Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does the UK tax system seriously discriminate against single parents?

118 replies

Porcelaincup · 12/04/2018 14:50

Single parent of an adult child.

I am fortunate that, in the last year, my annual salary has risen to 50k. Personal allowance of £11,850, therefore I hit the 40pc threshold. Yet, if I was married and each of us earned 25k, we would have double the combined personal allowance and not hit the 40pc threshold. My mortgage and most household bills would be the same whether I was married or single.

Inheritance tax rules mean that when I die I can use the extra residence nil-rate band to leave a property up to 500k to my child exempt from inheritance tax. But if I was married, I could leave a property worth up to a million.

So. I pay more tax on my income than two married people with the identical total income. And then when I die, my child has pay more inheritance tax on my property.

AIBU to think this is discriminating against single parents?

OP posts:
GinghamStyle · 12/04/2018 21:54

£975K*

GinghamStyle · 12/04/2018 21:53

YANBU and the tax system also is against married couples that stay married until they both die.

If say, Paul and Susan marry but then Paul dies, a few years later Susan remarries Peter who also dies - Susan would have IHT Nil Rate Bands of her own, Paul and Peter - so a combined Nil Rate Band of £975!! That's without considering the Residence Nil Rate Band if she leaves her main residence to her children and their descendants.

Yes. Married people may seem to have a better deal when it comes to inheritance tax, but there are also some couples who are not married who do not benefit from the transferable Nil Rate Band. There are also some people who will do all that they can to avoid paying IHT by setting up trusts, and others that are happy to allocate property/investments to "pay the IHT" when they die.

Some people end up in a nursing home and their house is sold to pay for their care fees and £600-£1,000+ a week soon gets through the proceeds of sale! While others who never own a property are in the same nursing home paid for by the local authority.

Bluelady · 12/04/2018 21:16

You can say exactly the same thing about everything you spend, it's not just inheritance tax. You pay income tax, then you spend what's left and pay VAT/fuel tax/council tax. The same money is taxed over and over again all the time.

Half a million tax free should be enough for anyone and if it's not they're just plain greedy.

Urubu · 12/04/2018 21:00

But the benefits system is highly favourable to single parents
This
For years DH was working and I wasn't (no DC). I didn't get any benefits because of his salary, but he was paying as much tax as a single person. We actually figured out that we would gain quite a lot from divorcing, as I would then be entitled to some benefits!
(we didn't though)

AvoidingDM · 12/04/2018 19:49

The unfairness in the system is 2 parents get taxed individuality but benefits are given on dual income or in the case of child benefit the higher earner. That is unfair as previously pointed out. It's crazy that 2 families with same gross income one pays way more tax than the other and the other gets a benefit.

Noting that the Ops Child is no longer a child but is an adult earning you are in no different position to any other unmarried person.

AlonsosLeftPinky · 12/04/2018 19:46

Inheritance tax is wrong because for me, having paid tax already on everything I've earned and accumulated, I should be free to give it away however I see fit.

cocacolamonster · 12/04/2018 19:43

If you were sharing your household you could achieve the same effect.

idobelieveinfairies86 · 12/04/2018 19:30

It's a bit like being given carers Allowance from 1 department and then having some of it taken away by 2 departments which once combined amounts to more than the CA itself.
The whole system just doesn't work for EVERYBODY but it does work for the majority.
x

Porcelaincup · 12/04/2018 19:21

Also, who ON EARTH thinks that this method of calculating child benefit is appropriate. It is utterly ridiculous that two parents esrningn49k each get child benefit, but one parent esrning 50k doesn’t is ludicrous.

OP posts:
Porcelaincup · 12/04/2018 19:19

Judas, I totally get the picture. 100%. It’s been an informative afternoon though, especially wrt the higher/lower tax earners or higher earner/SAHP being in the same position as a single parent.

You definitely can’t please everyone.

OP posts:
alltheworld · 12/04/2018 18:13

Child tax credits calculated on household income. Child benefit should work on the same basis.

Bluelady · 12/04/2018 18:10

If people think inheritance tax is unfair - I don't since the estate has to be worth more than half a million to incur it - the answer is simple. Just spend your money so you leave an amount that's under the threshold. I have zero sympathy for people inheriting a vast amount of money without lifting a finger and whinging about paying tax on some of it.

catinapoolofsunshine · 12/04/2018 18:06

Life isn't fair. Whining about paying tax on something you haven't earnt is very "poor little rich guy".

catinapoolofsunshine · 12/04/2018 18:05
  • earnt not sent
catinapoolofsunshine · 12/04/2018 18:04

Bugger your fil hadn't sent that money, and it is highly unlikely that the house hadn't at least doubled in value since his father bought it. Vast amounts of unearned wealth in the capital gain, as well as the fact that that your fil hadn't sent a penny of the value of the house.

ohreallyohreallyoh · 12/04/2018 18:04

But the benefits system is highly favourable to single parents

Ermmm....is the the fictitious ‘single parent benefit’?

Porcelaincup · 12/04/2018 17:45

MyDcAreMarvel, I don’t think for one minute that I should pay less tax than you.

In fact both my family and your family are in the same boat in terms of income tax. One high earner. So we pay more income tax per household than two middle earners and their child would pay.

But all three of these families could have the same heating bill, same council tax, same car insurance, same car tax, same electric bill, same telephone bill, same water bill (if un-metered). Our food bills will be different.

OP posts:
Judashascomeintosomemoney · 12/04/2018 17:44

I understand your grievance with the perceived unfairness in that but ultimately Tax (in all its forms) is a legal imperative not a moral one so I honestly cannot see how any government could make all things fair to all people. After all there are plenty of single parents that can’t get CMS, even though they legally should, out of an absent parent let alone an inheritance. Also just a read of this thread shows that no matter what the system someone will see it as unfair. “You’re single but on GBP50k? Well we’re married on GBP30k. You don’t pay child care but I have to, I don’t get CB but you do etc - sure you get the picture Smile. Maybe nobody should pay IHT?

BuggerOffAndGoodDayToYou · 12/04/2018 17:40

Alone why on earth is inheritance tax wrong? Do you mean morally? You think it's morally wrong to tax unearned income?

Tax has already been paid on the inheritance. My FIL had to pay a huge IHT bill when his DM died. Her DH had worked hard all his life, saved hard, prudent etc. He paid tax on his earnings, he paid tax on the interest on his savings, he paid tax on his pension income. FIL (and his siblings) then paid tax AGAIN. Definitely not fair.

catinapoolofsunshine · 12/04/2018 17:37

Nope Antislut - if you bought a house for 60k and it's now worth 260k that's 200k of unearned wealth.

In addition to which all income is taxed multiple times. You've paid income tax on the tenner in your pocket, but if you use it to buy yourself a packet of tampons and some toiletries you'll pay 20% VAT again. You pay capital gains tax (if you obay the law) if you sell expensive possessions too.

Most financial transactions can be taxed.

Porcelaincup · 12/04/2018 17:32

Sorry...the child inherits a 650k house!

OP posts:
Porcelaincup · 12/04/2018 17:31

Judas, I honestly do get what you are saying, but it still feels different treatment. But I am genuinely open to being shown that I am being wrong. Let’s assume that the mother, or father, of a child from a single parent has been absent from birth. No contact. Not on the birth certificate.

What if the estate was exactly that - modern version I guess of an ‘estate’. It was a 650k house. There is no other money at all. In the married scenario, parent one passes their 325k to parent 2. Parent 2 leaves the house to the child. So, the child inherits a 325k house.

For the child of the single parent in the conditions above, they don’t.

OP posts:
MyDcAreMarvel · 12/04/2018 17:23

Yabu op , your 50k only has to support you and your dc. My dh wages has to support myself as his disabled wife and his dc.
Why should you pay less tax?

Antislut · 12/04/2018 17:21

Taxation on inheritance tax is not untaxed earnings. Anything you own has already been taxed and you should be able to pass it on tax free as it's money/property that's already been taxed.

Judashascomeintosomemoney · 12/04/2018 17:19

Ha x post with curious!

Swipe left for the next trending thread