence of such proof, they may freeze accounts or kick out clients. I don't want to sound alarmist - this may be exceedingly rare - but it's not a zero-risk proposition to approach it this way.

Regarding who is or is not a US citizen, any person born in USA clearly is a US citizen (unless they have renounced US nationality), whether or not they have an SSN, were registered, or anything else. This is likely to turn up in banks' records at some point since they ask "where were you born", and many official documents include that information.

A person born to one US parent may or may not be a US citizen. There are different rules depending when they were born, how long the parent spent in USA at different ages, etc. I don't personally know the detailed rules, but they can probably be found online. American Citizens Abroad (www.aca.ch) may also be able to help with this.

underfall · 07/10/2018 18:01

Are you sure you're a US citizen? Were you registered as a US citizen when you were born, and/or have you had a US passport or SS number?

If not, you do have the option of simply never claiming the citizenship.

If you do need to renounce, you can do it very easily. There is no need to enter the US tax system in order to renounce. You can ring the Embassy (or email) and ask for an appointment to renounce. They'll tell you about the procedure. It costs $2350.

Pip14 · 06/10/2018 16:13

Hi,
I think I need to go through this us tax compliance and renunciation. I am looking for a recommended us tax accountant who won't charge the earth. So if you would tell me who you used that would be great. I'm London based, born here, lived here all my life, but my mother is American. Just bad luck.
Thank you, pippa

underfall · 29/09/2018 14:08

Here's a link to the information about the US-UK Totalisation Agreement, in case it may be useful to anyone reading:

www.ssa.gov/international/Agreement_Pamphlets/uk.html

underfall · 29/09/2018 14:03

Actually, I didn't even know I was entitled to SS until I learned about citizenship-based taxation and started looking into the renunciation process in order to keep my banks happy.

I only worked in the US for a few years, long ago. Not enough for a pension. But I learned that a Social Security treaty had been signed which meant that I was entitled to claim a (small!) SS pension by combining years worked in the US with a few of the many many years worked in the UK. So that's what the FBU helped me claim. I could have been claiming it for years, if I had known I was entitled! They did backdate it - three months, I think.

Paid for my renunciation! Smile

Troels · 29/09/2018 13:49

Thats lovvely to hear underfall We have just over 5 years left to collect early at 62 or is it 62.5 years old.
How far in advance did you apply.

underfall · 29/09/2018 13:28

For what it's worth, I never filed US tax returns while I was a US citizen, never having been aware that it was required. There has been no difficulty with my SS pension. I applied for it with the assistance of the Federal Benefit Unit at the London Embassy, at the same time I was in the process of renouncing US citizenship. The FBU saw the SS application through and then after the renunciation had been approved the FBU helped me notify the change of citizenship to the SSA.

The SS pension is taxable by the UK only, under the US/UK treaty. It gets paid into my bank account in sterling, with no US tax withheld, and I file a self-assessment return with HMRC each year in order to pay the UK tax due. Easy peasy, and entirely in accordance with the laws of both countries.

Troels · 29/09/2018 12:44

I file our federal taxes with Tax Act, you fill it all in online and print it off and mail it in. I also pay for their cover annually so if anything goes pear shaped with our return they will sort and represent us. We don't earn enough to pay taxes to both countries. But want no bother when we come to collect our US SS pensions.
I got the link for Tax act from the Embassy website in the section for the IRS. (or Social security I forget which)

underfall · 29/09/2018 11:57

If you're opting to keep the citizenship and file US tax returns, you may be able to do the returns yourself if your affairs are straightforward (e.g. no stocks-and-shares ISAs)

There is free software you can use to put in your numbers and generate a dummy return, which you can then use as a model. There's a (commercial but quite helpful) website where you can ask questions at www.expatforum.com/expats/expat-tax/

Alfiejessie · 15/09/2018 13:14

Hello

Can anyone recommend a specialist account. Reasonably priced. It's such an unfair system for us accidental Americans. TIA

underfall · 12/06/2018 12:41

^"If someone goes down the route of renouncing but not backfiling, and the IRS later catches up with them somehow, what are the penalties?"

The IRS can't "catch up with them" if they haven't filed because the IRS doesn't know whether they had any obligation to file or would have owed US taxes. Very likely the renouncer doesn't know this either. The IRS would have to prove in court that the renouncer owes taxes from before s/he renounced, yet they don't know whether that's so. And the IRS knows that they wouldn't be able to collect anything (assuming no US income/assets). (This is mutual, by the way: the two countries do not want to have to collect each other's taxes, so they don't agree to do so.)

Once you renounce you're no longer subject to US tax law.

USCs don't need to feel like criminals for choosing to end their citizenship because they've concluded that the obligations outweigh the benefits. It's a rational decision and it's your right. The taxation obligation ends with the other obligations (such as registering for military service, if that's still required of citizens) and the benefits (such as the right to enter the US).

You can see that that's true by considering the fact that as soon as you show your CLN to your bank, your account is no longer reportable. You're no longer "tax-resident" in the US. Time to celebrate! Smile

grc5060 · 12/06/2018 12:13

Should read 3520-A. Sorry, fat fingers.

grc5060 · 12/06/2018 12:12

The typical issue is when a former citizen inherits, or a covered expatriate dies with US Person heirs. Form 3520 could reveal the facts. Given that most people in Britain die in debt, some may ignore that issue. Besides, a British-born person, British citizen at birth, probably is exempt from covered status even if s/he has a valuable London property. But 8854 has to be filed, and 5 years of 1040s, 5471s, 3510-As and the rest -- if the renunciant had income above the filing threshold.

Of course people maybe most people manage to stay below the radar. And for some things (FBARs, keeping records) there is a statute of limitations. But if one doesn't file a complete return then there is no SOL on that, only on the FBAR which is not a tax law. Robert W. Wood in Forbes and Jack Townsend on his Federal Tax Crimes Blog have lots of hints.

grc5060 · 12/06/2018 12:06

@underfall wrote "'Suddenly the uncollectible penalties and taxes become, well, collectible'

"Not true. The US-UK treaty doesn't include a "Mutually Collection" article."

You missed, or perhaps I misstated, the qualification: that the British citizen moved to France, Netherlands, Sweden, Canada or Denmark which do have mutual collection provisions and unless the CJEU says otherwise (it's never been asked the question) that other country will collect against its noncitizen resident. I gave you the cite for the Danish citizen in the USA, as a parallel if nonexact example.

WickedGoodDoge · 12/06/2018 11:58

I should add that despite renouncing several years ago, I did live here for over 20 years, managing to stay out of the US system. My U.K. passport doesn’t say that I was born in the US so I just used it as ID for years and years. Unfortunately, due to personal circumstances, I found myself abruptly back in the IRS system some years back and at that point it made sense for me to file my five years worth and get out.

minipie · 12/06/2018 11:56

Thank you underfall, very helpful.

If someone goes down the route of renouncing but not backfiling, and the IRS later catches up with them somehow, what are the penalties?

I understand that the "dual at birth" exemption will be lost and the person will be a covered expat and so liable to Exit Tax if they have made sufficient gains. Will the gains still be measured as at the point of renunciation, or is it measured at a later date if you are discovered later? Are there fines?

Thank you

DGRossetti · 12/06/2018 11:38

I wonder if we could set the IRS and Home Office up on a date. They'd get on like a house on fire ....

underfall · 12/06/2018 11:36

"The US-UK treaty doesn't include a "Mutually Collection" article."

Opps. "Mutual Collection", I should have said.

underfall · 12/06/2018 11:29

"If you don't file Form 8854 etc you become a covered expat "

In your head, maybe. In the real world, nothing happens.

Uyulala · 12/06/2018 11:28

Boris Johnson was born in the USA - he is in no way an "accidental yank"

I would consider myself an accidental American if I were born in USA but grew up in Britain with a British sense of identity.

underfall · 12/06/2018 11:25

"Suddenly the uncollectible penalties and taxes become, well, collectible"

Not true. The US-UK treaty doesn't include a "Mutually Collection" article.

Uyulala · 12/06/2018 11:25

So you have to pay tax if you are a dual citizen even if you don't live in the country? Confused how fucked up.

underfall · 12/06/2018 11:22

"In a case I am working on, siblings have very different status, leading to US citizenship for some children, alienage for others also born abroad."

Working on? Are you a tax adviser?

Yes, some children may inherit US citizenship and some not. None need fear being hunted down by the US trying to make them pay taxes. Banks do indeed send out FATCA letters to those born in the US; all they want is the USC's SSN and a signed W-9. The USC is not obliged to provide them; the account is subject to being reported, either way.

grc5060 · 12/06/2018 11:20

Put it this way: I am working on the case of a single mum, she and child born in Britain, she is renouncing because he has a disability trust and the IRS is treating it as practically criminal, not acknowledging that the child is not and cannot be a US Person. That is the sort of IRS evil we come up against. And the mum earns minimum wage for 20 hours a week and depends on free housing (from family) and disability benefits for the child. I can only imagine what it would be for her if the family didn't or couldn't afford to, support her. Does the IRS want to consider the mum, or the family, "owner" of the trust? They won't say: they only threaten $10,000 or 35% fines for "improperly" filling out form 3520-A on which is written across the top: "There is NO US Owner of this trust: the disabled beneficiary is NOT a US person". Can IRS Ogden read? Or is it willfully negligent? Using their own terms.

grc5060 · 12/06/2018 11:14

If you don't file Form 8854 etc you become a covered expat even if otherwise you are exempt (born in Britain, British from birth, living here all your life (but hey, what if you were born in N.I. and are Irish from birth but (maybe) not also British: Chen/Zhu case of CJEU)?) The sad thing is (except for me, I don't accept money anymore, but also don't solicit clients or make it easy for them to find me) proper advice is costly, and much of the advice is incompetent and wrong.

Swipe left for the next trending thread