Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does the UK tax system seriously discriminate against single parents?

118 replies

Porcelaincup · 12/04/2018 14:50

Single parent of an adult child.

I am fortunate that, in the last year, my annual salary has risen to 50k. Personal allowance of £11,850, therefore I hit the 40pc threshold. Yet, if I was married and each of us earned 25k, we would have double the combined personal allowance and not hit the 40pc threshold. My mortgage and most household bills would be the same whether I was married or single.

Inheritance tax rules mean that when I die I can use the extra residence nil-rate band to leave a property up to 500k to my child exempt from inheritance tax. But if I was married, I could leave a property worth up to a million.

So. I pay more tax on my income than two married people with the identical total income. And then when I die, my child has pay more inheritance tax on my property.

AIBU to think this is discriminating against single parents?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OceanicBoundlessness · 31/01/2024 08:58

Op I can see what you're saying. A two adult family would get two tax allowances too. 22k they don't have to pay tax on between them vs 11k.
I know many 2 parent families each earning over 60k who can afford to pay extra into their pension so that they still receive child benefit. On a single income your tax burden is already higher and outgoings will not be much lower - maybe one less car to run.

Beckynotts · 31/01/2024 08:36

I completely agree with you and have been saying this for years. As a single parent we need to work more to provide than if we were in a 2
persons relationship. It is wrong as we get taxed more for the same household income.

fairertaxesnow · 03/05/2018 13:44

Sorry, I meant to wrote "have the right"

fairertaxesnow · 03/05/2018 11:13

Of course you gave the right to your opinion but you haven't provided any reasons why you think that nor commented on the reasons I've mentioned why it would be fairer to allow families to be taxed on their combined income.

Viviennemary · 03/05/2018 10:15

No I don't agree. People should be taxed as individuals. I think the benefits system is very favourable to single parents at the present time. So a lot of single parents simply can't afford to live with a partner as they will be worse off.

fairertaxesnow · 03/05/2018 02:50

I think the goverment should do more to help families and also single-parent families. It is extremely unfair that people are taxed as individuals regardless of how many other people depend on that income. In most other countries, couples are given the option of being taxed on the total household income, and this is much fairer.

It is unreasonable to charge the same amount of taxes on an individual without dependents who spends all their money on themselves, than a family breadwinner with several children and a partner/spouse who can't work because childcare is too expensive, or because he/she can't find a job, or even because he/she decided to stay with the children because it is best for them, as research has demonstrated.

In this country, families with single earmers carry by far the biggest tax burden, and while individuals enjoy some of the lowest tax rates in the western world, single-eaarner families are effectively taxed much more than in other countries (as much as 70% more, for example, than in Germany!).

Children are the future and with the decline in the population, it is wise for the country to encourage families to be able to have children and raise them without financial distress.

Please sign and share this parliament petition asking the government to base taxes on combined household income. This will also eliminate the inherent unfairness of the child benefit charge.
petition.parliament.uk/petitions/216429

More info:
www.telegraph.co.uk/women/mother-tongue/8365211/Britain-worst-place-for-tax-burden-on-single-earner-families.html
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/jul/11/single-income-families-inequality-workers-fathers-earnings

LifeBeginsAtGin · 14/04/2018 12:35

if nobody had kids who would pay taxes to pay your state pension and fund the NHS in your old age?

but that's never going to happen

CuriousaboutSamphire · 14/04/2018 12:08

Grin I do exactly the same - including having to apologise when I make the same mistake! Smile

catinapoolofsunshine · 14/04/2018 12:05

Sorry Curious ! Blush I guess despite reading the thread I paid no attention to who said what BlushFlowers

CuriousaboutSamphire · 14/04/2018 12:02

catinapool I think you may have missed my point! I was continuing with the sarcastic tone of my previous posts, taking the piss to make exactly the points you have so kindly edumacated me on! Hence the Smile and obvious idiocy of my post!

catinapoolofsunshine · 14/04/2018 09:27

Curious and if nobody had kids who would pay taxes to pay your state pension and fund the NHS in your old age? It's swings and roundabouts, but by not bringing up children you've saved yourself hundreds of thousands of pounds over 18 years - vastly more than child related benefits are worth. Nobody begrudges you use of services funded by the taxes of younger tax payers when you are elderly despite not having fed, clothed, looked after and supported any of those individuals through the dependent childhood years, but you begrudge any child related benefits because you don't have a child?

Moonandstars84 · 14/04/2018 08:55

Yes and those children are the taxpayers of the future.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 14/04/2018 07:51

Well, it was if you had kids. Those of us who didn't couldn't claim it... hardly universal, and just another example of the total and utter unfairness of the system Smile

Moonandstars84 · 13/04/2018 21:04

It's hardly tax relief when child benefit used to be an universal benefit.

CuboidalSlipshoddy · 13/04/2018 18:46

Plus your liability is reduced by Paying into a pension

That's the ultimate in middle-class perks, though. For someone earning £60 000 and claiming child benefit, they can put £10 000 into a pension, claim £1 700 of child benefit, and be in effect getting 57% tax relief.

Moonandstars84 · 13/04/2018 17:37

If you earn 50K you still get child benefit op. It is scaled from 50 to 60k. Plus your liability is reduced by Paying into a pension
I also think that in some occasions being a single parent is a benefit financially.

Me and a colleague were doing the same admin job and wanted to go back part time.
As I was living with dh I didn't qualify for Tax Credits so returning to work was pointless as my earnings would have been eaten up paying for childcare and fuel.
Meanwhile colleague was living with her mum as split up with father of her child. She had a high earning new partner but was putting off moving in with him as she was currently getting 80% of her childcare paid for.
This was years ago and I am sure they are not so generous now.
So we are individuals for income tax purposes but not for much else.

Urubu · 13/04/2018 16:59

My point is that someone having no or little income will benefit from NOT being married (single or not).

ohreallyohreallyoh · 13/04/2018 15:16

Ok so same situation but one DC: the married couple doesn't get benefits. They would if they divorced

And your point is what, then? That single people are more likely to be eligible to receive means-tested benefits because there is only one person able to earn a living therefore half the earning power therefore likely less money coming in?

The suggestion that the system favours single parents is ridiculous. Single-income families would receive exactly the same, wouldn't they?

Urubu · 13/04/2018 13:22

@ohreallyohreallyoh
Ok so same situation but one DC: the married couple doesn't get benefits. They would if they divorced.

CuboidalSlipshoddy · 13/04/2018 13:20

Married couples used to be taxed jointly, up until the late 1980s I think (certainly, since I've been working). They could opt for separate taxation of their earned income, but even then the wife's investment income (and possibly some other things) was taxed as though it were the husband's (and had to be declared to the husband).

This was obviously unreasonable and sexist, and was quite properly altered to a system in which people were taxed as individuals. In the process the married man's allowance was abolished, along with howls from the right about "penalising marriage" and so on.

And here we are. Do you want a return to joint taxation, in which spouses have to declare their income to each other and be taxed as one entity? I would hope the answer to that is "no". So yes, the situation now is that a couple have two personal allowances, and a single person has one. And there is a similar "unfairness" if you want to see it like that if you compare a couple with one person working versus two, and similarly for their pensions.

Do you want a return of the married person's allowance, at scale (not the political sop Cameron pushed through?) Unfair to cohabiters, surely? A child tax allowance? Unfair to the childless, surely?

A single, indivisible personal allowance is probably the least worst, least anomalous solution.

ohreallyohreallyoh · 13/04/2018 13:00

For years DH was working and I wasn't (no DC). I didn't get any benefits because of his salary, but he was paying as much tax as a single person. We actually figured out that we would gain quite a lot from divorcing, as I would then be entitled to some benefits!

In what way has this anything to do with single parents and the tax/benefit systems if you're not actually a parent?

immortalmarble · 13/04/2018 08:36

It’s just more expensive as one person than two.

What does PISS ME OFF (sorry) is that it’s more expensive to have things like national trust membership et al.

Harvestmoonsobright · 13/04/2018 08:34

Yep. Life is unfair. Suck it up! 😜

catinapoolofsunshine · 13/04/2018 06:18

Alonsos you haven't paid tax on the capital gain which is any increase in the value of your property since buying it. Perhaps a higher rate of capital gains tax just on the unearned wealth would be "fairer"?

For most valuable things you buy, there's tax to pay when you sell.

However as Bluelady says all income is taxed again when you spend it. 20% VAT on most things.

Inheritance tax is unfairly full of loop holes compared to taxes on most other things. The tax on the capital gain on million pound homes bought 40+ years earlier for a fraction of that should be paid at the very least.

evilharpy · 12/04/2018 22:14

ginghamstyle you can only ever use up to the value of 2x nil rate bands. If you were married twice and your first spouse used their NRB by writing a will leaving their estate to their children, then you could use your second spouse's NRB. Or you could use half of spouse 1's NRB and half of spouse 2's NRB and they could each use the other half themselves via trusts/wills/gifting/whatever. But you cannot personally use more than £650k of NRB. Not counting the additinal residence NRB.

Swipe left for the next trending thread