Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Drinks rule" is silly or am I being sensitive?

236 replies

KungFuPandaWorks · 22/04/2018 16:16

Hi!
Lost my login to my old account but made a very similar name for this account, So hopefully a few will recognise me.

(Quick run down. Sister kicked niece out over sister's new boyfriend is the crux of it)

In the last 6 weeks, my sister has suddenly wanted a relationship with niece. ( coincidental the reconciliation happened around the birth of baby number 7)
Last night niece went and stayed for the first time since her mum kicking her out, obviously I was wary because my sister is still with her partner who is a dick.

Niece has not long been back, hasn't slept all night because she was helping with the baby (which she says she didnt mind) But a few things stuck out too me, maybe I'm being over sensitive because of the previous situation but I would like opinions.

  • a 3 drink rule was put in place. She was only allowed 3 drinks when there (water was included in this) because she can't be drinking all the people's drinks who lives there Hmm
  • everytime she mentioned me, my child or pregnancy it was made clear by the boyfriend he doesn't want me being mentioned.
  • she wasn't allowed a shower or bath because she doesn't live there anymore
  • when she was playing with the younger siblings he told her too stop it and go and look after the new baby because that's why she is there.
  • Made it obvious he didnt want her there.
  • (not really on the best grounds with my sister but it's improved) I got a text about 40 minutes after niece came home, apparently from sister. Asking if neice is planning on making staying over a regular thing, could I start contributing something for when she stays and explain that she must listen,follow and respect what (boyfriends name) says.

She is so excited that her mum is allowing her back around the house and near her siblings, but Im just worried the boyfriend is setting her up to fail. Are the above "rules" Ok? Or am I just being a bitch and not giving him the benefit of the doubt because of last time.

OP posts:
Lizzie48 · 23/04/2018 08:28

Please update us on how your DN is when she gets back to you later today, @KungFuPandaWorks the poor girl she definitely shouldn't go back there however much she might want to. Meeting up with her mum somewhere in public with you there to back you up could be a plan. I'm sure her BF will want to be there, too, but no contact at all with him.

It must be heartbreaking for you. But you still must contact SS about them.

ThanksThanks

shouldwestayorshouldwego · 23/04/2018 00:31

If any of the younger siblings are in the same primary school that DN attended I would make an appointment to see the head so she knows to look out for the younger ones. I would also go down the route of making her residency with you official so you know she is safe before bf starts to think maybe having a slave at home has its benefits. As frustrating as it is your sister is an adult and can do what she wants.

SweetMoon · 22/04/2018 23:55

This has made my blood run cold. Please seek advice from ss and nspcc as to what you can legally do to protect this little girl. And what you can do to protect those other children in the household.

ShinyShooney · 22/04/2018 23:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

placebobebo · 22/04/2018 23:35

You need to legally formalise this arrangement because:

Your sister will stand by him no matter what and has already proved she will allow neglect and abuse to go unchecked to please him.

You don't know legally what you can do to protect your niece from her mother.

Involve social services again, the other children are at risk as well. If left unchecked this could rise to a national press level, because they are a dangerous combination of completely submissive to his demands and power crazed idiot.

You try to minimise this (saying oh it was only one night and she didn't want a shower anyway) because you know you need to take that step but don't want to rock the boat. You need to. Imagine your niece or one of the other children there permanently with him limiting access to fluids and hygiene facilities. That's already pretty extreme and when he no longer feels he has as much control where is there left for him go to feel he is re-establishing control?

One of them could end up severely malnourished or starved to death. You don't want to believe your sister is capable of letting it happen but from what you've already posted you know deep down she will put them last to worship at his altar.

I'm not trying to have a go, you've stepped up in a way a lot wouldn't, however your niece needs more protection and so do the others.

Maybe supervised access could be arranged with just her mother at first. Then the mother and her siblings. She should not be under the same roof as that utter pathetic excuse of a human being. None of them should, not even your sister but she is an adult and should be protecting them, but she isn't, she never will.

twinkletoes741 · 22/04/2018 23:32

With the text message you have, it certainly shows that your niece is not living with her mother.

Get social services involved and get a residency order. I'd also contact child benefit and whatever the CSA is called these days and get those paid to you as well.

What about the welfare of the other 6 children? Are they being subjected to this as well?

OfaFrenchmind2 · 22/04/2018 23:17

Good god, this man is an utter cunt. You are a wonderful woman, taÄ·ing in your niece like that. This poor girl!
And frankly, I know this is your sister and all, but she is unfit to be a mother and should really stop breeding.

Jamiefraserskilt · 22/04/2018 22:49

This has sorrow all over it.
DN desperate for a relationship with mum.
Relationship comes with terms laid down by BF who sees himself as the injured party.
BF laying down rules outside the hearing of DSis.
DSis in receipt of maintenance and family allowance for a child that does not live there.
BF will go nuts if income reduced and redirected as it should be so will demand her return via DSis but to live as unpaid servant.
DN desperate to spend time with siblings including new baby and take whatever emotional scraps DSis throws her way.
OP you are amazing to provide stability in all this. To protect her, you must apply for residency. BF will not like the implication s of this but she cannot go home and be safe from EA.
If you send her at all, send her with packing up and drinks. If Dsis wants to know why, tell her. As to that text, politely suggest that the "cost" of her one night stay can be deducted from the family allowance and maintenance that is paid by the government and her father to DSis despite her not living there.
As the eldest, she comes with a FA premium and they are not going to rock the boat risking losing that and you informing her father he is paying the wrong person.
As a previous poster said, as soon as they are old enough to challenge him, they will be fucked off outta there by which stage the EA will have worked into their psychi and they will need counselling.
What a bloody mess. Another MN regular wanting to rescue them all from this dreadful situation.

Poshsausage · 22/04/2018 22:25

Is the sister aware of everything the boyfriend was saying to your dn?

Is it worth doing a Sarah’s law disclosure here on this man or does ss involvement mean they would be aware anyway ? What’s his past ?

If your sister is aware what’s going on then she is just as culpable and guilty of abuse and neglect.

I totally agree he’s gearing up to escalate the abuse by isolation and demonising your dn. and damaging her self esteem and breaking that mother bond

Call ss make them aware

I’ve been that child going into care wat the best thing that happened to me and I shouldn’t.have been left for so long . Ive read my sw files and it’s hesrtwarming to know how many people tried to help by making reports etc. You’re dokng a really good thing keep at it

TaliZorahVasNormandy · 22/04/2018 22:25

Your Sis obviously needs some therapy. Stand by her man, but she's either too stupid or blind to the fact they dont stick by her. By the time she's realised, she'll have fucked up her relationship with all her kids, then in about 30 years, she'll be bitching to all and sundry about how her kids dont visit. It'll be entirely all of her own making.

Yumyumpigs · 22/04/2018 22:18

Jesus fucking Christ.. . I read mumsnet and think I've heard it all but.... fuck me... i think this tops it.

I think it was the "she's 11" bit that floored me... poor bloody kid.

You keep hold of her tight. Contact ss and don't let her near that pair of fuckers....

Sheesh...

backsackcraic · 22/04/2018 21:15

I remember you. Your sister clearly can't prioritise the needs of the dc above that of her boyfriend. Are SS aware of this? Please contact them again and put on record what niece has come back and said and contents of text. I also think you need to formalise your living arrangements and try to establish contact but not overnight at this stage. Can you get parental responsibility or some such legal order?

Shizzlestix · 22/04/2018 21:10

I know it wasn't my sister who sent that text. I honestly think he's trying to drive the older kids away and isolate my sister. None of us really like him, but my sister has that mentality that you stick by your man no matter what.

Given your sister’s record with men, hopefully this idiot won’t last long.

He’s abusive, I’d be discouraging her from going there, but get your sister to come to you instead.

SezziBaybee · 22/04/2018 20:58

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the request of the poster.

QueenofWhisperz · 22/04/2018 20:55

I agree with your DS having her tubes tied.

Blushlove · 22/04/2018 20:47

Fucking hell, I wouldn't even know where to begin with how disgusting your sister is!

OP, Just wanted to say your niece is incredibly lucky she has you, she may be desperate for her mum now but when she grows up she'll know who it was who cared for her.

Caramelapplecake · 22/04/2018 20:22

If you contact social services and explain what has happened they may support you wrt going to court for residence order (now called a child arrangement order) which will give you shared PR (parental responsibility) with your sister. Until this happens you are correct you have no legal responsibility for your niece and your sister could theoretically demand that her daughter is returned to her care - although from what you have said it's unlikely she will do this.

A child arrangement order will also lay down terms of contact - although SS can do this under an informal signed family agreement.
They may also help you with the paperwork involved in getting your nieces child benefit paid to you.

And as others said yes you do need to speak to SS with regard to the other children in this house in order that they can assess their safety. If you prefer you can raise your concerns with the school DSL of NSPCC and they can make referral on your behalf. If your sister' partner is emotionally abusive to your niece it's likely that he is also emotionally abusing (controlling) your sister. Living in this household may also be having an emotional impact on your other nieces and nephews and this is what SS should assess. They may hopefully try to support your sister with support from a children's centre / family support worker (if they aren't all being closed in your area). More importantly they can encourage her to attend domestic abuse awareness course such as the Freedom Programme in order to empower her and enable her to recognise emotional abuse in relationships (present and future)

Good luck OP Thanks

DinahMo · 22/04/2018 20:22

No need to be offensive, BigFatMermaid, I suspect the last thing SS are is lazy fuckers, given the lack of funding and huge caseloads they have.

OP please ask SS to help again, to help you formalise your care & responsibility for your niece, and investigate concerns about your sister’s partner abusing both her and other children in the household. I agree with also informing the fathers of her half-siblings as appropriate of your concerns about the new partner’s behaviour.

You have to put the children first, it’s clear that for most of them their own parents don’t. But please always make sure your sister also knows that you will always be there for her and support her if she chooses to leave her abusive partner. Although if she continues to collude with ‘rules’ like this then she’s complicit in the abuse of her own children.

shooshoopoopoo · 22/04/2018 20:21

I havent read whole of thread. I would be watching that man very carefully around all those little kiddies He is very controlling. SS need to be involved as this is a car crash waiting to happen. Don't allow neice to go there and be emotionally abused by this man.

Pinktruffles · 22/04/2018 20:18

but my sister has that mentality that you stick by your man no matter what

She sounds utterly vile, and needs to have her tubes tied.

NeedMoreSleepOrSugar · 22/04/2018 20:17

I can understand (not necessarily agree) with ss advice about not rocking the boat right at the beginning, but this is now a long term arrangement and needs to be formalised.

The money is one issue (you should be receiving the lot, not them!) but more importantly you are going to need some form of pr in place for things like consent for medical treatment, school trips etc. The last thing your poor dn needs is these parasites holding her to ransom later.

This would also give you the security to be able to put your foot down in her interests when needed, without feeling your over stepping or risking her place with you.

Unfortunately it looks like you'll have your work cut out keeping her safe from these two, she's lucky to have you Flowers

CherryChasingDotMuncher · 22/04/2018 20:14

I'm extremely surprised SS closed this case!

And OP with the best will in the world, as much as you don't want to go down the legal route, it's the only way to protect your niece. Also, you may not mind paying for her now, but children only get more expensive, you should be receiving her child benefit, money from your sister and the maintenance from her father. Why the hell should they have it?!

newtlover · 22/04/2018 20:03

You say that school have been supportive, I think PPs suggestion of talking to them is excellent, they will have an objective view of the situation and no one can blame you for any decision they take, plus they will be able to support your DN. And I think asking your sister round, or meeting at a neutral place is a good idea as that shows that you are not against them having a relationship. Although I wouldn't be surprised if new BF manages to prevent this somehow.

TheBigFatMermaid · 22/04/2018 19:43

They are already getting money for your niece that they shouldn't in the form they of child benefit, probably tax credits and maintenance from her Dad, then they want you to pay, you who gets nothing for her day to day care, if she visits again!

SS were being lazy fuckers! They need to formalise this arrangement, so you feel secure enough, niece feels secure enough to say no to this happening again and you get rightful money for her!

Orchidflower1 · 22/04/2018 19:34

Nspcc and ss need to be informed re all the chn. So sorry but you need to put chn first - your sister will recover from a broken relationship with her dp- the children could never. Wishing you strength and courage over the coming months x

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread