Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell new parents not to make a rod for their backs

380 replies

PenelopeChipShop · 30/04/2018 21:10

I’ve thought about how to phrase this but I really want to post it. I just feel like i’ve made so many mistakes and I don’t want others to go through the same.

My DC are 5 (nearly 6) and 2 and neither are good sleepers. I didn’t sleep train either of them and was quite laid back/ attachment parent-ish about their sleep, believing all the relaxed people (lots of them on the munsnet sleep boards!) who said that children will sleep through when they’re ready, you won’t regret the cuddles, etc. I was confident in my choice and while I didn’t judge those who did sleep training, I thought it wasn’t for us.

Well almost 6 years of sleep deprivation have taken my youth, sanity, skin quality, patience and all my confidence in what I thought was the right path. It also isn’t an exaggeration to say that conflict over how to handle sleep issues played a huge part in ending my marriage.

I am now a LP to two children who still don’t sleep, ex H doesn’t have them overnight (though he has said he will ‘in future’ - I think this means when the little one is weaned off boob, which I do understand tbf) and every morning I wake up sandwiches between them, utterly exhausted, and angry because it takes all fucking evening to get them to bed. I have no energy or time for myself, all because I thought Dr Sears was right about traumatising children who are left to cry.

Well guess what, he is a man who has never actually breastfed every fucking night for hundreds of nights on end. So he can stuff his theories up his arse.

AIBU to tell new parents to get their kids used to self setting and to night wean them earlyish (6-12 months) so they don’t end up like me, ie a husk of their former selves.

OP posts:
FeckBuggerAndArse · 02/05/2018 18:13

Penelope, you are clearly struggling, and in need of some support. I completely feel your pain as I have been there. However I now have a 14 yr old and 11 yr old who do sleep (and have done for many years!) and we all bed-shared (and boobed) for years. However, I did teach mine ‘bed manners’. I’d tell them to move over and not squash me, etc, I had a sidecar cot on a double bed and this gave us enough room to each get a decent sleep.

But, you have not made a rod for your back, you have given your children the support and nurture they need to cope with life, especially the changes and challenges of your marriage break up. These first few years are hard, they are intense and can feel impossible, but they do pass, and I don’t regret my parenting choices at all. My children still like to cuddle, and seem able to talk to me about stuff their peers feel uncomfortable discussing with their parents.

Hang in there, maybe introduce some boundaries, but you haven’t made a rod for your back, you’ve actually given your family a closeness & connection that will keep you together through the teen years ahead.

BigPinkBall · 02/05/2018 18:13

YABVVVVVU just because it didn’t work for you doesn’t mean it won’t work for other people and if they follow your advice they might miss out on special moments with their children.

I carry my baby in a sling, she slept in our room until 6 months, she sometimes sleeps in our bed if she won’t go down in her cot and she sleeps between 12-16 hours per night without waking and naps during the day. If she cries I breastfeed her and I wouldn’t change any of that.

It’s so totally dependent on the individual child.

ThatUsernameIsTaken · 02/05/2018 18:13

moreofaslummythanyummy that is absurd. How can you find a connection between parents who didn't sleep train to those with 'feral' children? And for your information I didn't train any of my kids and they slept through as soon I decided to stop breastfeeding. I assure you I am not a gentle parent with no boundaries. Sometimes I feel sorry for my kids because of the rules they have, yet the only rule I didn't follow was to sleep train.

AccioUsername · 02/05/2018 18:07

IMO yes YABU. My son was never sleep trained, slept in my bed from night one until about 2 1/2, very gentle parenting all the way. He's almost 5 and sleeps well on his own room 99% of the time.
I'm sorry that you haven't had that experience but you are unreasonable to think everybody else will. Had you said that to me I would have said that I do not believe in letting children cry themselves to sleep because research has proven that it does cause damage.
If you choose to let children self soothe that is entirely your choice but please do not try to get others to follow.

AssassinatedBeauty · 02/05/2018 18:06

Don't be daft, that's your personal opinion. You have no idea who might have done sleep training or who hasn't.

moreofaslummythanyummy · 02/05/2018 18:00

I'm sorry you are struggling but I'm afraid there is no evidence to support sleep training. Sleep research does not show any significant long term improvements to infant sleep through sleep training methods.

Wrong! You want evidence? Go to any place that parents of older children gather. You can instantly tell the "gentle parents" who are against any sleep training or any discipline for that matter . They normally look frazzled and at their wits end,with feral ( for want if a better word)children. Blush

Rockhopper10 · 02/05/2018 17:47

I was obsessed with the idea of sleep training when my first daughter was born. In the end I let her cry herself to sleep once, and it's the one choice that I really feel bad about regarding my parenting. I wish I'd been more chilled out.

At the moment it sounds like you're tearing yourself up because you didn't "sleep train" your children. But it could have been that it wouldn't have worked for your children. You never know.

Hope you get some peaceful nights soon. Don't be so hard on yourself. We all make it up as we go along, and doing the best we can under the circumstances.

BuntyII · 02/05/2018 13:48

'being a mum can be enjoyable'

But only if your baby is in a different room yeah? Couldn't possibly enjoy their company between 7pm - 7am.

GrabbyMcGrabby · 02/05/2018 13:24

@ethelfleda at about 5.5 years. Has a soothing effect and seems quite hypnotic. Wish I'd tried it before.

JessieMcJessie · 02/05/2018 12:33

I haven’t read all the responses but anecdotally I can say that I have 3 friends who are still breastfeeding children aged 18 to 20 months and they all report being woken repeatedly in the night (one is woken pretty much every hour!) and their DC only settling with a feed.

I weaned my DS at 7 months and put him in his own room. Didn’t sleep train as such and certainly no harsh CIO, but he got used to it quite quickly. He is now 20 months and (touch wood) a pretty good sleeper. Yes, he cried at 3am last night and had to come in with us for the rest of the night but he sleeps through probably 5 nights out of 7. Several friends who also weaned before a year have babies who sleep similarly well.

ethelfleda · 02/05/2018 12:25

Grabby at what age did you start using that CD?

Audree · 02/05/2018 11:56

Lloyd, I also have a 13 yo (and a 8 yo), both breasfed as babies, coslept with me or dh until they were 4. The first time I left them to go out they were newborns and their grandmother babysat with no problems. I also have (and had at that time) a job and a healthy relationship with dh. Sex is not mandatory to be had on the bed where your baby is sleeping Grin

myothernameismyrealone · 02/05/2018 11:08

Different approaches work for different families of course. However, the trouble with the "some babies are good sleepers, some aren't" viewpoint is that it's so... passive / helpless. My first was a horrendous sleeper, waking every 40-60 minutes around 7-10 months, needed rocking to sleep, standing up (I had back issues), screaming like he was traumatised. My husband had some serious health problems, I was coping with that and less than 60 minutes unbroken sleep night after night and the baby wouldn't co-sleep even if I'd wanted to. We sleep trained and it worked beautifully (and with very little by way of crying). So he went from being a "bad sleeper" to a good one in a couple of days. If I'd thought I couldn't change his sleep habits, had no influence and had years ahead of me of such severe broken sleep I would've have ended it, I couldn't have gone on much longer, I was on the brink of a terrible breakdown.

I have to believe while it's probably true some of its nature, nurture can surely help things along (and it sleep training doesn't automatically equal crying and abandoned baby).

GrabbyMcGrabby · 02/05/2018 10:17

You need a CD player, some relaxing audio books and the CD version of 'The Rabbit Who Wanted To Fall Asleep'. It has completely changed bedtime for our little one. On a good night as soon as the rabbit CD goes on they are asleep in minutes. It has also put an end to night waking. I discovered this a couple of months ago and feel like a completely different person.

If you want to know the full routine that works for us, let me know.

Flowers
Chocolatedeficitdisorder · 02/05/2018 00:14

My DC are grown up now, but I'm not aware that I did any deliberate formal sleep training - I just had expectations that once they were eating a reasonable amount of solid food they would be able to sleep through the night. With DS he was sleeping 7 hours through by 4 months and with DD it was nearer to 10 months. They both slept in a Moses basket then a cot in my room, then into their own room by a year old. It didn't cross my mind that they would become a permanent fixture in my bed or my room!

Sleep routines become really easy by the time they were a year old, pyjamas on, into sleeping bag, bottle and then bed with a musical mobile playing. I would listen to them grumble over the monitor but it never lasted more than 10 minutes.

I feel for the babies and the mothers who never get a good uninterrupted night of sleep. Sleep is wonderfully healing and refreshing, it shouldn't be such a struggle.

limitedscreentime · 01/05/2018 23:45

I have never left mine to cry and they sleep though, it did take nearly 3 years for one but I just think all kids are different. As are adults.
I still wake up in the night. And not just because of hubbys snoring. Sometimes I can't go back to sleep either.

76mum · 01/05/2018 23:25

Sorry really strongly disagree. I have 3 children my eldest co slept with us and breast fed until 16 months. Would not sleep / nap with out being breast fed. He went into his own room and after about 2 weeks of lots cuddles he finally slept on his own. He was never ever left to cry. He has slept really well ever since, never ever coming into our room even if he's ill. My other two slept better as babies, and play musical beds most nights. Currently lying with my 3 year old who has completely regressed her sleeping and now takes me about 40 mins to get to sleep only for her to wake back up again 2 hrs later if I'm lucky and the. It's s battle of wills every night until I give up and let her sleep in my bed

Sparrowlegs248 · 01/05/2018 21:29

@sdaisy26 your last sentence, all 2 words of it, is spot on.

Luxembourgmama · 01/05/2018 21:09

@BertieBotts wow your list is absolutely perfect. That describes my DH to a T

ethelfleda · 01/05/2018 20:55

I feel for you OP it must be terrible... BUT don't give advice out like that to new mums. We generally tend to lack in confidence quite a lot and quite often think we are doing the right thing until someone comes along with their experiences and makes us doubt ourselves. All children are different. And now ds is 6mo I am finding that following my instincts is the best way. I am co-sleeping and bf'ing and will continue to do so until it feels right to stop. My baby is a very happy and content little boy and slept last night from 8 until 6, only waking twice in the night for a feed. Some nights he may walk up more.

6 weeks ago he was waking every hour And I was beside myself. He wouldn't nap. We tried some gentle sleep training for naps and although it technically worked, the first few times he cried so much it turned my stomach even thinking about doing it again. We didn't leave him to cry, he just didn't want to sleep by himself. I won't be doing that again - only went against my instincts that time and tried it because of others unwanted advice.

nellieellie · 01/05/2018 20:26

I bf both mine till 13 months when they seemed to “go off” it. I expressed so they were fed an extra bottle in the evening. My first slept through from 5 months, my 2nd from 8 months. I never left them to cry. I carried my youngest about until she fell asleep, then put her in the cot. They have both had their own beds/cots, apart from when bf at night when they were small. As toddlers I lay next to their bed in the dark until they were quiet and nearly asleep/asleep. I have never ever had any sleep issues with either. After they were left in the evening, they’d be fine. I’d never consider sleep training. Not quite sure what it is actually but nighttime was for sleeping. I was there if they woke or cried, and when they were small, it could be tiring, but I never saw “sleeping through” as the Mecca of babycare.
However, am so so sorry to hear how difficult it is for you. Must be horrid when you’re alone. Just to say though, I think sometimes it’s about luck. I did just about everything that “you’re not meant to do” but it worked. I know people who did all the things I didn’t and had a hell of a time. I know people with a similar approach to mine and it went wrong. For your own sanity, try stopping the breastfeeding, take your children back to bed when they wake again and again and be thoroughly boring. Do hope it gets better.

Redrosebelle · 01/05/2018 20:08

If you’d said it to me as a new parent I’d have told you where to stick your rod. I took the same approach as you and my little boy sleeps through 8-6 every night. So I don’t think I made a rod for myself.

evaseven · 01/05/2018 20:06

There is some middle ground you know it's not just a choice between leave them to cry and breastfeed them all night

TheEagle · 01/05/2018 20:04

My DH was never daunted by getting up to ours in the middle of the night.

I adore sleep, it’s one of my favourite things.

The sleep deprivation didn’t last too long in the scheme of things.

roses2 · 01/05/2018 20:02

I sleep trained both of mine. Ds1 (5) wakes up in the night and comes to me.

Ds2 (2) sleeps through but in a cot so he can't get out. If he wakes I leave him which isn't very often.

I'm knackered from ds1 coming to my bed. Even if you did sleep train there is no guarantee they will continue to not disturb you.