Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to pay tax as an "Accidental American."

234 replies

budinbloom · 08/06/2018 15:06

Help! Is anyone facing/has faced this recently?

DH is a dual UK/US national from birth. (English Dad, American Mum, born in the US but left for the UK as a baby and never lived or worked there since). He received what we now know is a "FATCA" letter recently and after copious googling and increasing panic, it looks like he is supposed to file tax returns to the US and potentially pay tax on the funds he holds in his ISA. Luckily, they aren't threatening to close his account....yet but the internet says that is what's happening in other countries!

We're still flapping but becoming resigned to the fact that, we have to pay to enter a foreign tax system in the first place before we can exit and renounce his US citizenship if we are to even plan for our future retirement. We're still at the going backwards & forwards stage - should we/shouldn't we? It's so unfair? What do we do? How would they know? We can't lie/nor do we want to? At the same time, we don't want to pay ANY tax to a foreign government on our already taxed UK income. He's always been PAYE here! Is the final solution renouncement but this process which will involve backfiling tax returns which we should never have to do, in the first place and will costs thousands (yes, we've got a few general quotes for the work).

We really want to keep hold of his stocks and shares ISA. Do we only really need to sell the funds in them but keep the actual direct company shares? No-one seems to admit to having anything other than cash ISAs but is that because they have already sold them in advance of filing for the first time? No idea what to do without paying even more for expensive legal/tax advice.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SunSparkle · 20/07/2022 08:42

I contributed to this thread awhile ago and I still haven't renounced. I'm just filing my tax returns and FBAR each year and paying $10 or so on a measly amount of ISA interest but I don't have particularly complicated income. I just know I need to sort it before I sell a house in the UK as I understand that may have tax implications.

The most annoying thing is that I can't open a pension/stocks and shares account that I want to because the UK institution won't take me as a dual national. I just can't justify paying $2350 just to renounce at the moment. I was hoping the Biden administration might address this but I guess they are busy with lots of other things. $2350 is a huge amount of money for us as a family with a toddler having just been on maternity leave so I think I'm stuck paying an accountant $300 a year to do my tax return until I can afford the renunciation fee.

sorafon · 04/07/2022 16:43

Read what I wrote to the OP. You need not pay money to an expensive accountant or lawyer. If you have no assets, income or heirs in the USA it doesn't matter that you would be a "covered expat" if you didn't file 5 years back tax returns, use the (penalty-free) Streamlined IRS system, and file IRS form 8854. Nobody can do anything to you. If you do want advice you could do worse than ask John Richardson. I understand he charges $500 for basic advice. He wouldn't charge anything just to chat for 5 minutes. He can be found online; he lives in Toronto (he's a Canadian-American lawyer). Check on Facebook and Twitter -- there's lots being said on the subject of FATCA and renunciation.

sorafon · 04/07/2022 16:38

I am amazed that there are so many replies to a serious query that is so beyond the scope of Mumsnet. And unsurprised that most (perhaps all, I haven't read most of them) are not of great quality. Suffice to say I know something about the substance of "accidental Americans". You will find that there are groups of activists on Twitter and on Facebook. And that there are dozens, maybe many dozens, of accountants and lawyers eager, as the "compliance condors" they are, to take your money. There are two good American lawyers who specialise in renunciation and associated tax issues: John Richardson (search for him by name, as Toronto lawyer (he's a dual national)) and Phil Hodgen. John is the more reasonably priced -- far more reasonably than any of the dozens whose work I have had reason to judge. I am a retired tax and bankruptcy lawyer.

The first and most important advice is not to panic. Nothing is going to happen to you. If you have no assets, income or heirs in the USA the IRS is not going to pursue you. The issue you face (as you noted) is the possibility that a UK financial institution may refuse to do business with you until and unless you get a Social Security number (or ITIN, but you can't have an ITIN b/c you're a US citizen). Your assets cannot be seized for payment of U.S. taxes. Unfortunately a U.K. accountant or lawyer is stuck with a rather unfortunate U.K. "ethics" rule that requires him/her to insist you pay all your taxes, domestic and foreign. That's why I discourage you from contacting any UK-based professional, who anyway would have to charge you 20% VAT.

You can, as one of my (many) daughters did, renounce U.S. citizenship on your own. You have to download some forms from the U.S. Embassy's consular Web site and you have to make an appointment, answer some questions, pay $2,350 by credit card, and swear an oath. A few weeks later you get a Certificate of Loss of Nationality and your name will (probably) be published in the Federal Register.

A "compliance condor" would tell you that you must get a SSN, fill out 5 years' back tax returns and another one for the current year, complete IRS form 8854, and pay any back tax due. You also will be told you have to fill out FBAR forms (that is done online, Google "FBAR"). If you fail to do so, you become a "covered expat". The significance of that is that any American citizen or resident who inherits from you will have to pay 40% tax. You could also owe capital gains tax on the deemed value of all your assets and pensions except State Pension. If you do file form 8854 (which means you also need a SSN and would probably want to use the IRS Streamlined practice which is usually penalty-free (Google: site:irs.gov streamlined -- and watch out for private companies and shyster lawyers who want to frighten you and get big fees).

A lot depends on your age and your future intentions. It's unlikely you have minor children for whom you want green cards because they are not US citizens from birth (because, like my daughter, you never lived in the USA). The cynical but practical decision might be just to renounce for $2,350 and do nothing else. Once you have a CLN your bank will no longer want IRS form W-9 but maybe will want form W-8BEN, which is used by non-US and ex-US citizens.

If you have questions I'll be glad to answer either here on on FB (as Sora Fon). I am not your lawyer, I do not take clients, I cannot be paid.

One last reference: Google "FATCA Globalex" for a long and scary article on the penalties asserted against Americans who were actually guilty of hiding money abroad and not declaring it or paying tax on the dividends, interest and gains. That doesn't apply to you: you were not wilful, you are innocent, you knew nothing.

Best of luck.

BritWifeInUSA · 04/07/2022 13:59

microbean · 04/07/2022 13:53

My DH is also struggling to open bank accounts. Are you saying that when you renounce your US citizenship you do not have to file a tax return at all? Do you think that may have changed in the last few years?

this is a very old thread and the original poster may not be around any more. But that is correct. If you renounce your US citizenship you no longer have to file annual tax returns with the IRS. Unless you move back to the US, of course.

microbean · 04/07/2022 13:53

My DH is also struggling to open bank accounts. Are you saying that when you renounce your US citizenship you do not have to file a tax return at all? Do you think that may have changed in the last few years?

underfall · 24/02/2020 17:21

HomeOrAway - Congratulations on your brand-new single citizenship. If you don’t have any US income/assets, and are being taxed by HMRC, you shouldn’t owe any US tax, and can truthfully file Form 8854 to certify that you have been compliant with US tax law. That’s what I did, and the US was perfectly happy about it. To illustrate, here is my story:

I was born in the US, and lived there until I was 25. In 1965 I moved to the UK. From then on, all my income was UK income, fully taxed by the UK, so I never had income that would have been taxable by the US, and I never filed a US tax return after I left America.

For years I was a dual citizen. But I renounced my US citizenship in 2015, because FATCA was making it difficult for me to open bank accounts. The following year, I filed Form 8854 to tell the IRS that I was no longer a US. citizen. That’s all I had to do.

Serendipitously, while I was in the process of renouncing, I discovered that I was eligible for a (small) US Social Security pension, because of time I worked before I left. The Social Security branch in the London Embassy handled my application, and helped me get my social security record amended to show that I was no longer a US citizen. Nowadays I receive a small monthly payment every month - taxable only by HMRC. I mention this to show that the US government had no problem with my renunciation or with my 8854.

So you may want to consider just filing the 8854 and leaving it at that.

However, if you do opt to file US tax returns, I believe there’s a list of UK-located tax advisers somewhere on the US Embassy site. Good luck.

HomeOrAway60Plus · 14/01/2020 14:55

Right now I’m sitting in a cafe next to the US Embassy in London, having just renounced. I now have to wait and see how much I owe the US Government in taxes, despite leaving the country at the age of one, 60 years ago. The whole thing is unbelievably stressful and seems so unfair.

I’ve had contact with a tax advisor in the US via an online forum, but I’m nervous about doing anything with someone so remote.

Does anyone have any recommendations for people in the UK? I’m in Norfolk, but will travel within reason.

TFELUS · 11/06/2019 22:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

underfall · 15/11/2018 11:39

Link to the information on INA Sec. 349:

www.uscis.gov/ilink/docView/SLB/HTML/SLB/0-0-0-1/0-0-0-29/0-0-0-10446.html

underfall · 15/11/2018 11:35

Pip14 - you lose your US citizenship as soon as you swear the oath. The documentation of the loss (the Certificate of Loss of Nationality) is sent to you separately.

During the period when you're no longer a US citizen but don't yet have the CLN, some things, such as visiting the US, can present problems, because although you no longer have a US citizen's right of entry, your loss of citizenship has not yet been entered into the US system, so you are still not eligible to obtain a visa or visa-waiver (ESTA). So it's best to postpone visiting the US until you have the CLN and can use ESTA. If it's necessary to visit the US during the limbo period, you can ask the consular officer how to proceed.

That's it. Renouncing US citizenship, in accordance with US law, is your right. It's not conditional on filing US tax forms. (Google "UCSIS" and "Sec. 349" to see the statute)

Once you lose citizenship by swearing the oath, you're no longer a citizen, and from that moment you're no longer required to report your worldwide income to the IRS. However, loss of citizenship doesn't cancel out pre-existing liabilities. If you need or want to file a return for the final part year in which you were a citizen (e.g. if you owe tax or want to claim a refund, or just because you want to tidy things up), you can do so by filing a 1040NR as a "Non-Resident Alien", attaching an unsigned 1040 to report the necessary information for the "1040" portion of the year (when you were still taxable on your worldwide income) and supplying any information you need to report for the rest of the year (i.e. US-source US-taxable income that you may need or wish to report) on the 1040NR. (It's complicated and confusing, so read all the instructions very carefully.)

You can also file Form 8854 if you wish, during the year following renunciation, in order to confirm to the IRS that you're no longer a US citizen and provide information on your worldwide assets and agree to pretend you sold all your worldly goods (including your UK home if owned) the day before you renounced and therefore "owe" the IRS a share of the imaginary proceeds from the imaginary sale if the imaginary proceeds totalled more than a certain amount.

It's up to you; but the filing or non-filing of Form 8854 does not have any bearing whatsoever on the validity of your renunciation.

Pip14 · 15/11/2018 09:41

Underfall - you say 'the idea that you have to file tax forms to renounce is a fallacy'.

My understanding is that although someone can renounce US citizenship by paying the fee and doing the required forms, as you say, the renounciation isn't complete until you are also tax-compliant.

So you are still considered a taxable US citizen.

Am I mistaken about this?

underfall · 11/11/2018 16:08

"This has nothing to do with Trump, it's always been the case, although as the thread shows, little known and does feel very unfair."

Correct, all US citizens are deemed forever tax-resident in the US; but the US never bothered to mention this to said citizens until the mid1980s, when a tiny note about tax was added to the US passport.

It's very unfair, indeed, but fortunately cannot be enforced extra-territorially. It's one of the obligations of US citizenship: if you don't want the citizenship, renounce and all's well.

$2350: definitely worth the fee if you want it and can pay. The idea that you have to file tax forms in order to renounce is simply a fallacy.

"The US forms wanted seemingly random and impossible to find information about the cost of the land upon which our first house was sited, which we had bought 20 years previously and since sold. Super complex and definitely one for the experts."

US citizenship-based taxation is indeed extremely valuable to tax advisers. Smile

Walkingdeadfangirl · 11/11/2018 16:06

Trump is going to help with this if he is able to end birthright citizenship, probably wont be retrospective though.

Almondio · 11/11/2018 15:35

This has nothing to do with Trump, it's always been the case, although as the thread shows, little known and does feel very unfair.
We lived the the US for a few years and had to file returns in both the US and UK which was very complex and time-consuming, but thankfully had an equalised tax arrangement so we didn't pay tax twice. We did have to continue filing returns for years after our return to the UK.

The US forms wanted seemingly random and impossible to find information about the cost of the land upon which our first house was sited, which we had bought 20 years previously and since sold. Super complex and definitely one for the experts.

Yura · 11/11/2018 15:29

It is common knowledge that all US Americans have to pay us tax. Ignoring this was not a good idea - get legal advice!

underfall · 11/11/2018 15:22

MindDisco:

  1. Renunciation: you can go to the London Embassy site and have a look at the list of required forms, and download them to see what you think of them. Then, if need be, look elsewhere (Paris, Amsterdam, Iceland etc), and decide whether you need to go out of country to renounce.
  1. You can backfile previous years of returns and FBARs, if you decide you wish to become compliant after renouncing. There's no need to go through the so-called "amnesty" streamlined procedures.

FBARs are easy to do for yourself (but don't, until/unless you've definitely decided you want to become compliant).

As for the returns, a fairly easy way to do it would be to download the 1040 form and read the instructions to see if you can figure out for yourself where your income should go. Or use one of the free or cheap tax software packages (TaxAct or similar) to generate a return for 2017, and use that as a model for previous years. That's all a tax adviser will do for you - ask you for your income information, put it into a tax software programme, and charge you a lot of money for doing it.

Or you could just do as your mother does and assume you're under the income requirements.

  1. You can renounce with an expired US passport, but you then must wait until the CLN is in the system before you can obtain ESTA clearance in order to be allowed to board a plane to fly to the US. Don't book tickets until you have the CLN.
MindDisco · 06/11/2018 21:48

Hi,

I'm a dual national (mother American) but I was born and have lived in the UK my entire life.

I have never filed a tax return to the IRS. I have an ISA and a LISA where I declared my dual national status - they are both cash ISAs.

I own no property, and don't have complicated financial affairs, but I'm looking to a) buy a house, and b) overpay into my pension in the next few years which will complicate matters. I also have over $10k in my LISA as it is my house deposit.

I spoke with a tax account at www.expattaxprofessionals.com/ today and they advised becoming compliant under the tax amnesty as a non-wilful delinquent. This is 3 years tax returns, and 6 years FBARs, and a legal professional to guide and review the non-wilful disclosure statement.

The cost for this would be $1800 - is this about right?

Then he said to renounce my citizenship I would need 5 years compliance so would need to pay for x2 more years ($750), plus FBARs ($100) plus a dual status return in the year of renunciation (so year 6) $500, and then filling out 8854 ($500) and then finally the admin fee to the US government of $2350.

This seems insane. I know that I have no tax owed to the USA due to higher tax rates here. I cannot pass my citizenship on to any children due to not ever being a resident.

Does anyone a) think these charges are reasonable, b) has anyone completed non-wilful tax amnesty themselves with zero knowledge of the USA tax system?

As per Underfall's advice, my nearest consulate is London where they insist on filling out the invasive form - would I be better paying to go to Paris?

I'm so confused as to what to do. I can't really afford the fees above, but I'm worried about the future even though I rarely travel to the USA. My passport recently expired so I want to get this sorted so I can travel to the USA in the near future.

My brother lives in the USA so files yearly, and my mother has been in the UK over 30 years, earns very little and doesn't file as she is under the income requirements (or so she thinks).

underfall · 07/10/2018 20:46

FixitupChappie - language, for goodness sake!

underfall · 07/10/2018 20:44

"My main anxiety is about the possibility of having bank accounts frozen or refused. I know this has happened to people in Europe."

Only the US-born. We are every bank's worst nightmare. Smile Waving the CLN brings back the smiles and wipes the tears away.

"Another fear is having my status reported to the IRS (by a bank) and being pursued with all the heavy fines they threaten for people who 'wilfully' avoid complying. They treat voluntary compilers much more leniently. It's part of piling on the pressure. Because I believe the IRS has no direct power to force UK resident citizens ('accidental americans') to pay them anything."

You're correct, the IRS can't enforce US tax laws in the UK, and doesn't try. It's HMG that's requiring banks to report the bank accounts of US-born UK citizens. Neither country tries to enforce the insane US tax laws on UK residents, though both countries continue to pretend that the US extraterritorial tax laws are being enforced.

"I had both US and a UK passports as a child to but was told when I was 16 I wasn't eligible to renew my US passport as I wasn't living in America! Yet now I'm suddenly American enough to pay them taxes??
It's ludicrous. A form of unjust bullying. And the only real winners are the legions of accountants."

Correct. It's the tax advisers who peddle the fear.

Since you've had a passport you're undoubtedly a US citizen. It sounds like the official who told you couldn't renew, was just wrong. If you want the citizenship you can appeal that decision; or if you don't want the citizenship, you can renounce.

Third option is to ignore the whole business. That's what my UK-born children have done (they both had US passports as children, but not as adults).

FixItUpChappie · 07/10/2018 20:33

I am a Canadian with duel citizenship who has never lived in the States a day in my life but they are reportedly coming after even those who've never had any residency. It's a pre Trump problem and foreign governments like mine, have fucked us all up the ass lest the US sanction them (bunch of cowardly fuckers) by giving up their data on duel citizens. It doesn't mention I'm a duel citizen on my passport but my mother, who was born in the us, refuses to cross the boarder as she is worried she will be stopped and flagged.

She has secured a lawyer to try to denounce her US citizenship which has proved a costly process. I'm sure, while not started under Trump, that he would massively uptake this form of highway robbery so it's good to make people aware. I recommend speaking to a lawyer with this speciality OP.

Pip14 · 07/10/2018 20:09

Thanks underfall - it's helpful to know about the two different FATCA models. My main anxiety is about the possibility of having bank accounts frozen or refused. I know this has happened to people in Europe. Another fear is having my status reported to the IRS (by a bank) and being pursued with all the heavy fines they threaten for people who 'wilfully' avoid complying. They treat voluntary compilers much more leniently. It's part of piling on the pressure. Because I believe the IRS has no direct power to force UK resident citizens ('accidental americans') to pay them anything.
In my case I wouldn't owe any income tax but I sold my home a few years ago and under US rules the capital gain on that is taxable.
I believe in paying taxes but not to a country that I have no allegiance to, that gives me zero in return.
I had both US and a UK passports as a child to but was told when I was 16 I wasn't eligible to renew my US passport as I wasn't living in America! Yet now I'm suddenly American enough to pay them taxes??
It's ludicrous. A form of unjust bullying. And the only real winners are the legions of accountants.

underfall · 07/10/2018 19:34

I was born in the US. I moved to Britain long ago, filing my last-ever 1040 before I left. Never heard of citizenship-based taxation, and the IRS never mentioned it.

Three years ago a bank told me about FATCA. I made an appointment to renounce, and six weeks later I was $2350 poorer and no longer a US citizen.

Believe me, if it wasn't permitted they wouldn't permit it.

underfall · 07/10/2018 19:26

"With a US parent you don’t need to “claim” US citizenship - you either are a citizen or you aren’t. The flip-side of that is you don’t get to choose not to claim it."

Sure you do. You're required to claim it (and show proof) when you apply for a US passport.

If you never claim it, it's a moot point whether you "are" a US citizen. What matters to a person who doesn't want the citizenship is that with no US birthplace (and no other US indicia), your account is not reportable.

underfall · 07/10/2018 19:14

"One practical problem with renouncing citizenship without sorting out the tax side of it (per Underfall's suggestion to ring the embassy) is that some banks will, in certain instances, demand proof of compliance with US tax law (for instance copies of filed Forms 1040), and in the absence of such proof, they may freeze accounts or kick out clients. I don't want to sound alarmist - this may be exceedingly rare - but it's not a zero-risk proposition to approach it this way."

That can happen in countries which have opted for a Model 2 Fatca Intergovernmental Agreement. Britain opted for Model 1, under which the banks are protected from the US FATCA 30% withdrawal penalties. Banks in the UK are only required to identify accountholders with US "indicia" and report the accounts to HMRC.

Since Pippa was born in the UK, her accounts shouldn't be treated as reportable unless she has a US address, or other US indicia.

"Regarding who is or is not a US citizen, any person born in USA clearly is a US citizen (unless they have renounced US nationality), whether or not they have an SSN, were registered, or anything else."

Correct. Pippa stated she was born in the UK to an American mother. She may have a claim to US citizenship, if her mother fulfills the residence criteria.

ArfArfBarf · 07/10/2018 18:51

With a US parent you don’t need to “claim” US citizenship - you either are a citizen or you aren’t. The flip-side of that is you don’t get to choose not to claim it.