Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fecking hoarding by proxy. Anyone else have relatives who do this?

364 replies

TheQueenOfWands · 07/04/2018 11:36

My mum just found an old, filthy, partially deflated football near my house.

It's now in my garden. The same garden which I've recently spent great time and expense tidying up and decorating.

Why? Well, I'll tell you why. Apparently a child will be 'overjoyed' to receive it once it's been cleaned up and reinflated. Also, there's too much stuff in landfill so it's obviously not on to simply throw it out.

Today is my only day off from work. I worked 72 hours last week and 50 this week. I have no interest in laundering footballs and don't have a clue how I'd reinflate it. I also don't know any children, let alone any who would be overjoyed to receive a vaguely scrubbed, badly inflated foot ball.

This isn't the first time she's done this. My parents do this quite a lot.

It's such a shame to throw something out so obviously I have to make use of it or DS would be thrilled with it.

Aaargh!!

Doesn't help that I've recently been decluttering (much love to Marie Kondo) and am happy doing so.

They know this. Yet are still determine to fill my house with crap or visibly recoil when they see me give/throw something away.

OP posts:
alpacawhacker · 07/04/2018 12:38

My MIL used to do this. Her source was car boot sales. She once bought my son a second hand pair of pants at one, which was grim. She also used to try and offload all her unwanted old stuff on us. Sometimes she'd give me things I didn't want then ask for them back a few months down the line when I'd binned them. I soon learned to just say no to everything, which deflated her terribly.

She was the kind of person who likes to feel superior to others so I think it was all mind games serving to make her feel beneficient as well as making her feel superior because she would have had, to her mind, better stuff than us. If we bought something new she always wanted to know how much we had paid and then pointed out that we could have got it cheaper on the market or somewhere, trying to take the shine off. I remember once she acted all affronted that I had paid ten pounds for voile panels for my living room window when I could have got a net curtain on the market for about four pounds. Then she went and got herself a pair of custom made curtains for her front window that cost her about two hundred pounds. Hmm

AjasLipstick · 07/04/2018 12:36

My FIL does this....he picks up things off the road and brings them to me. He loves it...and so do I! Grin I am also a hoarder and love old shite.

He sees one old chair and grabs it "Ah! Aja will love this!" MIL is Hmm about it but I receive the old tat happily.

Eveforever · 07/04/2018 12:33

specialsubject or it could be a mental health problem. Hard to make even an educated guess from the information given.

IntelligentYetIndecisive · 07/04/2018 12:33

I have a toolkit.

I trash everything I don't need and seperate it into their component parts for recycling.

It's very therapeutic.

TheVastMajority · 07/04/2018 12:32

and my mother gave me nearly 200xCDs of religious music. And music books. And music scores.

Im tone deaf, not religious, and cannot play an instrument.

DarkDarkNight · 07/04/2018 12:31

My mum does this. She gave me a guilt complex for years about 'throwing away' perfectly good clothes (charity shop/recycling). I couldn't get rid because of the money I spent or because they were still in perfect condition.

I still have hoarding tendencies now that I am trying to get over. It is so mentally freeing to just get rid of stuff.

specialsubject · 07/04/2018 12:31

my parents are wartime children, they live with a lot more 'stuff' than I do but they don't pass on rubbish and have full understanding of the use of a bin and recycling.

this isn't 'war baby' this is either stupidity or idiocy.

TheFirstMrsOsmond · 07/04/2018 12:30

My step-mother was always giving me all sorts of old crap. To avoid conflict I would say thank you very much with a smile and throw it away after she'd left.

Tawdrylocalbrouhaha · 07/04/2018 12:30

I just wait until they are gone then bin it.

I love my parents dearly but their inability to chuck stuff out serves as a constant warning to me not to EVER EVER get like that. The worse their house gets, the more minimalist mine gets.

The worst thing is, when I suggest to my mum that she needs a clear out (I am the queen of understatement), she just a) blames it all on my father and then b) reassures me that after they are dead I can hire a skip and get rid of it all. She says this like she is generously doing me a huge favour.

TheVastMajority · 07/04/2018 12:28

my dad and his garage.....

I knew he thought I was a bossy cow, so i just thought - I may as well be hung for a sheep as for a lamb, and ditched 90% of it. He grumbled and cursed. But 2 weeks later was laughing about how his daughter had sorted out all the mess and chucked away years of rubbish and how great it was.....

Next visit I intend to tackle the 10% remaining.

GaryBaldyBiscuit · 07/04/2018 12:27

My mum would do this if I let her :/ I did have to loose my shit with her at one point and she did take it in luckily!

If people don’t listen then just throw junk straight in the bin and keep a bag or box somewhere handy to keep charity shop stuff together to drop off once a month or something. The second one is good practice anyhow for keeping on top of getting rid of your own stuff you no longer need.

TheMaddHugger · 07/04/2018 12:27

@SeamstressfromTreacleMineRoad Sat 07-Apr-18 12:11:31
Bought up in the war I think has a lot to do with it

How old are you and your parents..? confused I'm 70 later this year - and I was born years after the war had finished..!

My parents were born in 1924 and definitely had this hoarding/ Proxy issue.

Yes, I blame the war. They had nothing and wasted nothing

GeorgeTheHippo · 07/04/2018 12:26

So you've binned it - haven't you??

Eveforever · 07/04/2018 12:26

Any sign of hoarding difficulties in your mum's house?

You can either firmly but politely refuse to take the items she gives you, or take them and discard them. Discarding them for her is probably the best option, because if she is having difficulties at home leaving her with the items is probably not helpful.

RunRabbitRunRabbit · 07/04/2018 12:25

Years ago I mentioned to my grandmother that I had a new pair of slippers that I really loved.

Next time I visited she gave me a bag full of slippers, some new some from jumble sales. That was a WTF moment. The one thing she knew I did not need was slippers.

It was symptomatic of her issues.

Frequency · 07/04/2018 12:24

My mother sort of does this. She doesn't bring things to my house, but if I have anything I want to get rid of, she refuses to let my dad help me with it to the tip, insisting she will 'upcycle' it and/or sell it.

I currently have two tables because the one I bought to upcycle myself and replace my old wrecked beyond repair one is still in bits in the living room waiting for her to upcycle the old one and sell it.

Ditto wardrobes. I have three. I only want one. Two are waiting to be upcycled by her.

I'm a broke single parent. Without my dad to help me move/dismantle things, I'm stuck. Fortunately, he has put his foot down now I'm moving and has given her two weeks to upcycle my old furniture and get it gone or he is helping me to the tip with it.

I don't think he realised just how much space her upcycling projects were taking up in my home until he came to help me move things to my new house.

OTOH, she is already trying to buy a garden table from a charity shop to store in my garden to be upcycled.

CocoPuffsInGodMode · 07/04/2018 12:23

So what if they visibly recoil when you get rid of stuff Confused. It's none of their business and if it really bothers them they're free to fill their own homes with crap.

If you haven't already put that ball in the bin do it right now! Left in the street it was going to end up in landfill so unless you're running some kind of large scale recycling centre from your living room you really can't take responsibility for everything that's thrown away in your town/city.

People don't stop doing this kind of shit while you go along with them. Boundaries and stop caring so much what someone else might think. In your home what you think goes.

CoolGirlsNeverGetAngry · 07/04/2018 12:22

This in spades!
My MIL went through a load of stuff we bagged up for charity and decided she wanted to keep it. And somehow it all ended up back in our house. I was fucking livid.
It went to charity in the end of course.

SomeonesRealName · 07/04/2018 12:20

I just see this as a kindness I do my parents they can’t throw anything away even small scraps of leftover food get foisted on me! I just bin everything and tell them I ate it used it or passed it on. They rarely ask to be fair - I think they are just hugely relieved to be free of the anxiety!

viques · 07/04/2018 12:18

I used to live next door to an otherwise sweet old lady who gave me "stuff". The landlord owned both houses and I knew she was his spy so had to keep on her right side. I used to have to sneak them to my friends house to put in her bin so Miss R didn't spot them in our bins.

Elledouble · 07/04/2018 12:18

Freudian I’ve had exactly the same! A novelty bucket of mediocre sauces, when I told them the ONE I’d really really love but apparently it “didn’t seem like enough” Confused

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 07/04/2018 12:16

Hoarding is horrible... At its worse completely wrecks relationships....

Hoarders rarely come independently for treatment... It's often family members who are at their wit's end!

Elledouble · 07/04/2018 12:15

My in laws are like this. Quantity over quality, always. Bags full of charity shop crap. They have to ask everyone they know if they want something before they throw it out. No, no-one wants your broken, cat-scratched chair. Take it to the tip.

Freudian · 07/04/2018 12:12

This behaviour drives me nuts and its hereditary it seems ! MIL is a hoarder and so is some of her offspring. We keep quite decluttered but are overwhelmed with crap during visits. This also happens at Christmas with gifts.

I like hot sauces so i received a novelty pack of 30 hot sauces from some online catalog... it cost £40. All of them were disgusting and went into the bin. Now a decent quality hot sauce would be like £6 and much more appreciated. Who has room for 30 sauces ?

SeamstressfromTreacleMineRoad · 07/04/2018 12:11

Bought up in the war I think has a lot to do with it

How old are you and your parents..? Confused I'm 70 later this year - and I was born years after the war had finished..!