Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to hate the way MNHQ delete threads

38 replies

UmbridgeD · 08/05/2018 16:43

You get threads with hundreds of thoughtful posts. People sharing their own experiences and giving thoughtful and heartfelt advice which can be useful to anyone else in the situation.

Then suddenly it disappears because the op might not be real. Everything else is real but all gets flushed down the toilet.

Then there are clearly silly threads which provide comic relief, funny witty replies. Also deleted.

Why not instead highlight the Original Post and OPs replies in red or something and have an MNHQ warning saying ‘we have reason to believe the op may not be genuine so please bear that in mind in this thread.

While they’re at it, lock threads after 3 months so Zombie 2011 guff stops popping up.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Zombeheheheh · 10/11/2022 21:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

CarysMa · 08/05/2018 21:03

I think sometimes troll-hunters to force more information out of the OP than they were comfortable giving to begin with. IN the case of threads not going the way the OP expected. Actually I hate those pile ons, even if OP posted something a bit silly.

UmbridgeD · 08/05/2018 20:57
  • forums
OP posts:
UmbridgeD · 08/05/2018 20:57

There are some forms I’m on where you can ‘highlight’ certain users and only you can see that, so they are flagged in yellow or whatever with a note ‘troll’ or whatever. That could be a useful feature.

Thanks for letting us swear but please stop deleting the fucking threads.

OP posts:
UnimaginativeUsername · 08/05/2018 19:19

I don’t think it would necessarily put people off joining. But it might encourage them to think more before they post.

People should simply be aware that their thread may end up in the newspapers, or discussed on twitter or anywhere else. If they don’t want to have that happen, they need to not post it on the internet.

I do think that’s a perfectly fine position for MN to take. And, if they make people click to show that they understand that’s the case in the process of starting a thread, then the answer to ‘why didn’t they take it down?’ is very obviously that the thread starter agreed that they were fine with the fact that they were posting publicly on the internet and knew it was their responsibility not to post any identifying information that didn’t want in the public domain.

Because the other side of the coin is that lots of people may get very cross and stop using MN (other sites are available) because of the ever increasing number of very frustrating tantrums from OPs who then claim the thread is ‘too identifying’.

MissEliza · 08/05/2018 19:18

There was one deleted today about Meghan Markle, presumably because a couple of posters started to attack each other personally. It's frustrating because there were lots of posters trying to make sensible points. Also in the past, I've reported threads which I have found offensive as islamophobic but MNHQ have said they were fine. It feels very arbitrary.

HadronCollider · 08/05/2018 18:22

Good point Edmund

I think they ought to tackle the newspaper lifting stories thing. They seem very blase about it and I think it is wrong.

EdmundCleverClogs · 08/05/2018 18:09

I completely agree with the idea of a 'your responsibility' tagline.

It could put people off joining MN though. Whilst of course we all know that when you write on the internet, you might as well announce what you’re saying to a room full of people, the people who write here are asking a specific group of people. The trouble is, what you think is ‘just on MN’ can suddenly end up in an online newspaper - so if you’re moaning about your MiL who definitely doesn’t use Mumnet, too much information and she may well end up reading it in the Daily Mail. It doesn’t even always start as outing information, bits dripped in over a thread, put it all together and suddenly you see you’ve given far too much away.

Again, probably not MNHQ’s responsibility. However, it would only take one instance of an op asking to be deleted, it not happening, they get outed and there’s a big fall-out - then people will start asking ‘why didn’t they just take it down? I’m not risking posting there’.

HadronCollider · 08/05/2018 18:07

I will add that a lot of convos that make the 'Active' thread end up being shut down, likely because they may tend to be more controversial, heated discussions. But if you are an occasional MN user, who clicks in now and again and uses Active, then its entirely possible to have 2 or 3 threads you're watching or involved in shut down in a given week, or simply almost every time you use MN no matter how far apart those times are.

So despite having months with no MN use for me it feels like it happens a lot.

I also feel free speech is clamped down on far too often and people should be encouraged to use the hide button more, but I do understand that they are primarily supposed to be a parenting site so are balancing competing ethos.

HadronCollider · 08/05/2018 17:58

YANBU!!

It's the most annoying thing about this website, and has made me think about leaving quite a few times. The ones I hate especially are when, as has been said, the OP decides that they do not like the responses and begs 'identifying' then the entire thread is wiped out even if there is 600 pages of useful info. I completely agree with the idea of a 'your responsibility' tagline.

ILikeMyChickenFried · 08/05/2018 17:54

If Mumsnet highlighted a thread as potentially a troll post the thread wouldn't carry on as it was. It'd probably require a heck of a lot more moderation than they're prepared to.give it.

EdmundCleverClogs · 08/05/2018 17:52

because there were some interesting points made on the thread

Do you genuinely think that there was a worthwhile and educational discussion to be gained from that? Other than ‘don’t make fucking assumptions about people based on the country they grew up in’.

UnimaginativeUsername · 08/05/2018 17:49

However, if they claim ‘it’s outing’ or whatever they want to peddle to have it removed, what can MNHQ do? Under those circumstances, they don’t have many options.

Well they could see it as an opportunity to educate people about how the internet works and explain that the onus is always on the poster to avoid ‘outing’ themselves.

As I suggested, they could make clicking an agreement that this is the case part of the thread starting process. Then an OP would have to accept they’d agree to it. And some people might think a bit more before starting a thread.

ThenCameTheFools · 08/05/2018 17:48

Hissy fitters should not only not be deleted, they should be stickied so we can all point and laugh. Then a little doodah should pop up when you hover over their name saying "this is the toys out of pram privacy poster from the X thread"
That'll learn 'em.

C8H10N4O2 · 08/05/2018 17:47

The amount of racist/disableist/ageist etc threads allowed to stand at the moment is astonishing though

Yes I agree. I was pleasantly surprised at how quickly the English/Irish thread was taken down earlier but note that a disablist one is still standing with large numbers of lazy, stereotyped assumptions about disabled people. The OP was unsurprisingly a new name who fired and OP, stoked it an hour later and then disappeared.

CarysMa · 08/05/2018 17:47

The one that just got deleted, ''are the irish less sensible with money than the english'' it's a pity she didn't title the thread ''irish attitudes to money versus english attitudes to money'' because there were some interesting points made on the thread and it hadn't descended in to a bun fight. Then ppppoooofffff it was gone.

UnimaginativeUsername · 08/05/2018 17:44

The thread was also notable for the weird assertion that a net family income of £30k (after paying a £40k a year mortgage!) was some kind if poverty, which some people seemed to accept. That was a bit like falling down a rabbit hole.

It was amazingly polite, despite the OP getting ruder and ruder. And would have been very informative for lots of women undergoing divorce.

EdmundCleverClogs · 08/05/2018 17:43

OP changing their mind threads - mostly these happen where the OP doesn't get the answer they want.

It is very bloody annoying when that happens, I don’t deny it. However, if they claim ‘it’s outing’ or whatever they want to peddle to have it removed, what can MNHQ do? Under those circumstances, they don’t have many options.

The amount of racist/disableist/ageist etc threads allowed to stand at the moment is astonishing though. Especially currently about the upcoming royal wedding, it’s honestly sickening. Not just the threads either, but certain posters who continue to be able to post, when others have been banned over practically nothing.

UnimaginativeUsername · 08/05/2018 17:40

That’s the thread a PP was referring to. But it’s far from unusual. Threads are regularly deleted as ‘identifying’ because an OP doesn’t like the responses. The MN line is some nonsense about how they’re here to make parents’ lives easier, but they’d save the moderation team a lot of work (and not annoy loads of posters) if they took an ‘it’s your own responsibility’ stance.

C8H10N4O2 · 08/05/2018 17:39

Usernames (both!)

Yes it was notable simply because it was so clear and informative and had so little in the way of snarky comment (other than from the OP).

UnimaginativeUsername · 08/05/2018 17:35

An OP posted highly selective and incomplete information about her partner’s divorce settlement with his ex wife (importantly neglecting to include a business worth hundreds of thousands of pounds in the settlement). This made the settlement sound horribly unfair to the poor OP’s husband.

She wanted people to confirm that her husband should reduce his ongoing payments to his wife (who she demonised in various ways) because he’d mishandled his tax bills and they’d over-extended themselves in buying a house.

Posters worked out what the omissions were and didn’t give her the answers she wanted. They posted lots of useful info for women going through a divorce. So the OP had a caps lock tantrum and demanded her thread was pulled. MN initially decided to move it to 30 days only but then deleted it (presumably due to further tantrums).

C8H10N4O2 · 08/05/2018 17:32

Can’t be a two way thing

Two different issues.

Troll threads - I agree, should generally go unless there is some overriding issue meriting retention

OP changing their mind threads - mostly these happen where the OP doesn't get the answer they want. Its nearly always possible to remove key parts of OP posts if they are genuinely identifying but the whole thread goes.

It seems inconsistent with some of the really GF threads which are left to stand, despite large numbers of borderline ist posts where might be disability, race or any other common area of discrimination.

MyOtherUsernameisaPun · 08/05/2018 17:28

Which thread was deleted?

EdmundCleverClogs · 08/05/2018 17:27

Can’t be a two way thing. Either you’re happy to put up with trolls or you’re not. You leave one troll thread up, then it’s a free for all. For all the ‘funny’ trolls, there’s also a million pee/school trolls or ones about how horrible women are. The more trolls there are, the more troll hunting there will be, eventually the forum will be ruined for everyone.

If you feel there’s a valuable discussion that stems from a troll thread, start your own discussion on the matter.

C8H10N4O2 · 08/05/2018 17:21

Threads are usually deleted for good reason

Nope, the thread I'm thinking was not a troll and had loads of really valuable content. OP had hissy fit. HQ agreed it was not identifying but as a compromise were going to move it to limited life (90days or 30 I think). OP has more hissy fit and thread disappears.

That was 450 odd posts of good and informative discussion, maybe a handful were a bit snarky. That was a lot of time and useful contributions to be discarded at the OP say so.

I felt it was waste of time trying to offer information. OThers provided far more and their efforts were wasted.