Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to hate the way MNHQ delete threads

38 replies

UmbridgeD · 08/05/2018 16:43

You get threads with hundreds of thoughtful posts. People sharing their own experiences and giving thoughtful and heartfelt advice which can be useful to anyone else in the situation.

Then suddenly it disappears because the op might not be real. Everything else is real but all gets flushed down the toilet.

Then there are clearly silly threads which provide comic relief, funny witty replies. Also deleted.

Why not instead highlight the Original Post and OPs replies in red or something and have an MNHQ warning saying ‘we have reason to believe the op may not be genuine so please bear that in mind in this thread.

While they’re at it, lock threads after 3 months so Zombie 2011 guff stops popping up.

OP posts:
UnimaginativeUsername · 08/05/2018 17:18

if you let troll threads stand then the site will be inundated with them

Are you somehow under the impression that MN is not?

eggcellent · 08/05/2018 17:18

Yep. They delete threads far too readily and it's extremely annoying, has made me consider leaving the site a few times.

UnimaginativeUsername · 08/05/2018 17:17

its easy for an OP to claim identification but it makes it feel pointless trying to contribute to threads at times

I really do think a much clearer steer that posters are responsible for ensuring their own privacy is the way to go. If people are worried about being identified, they shouldn’t be posting on the internet about it.

JessicaJonesJacket · 08/05/2018 17:16

YABU.Threads are usually deleted for good reason and if you let troll threads stand then the site will be inundated with them.
If you don't care about reading fiction then there are lots of fiction sites on the internet. That's not what MN is supposed to be.

Butterymuffin · 08/05/2018 17:12

What UnimaginativeUsername said.

C8H10N4O2 · 08/05/2018 17:10

It might be worth asking for this thread to be moved to Site Stuff. I agree its worth discussing, have been thinking about raising it there recently.

Especially since a thread with with several hundred very civilised discussion posts and really useful content for older women in divorce was taken down after the OP had a hissy fit about the answers. HQ agreed it was not identifying but then apparently were bludgeoned into taking it down. I know its difficult for HQ - its easy for an OP to claim identification but it makes it feel pointless trying to contribute to threads at times.

Shrodingerslion · 08/05/2018 17:01

Totally agree or a thread you are saving to read later , as it is going on pages and pages ,when you have time and it is totally gone.

UnimaginativeUsername · 08/05/2018 17:01

Not as bad as when the OP throws her toys out the pram and insists that her thread is ‘too identifying’ and must be deleted because she doesn’t like the replies she’s getting. This happens far too often and is incredibly frustrating.

It might be a good idea to make people starting threads to positively click an agreement indicating that they realise that they are posting on the internet and that they have no control over the content after they’ve posted it. Then MNHQ can respond to deletion demands with ‘well you agreed to it; please don’t post things you aren’t comfortable being in the public domain’.

DialMforMordor · 08/05/2018 17:00

It's more annoying when there's a long genuine thread, containing thoughtful, and often unanimous, responses that don't fit with the OP's way of thinking, which is summarily deleted because the OP is suddenly 'concerned about privacy issues'.

IIIustriousIyIllogical · 08/05/2018 16:59

It's the only forum I'm on that does it and I don't really see the benefit.

This is the only forum I'm on that deletes Active attacks, but leave Passive ones and yet allows the word "cunt" to be thrown around with gay abandon.

Add in the fact that each moderator seems to have their own criteria & sometimes I wonder how it even works.

GaryWilmotsTeeth · 08/05/2018 16:55

presumable the deletion is to stop some of the more "emotional vampire" type trolls from admiring their handiwork and to not encourage others to do similar. I take your point though OP, it is annoying when a thread you have been invested in suddenly goes up in smoke.

Samcro · 08/05/2018 16:51

yabu, troll threads should be deleted

MissionItsPossible · 08/05/2018 16:50

Not in the same vein but I think posts in Chat should stay up forever or for at least 180 days. I think that's why so many post in AIBU instead.