Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fecking hoarding by proxy. Anyone else have relatives who do this?

364 replies

TheQueenOfWands · 07/04/2018 11:36

My mum just found an old, filthy, partially deflated football near my house.

It's now in my garden. The same garden which I've recently spent great time and expense tidying up and decorating.

Why? Well, I'll tell you why. Apparently a child will be 'overjoyed' to receive it once it's been cleaned up and reinflated. Also, there's too much stuff in landfill so it's obviously not on to simply throw it out.

Today is my only day off from work. I worked 72 hours last week and 50 this week. I have no interest in laundering footballs and don't have a clue how I'd reinflate it. I also don't know any children, let alone any who would be overjoyed to receive a vaguely scrubbed, badly inflated foot ball.

This isn't the first time she's done this. My parents do this quite a lot.

It's such a shame to throw something out so obviously I have to make use of it or DS would be thrilled with it.

Aaargh!!

Doesn't help that I've recently been decluttering (much love to Marie Kondo) and am happy doing so.

They know this. Yet are still determine to fill my house with crap or visibly recoil when they see me give/throw something away.

OP posts:
ClaraSais · 08/04/2018 18:04

Both my dearest parents were hoarders. My mum was a WW2 child (I'm writing up her memoirs) My house and shed I've had to clear, the latter still full of obsolete electronics that dad doesn't want to get rid off.

Eddie1940 · 08/04/2018 17:59

I ve got a garage full of shit belonging to my soon to be ex husbands ex partner . Taken on when she emotionally blackmailed him in front of the children . In the last 6 months of our relationship she sent more and more crap to our house - filling up the cupboards and dsd claimed to have emotional attachment to it all - including ie Tupperware . A major factor in our separating.

Bugjune · 08/04/2018 17:49

Your mum sounds kind of sweet!

TheQueenOfWands · 08/04/2018 17:39

Easily I moved a few towns away but they moved..!

This is really digging up some shit for me. I have work in 2 hours and I'm now a nervous wreck. Really, really just want to curl up and whimper.

The football was very much the cherry on the cake.

OP posts:
NerNerNerNerBATMAN · 08/04/2018 17:13

DH isn't a hoarder as such but definitely struggles to get rid of things. He's significantly improved since having to sort his parents stuff out upon their death. He'd hate for our DC to have to go through that amount of STUFF as it genuinely is a burden. No one needs 40 years worth of their GPs accounting files (kept by FIL).

A few of my friends have MIL horror stories similar to these:

  • one whose MIL presented her with her DHs baby teeth that she'd kept for 30+ years. Friends DC were teething and her MIL thought she might like them Hmm MIL had kept EVERYTHING from her DC childhood
  • one whose PIL also kept EVERYTHING from their DC childhood and will present them with half completed colouring books, very large and unsuitable kids furniture. They never ask if it's wanted, just present it as a fait acompli that it would be wanted and gratefully received. Friends house is small, these items are HUGE.
  • another whose PIL let themselves in whenever they want and potter about redecorating, going through their stuff. Absolutely no boundaries. They even found a house they thought she and her DH should buy and kept on and on at them until they eventually moved. Serious lack of boundaries. Friend is irritated by it but seems to think she is powerlessness to stop it
Easilyflattered · 08/04/2018 17:03

OP my controlling parents were a factor in why I chose to live on the other side of the world for five years.

They seem to have finally got the message. It is not normal for parents to be so involved, but it took me therapy to see this.

Occasionally a piece of mail addressed to me used to go to their house and they would open it "by mistake".

annandale · 08/04/2018 16:44

Spineless? Definitely not. Kind, gentle, yes. Most of us don't have to resist this sort of thing because NORMAL PEOPLE DON'T DO IT.

Given that you know it will happen, it is worth role playing how to hold your boundaries. Start by stating out loud to yourself 'it is normal to control who comes into my house' because this is normal, I assure you. None of my parents or in laws have keys to mine because it would never occur to them to ask. Then write down the things they have said to you about keys - make them up if you can't remember. Something like ' oh if we stop here you can get keys cut for us'? On another sheet, write some responses. 'No thanks' 'oh yes, I'm not falling for that one again [laugh]' stuff like that. Then literally practice with a friend so that you are prepared to actually say these things out loud. It takes some doing, if you are used to this complete steamrollering of your boundaries. Good luck.

betekoc · 08/04/2018 16:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TheQueenOfWands · 08/04/2018 16:14

Last time I changed the locks I was nagged and nagged for a key. I gave in during a weak moment.

The second time I claimed I lost my keys (cue losts of tutting about my carelessness and stupidity) and asked for hers which I then gave to friend who lives in the next street. She nagged and nagged for a key cut. One day we were out, passed a key cutting place and before I knew it I was handing my keys over to be cut. She even paid.

Not sure this time. Hopefully she might never find out.

The day they broke the gate they knew I was sleeping after a night shift so have no idea why they turned up and wanted to let themselves in.

I once woke up to find all of my bathroom stuff on the stairs because they'd decided to redecorate my bathroom with their left over paint.

There are no words. Now I write this down I feel like a spineless numpty.

OP posts:
YouTheCat · 08/04/2018 16:04

Queen, tbh it sounds like she's still emotionally abusive.

Get those locks changed and don't give her a key. What is she going to do about it?

TheQueenOfWands · 08/04/2018 16:00

This thread is actually opening a lot of stuff with me regarding my parents.

I should probably start a thread in relationships.

When she's here she'll often start sentences with stuff like, "What I want to do with your garden is..."

She always wants to take my stuff home and alter it. Goes on and on about how I need to knock various walls and stuff down even though I've said it's not what I want.

She was quite emotionally abusive throughout my childhood, teens and early twenties. She's packed it in now but it does seem the invasion of my home has taken over instead.

My dad is her enabler. He has a few boundary issues himself but nothing like her. But he will protect her and do what keeps her quiet. Hence my back gate, she wanted in, he got her in.

OP posts:
AuroraBora · 08/04/2018 15:52

Oh god. DH’s parents are the sorts to pass on stuff they won’t bin. It drives me mad. They clearly don’t want to deal with the emotional guilt of binning/selling/recycling/charity shopping their stuff, so offer it to us.

We got offered a rug that a client of FIL didn’t want anymore. DH took far too fucking long to say no, even with me saying “I don’t want someone else’s rug, I want to pick my own!” for 3 days straight.

We also mentioned we might treat ourselves to new sofas as our current one is old and tired. But of course they might be replacing their (good condition, not that old) sofas, so guess what?! We can have theirs!!! No! We’re in our 30s, I’m treating myself to brand new sofas!

I think they think we’re still skint students too.

Qwertytypewriter · 08/04/2018 15:51

My ex used to have the whole garage +2 sheds full of clutter; he had an idea that he would do some great woodworking projects in one of the sheds when he got it, but he filled it with stuff, and it was somehow all my fault he never got to doing the woodwork Hmm....

When he left he took a small part of it, because his new partner refused to have it...she also refused to accept that he had collected it all, and saw it as me being untidy, which I thought quite funny.
8 years later, he still thought he'd remove the rest eventually, but just not quite yet! I had to give him a date to do it by (which he didn't), then dispose of it.

bitmynailbrokemytooth · 08/04/2018 15:48

My DM and DF do this. The other day DM brought round a small metal bobbin which she had found at her home, because it goes with my sewing machine; she gave me her reconditioned old sewing machine years ago when she got herself a fancy new one. I was glad of it at the time, because we had moved house and I was making a few sets of curtains.

DH pointed out that my sewing machine has been sitting in the garage for 6 years now. It's true that I don't use it. I bought the last pair of curtains I needed. I already have about 10-15 bobbins for it. DM held up the bobbin and said " I nearly threw it away ". Then she remembered it went with my machine. So near and yet so far ( from actually binning something ).

There have been bigger items than that, that was just the most recent and was thankfully very small. When they come round I look out of the window if I've heard their car arrive, and dread it when I see them opening the car boot. I wish they would just rock up empty-handed for a change.

I am also a hoarder. DH is not. The DC are not. In common with PPs I want to avoid leaving clutter for DC to deal with in future. I am also determined that if I am visiting them in their homes in future I will not be taking random crap round to them.

peacheach's username reminds me of DC's lovely old book which I have stashed up in the loft. I need to tackle the loft.

Juells · 08/04/2018 15:38

@NorbertTheDragon
In the end I had to tell the council I couldn't do it. I'm having to pay them monthly instalments for the charge of them clearing it all out and decorating it

How were you responsible for it? I don't understand.

SickofThomasTheTank · 08/04/2018 15:28
Wink
SickofThomasTheTank · 08/04/2018 15:28

Tell her to take anything else she brings to the charity shop! Not only will a child be thrilled with it, but a charity will benefit! It's a win win...win! Hmm

IntelligentYetIndecisive · 08/04/2018 15:13

The other thing is that his stuff isn't all shit, there are some collections that are probably worth £10,000 or more each ........ I always say if he dies before me it is all going in a skip but can I really just throw away £40 or £50k worth of stuff? Probably not so I will have to try and sort it and sell it and I feel like crying now.

Is that how much he's spent on it? Or is that what it's currently worth?

Spending huge amounts on stuff and then 'storing' it in a shed is almost guaranteed to lose thousands of £££££.

In reality, most hoarders gather stuff together, cram it all into whatever space is available and then let it all rot.

No thought is given to storage conditions (damp, dust, vermin, temperature etc), fragile items get crushed under the weight of old machine parts, fabric disintegrates, paper fades and yellows and even plastic disintegrates into shards over time.

It may have been worth thousands at one point, but it could be worth fuck all now.

Fads and fashions change, so some collectibles are only worth a lot during the fashionable 'phase' are worthless now and will never be wanted (and worth something) again.

NorbertTheDragon · 08/04/2018 14:13

My mum died last year and I had 28 days to clear the rubbish from her council place. Impossible as I live 150 miles away and am a carer for my disabled son.

I took as much stuff as I could manage - photos, childhood stuff and some brand new in box furniture (she was always buying stuff from catalogues she had no need for. At one point she had three dining table & chair sets - for 1 person!)

In the end I had to tell the council I couldn't do it. I'm having to pay them monthly instalments for the charge of them clearing it all out and decorating it (she was a heavy smoker so the walls and ceilings were yellow)

I was a bit of a hoarder too but I'm not going to do that to my kids, so I'm slowly decluttering.

Sprinklesinmyelbow · 08/04/2018 14:13

My MIL does this. Another reallly frustrating things she does is insisting I return goods constantly. My daughter ripped her dress last week. She insisted that I return it to the shop despite being told 1. I have no receipt 2. It was in the same and 3. It was in perfect condition when bought. She basically ended up shouting at me to do it then in desperation said she would do it. I refused and hours later she phoned me to tell me to do it again

She told me to return balloons that deflated too quickly yesterday

LittleCandle · 08/04/2018 14:06

XH had a bit of a tendency to keep things. When we parted company and I was emptying the house, I had to get a skip (thank goodness I knew someone with a skip hire company!) to dump the shit from the loft. There were old computer games that would only play on DOS. All my LPs were there, but he had stacked them wrongly and they were all misshapen, so I couldn't even sell them. He had placed a bag of DM's Christmas decorations on the floor of the loft and then stepped on them (I was rarely up there, so know it wasn't me!) and they were in smithereens. There were a couple of Z beds that DM had loaned us and were never returned - the list goes on. There were three of us skipping it in a relay. I was in the loft and DD2 and a neighbour were trotting backwards and forwards dumping stuff.

thecatsarecrazy · 08/04/2018 13:56

My mum does things like this. Her partners mum still had a load of his old toys so she brought them round for my sons. I had 2 parts of a broken helicopter once, a rugby ball covered in pen. Various old cars. Once it was just as we were about to move house. She had a clear out. I said thanks mum but we are really short on space as it is and we need to have a clear out too

concretesieve · 08/04/2018 13:48

This thread is Shock

Gin and Flowers to all.

JazzHotBaby · 08/04/2018 13:34

There is one MNer who has several relatives that are determined to fill her house with crap to hoarding levels then complain about the state of it. They fill it faster than she can get rid, it's so extreme it's actually a form of abusive control.

As a single parent her and the DC don't deserve anything new or nice and she should be grateful for the literal rubbish they dump on her...

Make that two MNers Random! My DM and DSis throw out clothes all the time, but try to pass them on to me. DSis throws out newer, nicer stuff, sometimes still with tags, so that's ok. But DM often tries to give me old/unflattering/scratchy stuff then gets upset and offended if I say no thanks. So then I never wear it, I have two wardrobes that can't accommodate all my shit, of which I only wear a fraction, and when DM insists I have a clear out she gets offended again when she finds I'm keeping stuff of hers that I don't like and never wear, "Why didn't you just say no thanks?"
"I did, you got upset."
"Well, it was probably how you said it."
Sometimes she even takes stuff back home with her!!!

I'm trying to drop one bin bag per week at the charity shop. If she doesnt see the stuff again she won't remember what she did with it and I can pretend she never gave it to me.

annandale · 08/04/2018 13:23

Peach, the fact that you want to cry thinking about it and there are no-go areas in your own house just shows what a huge burden the hoarding is on you even though in theory you have been able to police your boundaries. That's extremely tough.

I do promise you that as and when you have to deal with the stuff, people would love to help you and will do it in a gentle way. But yes, it will be an emotional process and you should accept all the help you can manage. I can say that people like auctioneers are really lovely, they are used to dealing with this sort of thing and at least some of it will be much easier than you think.