Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Speakmans? I don't get what they do.

137 replies

donners312 · 21/03/2018 11:52

Fears and phobias are irrational and they just seem to appeal to your logical mind to combat them.

I don't get what methodology they use and I'm sure people just go along and agree with them to get away.

What they do doesn't make sense to me what am I missing?

OP posts:
Gottagetmoving · 22/03/2018 11:16

They aren't dealing with complex mental health problems. They deal with phobias which are irrational fears of something that is not a real threat. Phobias triggered by an overreaction to something or learned through seeing fear in someone else.
The people they see are otherwise mentally healthy.
I'm sure they check whether the person has other conditions.
Unless you actually know that they have caused damage, you are guessing.
I would be interested to know too but as yet nothing has been reported.
I doubt ITV's lawyers would try to cover anything up. The fallout would be expensive and damaging.

RadioDorothy · 22/03/2018 10:40

I have a fairly significant phobia, and watching the Speakmans a year or so ago made me so irritable - I kept yelling HOW CAN IT BE THAT SIMPLE at the telly. I nearly posted on MN about what a shower of shite it all is, how irresponsible TM was being and how are they getting airtime.

But then I watched a longer feature on them recently, because I couldn't believe they were back on TV and would get that airtime if there wasn't something in it. I still thought it completely ridiculous - until I tried to apply the theory to my own phobia.

It is absolute nonsense in its simplicity and the rather childish way it is delivered, but after hours of CBT and about 4 other types of therapy over the last 25 years - something shifted. I am not magically cured, of course not, but suddenly I can see it in a more rational way. And that is the first step to getting past it.

So I'm still a little sceptical, but I no longer dismiss them out of hand. There IS something in it.

Graphista · 22/03/2018 10:20

There's no evidence their method DOES work. The things I've tried have been proven to work for other people. Mine are complex, long term and deep seated plus relate to a condition which isn't "just" mh but relates to neurobiology too. There is treatment but no cure for this.

YouOKHun · 22/03/2018 09:04

gottagetmoving ‘Accepted’ methods of treatment are accepted because there is a body of evidence showing their effectiveness with a large sample size and measured against other treatments over time. There isn’t any evidence that what the Speakmans do works; only the edited highlights they present. Until they put their brand of ‘schema conditioning’ therapy up for proper testing we have no evidence it works other than the occasional happy accident. It is not ok for untrained people to work with people who may be vulnerable.

Gottagetmoving · 22/03/2018 08:16

Graphista
You say you have phobias that so far no one has been able to help with? I presume these were professional people? And yet, you are highly critical of the Speakmans who hi do have success in helping people with phobias?
You have no evidence what the Speakmans do is harmful and no evidence it doesn't work.
New methods have always come under suspicion over the last two hundred years, until they are accepted.
Professionals trained under accepted methods of treatments are unlikely to be happy with this because it's not what they have been taught.
I will keep an open mind until someone can provide evidence rather than an opinion or being critical if what they 'look like'

Roussette · 22/03/2018 06:56

TBH I think people like this are charlatans, they give people false hope. I would never consult someone like this because what's to say they know what they're doing?

There is a lot of 1 star reviews on QVC - they went on there selling a book and a DVD. The book is meant to be a self help book but apparently it's flimsy and full of stories about who they know and saying some of their friends wouldn't be in the place they are now if they had listened to the Speakmans! They even put pics of the 'doubters' up on the DVD to name and shame them!

One of their suggestions is to think back to when you were a teenager, put some music of the time on and dance round the kitchen. How groundbreaking!!

How people buy into these two, god alone knows.

Mummyoflittledragon · 22/03/2018 03:48

I don’t watch them. But tbh if we are going to talk about what it is possible to get on the nhs these days therapy wise, in my experience and from what I read on here, it’s woefully inadequate. I saw a newly qualified cbt counsellor at the dr surgery. I only saw her for 2 full sessions. I went back to the 3rd and stopped half way through because I felt I was mummying her.

I was then referred to mind. My first counsellor bullied me and ended up being sacked for her behaviour with a client (obvs idk anymore). The next liked the sound of her own voice too much and had difficulties with boundaries. For example she made disparaging remarks about my mother when discussing childhood experiences. In the end I went privately. Gone are the days of getting good access to the clinical psychologist.

The entertainment industry to a certain extent is filling a gap and satisfying our need for instant gratification and results.

omBreROSE · 22/03/2018 02:52

You can understand how to fix those fears, however simply then l think that is ok.

omBreROSE · 22/03/2018 02:52

There are highly qualified professionals that aren’t able to help
patients with irrational fears and PTSD.
If

choseausername1 · 22/03/2018 02:01

I would love to see them cure my ‘irrational’ desire to chuck the remote at the tv every time they appear.

Don’t buy them at all.

kimanda · 22/03/2018 00:06

I find them utterly ludicrous and laughable.

Some people have a lifelong phobia for 30-40 years or more, and it's cured in half an hour of the 'Speakmans' simpering over them and making them 'face their fear.' Do me a favour. Hmm

Utter, utter bollocks. Shame on ITV and 'This Morning' for broadcasting this shower of shite.

Graphista · 21/03/2018 23:49

Thank you youokhun. For the work you do in far from easiest conditions.

YouOKHun · 21/03/2018 22:14

Thank you Limon and Graphista and wellbanana you’re all spot on. And thanks for sticking up for us NHS psychotherapists who have to prove our academic standing and continue to prove our skills and knowledge in clinical supervision using evidence based approaches (and so we should).

LimonViola · 21/03/2018 21:43

Totally agree banana. It's actually fairly insulting to professionals who actually study their profession for years and undergo training and development and supervision and specialising to find people like the speakmans being referred to as therapists. Quite the same as your local lady offering essential oils for common illnesses being seen as a doctor!

If their methods worked and were robust and known (reproducible) then the MH profession would be delighted to have another way to help people. But they're none of those things to anyone's knowledge. Of course if they were open about their methods then a) they'd be scrutinised and proven to be a sham and b) they wouldn't be able to make a fortune keeping it all to themselves.

I'm sure they help some people in the way that if I were to pat everyone with a cold on the head, some would find their cold shortly improved. Correlation does not equal causation however.

It's despairing that in order for the public to have an interest in seeing mental health issues explored and treated it has to be distilled into a short fun segment on daytime tv delivered by a pair of fraudsters/crooks. I wonder if the people who are full of admiration for the speakmans admire their local mental health nhs workers who are treating umpteen cases every week with inadequate resources, a high caseload, and a fraction of the pay!

wellbanana · 21/03/2018 21:40
  • doesn't mean!
wellbanana · 21/03/2018 21:38

To echo @cheesydoesit - this times by many many clinical psychologist and other MH professional friends.
They are not open about their methods so there is no way of knowing what exactly they are doing but what you can ascertain is quite concerning in terms of the claims they make. I don't doubt they genuinely believe their methods, but that does mean they work long term and not being able to critique something you offer and recognise its limitations is a sign of a bad therapist/scientist/researcher. They don't have any formal qualifications in any kind of therapy. There's no follow up to prove long term effectiveness rates for their clients compared to what other therapists offer. I could go on all day tbh. They may well be nice people for all I know but they are kooks as far as the mental health professions are concerned.

LimonViola · 21/03/2018 21:33

Spot on graphista.

It's really quite shocking how many people are comfortable with somebody non accredited delivering treatment without a known evidence base, just because 'it seems to work', based on a tv programme segment. Where's the data? Where's the evidence? Where's the long term follow up to assess sustained improvement and side effects? Where's the transparency to the clients? I bloody wouldn't go to see someone who wasn't actually a trained accredited therapist who kept their methods secret!

Why do people think the NHS abides by NICE guidelines? So they can provide what is proven to be the most effective current treatment with evidence that it will work in a percentage if patients.

With your own private money, sure you can pay anyone if you like. You could pay a random person on the street a tenner to shout at you for half an hour and tell you to 'just get over it' if you want and nobody can stop you. But to state that people providing that aren't doing anything wrong when they're working with potentially vulnerable clients who need actual specialist, proven to be safe help, is hugely irresponsible imo.

Graphista · 21/03/2018 21:03

"They aren't treating serious mental health conditions. They are treating phobias.
They have helped some people with PTSD too." So phobias and PTSD aren't serious conditions? THAT is trivialising

I'm also an ex nurse and have done a significant amount of research (trying to find something to help me with my stuff) so I'm not giving an opinion purely from a lay perspective.

ANYONE purporting to give MEDICAL treatment to people with serious health issues without ANY regulated professional training is acting irresponsibly and dangerously.

I've seen no supported evidence that what they do works even in the medium let alone long term.

llangennith · 21/03/2018 20:48

I know it sounds bonkers but it really works! I know that from experience. It’s weird. There’s no eureka moment, you just feel calm and are no longer phobic about whatever you were frightened of before. Then you get on with your life.

Gottagetmoving · 21/03/2018 20:20

Honestly the trivialising of mh conditions by some on mn infuriates me sometimes

I wasn't trivialising anything! Graphista I have suffered mental issues myself and wouldn't trivialise it.
Everything I said was true and has been said by qualified people. I didn't make it up myself!
You have decided that what the Speakmans do is dangerous and doesn't work, without any evidence to back that up!
You have not had treatments that have worked for you so why slag off something that's worked for others?

donners312 · 21/03/2018 19:47

I also hope you realize I was being sarcastic about her stupid and irrational fears! What I am questioning is the speak mans ability to eradicate them. But maybe they did.

OP posts:
donners312 · 21/03/2018 19:46

sorry ssd I didn't mean to upset you.

OP posts:
ssd · 21/03/2018 19:45

actually I thought your thread was worth being on, but after that comment I'm out.

coldcanary · 21/03/2018 19:45

I see a couple of locals on this thread Grin
I do know one person who saw them for a phobia and she’s convinced they worked for her when nothing else did - I got no other details, she only told me during an argument when I said I thought he was a dick (dealt with him a few times and he really was!) He parked his hummer like a dick as well..
I have very fond memories - and a few fuzzy ones - of nights out in their house when it was a pub, such a lovely place.

ssd · 21/03/2018 19:44

totally harsh and below the belt there donners312, her brother was stabbed to death and she was obviously suffering terribly since it happened

am shocked at your post