Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does the UK tax system seriously discriminate against single parents?

118 replies

Porcelaincup · 12/04/2018 14:50

Single parent of an adult child.

I am fortunate that, in the last year, my annual salary has risen to 50k. Personal allowance of £11,850, therefore I hit the 40pc threshold. Yet, if I was married and each of us earned 25k, we would have double the combined personal allowance and not hit the 40pc threshold. My mortgage and most household bills would be the same whether I was married or single.

Inheritance tax rules mean that when I die I can use the extra residence nil-rate band to leave a property up to 500k to my child exempt from inheritance tax. But if I was married, I could leave a property worth up to a million.

So. I pay more tax on my income than two married people with the identical total income. And then when I die, my child has pay more inheritance tax on my property.

AIBU to think this is discriminating against single parents?

OP posts:
Judashascomeintosomemoney · 12/04/2018 17:18

My issue is that I feel a child of a single parent is is not treated the same as the child from married parents

But that’s sort of the point. With regard to IHT they ARE being treated exactly the same.
For example as an individual if I die I can have GBP325k allowance before I owe IHT on my estate. That is deferred for obvious reasons mentioned already. My husband gets my estate. If he dies he gets GBP325k allowance before he owes IHT. At the point of the second death both allowances are applied and all IHT owed to the government gets paid which depending on the value of the estate may or not mean our children get the actual house or just an amount of money after the property has been sold to pay IHT. IE the children do not owe the money, the estate does.
You as a single parent and an individual get exactly the same GBP325K allowance as I get as an individual or as my husband gets as an individual. You mention that your DC have a father but that he will choose not to leave them his money. He just as easily could choose to though. How do you think any government could possibly legislate for that?

Porcelaincup · 12/04/2018 17:15

Curious, that is a fair point to be honest. They do have the right to inherit from both parents and you can’t have a system that covers everything.

OP posts:
Backingvocals · 12/04/2018 17:11

curious the tax system is actually often used to to help us cope with various different circumstances. Ditto the benefits system. That's why it's not a flat rate and why there are rebates and exemptions to reflect different situations.

It's not well designed for this purpose as it's primarily obviously for taxraising - but the fact is governments do use it to alleviate hardship or to promote certain sorts of activity.

I totally agree that it cannot be perfect in this regard - but some of the quirks of it are particularly irritating to those raising a family on one income.

MaisyPops · 12/04/2018 17:09

I have never claimed unemployment benefits nor, because we have 2 incomes, any of the other benefits that my income tax contributes towards.
Am I complaining that I should be given a 'special badge' for this? No! That's just how the tax system works.
This.

People pay tax on THEIR incomes as individuals.
2 people get taxed as 2 individuals because there's 2 of them.
Hardly discrinination that 1 person gets taxed for 1 person.

Now there are other factors and costs where being single works out proportionately more expensive, but feeling sorry because you have to pay tax oj your earnings at the same threshold as any other person is a bit much.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 12/04/2018 17:07

My issue is that I feel a child of a single parent is is not treated the same as the child from married parents. I can't get my head round that!

Not in the slightest!

They absolutely are treated the same - they have the right to inherit from their parents. They have 2, no matter how they were conceived, we all have 2 biological parents! All that happens after that can happen to anyone... death, divorce, desertion etc etc. That's just life! You want the inheritance laws to reflect the myriad of life choices, calamities, and every day occurrences? How?

Backingvocals · 12/04/2018 17:07

Yes your personal tax is yours but on marriage family money is family money. So there are two different treatments going on.

It's difficult to address this without going back to dependent taxation which we probably don't want but the fact is, a couple on 25k have significantly more income to spend on their family than a single person on 50k. And although the couple are two people so more food, more clothes required, this is offset by the sharing of accommodation costs, utility bills etc.

catinapoolofsunshine · 12/04/2018 17:02

*unearned wealth, technically

Porcelaincup · 12/04/2018 17:02

chickenowner, I never said ‘AIBU to think I have a really low salary’ or ‘AIBU to think I pay too much tax’. I questioned whether single parents are discriminated against in the tax system.

From the informed posts I have decided that actually, it isn’t so much single parents being disadvantaged by income tax, it is the combination of a higher and a lower earner. That does have an impact on the actual money in a household.

As for inheritance tax, I maybe am not being clear. I agree that inheriting property screws up the property market, although not so much I think as the selling off an not rebuilding council properties. I agree with you all that 800k is a lot of money (not that I live in anything event remotely close to a 1 million pound property)

My issue is that I feel a child of a single parent is is not treated the same as the child from married parents.

I don’t care much what we do, just as long as it is equal

OP posts:
catinapoolofsunshine · 12/04/2018 17:02

Alone why on earth is inheritance tax wrong? Do you mean morally? You think it's morally wrong to tax unearned income?

Judashascomeintosomemoney · 12/04/2018 17:01

A married couple could leave their child a property that child could live in for the rest of their life. A single parent might not be able to do that
In many areas of London and SE where many people can find themselves asset rich but cash poor, even the children of a married couple may not be able to hang on the actual property itself. Also there’s nothing to say that a single parent is going to be financially worse off than a married couple. A single parent can already leave up to GBP450,000 in primary residential property to their child/ren. Up thread some one mentioned losing all their child benefit because as a single parent they earned over the GBP60,000 threshold. These are not figures that will garner much sympathy I fear. As far as any kind of tax is concerned surely every individual having the same tax allowances, with tax owed increasing in percentage incrementally based on income for income tax (or property value for council tax, or emissions for vehicle tax etc etc) is the only fair approach.
Btw I do agree with regard to the Child Benefit issue, with it based on high individual salary not household income. Not that a household on GBP50k plus should get it but rather a combined household on GBP100k should definitely not get it.

AlonsosLeftPinky · 12/04/2018 17:00

No. Because your personal allowance is just that. Yours.

Inheritance tax is just wrong.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 12/04/2018 16:52

Crikey! That seems a really blinkered way to look at it!

I am married
I don't have kids
I have never claimed JSA, housing, tax credits or any other state benefit. Not since I started paying income tax at 17, 35 years ago.

So... I have never had any of the tax breaks any parents get. None of the benefits my income tax contributes towards.

I have never claimed unemployment benefits nor, because we have 2 incomes, any of the other benefits that my income tax contributes towards.

Am I complaining that I should be given a 'special badge' for this? No! That's just how the tax system works. How would you like it to work? How about, every person gets their own government tax inspector who works out how to give you the tax breaks they think are equitable?

Pshaw!

Love51 · 12/04/2018 16:52

Won't the child of separated parents inherit twice at different times but the child of married parents will only inherit on the death the second parent. So the child of separated parents gets the tax free portion twice!
Also, i thought maintenance isn't counted as income for tax credit purposes. So that's a leveller.
Tbh it isn't enough to be worth a divorce!

catinapoolofsunshine · 12/04/2018 16:52

Porcelain enabling people to leave their property to one of their children tax free screws up the property market more not less!

The scarcity then drives prices up and screws the poor sods who don't inherit over utterly. Let alone the"pick your favourite child and give them a house, sod the others" idea...

Bluelady · 12/04/2018 16:52

It IS a lot of money, it doesn't just sound like it. If you leave a £1m property, your child will end up with £800k after inheritance tax, not really so bad, is it? I imagine it's a problem most of us wouldn't mind having.

swingofthings · 12/04/2018 16:49

OP, the taxation laws are there to penalise everyone as much as possible whether married or single. I agree with you, in your situation, you are being penalised compared to a married family.

Similarly, step-parent who live with the parent with residence is penalised as their income will be taken into consideration for the purpose of child benefit, tax credits etc... but the income of the non resident step-parent is totally ignored. That despite the fact that the child could potentially be closer to the non resident step parent than the resident one.

It's just easy taxation. Fairness rarely comes into it!

chickenowner · 12/04/2018 16:47

But a married couple each earning £25,000 is NOT the same as a single person earning £50,000.

The first is two people, the second is one person.

I think that you are looking at this completely wrongly.

And incidentally, your salary is hugely above the average. If you have a problem with paying the tax you are legally required to then maybe get a lower paid job.

No? Thought not!

Porcelaincup · 12/04/2018 16:43

Bluelady, I appreciate that that sounds a lot of money, but for me it isn’t so much the sum itself, it’s the issues with the property market. Round here half a million will get you a 2 bed flat. The introduction of the residence band was to help parents leave their main residence to one or more of their children. Presumably to address the way the government have systematically screwed up the property market.

If it were the case that young people had a hope in hell of affording to rent or buy, then I probably wouldn’t care much.

But with that situation as it is, the child of a single parent should not be disadvantaged.

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 12/04/2018 16:43

No I don't think the tax system discriminates against single parents at all. But the benefits system is highly favourable to single parents. And a married couple are two people working. And a single person is one person working.

BuggerOffAndGoodDayToYou · 12/04/2018 16:39

My DH is a higher earner. Until fairly recently I was a non earner (even now I earn below the personal allowance level). As he is a higher earner I can’t transfer my unused personal allowance to him AND we have to pay back the child benefit I get on his tax return each year.

So no, the tax system does not discriminate against single parents.

Porcelaincup · 12/04/2018 16:29

The situation with my child is the same as for Backing - my child’s father is married and will leave nothing.

Although my views are clearly overly simplistic, I am purely looking at the practical outcomes. A married couple could leave their child a property that child could live in for the rest of their life. A single parent might not be able to do that.

Regardless of views on whether anyone has the right to inherit what they have not earned, that is an unequal system.

Perhaps....this inheritance tax issue could be addressed with changes to the nil rate residence band? Maybe this could have redressed the balance, allowing a single parent to pass on their main residence to a child.

OP posts:
Hedgehoghogger · 12/04/2018 16:26

If you have a couple with one earner and one stay at home partner then you save hugely on childcare compared to a single parent. So no they're not worse off!

As a single mother earning over 60k I've lost child benefit but have to pay £1500 a month to work. Comparitivet that childcare is worth a 25k salary or about 50k on higher tax rates

Bluelady · 12/04/2018 16:18

A tiny percentage of estates attract inheritance tax. My heart isn't bleeding for anyone who finds themselves paying tax on an unearned lump sum of more than half a million.

Judashascomeintosomemoney · 12/04/2018 16:11

I think you’re looking at it as the children inheriting ‘owe’ less IHT. That isn’t what it means. It is the ‘estate’ (or, if you like, the individuals that have died) that owe the IHT. Each individual person dying ‘owes’ the same amount each, which is as fair as it can be, it just doesn’t get collected til the last asset owner dies.

megletthesecond · 12/04/2018 16:11

backing that's interesting about single parent inheritance. My dc's don't have a dad to inherit from either.