Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fecking hoarding by proxy. Anyone else have relatives who do this?

364 replies

TheQueenOfWands · 07/04/2018 11:36

My mum just found an old, filthy, partially deflated football near my house.

It's now in my garden. The same garden which I've recently spent great time and expense tidying up and decorating.

Why? Well, I'll tell you why. Apparently a child will be 'overjoyed' to receive it once it's been cleaned up and reinflated. Also, there's too much stuff in landfill so it's obviously not on to simply throw it out.

Today is my only day off from work. I worked 72 hours last week and 50 this week. I have no interest in laundering footballs and don't have a clue how I'd reinflate it. I also don't know any children, let alone any who would be overjoyed to receive a vaguely scrubbed, badly inflated foot ball.

This isn't the first time she's done this. My parents do this quite a lot.

It's such a shame to throw something out so obviously I have to make use of it or DS would be thrilled with it.

Aaargh!!

Doesn't help that I've recently been decluttering (much love to Marie Kondo) and am happy doing so.

They know this. Yet are still determine to fill my house with crap or visibly recoil when they see me give/throw something away.

OP posts:
StealthPolarBear · 08/04/2018 13:06

Each would you be able to ask a couple of friends to support you when the time comes. It will be so much easier for someone not involved to make judgement calls of what to do with stuff

Easilyflattered · 08/04/2018 12:55

Also I don't think it's just an old person thing.

There's a family nearish me where the parents just bought endless stuff at carboot sales and filled their house with it. Stuff was stored in the bath so the kids weren't bathed often, they sat on the stairs to eat dinner because they couldn't sit anywhere else. It was enough for the health visitor to tip off social services to intervene for the children's sake.

Grandmaswagsbag · 08/04/2018 12:40

Omg I was thinking of starting a thread asking if anyone else has to put up with this! My mil is a ridiculous hoarder to the point she has to rent a barn to store all her crap. And it really is old crap. She constantly brings stuff over for us and I don’t want any of it and take most of it to charity or chuck it tbh but I just can’t work up the courage to tell her we don’t want more stuff. Small house , too many people already, we just DONT WANT ANY MORE STUFF!!

myusernamewastakenbyme · 08/04/2018 12:37

My ex was a hoarder...i let him have the double garage but stuff kept creeping into the house...when we split i was delighted to get rid of the crap...and even now 4 years on im still decluttering.

SapphireSeptember · 08/04/2018 12:36

My in laws are hoarders, MIL gets it from her parents who never throw anything away, even food, and MIL is the same way. Husband has hoarding tendancies, BIL's room looks like a rubbish tip. I once put something of mine in the small recycling bin under the stairs, and MIL fished it out and said she was keeping it as it might be useful. Of course, now I can't find it to get rid of it agsin as it's disappeared under all the other junk (now anything goes straight into the big one outside). I also went through my stuff and got rid of loads and she was shocked I was throwing away birthday cards from when I was 18! There was no point in me keeping them, I hadn't looked at them for years. I think the longer I live with them the more ruthless I'm getting, recently I've charity shopped a load of stuff I no longer want or need, it felt good. (I just don't tell anyone about it.)

Gwenhwyfar · 08/04/2018 12:28

" there are some collections that are probably worth £10,000 or more each"

You have to also think of the cost of having a house and shed big enough to keep all the stuff though.
Sorry you're so upset. I definitely see how you can't throw away things that are worth so much money.

peacheachpearplum · 08/04/2018 12:15

The other thing is that his stuff isn't all shit, there are some collections that are probably worth £10,000 or more each and that actually oppresses me even more. I always say if he dies before me it is all going in a skip but can I really just throw away £40 or £50k worth of stuff? Probably not so I will have to try and sort it and sell it and I feel like crying now.

peacheachpearplum · 08/04/2018 12:13

Gwenhwyfar I did agree, it was on the basis that it was going to be part of him sorting things out, and he does want to, but he can't help himself. After over 30 years of trying to help him I've given up all hope of it being sorted and I don't go in the rooms, shed, garages, loft where it all is. If I think about it I could cry so I try not to think about it. I'm actually feeling quite overwhelmed just talking about it on here although it is comforting to know it isn't just me.

Gwenhwyfar · 08/04/2018 12:09

Peach - I presume you agreed to the shed being built especially to keep shit in though?

Tansie1 · 08/04/2018 12:09

I've skipped to the end, but this is an interesting thread!

I have quite well off work colleagues who actually throw grown-out-of baby and toddler things in the bin, expensive JL stuff that is still perfectly OK just out-grown, because they can't be arsed to take it to a charity shop, and we all live no distance from areas where there are folk who really would be only to happy to buy the stuff from charity shops, like I used to when mine were small. One was slightly discombobulated when she casually asked if my DSs would like her older DS's 'old' T shirts (designer, note!) and I said Yes Please! My boys were genuinely delighted, especially as the shirts looked slightly worn in. I've received quite a few hand-me-downs for her as a result, Next hoodies and shorts etc. She's glad not to be binning it, I'm gla dto be not buying it!

However, that's different to a scruffy deflated football!

My IL used to do a slightly similar thing. FIL used to be a fruit and veg wholesaler, so when they came to visit us (frequently...) they'd call into the big fruit and veg barns en route and snap up bargains, like 6 cabbages or 10 kg of carrots etc; they'd keep what they wanted and present us (me and DH, no DC at the time) with the rest, thus I found myself with 5 cabbages to use up, and 8 kg of carrots etc.

Thanks, but....

peacheachpearplum · 08/04/2018 12:08

It's all hoarding.
Piles and piles of old newspapers in a tidy room is still hoarding even if it's not as bas as the houses that we've seen on hoarding programmes on TV. The guy who lost weight because he couldn't get into his own kitchen is more extreme, but the person who keeps old empty packaging is also hoarding.

There might also be a partner (me) fighting it. My husband hoards it is in his office, his bedroom (no space for me in there any more) a large shed that was specially built, 4 garages and loft.

The rule is the rest of the house is not hoarding space. It does creep out and then we have a row and it gets moved. I have no doubt the whole house would be the same without me constantly fighting it.

frasier · 08/04/2018 12:01

MIL is very much into family assets and nothing to charity. She asked me what I wanted for my birthday once and I was involved in a huge fundraiser for a charity at the time and said a donation to the charity would be fantastic. It didn't have to be money, we were selling things online, having a bake sale, doing loads of different things. She refused.

Gwenhwyfar · 08/04/2018 11:55

Easily - I sort of get it - my DM wears our old school uniforms from over 30 years ago because they shouldn't go to waste, but I don't know to what extent you should be humouring her with this 'asset staying in the family thing'.
Would she find out if you just took them to the shop?

Easilyflattered · 08/04/2018 11:51

Gwenhwyfar giving the clothes to a charity shop would be letting the "asset" of these clothes leave the family, the money would be gone.

Whilst my mum likes to give stuff to me and other members of the family and will lend us money happily, she's not especially generous charity wise.

She grew up in real poverty. I think she holds a real fear that she will be poor again (unlikely) and also a sense of bitterness that she had that upbringing.

She once fished a dried up roll on deodorant out of my bin as a teenager and gave me a real lecture on how wasteful I was and insisted on using it herself.

Gwenhwyfar · 08/04/2018 11:33

"In unison they have a sort of hive mind and if you don't agree your very wrong."

I think you have to be brave enough to be unpopular otherwise you will be forever doing what they tell you to do.
The poster above who couldn't say no to her DM because the DM would tell people she was horrible. Well, so what? Life is not a popularity contest.

Gwenhwyfar · 08/04/2018 11:27

"His father was the same, as is his brother. I'm starting to wonder if there's a genetic element!"

Learned behaviour rather than genetic surely.
I hate hoarding and though I was the opposite, but have been accused of keeping some stuff as well so maybe you're view of normal is skewed if you come from a hoarding family.

Gwenhwyfar · 08/04/2018 11:23

"brand new clothes that don't actually fit me, she gets irritated with me that they don't fit me, despite the fact that they were never originally bought with me in mind. I feel obligated to keep this useless stuff despite not having much space in my house."

Why not give it to a charity shop for someone of the right size to enjoy. Wouldn't your DM want the clothes to be used?

Adversecamber22 · 08/04/2018 11:15

We were meeting up with MIL at a holiday home we had all rented for a week. She turned up with a dining table and four chairs in her car, I have no idea how she squeezed them in. She hadn't asked us if we wanted them , I refused to take them. DH really fretted we would offend her.

It's reasons like this I'm seen as very difficult by DH family. In unison they have a sort of hive mind and if you don't agree your very wrong.

Gwenhwyfar · 08/04/2018 11:13

"There's hoarding - lots of bits and pieces and there's real hoarding.

If you've ever experienced real hoarding, you'll not mistake it. I am talking about homes where you literally cannot see the carpet, or open the door of some rooms, such is the level of hoarding."

It's all hoarding.
Piles and piles of old newspapers in a tidy room is still hoarding even if it's not as bas as the houses that we've seen on hoarding programmes on TV. The guy who lost weight because he couldn't get into his own kitchen is more extreme, but the person who keeps old empty packaging is also hoarding.

Tawdrylocalbrouhaha · 08/04/2018 11:12

Sometimes you have to treat the symptoms if you can't treat the cause though don't you.

I really agree with this. There currently seems to be no effective treatment for hoarding, but that doesn't mean the hoarder should just be left in ever increasing squalor.

Sarawish · 08/04/2018 11:03

I find hoarding fascinating and infuriating.
My GP hoard and frequently attempt to offload stuff my way. I just bin it. I used to refuse it but they give it to my sons instead and then I become anxious as I can’t then throw it away.
My sibling hoards to a lesser degree but is very defensive about it and also quite nasty to me as they are jealous of my clutter free home.

I grew up with this hoarding and am now ultra minimalist. I love to throw stuff out. I am sure this is a reaction to my upbringing.

It is almost a challenge to my GPS to get me to accept stuff. A neve4 ending ongoing cycle of control.

Gwenhwyfar · 08/04/2018 11:00

"Getting rid of the clutter doesn't get rid of the problem if it's due to a mental health problem. "

It will take them some time to build up the hoard again though and in the mean time, the place will be less of a fire hazard.

"The mental health problem needs addressed or you could be doing more harm than good. "

Are these issues easy to solve though? It's not like there's a tablet you can take and then you'll be fine, or you talk to someone about why you hoard and then it's all over. Sometimes you have to treat the symptoms if you can't treat the cause though don't you.

tiredmummy1991 · 08/04/2018 10:59

My mil does this all the time, every time they visit she brings a bag of things for us and the DC that nobody particularly wants so I've started asking the DC in front of them if they want to keep the stuff at home or let me take it so they have something at their house for them when we visit. The DC very rarely want the things at home to use.

Gwenhwyfar · 08/04/2018 10:50

"I have read that in severe cases hoarding can be considered a form of OCD- it is compulsive fear of not having enough or having strong inexplicable attachments to random-seeming junk Eveforever so yeah, I think you have a point."

Yes, it can be OCD and I don't think it has to be extreme for that either. It's ironic because people associate OCD with being clean and tidy, but hoarders are usually neither of those.

Gwenhwyfar · 08/04/2018 10:40

" They are also the sort of people that take the sugar packets and spare serviettes home with them when they have a meal out."

I do that sometimes. If I buy a big pack of sugar for guests it just gets hard so the little sachets are quite useful. Nothing to do with hoarding.

Swipe left for the next trending thread