Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fecking hoarding by proxy. Anyone else have relatives who do this?

364 replies

TheQueenOfWands · 07/04/2018 11:36

My mum just found an old, filthy, partially deflated football near my house.

It's now in my garden. The same garden which I've recently spent great time and expense tidying up and decorating.

Why? Well, I'll tell you why. Apparently a child will be 'overjoyed' to receive it once it's been cleaned up and reinflated. Also, there's too much stuff in landfill so it's obviously not on to simply throw it out.

Today is my only day off from work. I worked 72 hours last week and 50 this week. I have no interest in laundering footballs and don't have a clue how I'd reinflate it. I also don't know any children, let alone any who would be overjoyed to receive a vaguely scrubbed, badly inflated foot ball.

This isn't the first time she's done this. My parents do this quite a lot.

It's such a shame to throw something out so obviously I have to make use of it or DS would be thrilled with it.

Aaargh!!

Doesn't help that I've recently been decluttering (much love to Marie Kondo) and am happy doing so.

They know this. Yet are still determine to fill my house with crap or visibly recoil when they see me give/throw something away.

OP posts:
Loonoon · 08/04/2018 10:30

My mum and my inlaws do this too. i thank them and then dispose of the items when they leave. If I kept every bit of tat they have bought round over the last 30 years I would have to move into the garden shed.

On a related note, when DC were small my mum gave them each a very small chocolate egg in an egg cup for Easter. They were delighted with them and she now does it every year, one for each DC and one each for me and DH. So over the last 20 years or so she has given us over 100 egg cups! And for the last 19 years or so they have all gone straight to the charity shop.

NymphInYellow · 08/04/2018 10:29

LittleCandle my DF died recently. I'm an only child too and am currently clearing out his 3 bedroom house, which is rammed full. I'm on my second skip and have 20 bags of stuff for charity so far. I found the awning for the caravan in the wardrobe. Caravan went about 30 years ago. Have also found the orange nylon sheets etc Smile. Yesterday I threw out all his pay slips for the 70's. It's made me determined to sort through my own stuff and have a declutter!

LittleCandle · 08/04/2018 10:18

When DF died, I had to clear out his flat. I knew he rarely threw things out, but he wasn't a hoarder compared to some on this thread. However, in his spare bedroom, the twin beds both had drawers underneath and they were filled with the old blankets from our caravan (gone more than 20 years before) and the really attractive orange and yellow bri-nylon sheets, valances and pillowcases from the 70s. (what was DM thinking when she bought those!) He had several sets of those ghastly ornamental plates that he had bought through Franklin Mint or some such place that he assured me would be worth thousands. There was a set for me and one each for the DDs. They would love them, he assured me. I think the auctioneer managed to sell each set for £1!

I had to get a skip to clear the place. His furniture went to charity and I took what I wanted from his garden shed (built from old doors from the school he had worked in!) and cravenly left the rest for the buyer of his flat to deal with. There was only so much I could cope with (his only child) and the shed gave me the heebie-jeebies!

I am making an effort not to keep stuff that is just tat. I do, of course, have some, but every now and then I have a clear out and have even got rid of books, which is very hard for me to do, but I don't want the DC to have to deal with the mountains of shit that I had to.

Mxyzptlk · 08/04/2018 10:12

They kicked up a huge stink and broke my back gate in an attempt to get in, kind of rammed it until the wood split rendering the bolt useless. Then threw stones at DS's window.

Shock I wouldn't give a key to someone who acted like that. I'd call the police.
frasier · 08/04/2018 10:12

MIL once cleared out her kitchen cupboards and sent me what she didn't want.

Out of date spices and cake decorations
Loads of cleaning stuff
A muffin tin (she'd bought a new one)
A couple of nasty tea towels.

Apparently her own daughters (only females need this stuff btw) didn't want her crap so she parcelled it up and sent it to me.

It all went in the bin. DH had a word. She thought I "might like it" apparently. That's a lie. SHE felt wasteful throwing it out so got rid of her guilt by trying to put it in my kitchen instead.

LakieLady · 08/04/2018 10:05

Both my parents were hoarders. I have hoarding tendencies. DP has hoarding inclinations (mostly motorbikes that he is "going to fix and sell"). His father was the same, as is his brother. I'm starting to wonder if there's a genetic element!

My father's speciality was hoarding packaging. When I cleared their house out after they'd died, I could have opened a bubble wrap shop. There was also a huge stack of the clear plastic domes you get on trays of pears.

In a cardboard box, I found my father's payslips (mostly handwritten) going back to 1958 (this was in 2010). On the desk in the hall, I found the appointment card for my brother's driving test in 1982. This had actually moved to Milton Keynes with them in 1983!

My father had over 50 shirts, mostly Viyella check jobbies that were all astonishingly similar. They had 9 washing up bowls, and in the utility room was a big plastic laundry basket full to the brim with tea towels.

If I'd got air miles for all the trips to the tip I did, I could have got halfway round the world for free.

Easilyflattered · 08/04/2018 10:03

My mother lives to the east of me, I take stuff she's given me to charity shops to the the west of my town. So she can't see it and buy it all back.

She can't bear the idea of waste. But the most expensive thing in my life is my massive mortgage because I live in an expensive area of the country. So I'm not wasting my money on having all my useful space filled up with junk.

NotSureThisIsWhatIWant · 08/04/2018 09:57

I just spent a week with the worst hoarder I have seen in my life. She is lovely, but if she likes something she buys twice of it just in case it gets lost/broken, have had containers brought in from abroad with hand me downs from her family ranging from clothes, beauty products to innumerable old and sometimes broken furniture.

We spent the week in shock,she goes through life thanking god, the spirits, the universe for providing her with so much so, in “gratitude” she can receive more. She founds it absolutely shocking that I do not feel the need to do the same, can’t understand I want to have a more minimalist approach (my dream is to get a skip to finish putting all that crap that I no longer use, like or love out of the house). I think she is convinced I’m poor Hmm. Regardless of how much I insisted I didn’t want or need anything, I came back with a lot of stuff she kindly gave me but that I would have preferred not to take. I couldn’t refuse more without insulting her so I just thought I just needed to shut up and dispose of it on arrival.

I really don’t think that saying “just bin it or send it to the charity shop” is particularly useful advice. There is so much crap that is too big for the car or require a few months of regular trips to the charity shop to clear. My wheelie bin contents are only collected once every forthnight so I may need to do a trip to the tip myselt to get other people’s old stuff out of the house. In fact, there are pieces of luggage in my attic left by friends who moved away more than 15 years ago. Every now and then I take something to the tip, it never cease to amaze me the amount of crap people are interested in moving around with them.

So I can see why you are annoyed OP, all those hand me downs are giving you a lot of work to do, be it by fixing them or getting rid of. It is sometimes expensive to get rid of them be it on terms of time and money.

My parents do not bring or send me any crap anymore, after a very clear conversation where I said that If there was something missing in my house it was not due to lack of money but due to the fact I prefer to wait for something I really like rather than filling my house with crap stuff I hate.

SinisterBumFacedCat · 08/04/2018 09:54

My mum does this a bit in that se buys things from Charity shops that I might like and piles them on me, about a year ago I started saying thanks, but I've got so much of my own stuff to sort I can't really take that, she's calmed down a lot. She also offered once to buy DS a sun hat on holiday, instead of going to Primark or a cheap supermarket, she went to the charity shop and got 2, one was far too small and the other was very obviously a girls hat, she probably spent more money than buying a new one that fits!

Easilyflattered · 08/04/2018 09:35

OP my mum does this. She realises she has a hoarding problem so she's trying to unclutter her house, but she can't actually bear to throw stuff out, so she gifts it to me. Quite often its brand new clothes that don't actually fit me, she gets irritated with me that they don't fit me, despite the fact that they were never originally bought with me in mind. I feel obligated to keep this useless stuff despite not having much space in my house.

She does similar to my brother although not clothes obviously, he has no qualms about ditching it as soon as he feels like it.

My brother and my husband completely cleared her double garage a year or two ago, giving up a weekend of their time and hiring a van. She has refilled it. My brother is furious.

Im moving house shortly, I've been told I don't need to buy any kitchen stuff or towels because she has stuff she wants to give me. It must sound ungrateful to some but actually it is quite a controlling behaviour.

OnTheRise · 08/04/2018 09:20

No she won’t.
That’s fine, I know she won’t, I’ve come to terms with her I love her how she is but she won’t ‘soon learn’ and it’s really irritating for people to say things like that about dealing with people you love who have mental health issues.
It’s like saying to someone with an autistic child that they just need discipline or a routine.

I'm so sorry, Teacup: I worded that really badly and didn't mean it to sound as if I knew better than you.

My mother is really manipulative and difficult--so much so that I haven't seen her for nearly five years, and the therapists I've seen have described her actions as "chilling". When I stopped engaging in her histrionics she ramped up her behaviours; that didn't work either; so she switched to other behaviours which were just as dysfunctional, but I kept on not engaging and she did eventually back down. She does still phone me every now and then, but perhaps four times a year rather than four times a day, so there has been an improvement.

It's difficult, it really is. I'm sorry I was so clumsy and offended you, I didn't mean to.

TheQueenOfWands · 07/04/2018 22:41

Stealth by 'trash' I just mean rip out all of my ivy and then leave it everywhere for me to clear up.

I love my ivy. She doesn't. Possibly because it's coming from the council's land, but I'm not sure.

She likes to 'prune' things but in reality she just kills them.

OP posts:
wherethewildthingis · 07/04/2018 22:40

My mum is a bit of a hoarder at home, keeps a lot of stuff I wouldn't give house room and has thousands of books, to a crazy extent. She has what I think is a related behaviour when it comes to food. She hates any kind of food waste - will eat the stalk of a raw brocoli, carrot peel rather than let me throw it away. And she cooks huge portions then puts a lot of pressure on people to eat them, and any leftovers - which there always are. I keep explaining to her that it's just as much of a waste if we overeat, as it is to throw food away. And suggesting she cooks smaller amounts! No joy though. To me it feels like the same psychological type of behaviour as described in this thread.

Middleoftheroad · 07/04/2018 22:37

The clown pyjama holders, plastic squirrels and locust farm win hands down.

We moved - in part - to a house that could accommodate DH's retro collection of games, consoles, monitors etc. He's watched me throw out precioys baby clothes yet won't get rid of free cassette tapes from Select Magaxine 1991 etc.

I've learned to throw out useless household tat (old mismatched chipped plates) when he's not around, otherwise he thinks they'll come in handy at some point.

His DM and my aunt bring us house plants when they know I hate them. Trouble is then DH won't get rid, but he won't water them either. Gave one to my mom but then he saw it.....

Turnocks34 · 07/04/2018 22:26

My MIL is a hoarder, it’s awful. She just doesn’t throw anything out. He front room is just covered floor to ceiling with tat she finds from charity shops. She’s not as bad as other people oh OH has spoken to at meetings etc, as MIL has allowed Oh to build 4 sheds in her garden and she’ll happily have stuff moved there and out of the house as long as it isn’t chucked.

She also skip dives and it’s mortifying. Like you’ll be walking with her, and she’ll see a skip and she’ll be climbing into it. And she takes anything from them too - broken toasters, bits of woood, scraps of wall paper.

LizzieDarcy1907 · 07/04/2018 22:15

For years, my Mum has emptied her wardrobe on a regular basis (to make room for more) and she gives it all to me. We are the same size. But that's it - she buys most of her clothes from QVC and they are ultra bright vivid floral in varying types of polyester. I break into a sweat just looking at them. And it's all skirts and dresses.
I wear leggings, jeans and Joe Brown or Seasalt tunic tops. Every day. And have done for around 20 years.

I am going to say No to the next lot after reading this. Thank you Flowers

StealthPolarBear · 07/04/2018 22:09

". She mentioned earlier about my garden and I wouldn"'t put it past her to trash it while I was asleep"
Shock

Juells · 07/04/2018 22:02

Or that you gave it to a passing waif. ("His little face, Mum! You should have seen it! The disappointment at being handed a piece of crap!")

lol that didn't go where I expected.

Atthebottomofthesea · 07/04/2018 21:42

My Mum, whilst by no means could be classed as a hoarder, does have a lot of stuff. I grew up not being able to use half the seats in the house - not great when there are 5 of you. She struggles to throw anything that might be useful, so rubbish and recycling goes (eventually) but other things might be useful. If she finds something of mine I now take it home and chuck it as I couldn't do it in her house. She has asthma and I am sure the accumulated stuff doesn't help.

She is late war and grew up in rationing in a poor family where everything was used and then used again. It is a habit she has never broken. MIL on the other hand who was a young girl in the war pretty much throws everything away, but 'hoards' food and household goods. So she'll have 5 toothpastes in the cupboard for example.

I do need to try and squirrel away some more stuff when I am next there. Talking to her just upsets her, so we don't do it. Trouble is it is so difficult to find our stuff as it is buried deep under stuff.

holiday101 · 07/04/2018 20:46

My DM never comes to my house (at least once a week) without a bag of 'bits and bobs'. It will contain a miscellaneous mix of old Woman's Own, hotel shampoo, broken DVD players ('because d's should be learning how things work') and last time 3 separate opened jars of chutney that someone in the WI made but didn't like Hmm. I now just ooh and a h and leave it by the back door to either bin/recycle/charity shop.

paranoidpammywhammy2 · 07/04/2018 20:30

I'm an ex hoarder who messes up every so often. Now I've made huge progress I have carpet showing. I see surfaces.

Part of my success has been due to trying to help are relative (who's a very excessive, high scoring hoarder) to reduce their hoard. We make progress and then one week later they've been out and picked up more. Every time they try to palm off crap onto me. It is as if my clear areas are stimulating them to fill it in.

We've cut down visits to my place and this seems to help. I can 'forget' to collect the tat from their house and it gets lost.

TheIncredibleBookEatingManchot · 07/04/2018 20:29

My nan sadly died last year. A few days after my mum and her siblings cleared her house out I came home to find my cupboards full of my nan's old crockery and cups.

Apparently it would be silly for me not to have them as they're perfectly good and the fact that I already have my own perfectly good crockery and cups and am never going to need 20 mismatched bowls is just me finding excuses to complain about nothing.

I also have about a million towels because my mum keeps seeming to find old ones in her airing cupboard and "they're nice."

Whenever I move house (which I have done several times over the last few years) she turns up with boxes of stuff from her attic, that I "might find useful in the new house." It's never useful.

And then she tells me my house is cluttered and I need "to learn to throw things away."

Winterdown · 07/04/2018 20:15

I shouldn't have been ageist and say "this is older people". But statistically, they have accumulated the most crap. Not all, of course, are hoarders.

pigsDOfly · 07/04/2018 19:47

This is older people. Really?

My parents never hoarded stuff. I'm nearly 70 and have no inclination to start hoarding stuff and doubt I ever will.

My exh is a bit of a hoarder but his DB is over 90 and has the smartest hoard free home you wish for.

Winterdown · 07/04/2018 19:23

Yes. This is older people. Psychologically unable to part with something, so they give it to you. It eases their anxiety. My aging auntie knits stuff for me. Hundreds and hundreds of little hats for my children. Because she has spent a lifetime amassing too much yarn. Hoarders. Loathe them.