Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU about Hadley Freeman?

267 replies

NoSquirrels · 31/03/2018 09:51

She’s a bit of a crush of mine.

I’ve always loved her writing. But this week she wrote this about 80s movies which is so good.

www.theguardian.com/film/2018/mar/27/1980s-favourite-film-decade-top-gun-stand-by-me-hadley-freeman

She’s been all over the anti-Semitism protests and other issues.
And now she has articulated what I’ve been trying politely to say for ages about the Self ID issue.

www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2018/mar/31/man-explains-what-means-be-woman?CMP=ShareiOSAppOther

Please have a read! Then if she’s convinced you sign the petition.

petition.parliament.uk/petitions/214118

If she hasn’t feel free just to ignore or talk about 80s movies here, or general women-journalists-who-rock, or your own inappropriate crushes.

OP posts:
Stillscreaming · 01/04/2018 09:49

Bloody hell, I thought they'd be coming for the gays next.

therealposieparker · 01/04/2018 09:49

Iran....

Definitely easier to be trans than gay. (As in most homophobic patriarchal religions)

therealposieparker · 01/04/2018 09:47

Hi Stillscreaming.

As someone under investigation for factual tweets, which are being viewed for Mal comms, I'm delighted to inform you that your comments tick boxes (for real) in Mal comms.

ItsuAddict · 01/04/2018 09:38

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Terftastic · 01/04/2018 09:06

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/petitions_noticeboard/3200824-to-ask-why-you-wouldn-t-sign-the-petition?pg=28

Link to pencil's excellent rebuttal - starting at 02:31.

GoodyMog · 01/04/2018 08:43

Transgendertrend have a very slick website that was obviously very expensive to put together

Looks like a wordpress theme to me. They are rarely expensive (in fact usually free).

NoSquirrels · 01/04/2018 08:34

On the thread that @stillscreaming has kindly posted about reasons not to sign the petition, @PencilsinSpace has posted responses to all screaming’s objections.

OP posts:
CircleSquareCircleSquare · 01/04/2018 07:47

Can you say Claig?

Terftastic · 01/04/2018 02:31

And you've linked to Pink News as a verifiable news source, which is such a joke.

They're the worst. Are they now sanctioning incest between twins of the same gender, or did I misread? And one of their white journalists has identified as black to attend an LGBT function. Because he can obviously self ID as black, he had a black stepmother..

Actually, is that last one even true, I can't actually believe it. Perhaps this is all a dream.

Terftastic · 01/04/2018 02:01

I suppose you'll deny that PosieParker was interviewed under police caution in the UK and told they were going for a test case with her now? Under new hate speech directives. Because, you know, you weren't there, you didn't actually witness the interview. And without seeing the evidence, you won't believe it. That's a nice place you have there. Denial. "Nothing bad can happen in denial".

Terftastic · 01/04/2018 01:57

Oh FGS stillscreaming. Way to miss the point - to miss every point put to you.

The point is, under Canadian hate speech laws, he could have had her arrested. Only he couldn't find her. He only had a picture of her at a Canadian Women's March holding the placard. He appealed on social media, but couldn't find her identity.

Plumsofwrath · 01/04/2018 01:56

Interesting article, and turn in this thread.

Reading the article I was struck by the similarity between:

(1) the pro-self IDing movement seeking to shut down opposition from biological women in order to create a safe space for themselves (ironically the very thing women want to preserve for themselves by keeping the debate moving forward);

and

(2) the increasingly vocal opposition by a section of the Jewish community to anyone who is a non-Jewish expressing views which aren’t flagrantly pro-Zionist, to the point of being branded anti-Semitic (I’m not commenting specifically on the mural here).

In both cases, if you’re not 100% for them in closing off space for respectful disagreement or a willingness to compromise and live in a grey area - well you’re against them. It’s totalitarian.

L’air du temps. There’s extremism all around these days.

Stillscreaming · 01/04/2018 01:46

@ Terftastic

Trying to have someone arrested, is meaningless. I could try and have you arrested because I don't like your shoes. I'm sure the copper would take a few minutes to smile and nod before walking away.

@C8H10N4O2

No, I haven't needed to do research on impact, the government have done that for me. The laws have been found to be so successful, that they are now looking at extending them to a sort of third gender category. The judicial review type thing that we have here has been unable to find evidence of a single GRC being applied for fraudulently and the take up has been lower than expected.

@ArcheryAnnie

www.pinknews.co.uk/2018/03/15/anti-trans-activists-hit-out-at-parasitic-trans-people-at-event-in-parliament/

If you want an example of lying to women in a way that puts them in danger. The poster directly underneath where I originally posted my reasons, claimed that women would be arrested for hate crimes, if they called the police on someone committing a sex crimes in front of them.

This is a perfect example of a moral panic, it's a lie, it's dangerous because it might cause a woman not to report a crime, and it's the threat of male violence being used to make a women carry out an act, in this case sign a petition, that she might not have carried out otherwise.

Here's the link:

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/petitions_noticeboard/3200824-to-ask-why-you-wouldn-t-sign-the-petition?pg=27

Vickxy · 01/04/2018 01:33

Sorry, forgot my NAMALT disclaimer there. As its always needed...even though it should be obvious.

Vickxy · 01/04/2018 01:32

Its not about trans people. Its about male people. You know, those who commit nearly all sexual crime (and almost all violent crime too)

Unless its scaremongering of course. As everyone knows male people are harmless? Hmm

Terftastic · 01/04/2018 01:29

I don't think we are currently subject to those laws in the UK.

But Id now like to bring your attention to PosieParker, a long-time MNetter and tweeter, who has been threatened with being subject to a test case of similar 'hate speech' laws in the UK. For speaking the truth, for repeating facts (facts already in the public domain) on twitter.

www.crowdfunder.co.uk/fighting-for-free-speech-in-uk

ArcheryAnnie · 01/04/2018 01:25

Stillscreaming what's the point of all that? We know lesbians were hated then. We were there. Lesbians are still hated now, and particularly by TRAs.

It remains true that being trans is a high-status position and being a lesbian is a low-status position, whether you measure it by governmental support, or by how the two groups are treated within LGBT+ circles, or anything else.

Terftastic · 01/04/2018 01:24

I'd like to just ram the point home - Morgan Oger, who is currently very politically active in Canada, claims to be a biological female. Claims that transitioning has made them an actual biological female, and you will be threatened with the full force of the law in Canada (Canada has hate speech laws) if you challenge this.

Terftastic · 01/04/2018 01:20

Morgan Oger - claims to be biologically female on twitter.

AIBU about Hadley Freeman?
Stillscreaming · 01/04/2018 01:19

Who is being backed by the government and all the major political parties? Transwomen are. Lesbians aren't.

I'm getting on a bit now but when I first came out there was an unequal age of consent, I could stil have been legally sacked for being a lesbian I couldn't marry. My relationships weren't legally recognised in any way. I had a spell in hospital and my girlfriend had to pretend to be my mum to get access to my hospital bed. Section 28 was about to come into force.

In the run up to section 28, the media were savage about gay people. They accused us of being perverts, trying to recruit children, having a 'gay lobby', of wanting to abuse children and having 'pretend families', so that we could abuse children, lesbians were presented as being 'unnatural' and I know a few women who lost their kids. We were also, of course, accused of spreading AIDS, while we watched our friends die of it, in a really unpleasant way.

It's loads better for gay people now. However, if you take away the dying of AIDS aspect, I see a lot of those accusations levelled at trans people. The underlying inference is always that trans people aren't safe to be around, that they have nefarious reasons for wanting to use the loo that matches their gender, that they are out to get someone.

I'm indifferent to self ID and I don't mind who pisses where but the narrative being framed around a minority group being dangers, is one that's familiar to me. I remember it being aimed at me and my community and I remember the isolation it caused. I do care about this 'trans lobby' nonsense, I remember it being claime that my fellow gays and I were part of a similar, powerful, lobby, who were trying to take something from the larger community, it was a lie then and it's a lie now.

ArcheryAnnie · 01/04/2018 01:19

Well indeed, Terftastic.

There's a lot of speculation by Stillscreaming but very little evidence. I'd bet it's born of confidence that if you state sexist nonsense in a calm, authoritative tone, and shove in a load of slanderous accusations about women, and a bunch of ridiculous, evidence-free strawmen, you'll get away with it. I wonder where that confidence comes from?

Terftastic · 01/04/2018 01:18

Canada - where Morgan Oger (transwoman) tried to have a woman arrested because she held a placard saying "transwomen are men". I think he only didn't because he couldn't find her - but by god, he tried.

Is that really where we want to be?

C8H10N4O2 · 01/04/2018 01:15

When I point out that Ireland and Canada have self ID and it's fine

You have to be joking! Have you actually done your own research on the impact? Or do you just ignore anything which doesn't fit your narrative?

Terftastic · 01/04/2018 01:07

Citation needed for all those 7 points as well, because they're not objective or true if they use words like 'moral panic' and 'I grew up 1970s Britain' - so did I - that was exactly when I grew up - and I don't share stillscreaming's views.

ArcheryAnnie · 01/04/2018 01:01

I think that there is a tiny but vocal minority on MN who would like to see trans people stripped of all rights