Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fecking hoarding by proxy. Anyone else have relatives who do this?

364 replies

TheQueenOfWands · 07/04/2018 11:36

My mum just found an old, filthy, partially deflated football near my house.

It's now in my garden. The same garden which I've recently spent great time and expense tidying up and decorating.

Why? Well, I'll tell you why. Apparently a child will be 'overjoyed' to receive it once it's been cleaned up and reinflated. Also, there's too much stuff in landfill so it's obviously not on to simply throw it out.

Today is my only day off from work. I worked 72 hours last week and 50 this week. I have no interest in laundering footballs and don't have a clue how I'd reinflate it. I also don't know any children, let alone any who would be overjoyed to receive a vaguely scrubbed, badly inflated foot ball.

This isn't the first time she's done this. My parents do this quite a lot.

It's such a shame to throw something out so obviously I have to make use of it or DS would be thrilled with it.

Aaargh!!

Doesn't help that I've recently been decluttering (much love to Marie Kondo) and am happy doing so.

They know this. Yet are still determine to fill my house with crap or visibly recoil when they see me give/throw something away.

OP posts:
Eveforever · 07/04/2018 14:18

CocoPuffsInGodMode I never suggested that people should 'allow' another person's mental health issue to impact their lives, although, as with many other illnesses, it undoubtedly will have some impact on friends and relatives. I also agree that people should decide what should go into their own homes, which why in my first post on this thread I suggest saying no to her mother, or taking the items, but throwing them away. I disagree that supporting someone with a mental health issue is akin to putting their feelings above our own. A mental issue is not a feeling.

The point I was trying to make is that aiming to get someone who is possibly suffering from a mental health problem to recoil is cruel and I cannot see how that could be helpful.

I didn't say that playing along and acting like the behaviour is perfectly fine is the way to go. If I thought my mother had a mental health problem I would be encouraging her to go to her GP and trying to read up on the disorder with the particular aim of finding out I can help and how I could deal with the problem.

Hoarding is a distressing disorder for the sufferers and their loved ones. However, I have already mentioned that sufferers typically have poor insight into the problem, so they may not be ignoring the problem, it could be they don't see it. It could also be that they don't know how to handle the situation, hoarding can be a very overwhelming problem.

Raver84 · 07/04/2018 14:15

Mil Is like this buys loads for the kids from junk shops, but I havr 4 children and she like to be 'fair" so if one get a charity shop book, the other three get one each. If one gets a shit toy I end up with 3 others. I have put my foot down many times and I think it's put a huge strain on our relationship as I dread seeing her as we get more stuff shoved at us and i always look mean saying I don't want it. She goes through stages of respecting my wishes and then like this week things start creeping back up she turned up this week with three massive sticker boos a puppet three tops and a bag. All of which I told her to keep if she done to every week which she would happily do afyer a month I'd have to find space for over 30 items if not more. It's not fun and this is my house. I don't want other people's crap.

AnnieAnoniMouser · 07/04/2018 14:14

Teacuphiccup. She really needs help. I think you’ve grown so used to it you only see it as a bit weird, when in fact, it’s very weird. Very sad too.

My Mum is mid ‘70’s & my Dad would have been too. They are very much post war minded. However, they are/we’re both very good at organising things and being tidy. My Dad’s garage/workshop is really full, but incredibly tidy and organised. There’s always exactly the bit of wood you need or that odd sized screw. All labelled. My Dad died unexpectedly several years ago and my Mum is now sorting her/their things out, which is very hard, but it’s going to destroy me sorting my Dad’s workshop/garage out.

Being ‘Wartime babies’ doesn’t mean hoarding any old shit, it means being careful with useful things and storing them properly so you can find them to use them in the future.

AnnabelleLecter · 07/04/2018 14:12

My dmum once tried to give me a clown pyjama holder she won in a raffle Smile
I reminded her I can't stand clowns and firmly said no thanks.
I don't know who invents unnecesssary shite like pyjama holders anyway.

Peregrina · 07/04/2018 14:11

Yes, I blame the war. They had nothing and wasted nothing

Not necessarily. DF was born in 1917 and DM in 1921. DM was a shocking hoarder, DF something of a minimalist. DF was the one who grew up the more impoverished. DM's family were 'comfortable' and didn't want for much.

biscuitaddict · 07/04/2018 14:03

My DGM lives next door to us and has a shopping/ hoarding thing. She gives me everything from packets of vegetables to pans to canvas prints - then guilt trips me if I say no. I massively offends her if I decline. Drives me nuts!!

spontaneousgiventime · 07/04/2018 14:03

I am dreading the time when she dies, and it falls to me (only child) to sort through her things.

Yep. While I don't plan on shuffling off this mortal coil just yet I've got rid of almost all my cutter so my DC don't have to much of a job when I do. I think all older parents should, it's not fair on our DC.

User09876543321126 · 07/04/2018 14:02

My FIL is like this and it drives me and my DH insane! Luckily when he decides to dump stuff at the house, DH just sorts through it and it goes straight to charity, recycling etc... FIL won’t ever change but dread when we have to clear out their house. His parents were the same and kept every toy he ever had... they now have those v old toys (now FIL parents have died) and the ones from their own kids incase the grandchildren want to play with them... Fair enough you’d keep a few of the ones that are safe etc but not everything!

Mulberry72 · 07/04/2018 14:02

My MIL is like this, always trying to palm off tat/crap she’s picked up God knows where!

Luckily DH tells her straight that we don’t want/like/need it and to take it back with her. She huffs & puffs a bit, but we can live with that.

pimlicolife · 07/04/2018 14:01

I'd just chuck it in the bin when she leaves

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 07/04/2018 13:58

*My parents do this.

Bought up in the war I think has a lot to do with it*

This in spades. My DParents are the same/worse. Both in 80s (so post War rationing)

I spent several weeks last year and this year moving things out, this year I took my car so I could load things in a discard (Charity Shop/skip as appropriate)

Main issue that tipped it was safety, all this STUFF in the house .

The 'permission' aspect and the giving the responsibility to get rid of things really does resonate. My DMum bought some curtains (nice enough but wouldn't go in their house) just because they were a 'bargain' but she never parted with them until she said "OK, I'll give these to you and you do something with them" , so they went to the charity shop , they were still wrapped )

She keeps boxes and baskets, they all get filled with random tat, so once they're emptied , the boxes need to go in recycle.
The only reason she cannot fill my house with things is they live too far away and she's not mobile.
But my Dad shows me random things and asks if my DC would like it, I graciously decline "Erm no, teens don't read books nowadays, they use iPhones"

Who needs 4 books about cooking with herbs and 14 Bibles? (my Dmum that's who)

CocoPuffsInGodMode · 07/04/2018 13:57

Eve it is possible it's a mental health issue but people are not obliged to allow this to impact their own lives. Certainly not to the extent of some of the stories posted here. No one can force another person to seek help (if that's actually needed but it's not always a mental health issue) but we can all decide what we will and won't allow in our own homes. And gardens come to think of it... We don't always have to put other people's feelings above our own.

Even if it is a MH problem I'm not sure playing along and acting as though the behaviour is perfectly fine is in any way helpful. That's just allowing them to tell themselves there's nothing wrong with what they're doing and ignore the effect and sometimes distress being caused to others.

DameDoom · 07/04/2018 13:54

MIL is now having to move to sheltered accommodation and has thoughtfully suggested I take over the collection of hideous doll's houses she has curated over the years and currently reside from floor to ceiling in her back bedroom.
She thinks it's a collection I could continue to build up myself as a nice hobby.
At least she has kept them at home - I wouldn't appreciate arriving home to find them adorning the front garden.

tiggersneverdie · 07/04/2018 13:50

I have read that in severe cases hoarding can be considered a form of OCD- it is compulsive fear of not having enough or having strong inexplicable attachments to random-seeming junk Eveforever so yeah, I think you have a point.

Ellie56 · 07/04/2018 13:50

My dad was a truly dreadful hoarder. He hoarded not only his own rubbish but everyone else's as well. Mum used to beg us not to say we were getting rid of anything as he would want it, whatever it was.

Anything we threw out we had to make sure was well hidden under the stinky kitchen rubbish otherwise he would fetch it out and take it home with him. Grin Grin

Eveforever · 07/04/2018 13:47

BrendasUmbrella Again, there is a possibility this an issue caused by a mental health problem, so why would you want to make her recoil?

BrendasUmbrella · 07/04/2018 13:41

Tell her you put it in the bin. Let her recoil.

DameDoom · 07/04/2018 13:41

TheQueenOfWands I do sympathise. PIL were determined to turn our lovely garden into a plastic tat-riddled, knackered old furniture-filled shit hole.

Arrived home one summer's evening to discover two huge plastic squirrels had been attached to my ivy with massive sticky out cable ties. Oh the horror! The squirrels had once been a fluorescent pink and yellow but had faded over many, many years. The plastic was so old it crumbled as I desperately tried to remove the fuckers. Apparently, they were a lovely, decorative feature that FIL had got from the car boot.

They also generously offloaded a free from a catalogue coffee-coloured dinner service. The quality was shocking. I only have white plates etc. because I have a thing about eating off coloured crockery and we have open shelves so they are on display. A few weeks later they turned up more free shit from a catalogue - a wobbly-handled knife block and some very crap pans.

I made DH take it all to the tip which was a right ball ache round trip and waste of an afternoon. He was very firm with them after that.

CoolCarrie · 07/04/2018 13:36

My dm is like this! I love a bargain and like a charity shop, but she is outrageous. She is 82 and it’s definitely a brought up during the war thing with her, and my late dad was too soft with her.
It took me weeks, and weeks to clear her house to renavatie it and she is now building up the crap again, although my cousins kindly keep a eye on her behaviour because I am 6000 miles away!

BlueEyedBengal · 07/04/2018 13:36

It's lethal to say you bought anything to my mother, she will go out and clear the shelf and dump it in my house if I say I cooked chicken last night she will go and buy 8 packs. She is a shopaholic and an hoarder her bungalow is full and she is now buying loads of clutter and tries to fill my house with stuff she knows is not my taste. If I confront her she will become abusive and behaves in a bullying manner. I think that she likes to control and this is the only way to get to me. There is no reasoning or respect. My sister went no contact 20yrs ago when mum told everyone on her hen do it was good she found a man because she could never have a child., not true she got pregnant on her honeymoon and had 2 in 21 months. She is so upset because a tumble drier she has has been turned down by me because I already have one. She knows my kids only have home made cake and meals but has just called my husband to pick up 6 shopping bags of cakes and sweets as she knows we keep sweets for a rare treat to keep them special, and to prove that all4 boys went to the dentist last week and perfect no treatment needed. I am renovating my house Soon there will be a skip outside and anything I haven't bought will be in there. My husband has agreed to that and to refuse entry to anything she has got.

TheBrilliantMistake · 07/04/2018 13:32

My team could have done with a football on Wednesday night.
Sadly, it looked like they didn't have a clue what to do with one!

(sorry, not really appropriate, but just meant to be lighthearted!).

I think older people haven't fully grasped consumerism. We really do live in a throw-away society (sadly) and back in the day, a football would have been quite an investment for a child.
She's right in as much as it's surprising how something as simple as a football can bring a lot of joy to a child, but times have changed. If you start trying to salvage something like that, you'll end up salvaging half the rubbish in the world!

MereDintofPandiculation · 07/04/2018 13:29

I guess I'm just massively upset that someone sees my much laboured over garden as a public bin. But she doesn't see it as a public bin. She's giving you a football that only needs a bit of tarting up to make it into a treasured possession - no way would she be putting that into a public bin. Yes, it's unwanted behaviour, it's causing you more work, but try not to read messages that aren't there. This is your emotional response, not her opinion.

annandale · 07/04/2018 13:27

Teacup I will join your 'wtf' faced friends - that's unbelievable about the smoke alarm!

Biber · 07/04/2018 13:26

My MIL was overwhelmed by a drive to -force things on me- give me things for the children. Clothes she brought round I'd have to wash as they stunk of smoke. She got offended once that I didn't undress dd and put her in the offerings she had brought. Never nice things, or not to our family's taste anyway.

The worst ever was the time she brought round a big toy for ds that had a vital part missing. 'Never mind', she said 'clever mummy can make a replacement.'

'Clever mummy' was overwhelmed at the time and really did not need this project. Despite the flattery. In the end dh had to tell her she could only come round if she came empty handed.

The worst of this story ... I turned into a hoarder too. Am battling to dispose of things now for the sake of my now grown dc.

diddl · 07/04/2018 13:24

" But for now I just keep them in what I call the 'Pain Of Death' bag. "

Just give them back to MIL to store if she's the one who wants them storing in case they can be passed on!

Swipe left for the next trending thread