Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fecking hoarding by proxy. Anyone else have relatives who do this?

364 replies

TheQueenOfWands · 07/04/2018 11:36

My mum just found an old, filthy, partially deflated football near my house.

It's now in my garden. The same garden which I've recently spent great time and expense tidying up and decorating.

Why? Well, I'll tell you why. Apparently a child will be 'overjoyed' to receive it once it's been cleaned up and reinflated. Also, there's too much stuff in landfill so it's obviously not on to simply throw it out.

Today is my only day off from work. I worked 72 hours last week and 50 this week. I have no interest in laundering footballs and don't have a clue how I'd reinflate it. I also don't know any children, let alone any who would be overjoyed to receive a vaguely scrubbed, badly inflated foot ball.

This isn't the first time she's done this. My parents do this quite a lot.

It's such a shame to throw something out so obviously I have to make use of it or DS would be thrilled with it.

Aaargh!!

Doesn't help that I've recently been decluttering (much love to Marie Kondo) and am happy doing so.

They know this. Yet are still determine to fill my house with crap or visibly recoil when they see me give/throw something away.

OP posts:
babyface · 09/04/2018 10:01

Well, you could always turn it into art 😂😂www.apartmenttherapy.com/waste-not-by-song-dong-the-mus-89327

LotsToThinkOf · 09/04/2018 09:17

My mum does this, as does my sister now who has learned the behaviour from her (SEN) and it drives me mad.

They work in a charity shop, so every week they buy 'presents' for the DC which are always thoughtful but it's too frequent. Often it's versions of things we already have or have got rid of. I've asked them to reduce the frequency but they don't, I end up using a different charity shop to offload it all.

I've given them several bags of stuff to take to the shop with them in the past, hardly any of it made it there and they have most of it in their house - old cushions, vases, items of clothing that aren't even in their sizes. I've stopped giving them things now and I just take things myself to a different shop (they'd just go in the bags at the shop and buy it back).

The most recent purchase was a nest of tables which were definitely not needed (they have 3 tables in their living room already). She'd managed to get them back to the house but then moving them in the house proved too much and lumps of wood were falling off exposing nails. This still wasn't enough to get rid of them, DM went out and bought super glue. More wood fell off, exposing yet another nail and my 2 year old was sitting at it. I picked it up and put it on the boot of my car for the tip. DM didn't speak to me for a week.

They have 4 bedrooms but only 2 can be used because the others are full of junk, as is the loft. Every time I sort things out with them they just rescue more stuff from various other people and from the shop. It's irritating, especially when they then say they have no money and when I spend time I haven't got to absolutely no avail.

I've tried everything, so I've given up.

Peregrina · 09/04/2018 09:13

My late DM kept every single birthday and Christmas card since her wedding in 1948. Plus "get well after your operation" cards for DGM (who died not long after the operation.) This despite a half dozen or so house moves. The 'get well' cards I found particularly upsetting when clearing out the house - they were a reminder of a failed operation and the painful last days of DGM. Why on earth keep those? Keeping one or two especially nice cards OK - a friend of theirs used to paint and would sent a small hand painted card - so worth keeping, but the other stuff????

Flisspaps · 09/04/2018 08:45

*entirely possible

Flisspaps · 09/04/2018 08:43

@YearOfYouRemember it's entirely your DC will not want to use a cot or pram that's been stored for so long - even for visits.

They may well want to choose their own for many reasons - style, cleanliness, practicality, size, comfort.

It may be more practical to have a folding travel cot when the time comes.

Re the USB stick, it's really easy to get the hang of.

Don't try to find excuses for hanging on (my Dad does this!)

Spudlet · 09/04/2018 08:42

PiLs (just FiL as MiL sadly passed away last year) started bringing DHs school stuff over pretty much as soon as we moved in together. They started arriving with bags and bags of ancient exercise books and school reports!

The last lot that FIL brought over really annoyed me, as they were DHs A-level reports - which were not a happy time for DH. He has done well in life since but he was a bit deflated to be reminded of a time when he failed. We burnt them (turns out 20+ year old paper makes good fire starting material) but it did annoy me that we needed to. I don't know why we would ever want this stuff.

We also have a small heap of junk in the garage, some of which was originally acquired by DHs grandmother, was palmed off onto MiL, and has now migrated to us 🙄 There's a bloody ugly set of crystal glasses in a box - I nearly smashed them trying to get to some garden tools the other day, and I kind of wish I had, except that I'd have then have had to clean it up.

Small potatoes compared to many of the stories on here, but it is so annoying sometimes! But I almost feel it's like they started clearing the decks as a way to prepare for MiL dying (it was cancer, so she knew it was coming) and FiL has just sort of carried on with it, maybe as part of grieving. So I don't say anything.

OP - as well as changing your locks, get a chain fitted to your door. And if they try battering your gate again, you could always call the police and say you didn't realise it was your parents... well, I suppose you shouldn't really, but it's a satisfying picture to imagine!

notanurse2017 · 09/04/2018 08:38

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

MorrisZapp · 09/04/2018 08:30

My mum is just ridiculous. She recently downsized her house and it took me and my three adult siblings six months to get her home in anything close to selling condition. Car load after car load to the dump and charity shop. In the end, we gave up trying to get her to say what she wanted done with her stuff and had no choice but to fling it in boxes which are now in her new garage.

Whenever she needs anything, she buys it again as she 'doesn't know where anything is' as her wretched children put it all in boxes.

I. Give. Up.

JustDanceAddict · 09/04/2018 08:09

Dh’s parents were like this. It annoyed me as they’d just lump crap onto him - I asked him why he accepted it and he said ‘it’s less hassle then telling them I don’t want it.’ He’d then give to charity, etc.

MrsCrabbyTree · 09/04/2018 08:07

My dad (when he was alive) and my stepmother used to force things on me to take home ..... on the plane. They refused to believe there is a limit to carry on luggage, and no matter how 'valuable or nice or delicate' it was impossible to transport these treasures on my lap. I offloaded everything into airport bins and as they never visited me if was an easy secret to keep from them.

Alleycat1 · 09/04/2018 08:02

I am drowning in paper thanks to a friend who can't resist bringing me articles cut out of magazines and newspapers that she thinks I will find interesting. I have asked her repeatedly to stop and just to tell me about these 'interesting' things. A few weeks ago I refused to accept a pile of papers and when I was out she posted them through the letterbox. She is completely normal otherwise and a good friend so it's a bit awkward.

YearOfYouRemember · 09/04/2018 08:00

Ridiculously I think I'm keeping the pram and cot for the grandchildren to use when noted visit. The USB stick with photos of stuff is a good idea but dh would have to do it as I'm tech rubbish. I'm keeping all their books though. I had five books from childhood, 49p and 75p, and the same books are about £6 now so won't pay £12 to buy same again for the grandchildren.

Shucks. I think I'm projecting my childhood onto my dc and future GC.

YearOfYouRemember · 09/04/2018 07:53

RandomMess I suppose it says it all that they'd chuck stuff I think they should keep. DC want to keep the 2200+ letters and cards they've received from PIL. It's amazing how much space flat letters take up.

Sunshinewater · 09/04/2018 07:42

All you need to do is casually mention before next handover, that you have had a big clean up and never again. From now on you are being more minimalist. If they go to do it afterwards, remind them that you have had a clean out and you don’t want to hoard stuff anymore.

MyOtherProfile · 09/04/2018 04:54

Oh my goodness I've found my people. My mother is like so many of the ones here. She always arrives for a stay with a car load of stuff for us that we just don't want. Her own house is full to the rafters. It's definitely some kind of mental health thing. Some of it is a drive to collect stuff. When ds was little someone gave him a wooden elephant. He loved it and started a little collection which has grown over the years to about 10 ornamental elephants which each have a significance. My mum went on a mad drive when he started his collection and now has a table in her hallway with about 40 ornamental elephants on, bought from charity shops and who knows where. She's not the least bit interested in elephants and frankly it looks silly having this massive collection in her hallway but she clearly thought collecting elephants was the thing to do and became obsessive abiut it for a while.
And the presents we have had over the years! My dc now always accept them with a smile then give them to me to dispose of as soon as she has gone.

So much of my life has been spent dealing with her obsessive gathering of things and attempts to share them with me.

Jamiefraserskilt · 09/04/2018 00:55

My mum and I go to the same charity shop.
Her house is hoard free.
Mine is full of her hoard.
Had a clear out today.
Let's hope she doesn't visit the shop this week!

mathanxiety · 09/04/2018 00:42

Eveforever
If you are dealing with a person with a mental health disorder, throwing items away just to get a negative reaction out of a person i.e. to see them get upset or distressed, seems to be a passive aggressive or cruel thing to do imo.

Discussing why the item is useless and should be discarded (with a possible conversation about their mental health) then throwing the item away and getting a negative reaction is an attempt at being constructive.

This disorder is characterised by imperviousness to what others say about their habit and its effects, and dogged adherence to the hoarder's own way of seeing things.

The people on the receiving end have little use trying to discuss reasons why each individual item must be thrown out. To focus on each individual item is a form of enabling because this is how the hoarder is approaching the growing of the hoard too. It's all one little bit on top of another. It's not constructive to address the flaws of each item. The problem is not that each item is flawed.

Letting off steam a little when faced with yet another piece of junk, throwing it out then and there, or saying a flat, "No, and if you don't throw it out right now I will," will do absolutely no good, but it will do no harm either, and the person on the receiving end might feel a little better for being straightforward.

Hoarders are as resistant to bald statements that they have a problem as they are to gentle suggestions and repeated hints. It's all water off a duck's back to them. The person they are trying to foist the junk onto might as well be hung for a sheep as a lamb therefore.

There is no harm in honestly addressing what is right there in front of you, causing you distress. You don't have to get angry. You don't have to slam dunk the item into the bin.

Mxyzptlk · 09/04/2018 00:30

And snoop around their house? And smash their garden gate, Abbylee?

Abbylee · 09/04/2018 00:08

I have been quite poor. I hesitate to throw things out bc when you've been poor, you do not forget it.

Instead of being so harsh, think of it as what it is: fear and insecurity about the future.

If the ball is a problem, simply toss it when she leaves and say you have given it to charity. Mothers are people, we aren't on earth to annoy you...well most of us....occasionally when we think you're too full of yourself, we might wind you up...for your own good.Grin

annandale · 08/04/2018 23:53

PJs used to be seen as quite naughty I think. My parents never came downstairs in their PJs and would no more have gone to the supermarket in them than they would have had sex on telly.

IntelligentYetIndecisive · 08/04/2018 23:44

If you do want to keep your PJs out of sight, a fancy cushion cover would do the trick.....

RandomMess · 08/04/2018 22:50

Norks- I think they just looked nice??? Or didn't have to I make the bed (tucked in sheets etc) to dig your pjs out...

NorksAreMessy · 08/04/2018 22:49

But...but...but......

Why do you need to put pyjamas into a case at all? To stop them escaping? To hide them from burglars? To keep them warm? I don’t GET it.

Atthebottomofthesea · 08/04/2018 22:44

I would have made it into a planter or something.

Maybe my Mum's hoarding is rubbing off on me.

Atthebottomofthesea · 08/04/2018 22:41

Enamel crockery stashed in an outside toilet?

My bet would be on a guzunder or a chamber pot. Dad had one as they only had an outside toilet.